<-- Back to proposed bills
Prisoners (Disclosure of Information About Victims) Bill
11 February 2020
Type
Bill Debate
At a Glance
Issue Summary
The statement addresses the Prisoners (Disclosure of Information About Victims) Bill, also known as Helen's law, which aims to ensure that a prisoner's failure to disclose information about a victim's remains is considered by the Parole Board in their risk assessment before releasing a murderer on licence. The statement discusses the Prisoners (Disclosure of Information About Victims) Bill and its provisions for dealing with prisoners who refuse to disclose information about victims' remains or identities. The statement discusses a Bill aimed at mandating the disclosure of crucial information to the Parole Board regarding victims' bodies or child victims of indecent images. The statement discusses the Prisoners (Disclosure of Information About Victims) Bill, which aims to enforce Parole Board considerations for non-disclosure of victim information by serious offenders. The statement discusses the introduction of a Bill that would require the Parole Board to consider a prisoner's failure to disclose information about victims when deciding on release. The statement discusses the Prisoners (Disclosure of Information About Victims) Bill, which aims to address the issue of murderers who refuse to disclose information about their victims' remains before being granted parole. The statement discusses the Prisoners (Disclosure of Information About Victims) Bill and its implications for victims' rights, particularly focusing on the Parole Board's role and accountability. The MP discusses the Prisoners (Disclosure of Information About Victims) Bill, focusing on the abuse case involving Vanessa George and advocating for changes to protect victims' identities and rights. The statement addresses concerns regarding the implementation of a new law aimed at protecting victims' identities in cases involving serious offenders like Vanessa George. The statement discusses the Prisoners (Disclosure of Information About Victims) Bill, which aims to address the issue of murderers who refuse to disclose the location of their victims' bodies. MPs are debating the Prisoners (Disclosure of Information About Victims) Bill, which aims to make it easier for Parole Boards to consider whether prisoners have disclosed information about their victims when deciding release conditions. The statement discusses Helen's law, which aims to require the Parole Board to consider a murderer's refusal to disclose information about a victim when reviewing an offender’s suitability for release. The statement discusses the Prisoners (Disclosure of Information About Victims) Bill, which aims to ensure the Parole Board considers non-disclosure of victims' information by prisoners serving sentences for specific offences.
Action Requested
The minister requests that the House read and consider the Bill during its Second Reading. The legislation proposes amendments to release provisions for life sentences, obligating the Parole Board to take non-disclosure of victim information into account when assessing prisoner safety for release.
Key Facts
- Helen McCourt disappeared in February 1988 and was murdered by Ian Simms.
- Simms has never disclosed where her body is located.
- Marie McCourt campaigned for this change to the law.
- The Bill consists of three clauses addressing the Parole Board's duty to consider non-disclosure when assessing prisoner release risk.
- Robert Buckland acknowledges the Chair of the Select Committee's experience in criminal justice.
- The case of Vanessa George is cited as an example of a horrific situation where the offender refused to disclose victim identities.
- Clause 1 and Clause 2 of the Bill aim to legally mandate that non-disclosure be considered by the Parole Board when making release decisions for prisoners.
- Schedule 21 of sentencing guidelines allows judges to adjust sentences based on factors like remorse or non-cooperation.
- The provision is already part of Parole Board practice.
- The Bill addresses cases like Helen McCourt's murder and Vanessa George's crimes against children.
- Support from both sides of the House is sought.
- The Bill will put into statute existing Parole Board guidance for considering non-disclosure of victim information by offenders convicted of murder, manslaughter, or taking/creating indecent images of children.
- Helen McCourt was murdered in 1988, and her body remains undiscovered despite the release of her murderer last week who refused to disclose her whereabouts.
- Vanessa George abused multiple young children at Little Ted’s nursery; she was released from prison in September 2019 without revealing the identities of all her victims.
- The Bill places a statutory obligation on the Parole Board to consider non-disclosure of victim information in release decisions.
- Helen McCourt's case is highlighted where her killer was released despite not disclosing her body's whereabouts.
- Danielle Jones' murder case is mentioned, with her murderer potentially being considered for parole without revealing her remains.
- Helen McCourt was murdered in 1988 and her murderer has not disclosed her location.
- The Bill applies to England and Wales but similar cases exist elsewhere, such as the case of Charlotte Murray in Northern Ireland.
- Ian Simms, Helen's murderer, was released recently causing additional suffering for Marie and her family.
- The Bill aims to place a statutory duty on the Parole Board to consider non-disclosure issues but will not fundamentally change current practices.
- In the Worboys case, the Parole Board released a serial offender early in January 2018 after only eight years of imprisonment.
- A further, more in-depth review of the Parole Board’s activity was recommended in 2018.
- The Bill aims to safeguard victims' identities and protect their innocence.
- Vanessa George was released without naming the children she abused, leading to ongoing public pressure for legal changes.
- Parents and families have campaigned for over 32 years to bring about justice and changes in the law.
- The case of Vanessa George is highlighted as a critical example.
- Concerns about how additional charges will interact with the primary charge under the new law are raised.
- Comprehensive licence conditions have been set for Vanessa George to prevent contact with abused children and restrict internet access.
- Parents often learn about offender releases through social media or local papers due to outdated communication details.
- Helen McCourt was murdered in 1988 and her body has never been found.
- Ian Simms, convicted of murder with overwhelming evidence, recently refused to disclose the location of Helen's body upon release from prison.
- Over half a million people signed a petition supporting Helen’s law.
- The Bill has been in discussion for at least 16 years according to one MP.
- Over 1,800 victims were sexually assaulted at Medomsley detention centre between the 1960s and 1980s.
- Cases like Reynhard Sinaga and John Worboys highlight the importance of considering victim information in parole decisions.
- The Parole Board must consider withholding information by offenders during review processes.
- Helen McCourt was murdered, leading to a campaign by her mother Marie McCourt.
- The Bill aims to ensure that murderers who refuse to disclose the location of victim bodies are not granted parole.
- The Bill aims to make non-disclosure of victims' information by prisoners mandatory for the Parole Board to consider.
- It covers serious offences such as murder, rape, and indecent image offences involving children.
- The Government introduced changes allowing the Lord Chancellor to ask the Parole Board to reconsider decisions if they were not correct initially.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy