<-- Back to proposed bills

Criminal Justice Bill - Sitting 10

18 January 2024

Proposing MP
N/A
Type
Public Bill Committee

At a Glance

Issue Summary

The statement discusses amendments to the Criminal Justice Act 2003 to include offenders convicted of coercive or controlling behaviour who receive a sentence of 12 months or more under multi-agency public protection arrangements. The statement discusses a clause aimed at automatically placing offenders convicted of coercive or controlling behavior for 12 months or more under category 2 Multi-Agency Public Protection Arrangements (MAPPA) management. The statement addresses the extension of mandatory polygraph testing for certain offenders under the Criminal Justice Bill. Laura Farris responds to Jonathan Hall's comments on polygraph testing and provides an example of where such measures were implemented. The statement discusses the categorisation of former terrorist offenders and the implications of retroactive provisions in law, specifically addressing concerns raised about the fairness and public interest of such measures. The statement discusses reforms to the confiscation regime under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 in England and Wales, addressing issues raised by the Law Commission. The statement discusses the draft legislation related to confiscation orders under Schedule 4 of the Criminal Justice Bill, specifically addressing the conditions and test for exercising powers to prevent the dissipation of assets. The statement discusses a proposed scheme to create suspended accounts for suspected criminal funds, allowing financial institutions to transfer these funds to a Government-appointed administrator for use in combating economic crime. The statement discusses the implementation and regulation of a scheme for releasing funds from suspended bank accounts suspected of criminal activity. The statement discusses proposed amendments to extend serious crime prevention orders (SCPOs) to Northern Ireland and introduce electronic monitoring requirements as part of SCPOs. The statement discusses the proposed changes to clause 34 of the Criminal Justice Bill regarding electronic monitoring requirements for serious crime prevention orders (SCPOs). The amendments to Clause 35 address changes to the applicants for serious crime prevention orders in England and Wales and Northern Ireland. The statement discusses amendments to the Criminal Justice Bill aimed at expanding the range of law enforcement agencies that can apply for a Serious Crime Prevention Order (SCPO) and standardizing notification requirements for individuals subject to SCPOs. The statement discusses the acceptance of a set of measures aimed at improving court system efficiency. The amendments aim to clarify jurisdictional differences and penalties for individuals subject to serious crime prevention orders in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland. The statement addresses amendments to clause 37 of the Criminal Justice Bill, which grants the Crown Court in Northern Ireland and England & Wales the power to impose Serious Crime Prevention Orders (SCPOs) on acquittal or when allowing an appeal. The speaker discusses the monitoring and review of the Serious Crime Prevention Order (SCPO) provision in the Criminal Justice Bill.

Action Requested

The Government proposes amending the Multi-Agency Public Protection Arrangements (MAPPA) to manage high-risk domestic abuse cases, including those involving coercive control. This builds on previous legislative actions and aims to disrupt potential abuse and prevent revictimisation by aligning coercive control with other violent offences.

Key Facts

  • The amendment applies to offenders convicted of coercive or controlling behaviour receiving a sentence of 12 months or more.
  • There was a 30% increase in the take-up of discretionary management under MAPPA for domestic abuse cases in the last reporting year.
  • Other violent offences connected with domestic abuse, such as threats to kill and actual/grievous bodily harm, are already eligible for automatic MAPPA management.
  • The Serious Crime Act creating the offence of coercive or controlling behaviour received Royal Assent in February 2015.
  • In 2022, 566 people were convicted of coercive control, and it is estimated that around 200 would have been eligible for MAPPA management if sentenced to 12 months or more.
  • The government supports the clause and welcomes its implementation as a means to protect victims from further harm.
  • Polygraphs have been used by the probation service since January 2014.
  • They are 80% to 90% effective in monitoring compliance with licence conditions.
  • A pilot for mandatory polygraph testing on domestic abuse perpetrators was enabled under the Domestic Abuse Act.
  • Jonathan Hall's comments on polygraphs for released terrorist offenders.
  • Polygraph measures were brought in shortly after an incident involving Usman Khan.
  • Polygraph conditions are set by the Secretary of State.
  • The government injected £155 million extra funding into the probation service annually.
  • Over 4,000 new recruits have been added to the probation service since 2021.
  • Amendment 37 excludes certain Scottish offences from inserted subsection (4BB).
  • Amendments include adding offences under sections 1 and 3 of the Criminal Justice Act 2024 to Schedule 5 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002.
  • Clause 32 introduces schedule 4 with reforms to POCA.
  • The Law Commission published its report in November 2022 with 119 recommendations.
  • The reforms aim to prevent criminals from retaining ill-gotten gains and make crime unprofitable.
  • The first test is that the first to fifth conditions in section POCA already apply.
  • Paragraph 25(2)(a) sets a critical phrase stating there must be 'a real risk' for relevant property being dissipated.
  • The court considers various factors, including the nature of the property and the circumstances of the person.
  • Clause 33 and schedule 5 will enshrine the power for the Secretary of State to create a suspended accounts scheme.
  • Financial institutions have been suspending customer accounts worth approximately £200 million due to suspected criminal activity.
  • An additional £30 million is expected to be suspended annually in future.
  • The funds would be used to finance projects related to economic crime.
  • The scheme aims to govern suspended bank accounts and the funds within them.
  • Organisations in the financial sector have been suspending accounts for 15 years based on private law and terms and conditions.
  • It is estimated that there are currently £200 million worth of suspended funds, with an expected annual flow of at least £30 million.
  • Financial institutions “may” take part in the scheme.
  • There is a compensation mechanism for individuals affected by account suspensions.
  • The Government anticipates wide industry participation and aims to ensure the scheme remains solvent.
  • Clauses 34 to 37 apply to England and Wales only as drafted.
  • Amendments extend the application of clauses to Northern Ireland.
  • SCPOs are currently underutilised since their introduction in the Serious Crime Act 2007.
  • The government has recognised the Bill’s weaknesses by tabling numerous amendments to clause 34.
  • Since the 2007 Act was passed, applications to the High Court for SCPOs have been significantly lower than anticipated.
  • Clause 34 aims to streamline the process for law enforcement agencies and place restrictions on offenders or suspected offenders to prevent further criminal activity.
  • The probation service has recruited an additional 4,000 staff members but is still facing challenges due to high caseloads and staffing shortages.
  • In the year to March 2023, 2,098 staff left the probation service, a 10% increase from the previous year.
  • The National Crime Agency’s budget increased by 21% between 2021-22 and 2023-24 from £711 million to £860 million.
  • Amendments 90-106 address changes to applicants for serious crime prevention orders.
  • The Serious Fraud Office, National Crime Agency, HM Revenue and Customs, and Ministry of Defence Police are listed as new applicants.
  • The amendments require certain authorities to consult the Director of Public Prosecutions before making applications in Northern Ireland.
  • Only two applications were made to the High Court for an SCPO between 2011 and 2021.
  • Additional agencies like the National Crime Agency, HMRC, police, British Transport Police, and Ministry of Defence Police will be given powers to apply for SCPOs.
  • The CPS evaluates application merits and can intervene if appropriate.
  • Notification requirements include personal data such as address, employment details, contact information, and financial information.
  • Individuals must notify the police within three days after an order comes into force.
  • The Minister and the speaker have interacted over several years.
  • This set of measures improves court system efficiency.
  • Automatic addition of information will ease future monitoring.
  • Amendments clarify jurisdiction for offences under serious crime prevention orders.
  • Penalties are specified for summary conviction in both England/Wales and Northern Ireland.
  • Definitions and requirements related to user-to-user services and false notifications are introduced.
  • Clause 37 amends the Serious Crime Act 2007.
  • The Crown court can now impose an SCPO on acquittal or when allowing an appeal if certain tests are met.
  • These orders apply to serious crimes such as slavery, drug trafficking, and terrorism.
  • Post-legislative review will occur three to five years after Royal Assent.
  • SCPOs can be issued immediately at the point of acquittal without a separate High Court application.
  • The purpose is to ensure that SCPOs are applied in all cases where they could protect the public.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy