<-- Back to proposed bills

Tobacco and Vapes Bill - Sitting 3

01 May 2024

Proposing MP
Mitcham and Morden
Type
Public Bill Committee

At a Glance

Issue Summary

Siobhain McDonagh introduces a panel of chief medical officers who provide evidence in support of the Tobacco and Vapes Bill. The discussion focuses on the impact of the Tobacco and Vapes Bill on pregnant women and unborn babies, highlighting its potential to reduce smoking during pregnancy and improve health outcomes. The MPs discuss the detrimental health effects of smoking and vaping on individuals and society, including costs to the NHS and impacts on families. The statement addresses concerns about the impact of vaping on young people and the marketing practices surrounding vape products. The speakers discuss the Tobacco and Vapes Bill, focusing on its aim to restrict vape sales to under-18s and prevent family members from buying vapes on their behalf. Siobhain McDonagh is managing the timing of the committee meeting and ensuring that all members have an opportunity to speak before concluding the session. The statement discusses the Tobacco and Vapes Bill and its impact on vaping products, particularly focusing on flavour bans and their potential risks to ex-smokers and young people. Siobhain McDonagh closes the Committee session on questioning witnesses about youth vaping and its impact. The statement discusses the negative health impacts of smoking during pregnancy and its effects on newborns' health outcomes. The discussion focuses on the impact of vaping and smoking on public health, particularly in relation to pregnant women and children. The statement discusses the impact of tobacco and vaping on public health, particularly focusing on the support for the Tobacco and Vapes Bill aimed at reducing smoking rates among pregnant women and protecting children. The statement discusses the potential harms of nicotine and vaping on children's health and development. Siobhain McDonagh is managing time for remaining questions during a discussion on the Tobacco and Vapes Bill. The statement addresses the impact of vaping on children and potential bans on vaping in public places.

Action Requested

The chief medical officers strongly support the Bill, arguing that it is crucial for public health. They call for Ministers to have powers to regulate flavours as well as packaging, colours, and other areas to prevent the vape industry from undermining the Bill's aims.

Key Facts

  • Professor Sir Chris Whitty, Sir Francis Atherton, Professor Sir Michael McBride, and Professor Sir Gregor Ian Smith gave evidence.
  • The panel stresses that tobacco is highly addictive in all forms and causes significant health issues.
  • The chief medical officers argue that the Bill supports choice by preventing addiction rather than removing it.
  • There is a consensus across the medical community supporting the Bill.
  • Smoking in pregnancy affects stillbirth, premature birth, small for dates babies, and birth deformities.
  • Pregnant women in their late teens or early twenties have the highest rate of smoking.
  • In Northern Ireland, smoking rates are over three times higher in the most deprived areas compared to the least deprived areas.
  • In Scotland in 2023, there were 5,500 pregnancies where the mother was recorded as still being a smoker and an additional 6,000 where the mother was a former smoker.
  • Wales aims to reduce smoking prevalence from about 13% currently to 5% by 2030 through the Bill.
  • In Wales, there are about 5,500 deaths each year from smoking-related diseases.
  • Hospital admissions due to smoking-related issues account for approximately 5% of overall hospital admissions in the over-35 group.
  • Northern Ireland sees more than 2,000 deaths annually directly attributable to smoking cigarettes.
  • Scotland has 9,000 deaths a year attributed to tobacco addiction and smoking, one death every 61 minutes.
  • The Scottish burden of disease study projects a 21% increase in the general burden of disease across Scotland by 2043.
  • The evidence suggests vaping is harmful to young people.
  • Sports companies are using their appeal to promote vape products.
  • Professor Sir Gregor Ian Smith and Professor Sir Chris Whitty agree on the need for stricter regulations.
  • The Bill aims to stop selling vapes to under-18s and prevent family members from buying on their behalf.
  • Over the last three years, vaping among children and young people has tripled.
  • No prescription vape products are currently available for use.
  • The committee has 14 minutes left before concluding.
  • Three members have not yet spoken and wish to do so.
  • Professor Sir Chris Whitty discusses the consensus on using some flavours to help smokers quit but warns of industry manipulation.
  • The Bill gives Ministers power to restrict product attractiveness to prevent attracting non-smokers and children.
  • Social media influencers are a concern in marketing vaping products, especially for young people.
  • The session ends at 10:55 am.
  • Professor Sir Stephen Powis is the national medical director of NHS England.
  • Kate Brintworth is the chief midwifery officer for NHS England.
  • Smoking is the single biggest modifiable risk factor for pregnant women.
  • Quit rates among pregnant women are between 30% and 40%.
  • Smoking increases stillbirths by 47%, doubles the likelihood of a baby not growing properly, and makes premature birth 27% more likely.
  • In deprived areas, 21% of pregnant women smoked at delivery in 2021-22 compared to 5.6% in least deprived areas.
  • Smoking is considered the most significant driver of health inequalities in the UK.
  • The Bill could prevent about 30,000 new cases of smoking-related lung cancer every year.
  • Vaping has a relatively small impact on the NHS compared to smoking but numbers are increasing.
  • Admissions related to vaping have doubled over recent years.
  • Nicotine crosses through the placental barrier affecting both mother and baby's health.
  • Smoking-related illnesses cost the NHS about £2.5 billion a year.
  • Professor Kamila Hawthorne works as a GP in a deprived area of Wales where she sees many patients with smoking-related chronic obstructive airways disease.
  • The speaker thanks witnesses for their information and acknowledges support from medical professionals for the Bill.
  • Nicotine is harmful and causes developmental issues in foetuses.
  • Vaping contains nicotine which affects learning outcomes and future economic productivity.
  • Long-term effects of vaping are not well understood beyond short-term risks like popcorn lung.
  • The session has about 13 or 14 minutes remaining.
  • Four Members want to ask questions.
  • Professor Turner notes that vaping in schools disrupts education and affects children with asthma.
  • Dr Caroline Johnson refers to testimony from Dr Helen Stewart about second-hand effects of vaping on children.
  • Professor Hawthorne supports the Tobacco and Vapes Bill as a landmark suggestion.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy