<-- Back to proposed bills
Victims and Prisoners Bill - Sitting 9
04 July 2023
Type
Public Bill Committee
At a Glance
Issue Summary
The statement addresses the Victims' Commissioner's role and proposes changes to enhance their authority and effectiveness. Stewart Hosie discusses clauses 17 to 20 of the Victims and Prisoners Bill, which relate to enhancing oversight by criminal justice inspectorates for better treatment of victims. The statement discusses Clause 21 of the Victims and Prisoners Bill, which aims to simplify the process for victims to escalate complaints directly to the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman. The statement discusses the consensus and challenges surrounding a clause that aims to improve the ability of victims to complain to the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman (PHSO). Stewart Hosie is discussing the Victims and Prisoners Bill, specifically Amendment 89 which aims to require joint strategic needs assessments (JSNAs) for victims of domestic abuse. The statement addresses the amendment proposed by the hon. Lady regarding joint strategic needs assessments for victim support services and the importance of tailored local support. Stewart Hosie is addressing concerns about the Victims and Prisoners Bill's funding strategy for victim support services. MP Stewart Hosie is discussing new clause 19 regarding the commissioning of specialist women's community-based domestic abuse and sexual violence support services. MP Jess Phillips discusses the limitations of the Victims and Prisoners Bill regarding support for victims of domestic abuse and sexual violence, emphasizing the need for specialist services. The statement discusses the need for specialist support services for victims of domestic abuse, including children in schools, older adults, and those from minority backgrounds. The discussion focuses on amendments to ensure local authorities create specialist women's community-based domestic abuse and sexual violence support services based on need. The statement addresses the need for local authorities and commissioners to prioritize victim support services, particularly for women affected by domestic abuse and sexual violence. Stewart Hosie is proposing amendments to the Victims and Prisoners Bill to expand the duty to collaborate on victim support services to include child victims, victims of fraud, and victims of modern slavery. Anna McMorrin is discussing amendments to the Victims and Prisoners Bill, focusing on extending the duty to collaborate to include child victims and victims of fraud. The statement discusses the need for clearer support and collaboration among agencies for victims of modern slavery and fraud. The statement discusses amendments to expand the duty to collaborate for victim support services, particularly regarding fraud and modern slavery. Edward Argar addresses concerns about the Victims and Prisoners Bill, focusing on serious violence and modern slavery.
Action Requested
The clause introduces a requirement for the Victims' Commissioner to lay annual reports in Parliament, mandates departments and agencies to respond within 56 days to recommendations made by the commissioner in published reports, and expands the scope of agencies subject to the commissioner's recommendations.
Key Facts
- Clause 16 aims to raise the profile and effectiveness of the Victims’ Commissioner.
- The clause requires the Victims' Commissioner to lay annual reports in Parliament.
- Departments and agencies must respond within 56 days to recommendations made by the commissioner in published reports.
- Clauses 17 to 20 introduce measures to enhance oversight of victims' treatment in criminal justice agencies.
- HM Inspectorate of Prisons oversees prison responsibilities towards victims.
- HM Inspectorate of Probation oversees the delivery of probation's responsibilities towards victims, including the victim contact scheme.
- Clause 21 simplifies the process for victims to escalate complaints directly to the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman.
- Victims may complain either personally or through a nominated representative such as a friend or relative.
- The PHSO can recommend actions like preventing future issues, issuing apologies, making payments, and reporting non-compliance to Parliament.
- The ombudsman, Rob Behrens, is praised for his work.
- There is a broad consensus within the Committee on the measure being discussed.
- The clause aims to make it easier for people to complain to the PHSO.
- The amendment is supported by the Domestic Abuse Commissioner Nicole Jacobs.
- In November last year, the Domestic Abuse Commissioner released a report titled “A Patchwork of Provision” highlighting discrepancies in domestic abuse services across England and Wales.
- Fewer than half of survivors were able to access community-based support they wanted; 35% found it easy or straightforward to access help.
- Over 70% of survivors who needed support for their children could not access it, only 7% received perpetrator intervention support.
- Only 23% of survivors needing work-related support and 27% seeking financial assistance were able to get it.
- JSNAs provide a comprehensive picture by drawing from data on social, demographic, and economic characteristics in an area.
- The amendment would require relevant authorities in police areas to conduct joint strategic needs assessments.
- These assessments would inform the strategy for commissioning victim support services.
- The Secretary of State is required to publish a statement every three years assessing current support for victims of domestic abuse.
- The Victims funding strategy was published last May.
- Clause 13(3) requires relevant authorities to have regard to any assessment of victims' needs when preparing their joint strategy.
- Subsection (1B) of amendment 89 would require the Secretary of State to provide a statement every three years on support available for domestic abuse victims.
- The proposed new clause would establish a duty for local authorities to commission specific support services.
- Services include counselling, legal advice, helplines, outreach initiatives, and more.
- The Secretary of State must define 'specialist community-based services' in collaboration with the violence against women and girls sector.
- The Bill risks having a good title but lacking substantive provisions for victims' support.
- Phillips has tabled an amendment to ensure that police and crime commissioners, local authorities, and health bodies must commission specialist women's community services.
- 70% of domestic abuse victims rely on community-based services currently available.
- Surviving Economic Abuse reports that 95% of domestic abuse victim-survivors experience economic abuse.
- 57% of women in prison and under community supervision are victims of domestic abuse.
- 63% of girls and young women aged 16 to 24 have experienced rape or domestic abuse in an intimate partner relationship.
- A study found an 82% reduction in physical abuse among participants in the Drive Project's perpetrator intervention programme.
- Only 7% of survivors who wanted their perpetrators to receive support were able to access it.
- There were 1.8 million stalking victims in 2022, but less than 1% received support from specialist stalking advocates.
- Amendments aim to place a duty on relevant local authorities to create specialist women’s community-based domestic abuse and sexual violence support services.
- Grants are provided by the Department to police and crime commissioners (PCCs) for commissioning practical, emotional, and therapeutic support services in their areas.
- The rape and sexual abuse support fund is nationally commissioned to fill gaps in provision.
- Government aims to set expected standards for commissioning victim support services.
- Clause 13(2) requires relevant authorities to consult with persons representing victims' interests and providers of specialist services.
- The Government published a revised strategic policing requirement in February 2023 focusing on violence against women and girls.
- £125 million has been awarded through the safer streets fund and safety of women at night fund.
- Up to £3.3 million is allocated for Domestic Abuse Matters training across police forces.
- Amendment 9 aims to include child victims in collaborative duty.
- Amendment 19 seeks to cover victims of fraud under the collaborative support services provision.
- Amendment 82 proposes extending support to victims of modern slavery.
- Amendment 9 seeks to extend the duty to collaborate to include victim support services for child victims.
- According to Victim Support, children and young people are disproportionately more likely to be victims of crime.
- UK Finance reports that over £1.2 billion was stolen through fraud in 2022.
- In the year ending December 2022, 3.7 million offences were reported to the crime survey for England and Wales, equating to 41% of total offences.
- The Centre for Social Justice supports the amendment to cover support services for modern slavery victims.
- Local authorities often lack clarity on their responsibilities towards supporting victims of modern slavery.
- In 2012, 2,629 people were jailed for fraud, but in the last year, this figure dropped to 1,177 despite an increase in offences from 441,000 to 3.7 million.
- Action Fraud often fails to provide adequate response or support to victims of fraud.
- The duty to collaborate requires local commissioning bodies to work together for support services for domestic abuse, sexual abuse, and serious violent crimes.
- £400 million over three years has been allocated to tackle economic crime including fraud.
- MAAF hubs should be rolled out across all England and Wales by September.
- Child victims are covered under the current definition of victim in part 1 of the Bill.
- Modern slavery victims can be captured by the duty if they have suffered conduct that constitutes domestic abuse, sexual abuse or other serious violent crimes.
- The definition of serious violence in the duty mirrors the approach taken from the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022.
- Independent child trafficking guardians have been rolled out to two thirds of local authorities in England and Wales by Barnardo’s until March 2024.
- Adult victims of modern slavery can access support through the national referral mechanism under the Government-funded modern slavery victim care contract delivered by the Salvation Army.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy