<-- Back to proposed bills
Energy Bill [Lords] - Sitting 2
23 May 2023
Type
Public Bill Committee
At a Glance
Issue Summary
Alan Whitehead is addressing clause 7 of the Energy Bill, discussing the power to grant licences for carbon capture projects. Alan Whitehead discusses Clause 8 of the Energy Bill, which grants the Secretary of State the power to create different types of licences for carbon capture and storage activities. Alan Whitehead discusses the importance of implementing a 'fit and proper' persons test in licensing arrangements for carbon capture and storage activities to prevent unreliable entities from obtaining licences. The statement discusses the provisions of the Energy Bill related to carbon capture, usage, and storage (CCUS) cluster sequencing and licensing processes. The discussion focuses on the discretionary power for future competitive licensing of carbon capture and storage (CCUS) licences and the conditions under which economic licences are granted. The statement discusses the publication of standard conditions for licences and their modification. The statement discusses the ambiguity in the Energy Bill regarding the definition of the economic regulator. Alan Whitehead discusses the unclear mechanism for ending the Secretary of State's power to grant interim licences and transitioning this authority to Ofgem. Alan Whitehead is discussing the transfer of licences in the event of a termination event and emphasizes the need for 'fit and proper people' to take over. The statement discusses clauses in the Energy Bill regarding appeals for licence modification decisions related to carbon dioxide transport and storage, focusing on the role of the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) in these processes. Alan Whitehead addresses concerns about the powers granted to the CMA under the Energy Prices Act 2022 and questions whether these powers need to be restricted. Alan Whitehead discusses the vagueness of clause 30 regarding the requirement for impact assessments. The statement addresses concerns over the clarity of legislation governing energy impact assessments and regulatory processes.
Action Requested
Whitehead requests more clarity on the interim period during which the Secretary of State grants licences and the expertise available during this time. He also seeks details on when the first licences will be granted by both the Secretary of State and Ofgem, and how these licences comply with standardisation requirements.
Key Facts
- Clause 7 pertains to the grant of licences for carbon capture projects.
- The interim period allows the Secretary of State to grant licences before transferring responsibility to Ofgem.
- Licences will be granted in the mid-2020s for track 1 CCS clusters.
- Clause 8 grants the Secretary of State power to create different types of licences for carbon capture and storage activities.
- Whitehead's amendments aim to ensure that only fit and proper persons can receive licences or transfer them under various clauses of the Energy Bill.
- Amendment 77 aims to introduce a fit and proper persons test for licensing carbon capture and storage activities.
- The amendments would affect the licence application, transfer, special administrative regime, and transfer schemes.
- LCCC is expected to be the counterparty for low-carbon hydrogen agreements.
- Amendment 1 corrects a drafting error related to consultation with devolved Administrations.
- The Government’s CCUS cluster sequencing programme is underway to identify eligible clusters for support.
- Clause 9 provides for a licence application process set out in regulations, including procedures and conditions.
- Fees will be proportional to the size of entities applying for licences.
- Clause 8 enables discretionary power for future licensing.
- Clause 11 makes general provisions regarding conditions of transport and storage economic licences.
- The clause confirms that the licence may contain conditions requiring a payment to be made to the economic regulator during the term of the licence.
- Clause 12 enables the Secretary of State to specify standard conditions for licences.
- Subsection (2) allows the Secretary of State to publish conditions in whatever manner they consider appropriate.
- Alan Whitehead expresses concern that publication may be restricted or inappropriate.
- The Minister assures that information will be published widely and easily accessible.
- Andrew Bowie confirms Ofgem as the economic regulator.
- Clause 1 sets out that the economic regulator refers to Ofgem.
- The Bill includes provisions for the Secretary of State to grant licences during an interim period.
- The clause refers to schedule 1 which outlines interim power of the Secretary of State to grant licences.
- There is concern about how and when this interim power will be transferred from the Secretary of State to Ofgem.
- The Minister commits to providing a road map for CCUS with increased clarity on timescales.
- Carbon dioxide transport and storage licences cannot be bought or sold separate from the legal entity they are granted to.
- Clause 18 of the Energy Bill allows for carbon dioxide transport and storage licences to be transferred with Ofgem's consent.
- The economic regulator must notify the Secretary of State before giving consent to a licence transfer.
- Clauses 20 to 25 relate to appeals for licence modification decisions made by the economic regulator for carbon dioxide transport and storage.
- Appeals can be brought to the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) with its permission, addressing matters such as being trivial or vexatious.
- Schedule 2 outlines detailed processes for appealing CMA decisions, including timeframes of four months for most appeals and six months for price control decisions.
- The Energy Prices Act 2022 grants significant powers to the Secretary of State in the energy sphere.
- Clause 20(4) allows the CMA to refuse permission for an appeal on fairly wide grounds.
- Clause 22(4) permits the CMA to limit appeals based on errors of fact.
- Clause 30 is vague about whether impact assessments should be undertaken.
- The clause does not define what 'important' means, leaving it open to subjective judgment by the economic regulator.
- There are multiple grounds under which an impact assessment can be voided or avoided.
- The government aims to provide as much clarity as possible about how the energy sector is governed.
- There are concerns over subjective interpretations of impact assessments.
- Vaguer language could lead to judicial reviews.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy