Topical Questions

2026-09-15

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Context
The Courts and Tribunals Bill is under consideration. The backlog of Crown court cases has more than doubled from around 38,000 in 2019 to over 80,000 today, delaying justice for victims.
I am concerned about the Courts and Tribunals Bill and the rising Crown court backlog. The backlog has more than doubled from around 38,000 cases in 2019 to over 80,000 today. Despite investments in modernisation, victims are still facing significant delays. Will the government make a statement on their departmental responsibilities to address this backlog and ensure justice is not diminished?
As I have mentioned, the Courts and Tribunals Bill will shortly come back to this House. The record and rising Crown court backlog we inherited has more than doubled from around 38,000 cases in 2019 to more than 80,000 today, denying victims justice for months or even years. To fix the system, as the Minister for Courts and Legal Services has said, we have invested in and continued to modernise the courts, and through the returning legislation, we have set in train much-needed structural reform. The Prime Minister has been clear that the answer to justice delayed cannot be justice diminished. We are looking again at the proposals, considering the evidence and listening to experts both inside and outside this House and, of course, to victims.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a direct statement on departmental responsibilities
Under Review Considering The Evidence
Response accuracy
Q2 Direct Answer
Context
Court backlogs in the south-east have trebled over the last decade, placing extreme pressure on the criminal justice system. A new justice quarter in Milton Keynes could provide extra capacity and faster access to justice for constituents.
Court backlogs in the south-east have trebled over the last decade, placing extreme pressure on our criminal justice system. A new justice quarter in Milton Keynes could provide extra capacity that would deliver faster access to justice for my constituents in the Buckingham and Bletchley constituency and a modern justice hub in one of the fastest-growing cities in the UK. Will my right hon. Friend grant me a meeting, alongside my Milton Keynes colleagues, to discuss how we can take that proposition forward?
I recognise the ambition of local partners to develop a justice quarter in Milton Keynes. I know that engagement has gone on—indeed, the Courts Minister is going to meet MPs—and that the Milton Keynes MPs are hunting in a pack on this matter. I think I have already committed to a visit, which I am sure I will make shortly. In the meantime, the Minister looks forward to meeting my hon. Friend.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q3 Direct Answer
Context
The Government held five different positions on early release in just six weeks. They are now using secondary legislation to exclude certain types of offenders from early release, despite previous claims that this was impossible.
This summer, the Government held five different positions on early release in just six weeks. In seeking to exclude killers, rapists and paedophiles—something the Government previously claimed was impossible—the Justice Secretary has used secondary legislation. He says: 'No further legislation is required in the short term... primary legislation will... be considered when Parliamentary time allows.' Will the Secretary of State guarantee that after relying on secondary legislation to change Labour's early release scheme, no prisoner will successfully challenge their exclusion in the courts?
Yes, I give the hon. Gentleman the assurance that I have no concerns in that regard. The device we used was the commencement order. We chose to commence the provisions for some offences, but not for others. The point I was making to him in writing was that for parliamentarians it is discomfiting to have things lying on the statute book that are not intended for use, so it is good practice to remove them. It would not be without precedent for many provisions to be on the statute book without being turned on; nevertheless, that is what I was referring to in respect of further legislation. I am confident in our legal position.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Context
The Justice Secretary proposes to release prisoners serving imprisonment for public protection sentences despite their being assessed as too dangerous for release or returned to prison due to their behaviour. In the past year, 426 prisoners were assessed as too dangerous for release.
The Justice Secretary proposes to let another set of dangerous criminals out of prison as well. Every prisoner serving an imprisonment for public protection sentence has been assessed to be too dangerous for release or returned to prison because of their behaviour—last year, there were 426 of them. The Justice Secretary has reiterated his commitment today to ending IPP sentences by the end of this Parliament. Will he tell the House very clearly if he has decided that it is, indeed, safe to release every single one of them?
I understand that the hon. Gentleman is a champion of individual liberty, and I understand him to be someone who believes in the equal application of liberty for individuals too. He must, surely, share my discomfort that there are individuals with tariffs of 18 months who have served 18 years on those sentences. This has been a matter of consensus for a long period of time; that is why his colleagues, when in government, discontinued those sentences. That is not to say that it is easy. In exactly the spirit in which he says that it must be done safely, my commitment is to do that with him and with colleagues across the House.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a clear commitment on safety of release
It Is Not Easy
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Context
The Government have promised to halve violence against women and girls, but charging and conviction rates for perpetrators have fallen sharply over the past decade, affecting victim confidence in the justice system.
The Government have promised to halve violence against women and girls. In the context of the charging and conviction of perpetrators falling sharply over the past decade, which has affected the confidence that victims have in the justice system, what measures are the Government taking to ensure that perpetrators are brought to justice?
My hon. Friend is a stalwart campaigner on tackling violence against women and girls, and he will know that pursuing and punishing perpetrators is a key pillar of our strategy to halve it. We have a 10-year plan to meet this ambitious goal, and we are carefully monitoring the progress and will publish our one year update in the coming months. I want to reassure him that rape charge volumes have more than doubled since 2019, and that 5,206 rape cases were brought before the courts in 2025, compared with just 1,684 in 2019.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify measures currently being taken
We Have A Plan
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Context
The Liberal Democrats have secured an amendment to address the injustice of locked child trust funds for disabled children. This issue has been a long-standing campaign for the Liberal Democrats, especially for their leader who has personal experience with this issue.
The Liberal Democrats in the other place have secured an amendment to address the injustice of locked child trust funds for disabled children. The leader of the Liberal Democrats has experience of this issue with his own disabled son, and he has been a passionate campaigner for a change in the law for many years, working with other campaigners such as Andrew Turner. When the amendment comes back to this House, will the Labour Government support it?
The hon. Lady is absolutely right to raise this issue. Some 80,000 disabled people are unable to access funds that are legally theirs, and that is a disgrace. This is a complex issue, because mental capacity is a complex area of law and we must have due regard to the safeguarding mechanisms, but it cannot be beyond the wit of this place, or indeed of the Government, to overcome that obstacle. I met the leader of the Liberal Democrats last week to discuss this issue, and we are going to make progress in the coming weeks.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to support the amendment
It Is A Complex Issue
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Context
High street law firms are concerned about the government's proposals to take a proportion of interest earned on client accounts, which may affect their viability.
I recently met a high street law firm that has offices in Whitby, Scarborough and Filey. As a small company, it worries that the Government's proposals to take a proportion of the interest earned on client accounts could lead it to shed jobs and, potentially, premises. Will the Minister outline what assessment she has made of the impact of these proposals on the viability of high street solicitors?
We recognise the vital role that high street law firms play in serving communities such as Scarborough and Whitby, and I greatly valued the meeting that we had, in which my hon. Friend raised a number of concerns in relation to the consultation that is currently being undertaken, in which we are engaging extensively with stakeholders to ensure that the potential impacts of the proposals—which are targeted, by the way, at access to justice—and all views are carefully considered.
Assessment & feedback
Specific impact assessment not provided
Engaging Extensively With Stakeholders
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Andrew Murrison Con
South West Wiltshire
Context
Prison officers face delays in receiving their pensions and lump sums due to incompetence of MyCSP, Equiniti, and Capita.
Prison officers do an increasingly tough job that most of us would not want to do or could not do, and the least they should be able to expect is to have their pensions and lump sums paid on time, yet thanks to the incompetence of MyCSP, Equiniti and now Capita, that is not happening. What is the Minister going to do about it?
I absolutely agree with the right hon. Gentleman, and I am working with Cabinet colleagues to make sure that prison officers who have worked hard all their lives in, as he says, incredibly challenging circumstances get the retirement they deserve.
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions not provided
Working With Cabinet Colleagues
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Sharon Hodgson Lab
Washington and Sunderland West
Context
The backlog of cases in Newcastle Crown Court has reached an unprecedented high.
I visited Newcastle Crown court before the summer recess, where I learned that the backlog of cases had reached an unprecedented high. As we have heard, measures such as the blitz courts in Teesside, which were mentioned earlier, and specialist sexual offences and domestic abuse courts can help with this backlog. Will the Minister ensure that the Crown Prosecution Service and the police take ownership of the backlog with realistic reviews, and will she outline what measures she is taking to reduce the backlog in Newcastle?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right to say that cross-criminal justice system working between the police, the Crown Prosecution Service, the judiciary and our Courts Service is vital. I know that steps have been taken in Newcastle. Some agility has been shown on courtroom capacity and case progression, which is starting to bear results, and I encourage more of that right across our Crown court system.
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures not provided
Steps Have Been Taken Agility Has Been Shown
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Context
Citizens Advice offices in Bridport and Dorchester are reporting huge demand for their services due to cuts in legal aid, particularly in housing, welfare, and immigration law.
Citizens Advice offices in Bridport and Dorchester are reporting huge demand for their services as a result of cuts to legal aid, especially in housing, welfare and immigration law. What steps is the Minister taking to restore sustainable legal aid provision and ensure that rural advice services are properly funded?
Early legal advice is absolutely essential to access to justice, and that is why one of the first actions we took when I became the Minister responsible for legal aid was to give legal aid lawyers delivering immigration and housing advice the first pay lift they had received since 1996—an injection of £20 million. That was precisely because of the issues the hon. Gentleman raises.
Assessment & feedback
Specific steps not provided
Early Legal Advice Is Essential
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
A constituent struggled to get clarity about what protections would be put in place during evidence delivery and whether their victim personal statement was properly considered during sentencing.
Vulnerable victims and witnesses of crime deserve full and proactive support from the Crown Prosecution Service and the police. Yet one of my constituents struggled to get clarity about what protections would be put in place should they give evidence in court, and also whether their victim personal statement was even properly considered during the sentencing stage of the trial. Will the Minister outline what is being done to better support victims, particularly vulnerable witnesses, to ensure they get proper advocacy in the court system?
My hon. Friend is right to raise this issue. He is correct that special measures help vulnerable witnesses and victims to give evidence and reduce the stress in attending court. These include the use of screens, live video links and pre-recorded evidence. He will know that the Courts and Tribunals Bill, which is due to come back to this place soon, includes reforms to special measures, including clarifying that vulnerable witnesses and victims may use them when delivering their personal statements. We have also revised the victims code to ensure that this is taken into account.
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures not detailed
Special Measures Help
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Context
Ministry of Justice contractors are causing delays and affecting local residents in the construction of a new mega-prison adjacent to HMP Grendon.
Ministry of Justice contractors are acting in a deeply inconsiderate manner, affecting my constituents in Edgcott, Grendon Underwood and the Springhill Road estate in the construction of a new mega-prison adjacent to HMP Grendon. I asked the Minister in writing over the summer if she would come and see with her own eyes those problems. She wrote back to me yesterday to say no. Why will she not, and will she reconsider?
The hon. Gentleman will know the importance of ensuring that we build the prison capacity that was so lacking under the previous Government. Officials continue to regularly meet the local council, elected councillors and parish councils to agree all traffic management and address challenges around the site. I am visiting as many prisons as I can get to, and I will certainly endeavour to visit HMP Grendon in due course.
Assessment & feedback
Specific visit date not provided
Endeavour To Visit
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
A mother and her child have been waiting since last November for non-molestation papers to be served, resulting in eight failed court hearings.
Failings in the family court system are having a heartbreaking impact on too many in my constituency. In one instance, a mother and her child have been waiting since last November for non-molestation papers to be served. In the meantime, they have had not one, not two, but eight failed court hearings where process failings have meant the papers could not be served, exposing them to risk and continued stress and strain over a very long period. Will the Minister meet them to discuss how we can put this right and fix the broken system?
I am not just happy to meet them; I am keen to meet them. If we are going to improve the family justice system, we need to hear from those who have experienced it. We are rolling out child-focused courts, which will help, but we have to improve productivity more generally, and we are getting on with that.
Assessment & feedback
Specific meeting details not provided
Rolling Out Child-Focused Courts
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Context
Alicia Kearns has repeatedly raised the case of a paedophile moved to an open prison despite concerns.
I am concerned about a paedophile moved to an open prison two years into a 10-year sentence despite previous promises for an answer. Why has this individual been placed in an open prison?
I will look into that immediately and meet the hon. Lady behind the Speaker's Chair to confirm how we will proceed.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide an answer on why the paedophile was moved to an open prison
I Will Look Into That Immediately And Meet The Hon. Lady Behind The Speaker'S Chair To Confirm How We Will Proceed.
Response accuracy
Q15 Direct Answer
Kerry McCarthy Lab
Bristol East
Context
Kerry McCarthy seeks support from the Minister to identify children of prisoners and provide them with necessary support.
The Minister has been helping to identify children of prisoners. Will he join me on 25 November for Children with a Parent in Prison Day to hear from young people and discuss support needs?
Yes, I am a massive champion of this issue and will be at the event at the end of November.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Context
Anna Dixon raises the case of Jimmy, who received an IPP sentence and remains in prison despite passing a mental health tribunal.
Jimmy, a Shipley constituent, received an IPP sentence and remains in prison despite passing a mental health tribunal. Can the Secretary of State assure me that prisoners like Jimmy with autism will get support to start a new life?
We intend to publish legislation and ensure those individuals leaving prison have the best possible support to sustain their exit.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide assurance specifically for Jimmy or those with autism
We Intend To Publish Legislation And Ensure Those Individuals Leaving Prison Have The Best Possible Support To Sustain Their Exit.
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Context
Vikki Slade visited Margaret Green Animal Rescue, where she learned about the delay in rehoming animals due to court backlog.
Animals taken in by Margaret Green Animal Rescue cannot be rehomed during the delay before prosecution. Will the Minister look at how we can ensure these animals are rehomed and not delayed in these facilities?
Local authorities have a responsibility, and if she writes to me, I will provide a full answer about what the Ministry of Justice is doing.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a direct commitment to address the issue
Local Authorities Have A Responsibility, And If She Writes To Me, I Will Provide A Full Answer About What The Ministry Of Justice Is Doing.
Response accuracy
Q18 Direct Answer
Context
Kim Johnson has launched a campaign for Trew's law, calling for a review of cases of imprisoned police officers.
Last week, Appeal launched a campaign for Trew's law to review cases of imprisoned police officers. Will the Minister agree to meet me and the campaigners to discuss this law?
Yes, I would be happy to meet my hon. Friend.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q19 Direct Answer
Context
Danny Chambers refers to The Links Group, which researches the link between animal harm and domestic abuse.
The Links Group has highlighted the link between animal harm and domestic abuse for 25 years. Will the Minister agree to meet me and the Links Group to draw on their expertise to help prevent avoidable harm?
Absolutely, I would be delighted to meet the hon. Gentleman.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Context
Jayne Kirkham raises concerns about prisoners convicted under joint enterprise laws, requesting a review.
There are hundreds of people in prison for joint enterprise, but the Law Commission will not look at it under the homicide review. Will the Secretary of State look at joint enterprise law to reform it?
We have been looking carefully at this and would be happy to meet her and others to discuss it in more detail.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to a review or reform of joint enterprise law
We Have Been Looking Carefully At This And Would Be Happy To Meet Her And Others To Discuss It In More Detail.
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Context
Andrew Snowden previously raised concerns about drug testing in open prisons, noting that those failing tests should not remain there.
Anyone who fails a drug test on arrival in an open prison like Kirkham does not belong there and should be sent back to a more secure prison. Has the Department had more thoughts on consequences for failing a drug test on arrival?
We have a review ongoing into these issues within prisons, led by Amber Rudd, and we will continue to ensure that we have the deterrence, to stop drugs getting in, and that the right actions are taken when they do.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a specific answer on consequences for failing a drug test
We Have A Review Ongoing Into These Issues Within Prisons, Led By Amber Rudd, And We Will Continue To Ensure That We Have The Deterrence, To Stop Drugs Getting In, And That The Right Actions Are Taken When They Do.
Response accuracy