<-- Back to proposed bills
Finance (No. 2) Bill - Sitting 4
27 April 2021
Type
Public Bill Committee
At a Glance
Issue Summary
Angela Eagle is proposing amendments to reduce penalties for late tax returns and ensure fair treatment for taxpayers entering into time-to-pay agreements with HMRC. The statement discusses reforms to Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (HMRC) penalties for late tax filings and payments, introducing a points-based system and two-penalty model. The statement discusses new schedules introduced by clause 112 and 113 of the Finance (No. 2) Bill which establish penalty systems for tax compliance and late payments. The MP is addressing concerns over HMRC's proposed penalty regime for late tax submissions and payment arrangements. The statement addresses concerns about complexity and compliance in the new tax penalty regime, emphasizing its positive reception by organisations like the Chartered Institute of Taxation and the Low Incomes Tax Reform Group. The statement addresses amendments to late payment interest and repayment interest for VAT to align with income tax self-assessment, and changes enabling HMRC to issue financial institution notices to banks without tribunal approval. The statement discusses the new powers granted to HMRC under Clause 122 of the Finance (No. 2) Bill to issue financial institution notices without taxpayer approval or tribunal review. The statement discusses Clause 123 of the Finance (No. 2) Bill which aims to amend Schedule 36 of the Finance Act 2008 to allow HMRC to issue information notices for collecting tax debts. The statement discusses a clause introducing international reporting rules for digital platforms in the gig economy as part of the OECD model rules. The statement addresses changes proposed in Clause 126 of the Finance Bill which aims to amend the Customs and Excise Management Act 1979 to allow HMRC and UK Border Force to impose civil penalties for unauthorised removal or disposal of seized goods. Angela Eagle is proposing a new clause to review the impact of capital allowance provisions on GDP and compare it with scenarios where these provisions are not enacted or if the UK fiscal stimulus package mirrors that of the US. The MP discusses the impact of the UK Government's stimulus package compared to President Biden's approach and suggests a more cooperative process for setting tax and spending plans. Angela Eagle facilitates a discussion on the Finance (No. 2) Bill, with MPs offering thanks to various stakeholders.
Action Requested
The amendments aim to remove proposed penalties at specific days after the due date, extend the time limit for assessment of a penalty from two years to three months, and require a review of the effects on tax revenues within six months of the Act passing.
Key Facts
- Amendments reduce penalties at 15 and 30 days post-due date.
- Amendment extends the time limit for assessing penalties from 2 years to 3 months.
- New clause mandates a review by the Chancellor of Exchequer within six months on the effects of sections and schedules related to tax revenues.
- New points-based penalty system introduced by clauses 112 and schedules 23-24 for regular tax return obligations.
- Two-penalty model for VAT businesses and ITSA taxpayers introduced by clause 113 and schedule 25.
- First late payment penalties will not be applied after 15 days in the first year, giving taxpayers 30 days to contact HMRC before any charges are made.
- Regulations will take effect from April 1, 2022 for VAT taxpayers; April 6, 2023 for ITSA taxpayers with income over £10,000 submitting quarterly returns digitally; and April 6, 2024 for all other ITSA taxpayers.
- Two-year time limit remains for HMRC to assess penalties after missed obligations.
- 'Time to pay' arrangements can be renegotiated if circumstances change.
- HMRC introduced a new points-based penalty system for failure to make or late submission of returns.
- Schedule 24 makes minor changes to the penalty for deliberately withholding information from HMRC.
- Taxpayers face six separate filing obligations under Making Tax Digital for income tax self-assessment over a year.
- The first penalty for businesses and individuals not paying their tax on time is 2% of the amount unpaid after 15 days, with an additional 2% after 30 days.
- A new late-payment penalty interest rate of 4% per annum applies from day 31.
- Schedule 26 amends section 1303 of the Corporation Tax Act 2009.
- Amendment 24 aims to reduce HMRC's time limit to assess penalties.
- Amendments 3 to 14 seek to simplify the proposed penalty regime for late payment.
- The tax gap is estimated at £30 billion in 2018-19.
- Scottish limited partnerships are criticized for potential abuse by sophisticated criminal players.
- The Chartered Institute of Taxation welcomes harmonisation of interest rules.
- The Low Incomes Tax Reform Group acknowledges HMRC's efforts to ensure the penalty regime is fit for purpose.
- Buzzacott, a UK top 20 accountancy firm, supports the system as fairer and less likely to excessively penalise traders.
- HMRC will notify taxpayers of points or penalties at regular intervals via digital tax accounts and written letters.
- Clause 116 and schedule 28 amendments aim to align late payment and repayment interest for VAT with income tax self-assessment.
- The changes will take effect by way of regulations from accounting periods starting on or after 1 April 2022.
- Amendment 19 removes restrictions on VAT credit carrying repayment interest during HMRC inquiries or corrections.
- HMRC can issue financial institution notices without taxpayer or tribunal approval.
- The measure is justified by HMRC's need to meet international obligations for tax avoidance and evasion.
- The House of Lords Economic Affairs Finance Bill Sub-Committee recommended reviewing the process to streamline information requests.
- An authorised HMRC officer must approve each notice after training and passing a test.
- Financial institutions have appeal rights against penalties.
- HMRC will submit an annual report on the use of financial institution notices to Parliament.
- Clause 123 amends Schedule 36 of the Finance Act 2008.
- HMRC will issue information notices to obtain documents and information for collecting tax debts.
- The changes aim to comply with OECD international standards on exchange of information.
- Clause 125 introduces a new power for international reporting rules for digital platforms.
- The OECD model rules apply to platforms like taxi and private hire services, food delivery, freelance services, and short-term accommodation letting through apps and websites.
- An estimated 2 to 5 million businesses providing services via digital platforms will be affected by these measures.
- Goods seized in situ can currently be removed without penalty.
- Pressures on existing warehouse space mean more seizures occur at traders' premises.
- Clause 126 amends schedule 3 to include civil penalties for unauthorised removal of seized goods.
- The Chancellor must review the impact on investment in parts of the United Kingdom and regions of England within six months.
- The review compares GDP estimates under three scenarios: with the provisions enacted, without them, and if UK fiscal stimulus mirrors US levels.
- 'Parts of the United Kingdom' include England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland.
- The stimulus package suggested by President Biden could have added up to 134,000 jobs in Scotland.
- A different approach might result in approximately 1 million to 1.5 million additional jobs in England.
- The Scottish Parliament's Budget process often incorporates suggestions from opposition parties.
- The Finance (No. 2) Bill has completed its Committee stage.
- MP Jesse Norman thanked the Chair, Sir Gary Streeter, Hansard, Whips, parliamentary private secretaries, and officials for their support during the Committee stage.
- External stakeholders from organisations such as ATT, CIOT, ICAEW, and Low Incomes Tax Reform Group provided constructive input.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy