<-- Back to proposed bills

Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Bill - Sitting 4

14 December 2021

Proposing MP
Dundee East
Type
Public Bill Committee

At a Glance

Issue Summary

Stewart Hosie proposes a new clause requiring the Secretary of State to review awards under sections 15 and 16 of the Act to assess consistent interpretation by arbitration bodies. The statement discusses the Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Bill and its provisions regarding arbitration for rent debts. Stewart Hosie discusses amendments to Clause 19 regarding arbitration fees and expenses. Stewart Hosie is discussing amendments to Clause 21 of the Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Bill, focusing on the publication and content of guidance for arbitrators. Stewart Hosie is proposing an amendment and discussing a clause in the Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Bill. The statement discusses clause 23 and schedule 2 of the Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Bill, focusing on protections for tenants during a moratorium period. Stewart Hosie is discussing Clause 26 and Schedule 3 of the Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Bill, which aim to prevent landlords from initiating winding-up petitions or bankruptcy orders against businesses due to rent arrears related to the pandemic. The statement addresses the Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Bill, discussing clauses related to Northern Ireland, Crown application, and extent, commencement and short title.

Action Requested

The Secretary of State is requested to conduct a review no later than three months after the Act's passage, considering published awards, and issuing further guidance if material inconsistencies are identified.

Key Facts

  • Clause 15 addresses arbitrator’s principles.
  • New clause 1 proposes a review by the Secretary of State within three months post-passage to assess consistent interpretation.
  • The review will consider published awards and may lead to guidance amendments.
  • Arbitration bodies will only appoint suitable and impartial arbitrators.
  • The government expects all applications to arbitration within six months of the Bill being in force.
  • Clause 16 outlines factors for assessing landlord solvency and viability of a tenant’s business, including non-exhaustive evidence listed in annex B of the code of practice.
  • Under clause 17, arbitrators are required to make an award as soon as practicable or within 14 days if there is an oral hearing.
  • Amendment 4 moves to require the Secretary of State to specify limits on arbitration fees.
  • Amendment 5 adds consideration for accessibility and affordability in setting arbitration fee limits.
  • There is concern about high arbitration costs affecting struggling businesses.
  • Amendment 6 would require the Secretary of State to publish guidance on the exercise of arbitrators’ functions and making references to arbitration.
  • Amendment 7 proposes that guidance must provide further information on assessing 'viability' and the relevant timescale for this assessment.
  • Amendment 8 in schedule 2 aims to include claims against guarantors.
  • The amendment would clarify the definition of 'debt claims'.
  • Stewart Hosie supports the clause standing part of the Bill.
  • Clause 23 prevents rent debts from being collected during a moratorium period.
  • Schedule 2 outlines detailed measures preventing landlords from making debt claims or using commercial rent arrears recovery powers.
  • Amendment 8 seeks to clarify protections for guarantors and head lessees.
  • Clause 26 prevents landlords from petitioning for winding-up businesses due to protected rent debt.
  • Schedule 3 supports viable businesses by allowing debts to be resolved through arbitration.
  • Paragraph 3 of schedule 3 ensures existing bankruptcy orders made before the Bill's enactment will have no power regarding future rent arrears.
  • The Bill includes clauses enabling measures in Northern Ireland at their discretion.
  • Clause 29 binds the Crown where it is a landlord under business tenancies covered by the Bill.
  • The extent of the Bill is carefully considered for England and Wales, with limited provisions extending to Northern Ireland and Scotland.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy