<-- Back to proposed bills

European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill

09 January 2020

Proposing MP
Doncaster Central
Type
Bill Debate

At a Glance

Issue Summary

The statement discusses the Third Reading of the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill, which aims to implement the withdrawal agreement between the UK and the EU in UK law. The speaker discusses the scrutiny and concerns surrounding the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill, particularly focusing on parliamentary scrutiny and citizens' rights. Rosie Winterton discusses the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill, emphasizing concerns about equality impact assessments, independent monitoring of the settled status scheme, and commitments on unaccompanied child refugees. The statement discusses the divide between Scotland's voting preferences and those of England in relation to Brexit. Philippa Whitford is moving a motion to decline giving a Third Reading to the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill due to lack of Scottish Parliament consent and concerns about undermining devolved competencies. The statement discusses the principle of parliamentary sovereignty and the importance of respecting the democratic will of the British people regarding Brexit. The statement addresses the UK's intention to take full control over its Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) and marine resources upon leaving the EU. MP Pete Wishart is debating the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill and criticizing the hard Brexiteers for their victory in pushing through a deal that goes against Scotland's wishes. The speaker discusses the implications of the Brexit deal being passed in Parliament. Pete Wishart is addressing the UK Parliament regarding the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill and its implications for Scotland. The statement addresses the impact of denying Scotland's democratic rights and the growing support for Scottish independence. Craig Williams is speaking about the Third Reading of the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill in his constituency of Montgomeryshire. Fleur Anderson gives her maiden speech on the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill, discussing various issues affecting her constituency including poverty, housing, climate change, and Brexit. Bill Cash discusses the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill and its implications for parliamentary sovereignty and democracy in the UK. The statement discusses the UK's decision to leave the European Union and the implications for governance, democracy, and specific industries like fishing. Rosie Winterton debates the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill, focusing on its potential impact on Northern Ireland and the future of the UK as a unitary state. Rosie Winterton discusses the impact of clause 37 of the EU Withdrawal Agreement Bill on refugee resettlement and family reunion provisions. Caroline Lucas discusses her concerns regarding the European Union withdrawal agreement, focusing on environmental standards and the possibility of a no-deal Brexit. Caroline Lucas criticizes the Conservative government for its stance on environmental legislation and the treatment of refugees, highlighting concerns about parliamentary sovereignty and the lack of democratic scrutiny in trade agreements. The statement discusses the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill and its implications for UK-EU relations. Rosie Winterton discusses the importance of maintaining regulatory alignment with the EU in certain sectors while allowing divergence in emerging technologies. Tommy Sheppard is opposing the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill, arguing it diminishes national character, affects foreigners living in the UK, changes relationships between devolved administrations and the central government, and will lead to a reduction in living standards. Tommy Sheppard discusses the legitimacy of the UK Government's mandate to deliver Brexit in Scotland following the December 2019 election. The statement discusses the political situation regarding Scottish independence and the response of the UK Government to the mandate given by Scottish voters. Neil Parish discusses the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill and supports the government's efforts to negotiate with the EU while taking executive powers. Neil Parish discusses the implications of leaving the European Union Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) and the potential for improved fishing rights and environmental management in the UK. Rosie Winterton is addressing concerns about the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill and its impact on Northern Ireland. Toby Perkins discusses regrets over the inability of Parliament to reach a compromise on Brexit and criticizes both parties for their handling of the situation. The statement discusses objections to the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill and expresses concerns about the future relationship with the EU after Brexit. The statement discusses the progress and importance of the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill in implementing the UK's withdrawal from the EU. Rosie Winterton is discussing the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill and its progress.

Action Requested

The Minister requests that the House commends the Bill for its Third Reading, ensuring it moves to the House of Lords next week. The statement also highlights the constructive spirit and support from Members during the debates and expresses optimism about the progress of the Bill in the other place.

Key Facts

  • Mr Speaker has selected the amendment in the name of the leader of the Scottish National party.
  • The Bill will move to another place after Third Reading with substantive stages beginning on Monday.
  • There is a political declaration and interest to conclude a trade deal within 11 months.
  • The government has brought forward legislation that many perceive as disrespectful of parliamentary scrutiny.
  • New clause 4 was proposed to give Parliament a greater role without extending the transition period.
  • Almost half of EU citizens applying for settled status have been granted pre-settled status instead.
  • The settled status scheme is open to error.
  • Schedule 2 of the Bill makes the independent monitoring authority far from independent from Government.
  • The Bill will remove commitments on unaccompanied child refugees.
  • Joanna Cherry identifies herself as a bourgeois liberal but argues her party's broader appeal in Scotland.
  • John Hayes criticizes the disconnect between certain MPs and their constituents' views on Brexit.
  • The Prime Minister sought a clear mandate from the people to deliver Brexit, which was accepted by the British electorate.
  • The Scottish Parliament voted by 92 to 29 against legislative consent for the Bill.
  • Scotland’s Place in Europe report proposed staying in the single market and customs union as early as December 2016.
  • 62% of Scottish voters voted to remain in the EU.
  • Owen Paterson congratulates the Deputy Speaker on his re-election.
  • The hon. Member for Central Ayrshire and Weaver Vale are praised for their contributions.
  • The European Communities Act 1972 (Disapplication) Bill from 2005 is referenced, with its clause 39 now part of the current Withdrawal Agreement Bill.
  • 17.4 million people voted to leave the EU in the referendum.
  • 80% of votes went to parties promising to honor the referendum result in the 2017 election.
  • The Brexit party came first in the European elections, while the Conservative Party came fifth.
  • Owen Paterson highlights that the Common Fisheries Policy was disastrous for fishing communities and marine conservation.
  • The statement calls for independent maritime nation status similar to Norway and Iceland's bilateral relations.
  • Exports to non-EU countries grew by 6.3% last year, reaching £376.7 billion compared to a 1.3% increase in exports to the EU at £296.8 billion.
  • The Bill has been passed through the House of Commons despite opposition.
  • Wishart believes the decision to leave the EU goes against Scotland's national collective will.
  • Hard Brexiteers have achieved a complete victory in securing the hard Brexit they sought.
  • The speaker credits Nigel Farage for realizing the vision of Brexit.
  • The new era is described as an 'age of hard Brexitism'.
  • Economic damage from hard Brexit could be between 5% to 6% GDP reduction.
  • The Bill symbolises the difference between Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom.
  • Scotland voted 62% to remain in the European Union during the EU referendum.
  • The SNP won 80% of Scottish seats in the general election, resulting in significant losses for the Scottish Conservatives.
  • The idea of Scottish independence will continue to grow.
  • Scotland is on a different trajectory from the hard Brexit UK.
  • The speaker advises Conservative Members to give Scotland an independence referendum.
  • Craig Williams is not making a maiden speech but reflects on his non-participation in debates over two and a half years.
  • The Montgomeryshire constituency covers an area from Welshpool to Llanidloes, forming the gateway to mid-Wales.
  • The Welshpool and Llanfair railway campaign received the Queen’s award for voluntary service.
  • Williams aims to work with Russell George and the Welsh Government on agricultural funding commitments until 2024.
  • Montgomeryshire has both agriculture and tourism sectors, primarily affected by the Bill.
  • One in three children in Anderson's constituency lives in poverty.
  • 30% of families live in overcrowded homes.
  • Over 3,000 children in Wandsworth borough are homeless and living in temporary accommodation.
  • More than 74% of Wandsworth residents voted to remain in the EU.
  • Over 700 youth centres have closed across the UK in nine years.
  • Bill Cash refers to himself as a Maastricht rebel from 1992-93.
  • The bill is described as being about democracy and governance through elected representatives rather than subjugation to the European Union.
  • Cash argues that Scotland would be negatively impacted economically if it were to leave the UK and remain in the EU.
  • People in constituencies north of Coventry felt let down by Labour MPs who did not support their decision to leave the EU.
  • The European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC) framework was seen as anti-competitive and contributing to the collapse of steel and coal industries.
  • Brexit was achieved through democratic means, with the UK gaining sovereignty after abdicating it in 1971.
  • The Bill risks leaving Northern Ireland under different regulatory arrangements from the rest of the UK.
  • A company in Orkney employs 23 people, highlighting potential job losses due to no-deal Brexit.
  • The Department for Exiting the European Union is set to be wound up after December.
  • Nick Hurd was previously the Member of Parliament for Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner.
  • Hillingdon is a gateway authority by virtue of Heathrow airport.
  • Since the 2003 Hillingdon judgment, there has been an increase in unaccompanied young people arriving into care authorities.
  • Over the past decade, arrival rates of child refugees have more than doubled.
  • Caroline Lucas was a Member of the European Parliament for 10 years.
  • Conservative MEPs were often seen trying to water down environmental regulations during her tenure.
  • Vicky Ford, a former Conservative MEP, refutes these claims by highlighting conservative leadership in climate change conferences.
  • The Conservative government's position on refugees is described as cruel and hostile.
  • Parliamentary scrutiny of trade agreements is absent from the new Bill.
  • MPs have less say over trade deals than Members of the European Parliament will have in Brussels.
  • An independent body was proposed to assess the impact of any new deal on climate change, human rights, and the economy.
  • The Prime Minister's father led landmark environmental legislation.
  • David Simmonds made an excellent maiden speech focusing on refugee issues.
  • The Bill paves the way for a free trade agreement between the UK and EU.
  • Trade negotiations aim to achieve no tariffs, fees or quotas by end of year.
  • Rolls-Royce is based in Chichester.
  • Car manufacturers rely on just-in-time supply chains with parts moving across the channel several times during manufacturing.
  • Digital venture capital investment exceeded £6 billion in 2018 alone—the highest in Europe.
  • The UK boasts three of the top 10 universities worldwide.
  • The proposals before parliament are seen as myopic, small-minded, and miserable.
  • Tens of thousands of people in Sheppard's city will lose or have their status fundamentally altered due to the loss of freedom of movement.
  • United Kingdom Ministers are taking powers to make secondary legislation in areas that should be devolved.
  • The Conservative party won 43% of the vote with more than an 86-seat majority.
  • The Scottish National Party (SNP) won 80% of contested areas in Scotland.
  • 80% of MPs returned from Scotland are SNP members.
  • In December 2019, the SNP explicitly asked for endorsement on whether Scotland should choose how it is governed and if it wants to follow Brexit.
  • SNP proposition was voted in a democratic election.
  • Scottish voters rejected the Conservative party's mandate against another referendum on independence.
  • First Minister of Scotland has requested negotiations with UK Government.
  • Scottish Parliament endorses claim of right for Scotland.
  • The European Union has common agricultural and fisheries policies that Neil Parish believes can be improved upon by creating individual policies for each nation within the UK.
  • Biodiversity is highlighted as an important aspect of future agricultural policies in the UK.
  • Concerns are raised about potential competition between Scottish and English agricultural policies if divergence occurs.
  • Neil Parish states only about 20% of American chicken is processed using chlorine gas.
  • The US rears broilers at three or four times the density compared to UK practices and uses more antibiotics.
  • Parliament aims to have an Agriculture Bill with higher welfare standards for chickens.
  • The Bill faces unresolved issues regarding trade, borders, and regulatory alignment.
  • There is concern about a potential border down the Irish sea or on the island of Ireland.
  • Businesses in Northern Ireland want unfettered access and no discrimination against their goods.
  • The Parliament was unable to agree on a settlement respecting both the referendum and the 2017 general election result.
  • The SNP spent less than 10% of the money on the EU referendum compared to the independence referendum.
  • Vote Leave promised during the last referendum that they would negotiate the terms of a new deal before starting any legal process to leave.
  • The Labour party will be focused entirely on voting against the entire Bill.
  • Clause 33 of the Bill is seen as binding the Government's hands regarding trade negotiations extensions.
  • The Opposition stood up for child refugees by trying to hold the Government to their commitment to Lord Alf Dubs.
  • The Bill will implement in UK law the withdrawal agreement between the UK and EU.
  • The Bill ensures that the UK departs from the EU with a deal on January 31, 2020 as promised to the British public.
  • Mark Francois suggests using Big Ben to mark the moment of Brexit.
  • The Bill passed its Third Reading with 330 Ayes and 231 Noes.
  • The Prime Minister met with the European Commission President to discuss future relations based on shared history, interests, and values.
  • The Scottish Parliament voted against giving consent for the withdrawal agreement.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy