<-- Back to proposed bills
Victims and Prisoners Bill - Sitting 4
22 June 2023
Type
Public Bill Committee
At a Glance
Issue Summary
Edward Leigh facilitates testimony from Jenni Hicks, a Hillsborough justice campaigner, who shares her experience and the need for an independent public advocate panel. Jenni Hicks discusses the importance of an independent public advocate for families affected by major disasters like Hillsborough. The statement discusses the importance of an independent public advocate for victims' families following major disasters. Edward Leigh acknowledges Kimia Zabihyan's testimony regarding her involvement with Grenfell Next of Kin and the impact of the Grenfell Tower tragedy on the local community. Kimia Zabihyan discusses the need for an independent public advocate in response to disasters and tragedies. Edward Leigh is chairing a session during the examination of witnesses for the Victims and Prisoners Bill, focusing on legal aid provision and the roles of the Independent Public Advocate (IPA). Sophie Cartwright discusses confusion surrounding the role of the Independent Public Advocate (IPA) in providing support to victims after major incidents. The statement discusses the function and effectiveness of the Independent Public Advocate (IPA) in supporting victims of major incidents. Edward Leigh is concluding the session and thanking Sophie Cartwright for her testimony regarding the Victims and Prisoners Bill.
Action Requested
No specific action is requested in this statement; Edward Leigh allows Jenni Hicks to testify about her experiences and呼吁设立独立的公共辩护人团队,以确保类似情况不会再次发生。
Key Facts
- Jenni Hicks testified as a Hillsborough justice campaigner.
- Hicks described the tragic events of April 15, 1989, where she lost two daughters in the Hillsborough disaster.
- It took 23 years for families to receive truth from the Hillsborough Independent Panel and another four years for correct inquest verdicts.
- Jenni Hicks experienced a lack of support from authorities after the Hillsborough disaster.
- It took 23 years to have transparency about what happened at Hillsborough in 2012.
- The Hillsborough Independent Panel provided necessary documentation and evidence leading to truth and correct verdicts.
- Jenni Hicks experienced a significant lack of funding compared to the opposing side during the inquest, with her family paying £3,500 for a junior barrister while the other side had 12 top QCs and their teams.
- The Hillsborough families received death certificates stating "accidental death" initially but later reissued ones stating "unlawfully killed" after a 23-year wait.
- Hicks emphasizes that an independent advocate should be immediately available to prevent cover-ups and provide essential support.
- Kimia Zabihyan is a volunteer and member of Grenfell Next of Kin.
- The majority (85%) of those who died in the Grenfell Tower tragedy were black and brown people, many of whom were recent migrants.
- There was initially reluctance to discuss race in relation to the disaster.
- Kimia Zabihyan has been acting as a pro bono public advocate for six years.
- The current proposal allows Ministers to appoint, set terms of reference, arrange remuneration, and dismiss the public advocate.
- An independent advocate needs power to make policy interventions at ministerial level.
- Sophie Cartwright KC, a barrister at Deans Court Chambers, testified.
- Legal aid for victims of major incidents should be non-means-tested to ensure access to necessary advice and support.
- The IPA is not intended to provide legal activity but rather to offer guidance in a daunting landscape.
- The IPA is not meant to be a legal advocate but provides support as deemed appropriate.
- There will likely be delays due to the process of appointing an IPA after major incidents occur.
- Cartwright suggests having someone already in post with a trauma focus and psychological expertise.
- Sophie Cartwright discusses the IPA's function and effectiveness.
- IPA was initially proposed to help victims like those affected by Hillsborough tragedy.
- The speaker suggests that an existing IPA could have assisted Manchester Arena bombing victims.
- Edward Leigh thanked Ms Cartwright for her detailed analysis of the Bill's implications.
- The session was ordered adjourned for further consideration.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy