<-- Back to proposed bills
Energy Bill [Lords] - Sitting 17 (Afternoon)
27 June 2023
Type
Public Bill Committee
At a Glance
Issue Summary
The debate focuses on new clause 44 regarding the removal of 'Maximum Economic Recovery' in the North Sea from the Petroleum Act 1998 and new clause 45 which proposes a strategy for increasing electricity storage facilities. Alan Brown moves a new clause in support of pumped-storage hydro and other electricity storage solutions, calling for a fair pricing mechanism to encourage investment without subsidies. The statement addresses the importance of nuclear energy investment and the regulatory clarity provided for electricity storage through the Energy Bill. The statement discusses the need for a comprehensive strategy for energy storage, particularly carbon capture, usage, and storage (CCUS). The statement addresses the lack of concrete commitment from the Government regarding their £20 billion pledge on carbon capture and storage, specifically highlighting the importance of making this commitment binding. The statement discusses the UK Government's support for carbon capture, usage and storage (CCUS) projects, particularly the Acorn project in Scotland. The MP discusses the uncertainty and funding issues surrounding carbon capture and storage (CCS) projects in Scotland and other regions. The statement addresses considerations for hydrogen grid conversion trials and the consultation process required before conducting such trials. The statement discusses the proposed new clause that would prevent the issuance of new exploration licences for petroleum outside existing fields. The statement discusses the UK's role in reducing global oil and gas production to meet climate targets and proposes aligning with international efforts to limit exploration and extraction. The statement discusses a new clause that would ensure onshore wind installations are treated as local infrastructure for planning purposes. The statement addresses the government's approach to achieving a low-carbon energy economy, focusing on wind power as a key element. The discussion centres around proposed changes to national planning policy for onshore wind installations in England. Andrew Western discusses the challenges in increasing onshore wind energy production due to planning system barriers. The statement discusses a proposed new clause to implement a ban on issuing new fracking licences after January 1, 2024. The debate concerns the distinction between a moratorium and a ban on fracking, with the MP arguing that legislative action is necessary to bind future governments.
Action Requested
The speaker does not propose any specific actions but expresses hope that work will be done to remove maximum economic recovery off the statute book soon. Additionally, new clause 45 requests the Secretary of State to lay before Parliament a strategy within six months of the Act's passage for increasing electricity storage facilities.
Key Facts
- New clause 44 aims to remove reference to Maximum Economic Recovery in the North Sea from the Petroleum Act 1998.
- New clause 45 requires the Secretary of State to produce a strategy within six months after the Act is passed.
- The strategy must cover various forms of electricity storage including battery, hydrogen, ammonia, adiabatic compressed air energy storage systems, and hydroelectric storage.
- Last year system-balancing costs reached £4.2 billion.
- Coire Glas has an estimated output of 1.5 GW and could generate enough power for 3 million homes for a 24-hour period.
- Coire Glas will cost approximately £1.5 billion with SSE committing £100 million to advance investigation and design works.
- Other projects like Red John, Glenmuckloch, Balliemeanoch, Corrievarkie could add 5 GW of additional storage capacity.
- The Scottish Renewables report estimates the creation of 15,000 jobs by 2035 and £6 billion in economic benefit for the UK economy.
- The Government's approach is to remove barriers, facilitate change, and spur innovation for all low-carbon flexibility technologies.
- Up to £69 million has been allocated to accelerate the commercialisation of longer-duration energy storage technologies.
- A business rates exemption for eligible electricity storage facilities will be in place from 2023 to 2035.
- There is a temporary zero VAT rate for battery storage when supplied as part of a qualifying material installation.
- The new clause requires the Secretary of State to bring forward legislation committing £20 billion in CCUS spending within one month of the Act being passed.
- Another clause aims to set out a timeline for track 2 CCUS projects within one month of the Act's passage.
- Track 2 CCUS projects refer to specific carbon capture, usage, and storage initiatives.
- The Government has pledged £20 billion over 20 years for carbon capture and storage starting from 2028.
- This commitment does not have a corresponding Budget line or legislation currently.
- Acorn carbon capture cluster received only £40 million from the UK Government, while the Scottish Government provided £80 million.
- The Peterhead facility's emissions need to be addressed by carbon capture and storage projects for Scotland to meet its 2030 emission reduction target.
- UK Government has spent £40 million supporting the Acorn project.
- Track 1 selected two clusters, including a reserve cluster (Acorn).
- Track 2 will select further two clusters to be deployed by 2030.
- The government aims to capture and store 20-30 million tonnes of CO2 per year by 2030.
- The Scottish Acorn cluster is seeking funding support.
- Investors are experiencing uncertainty about future commitments from the Government.
- The economy is currently strained, and additional funding would likely impact energy bills or taxes.
- Hydrogen trials require financial support.
- Two final proposals for the village trial have been received from gas transporters after extensive consultation.
- An independent external source like a local council must validate strong community support for selecting the trial location.
- The Health and Safety Executive will need to confirm that any community trial can be run safely before proceeding.
- No new licences to search and bore for petroleum will be issued after 1 January 2024.
- The article in Nature states nearly 60% of oil and fossil methane gas, and 90% of coal must remain unextracted to limit warming to 1.5°C.
- The International Energy Agency's roadmap for net zero by 2050 concludes no new oil and gas fields should be approved beyond those committed as of 2021.
- World consensus and academic research indicate that leaving oil and gas reserves untouched is necessary to limit global warming to 1.5°C.
- UK demand for oil and gas has been declining, expected to accelerate as vehicles transition to electric and homes move away from gas heating.
- The new clause seeks to prevent the approval of new exploration licences in the future, aligning with international efforts but is not pressing for a vote.
- New Clause 56 aims to treat onshore wind installations as local infrastructure for planning purposes.
- Regulations under this new clause may amend any primary legislation passed before the passage of this Act.
- The clause is designed to ensure that onshore wind projects are permitted or otherwise regulated in a manner similar to other forms of local infrastructure.
- The UK aims for a low-carbon economy by either 2035 or 2030 according to the Government and Opposition respectively.
- Current offshore wind energy development is around 14 GW or 15 GW.
- Onshore wind deployment has been effectively banned since 2015 in England, leading to a virtual standstill with only three turbines put up recently.
- Onshore wind is currently the cheapest form of renewable energy.
- Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall sent a letter to Secretaries of State expressing concerns about the potential reneging on promises to lift the onshore wind ban.
- The UK has around 15 GW of onshore wind installed, making it the largest renewable technology in the country.
- Onshore wind generated approximately 10% of electricity in the UK last year.
- Fewer than half of local authorities have an up-to-date local plan.
- Only 11% of local authorities have been able to bring forward a local plan that addresses onshore wind.
- The austerity measures since 2010 have decimated local authority planning departments.
- New clause 58 aims to prohibit hydraulic fracturing after January 1, 2024.
- There is currently a presumption against issuing further hydraulic fractoring consents in the UK.
- The Government's position aligns with the 2019 Conservative manifesto commitment not to support fracking unless it can be proven safe.
- The Minister used the term “moratorium” but not “ban”.
- A vote was held with 5 Ayes and 9 Noes, resulting in the negation of the clause.
- Further consideration is ordered for Thursday 29 June at half-past Eleven o’clock.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy