<-- Back to proposed bills
Tobacco and Vapes Bill - Sitting 2
30 April 2024
Type
Public Bill Committee
At a Glance
Issue Summary
MP Gary Streeter chairs a session where Councillor David Fothergill and Greg Fell discuss their views on the Tobacco and Vapes Bill. MPs are discussing enforcement measures, penalties, and packaging regulations for tobacco and vaping products under the Tobacco and Vapes Bill. The statement discusses the effectiveness of a complete ban on tobacco and vapes compared to raising the smoking age limit. Gary Streeter addresses concerns about the Tobacco and Vapes Bill, particularly regarding enforcement challenges and ideological views on vaping as a smoking cessation tool. Gary Streeter introduces Ailsa Rutter to provide evidence on the impact of tobacco smoking and vaping products. Ailsa Rutter discusses the importance of the Tobacco and Vapes Bill to tackle smoking-related issues, highlighting its role in promoting a societal shift towards healthier behaviors. Gary Streeter is managing a session discussing the Tobacco and Vapes Bill with Adrian Simpson, a policy adviser from the British Retail Consortium. Adrian Simpson discusses challenges and considerations related to the Tobacco and Vapes Bill, particularly regarding enforcement of age restrictions and licensing requirements. Gary Streeter is informing the committee about potential disruptions due to votes in the Chamber. The discussion focuses on the Tobacco and Vapes Bill and its implications for regulating illicit vape products. Gary Streeter addresses the need for concise questions and answers regarding the Tobacco and Vapes Bill. Gary Streeter is discussing potential measures to regulate vaping products similar to tobacco track-and-trace legislation. Gary Streeter is thanking John Herriman and Kate Pike for their clear and detailed testimony on the Tobacco and Vapes Bill. The statement discusses the environmental impacts of disposable vapes and cigarette butts. Gary Streeter responds to a question about the broader issue of disposable technology beyond vapes. The statement is about the adjournment of the committee session and the scheduling of remaining witness testimony for a future date.
Action Requested
Cllr Fothergill and Greg Fell request clarity from the Government regarding trading standards responsibilities, funding, apprenticeship funds for training new officers, sustainable investment in enforcement measures, and consideration of a licensing regime to ensure effective implementation of the Bill.
Key Facts
- Councillor David Fothergill is the deputy chair of the Local Government Association.
- Greg Fell is the president of the UK Association of Directors of Public Health.
- Local authorities need clarity on responsibilities, funding, and apprenticeship funds for trading standards officers.
- Trading standards in Sheffield regularly confiscates large quantities of illegal tobacco linked to organised crime.
- The fine size of £100 or £50 is deemed insufficient and needs review.
- Multi-local authority enforcement may be necessary due to the nature of organised crime networks.
- The current fine for selling tobacco to under-age individuals is £100, reduced to £50 if paid within 14 days.
- Cllr Fothergill supports moving vapes away from counters and restricting flavours to make them less accessible to children and younger people.
- Greg Fell suggests a licensing scheme for shisha bars due to the high tobacco consumption rate and potential lung damage.
- Greg Fell supports a complete ban on tobacco and vapes rather than raising the smoking age limit.
- Action on Smoking and Health has co-produced resource packs with local authorities, but these are insufficient by themselves.
- There is a risk of young people transitioning from vaping to smoking, as shown in a York schools survey where 42% of children think vaping is equally dangerous or more harmful than smoking.
- The Bill aims to set norms for tobacco and vape regulation.
- Some argue that excluding certain items might increase illicit trade, but this should not prevent proper funding and enforcement of trading standards.
- There is a concern about the unintended consequences of taking a tougher stance on vaping.
- Ailsa Rutter is the director of Fresh and Balance North East.
- In the north-east region since the turn of the millennium, 120,000 people have died from smoking.
- The regional programme has been running for 20 years and aims to drive down harms on both tobacco and alcohol.
- Cumbria has a smoking rate of about 12.3% at birth.
- About 3,500 hospital admissions, 74,000 GP appointments, and 80,000 sick days are caused by smoking-related illnesses in Cumbria annually.
- One in four beds in the north-east is occupied by someone with a smoking-related condition.
- Large retail sector represented by the British Retail Consortium is broadly supportive of the Tobacco and Vapes Bill.
- The Bill introduces £100 fixed penalty notices, restricted premises orders, and restricted sale orders as new enforcement powers.
- Trading standards need to ensure adequate notification to businesses about fines to prevent negative impacts on shop workers.
- The British Retail Consortium has been working closely with local authorities on the potential vape ban and age restrictions since they were announced.
- Adrian Simpson mentions concerns about education and enforcement of new regulations, including issues with changing point-of-sale systems and store layouts.
- There are challenges in distinguishing between customers who may be just above or below the legal age limit.
- Votes are expected in the Chamber from about 3.30 pm or 3.45 pm.
- The session might be cut short if votes start early, preventing later sessions.
- Colleagues need to be concise and efficient for the first 20 minutes of evidence gathering.
- The Bill provides enabling regulations to restrict vape product attractiveness to children.
- Illicit cigarette consumption has dropped from 17 billion in 2000 to between 2.5 and 3 billion currently.
- Trading standards collaborate with HMRC, Border Force, and other agencies on enforcement activities.
- The statement is about facilitating quick voting on the Tobacco and Vapes Bill.
- Gary Streeter calls for concise questions and answers from colleagues.
- Track-and-trace legislation on tobacco could potentially be applied to vapes.
- There is a consultation ongoing for vapes to become an excise product.
- The profession of trading standards has faced significant cuts in resources over the last decade.
- The Tobacco and Vapes Bill aims to tackle supply and demand issues around vaping products.
- Trading standards needs additional resources to enforce the age restrictions outlined in the Bill.
- There is support for extending track-and-trace systems used for tobacco products to vapes.
- Laura Young is a PhD researcher in environmental science.
- The number of disposable vapes quadrupled from 2022 to 2023, reaching about 5 million per week in 2023.
- Disposable vapes pose risks to waste workers due to lithium batteries causing fires.
- Cigarette butts are the No. 1 item littered globally.
- The question raised by Mary Foy addresses the broader issue of disposable technology and its environmental impact.
- Gary Streeter acknowledges the relevance but notes it is not within the scope of the Tobacco and Vapes Bill.
- Further consideration is ordered to be adjourned.
- The session is scheduled to resume on Wednesday, 1 May, at twenty-five past Nine o'clock.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy