<-- Back to proposed bills

European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill

22 January 2020

Proposing MP
Chorley
Type
Bill Debate

At a Glance

Issue Summary

The statement addresses the House of Commons' disagreement with Lords amendments 1 through 5 in the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill, focusing on citizens' rights and the interpretation of retained EU law. The statement discusses the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill and addresses concerns about the interpretation of retained EU law post-Brexit implementation period. The Speaker is addressing concerns about legislative consent and the Sewel convention in relation to the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill. The MP opposes the Government's motions regarding EU citizens' rights and proposes supporting amendments for a declaratory system and physical documents for settled status. The statement addresses concerns over the separation of powers and the removal of provisions for protecting unaccompanied child refugees in the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018. The speaker discusses concerns about the Government's approach to devolution and the respect for the Sewel convention in the context of the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill. The debate focuses on the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill and its impact on devolution, EU citizens' rights, and the Sewel convention. The debate focuses on amendments related to EU citizens' rights and refugee children's protection under the Withdrawal Agreement Bill. The statement discusses the EU Withdrawal Agreement Bill, focusing on amendments from the House of Lords and the necessity for timely implementation of status provisions for individuals.

Action Requested

The Secretary of State requests that the House rejects Lords amendment 1 regarding declaratory status for EU citizens as it would undermine the successful EU settlement scheme. He also discusses amendments related to judicial interpretation of retained EU law and emphasizes the importance of maintaining control over borders post-Brexit.

Key Facts

  • The Government has committed £9 million to help vulnerable groups apply for settled status.
  • Almost 3 million people have successfully applied through the EU settlement scheme.
  • The House of Lords sat for nearly 40 hours to debate more than 100 amendments.
  • The power in clause 26 is sunset until the end of the year when courts start interpreting retained EU law.
  • The Government has granted protection to more than 41,000 children since the start of 2010.
  • In 2018, the UK received over 3,000 asylum applications from unaccompanied children and dealt with 15% of all claims in the EU.
  • The Sewel convention is already enshrined in statute through the Scotland Act 1998 and the Government of Wales Act 2006.
  • The Prime Minister and the Secretary of State value the Union and are committed to working with devolved Administrations.
  • A meeting was held on January 17th with representatives from Scottish and Welsh Governments to discuss future negotiations.
  • The Government's programme has granted settled or pre-settled status to approximately 2.5 million people.
  • Many who are entitled to settled status have been given only pre-settled status.
  • Amendments propose a declaratory system for gaining settled status and a physical document to prove it.
  • Experts from the Home Affairs Committee, Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants,3million, and Residential Landlords Association support these amendments.
  • The Government's motions to disagree with amendments 2 and 3 will blur the separation of powers.
  • Clause 17 removes the obligation on the Government to negotiate future arrangements for protecting unaccompanied child refugees.
  • Lord Dubs' scheme originally committed to taking 3,000 children but only took fewer than 500.
  • The Sewel convention is important for ensuring proper consultation between Westminster and devolved institutions.
  • Devolved Parliaments in Northern Ireland, Wales, and Scotland have refused consent on certain provisions of the Bill.
  • Labour Members warn that if the Government's approach leads to negative consequences, they will hold Conservative Members accountable.
  • The Government's manifesto promised to protect the rights of European citizens.
  • Between 300,000 and 450,000 EU or EEA citizens may struggle with obtaining settled status.
  • Amendments aim to address issues such as judicial independence, unaccompanied child refugees, and legislative consent from devolved Parliaments.
  • Amendment 1 deals with the declaratory system and documents for EU citizens.
  • Amendment 4 addresses protections for refugee children under the Dubs amendment.
  • The European Union has committed to agreeing on a future relationship by the end of the year.
  • The government's programme needs to deliver status for millions of people.
  • Lords amendment 1 was disagreed to with Ayes 338, Noes 252.
  • Lords amendment 2 was disagreed to with Ayes 348, Noes 246.
  • Lords amendment 3 was disagreed to with Ayes 350, Noes 247.
  • Lords amendment 4 was disagreed to with Ayes 342, Noes 254.
  • Lords amendment 5 was disagreed to with Ayes 349, Noes 246.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy