Topical Questions 2026-09-10

2026-09-10

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Direct Answer
Context
The questioner criticizes the government's approach to introducing legislation, citing the example of microchipping cats.
If she will make a statement on her departmental responsibilities. The questioner argues that the government's approach to introducing legislation is too bureaucratic and has resulted in absurdities like three consultations on microchipping cats. The public expects change and less red tape.
The government is stripping out needless bureaucracy and will introduce reforms to minimize the risk of judicial review. Transport, water and other major infrastructure projects will benefit from parliamentary authorisation, allowing the government to lead and put public control at the heart of decision making.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Context
A constituent of the MP lost his father due to contaminated blood products. The scheme to compensate victims has faced delays.
The questioner asks if the government will consider index-linking compensation to inflation to prevent delays from reducing the value of compensation awards. The scheme has faced delays and the constituent's family has been affected.
The government is considering the hon. Gentleman's question as they go forward. Reports are being laid in the House today regarding improvements to the scheme.
Assessment & feedback
Index-linking compensation to inflation
Will Consider The Hon. Gentleman'S Question As We Go Forward
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Context
A constituent's mother worked for the Department for Work and Pensions and died before receiving her pension. The delay caused significant distress.
The questioner asks what steps are being taken to ensure prompt pension payments for civil servants upon retirement. The current delays are unacceptable and cause distress to families.
The Minister continues to use commercial levers under the contract, including withholding contractual payments. Surge staff are deployed to fix service levels.
Assessment & feedback
Permanent fixes to service levels
We Will Not Be Moving Any Of Those Team Members Until Service Levels Are Permanently Fixed
Response accuracy
Q4 Direct Answer
Alex Burghart Con
Brentwood and Ongar
Context
The Prime Minister announced that mayors will keep a proportion of income tax receipts but did not clarify if they can use this to cut taxes or offer rebates.
The questioner asks why Conservative Mayor Ben Houchen will not be allowed to use the income tax receipts to cut taxes or offer rebates. The questioner believes that mayors should have the same power as councils to offer rebates.
The mayor does not have the ability to provide rebates now and is unlikely to in the future, as it would involve data from HMRC and setting income tax thresholds.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q5 Direct Answer
Alex Burghart Con
Brentwood and Ongar
Context
The Prime Minister announced that mayors will keep a proportion of income tax receipts but did not clarify if they can use this to cut taxes or offer rebates.
The questioner reiterates his previous question and asks again about the income tax receipts that Ben Houchen will retain. He wants to know why mayors cannot provide rebates like councils.
The mayor does not have the ability to provide rebates now and is unlikely to in the future, as it would involve data from HMRC and setting income tax thresholds.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Context
Young people in the MP's constituency face challenges in getting their foot on the career ladder. The new procurement rules aim to create more jobs, apprenticeships, and opportunities.
The questioner asks what specific steps the Cabinet Office is taking to ensure that the Government's new procurement rules translate into more jobs, apprenticeships, and opportunities for young people in rural communities.
The Government is asking Alan Milburn to push forward the agenda for young people not in employment, education, or training. Local social value schemes will provide education, employment, and training for young people.
Assessment & feedback
Specific steps
Asking Alan Milburn To Push Forward This Agenda
Response accuracy
Q7 Direct Answer
Context
Channel 4 showed senior figures from Reform UK discussing how money from an American donor could reach the party through his UK-based son. The questioner believes this is a threat to national security.
The questioner asks if the Government agrees that covert overseas finance represents a threat to national security and if measures in the Representation of the People Bill are sufficient to stop foreign money from influencing UK democracy. She suggests capping political donations as a solution.
The Government understands the concerns and is assembling a new cross-Government task-and-finish team to tackle the issue of megadonors in UK politics. The Rycroft review and defending democracy taskforce are addressing these matters.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q8 Direct Answer
Context
During his constituency tour, Morris met with farmers who felt previous procurement reforms did not benefit them adequately.
I welcomed the announcement about reforming procurement to benefit British businesses. I met farmers in Northumberland who felt previous reforms did not benefit them as they hoped. Will the Minister join me on a visit to a local farm to discuss how procurement can benefit British farmers?
I commend my hon. Friend for his remarkable stamina over the summer, with more than 80 visits across his constituency—the largest in England. He is certainly a passionate campaigner for farmers. He will know that our recently announced reforms to social value mean that businesses bidding for Government contracts—a market worth £90 billion—will be rightly judged on whether they create high-quality jobs, skills and apprenticeships in local communities. That includes food procurement, and our aim is for at least half of all public sector food to be produced locally. I will gladly join him and one of his local farmers to talk about that further.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
Simon, a Maritime and Coastguard Agency employee, contacted Capita three times before his retirement but his pension case is still pending triage.
My constituent Simon gave 31 years' service at the Maritime and Coastguard Agency, supporting the Royal Navy. He contacted Capita in March, June and July, and was assured that his pension would be sorted. His case is still awaiting triage. Can the Minister say when the backlog will be cleared and when Simon can expect his pension?
I thank the hon. Member for raising that case. As I have said, Capita's performance is diabolical. I will not make any excuses for it from the Dispatch Box—there are no excuses for it—but we are holding Capita to account every day. As I said, we have deployed 147 surge staff to help during this crisis—they will not be removed until service levels are brought up to scratch—we are withholding contractual payments, and an independent Capita-funded remedial adviser has been appointed to identify further issues. If the hon. Lady writes to me about that case, I will ensure that it is escalated.
Assessment & feedback
When the backlog will be cleared
Holding Capita To Account Every Day
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Ian Lavery Lab
Wansbeck
Context
The contaminated blood inquiry report was published nearly two years ago, yet some 18,000 infected and affected individuals have not begun their claims.
It has been nearly two years since the contaminated blood inquiry report was published. People think that the matter is finished, but it is not: some 18,000 infected and affected individuals still have not begun their claims. Will my right hon. Friend reaffirm to this House her commitment to the contaminated blood community, and will she meet the all-party parliamentary group on haemophilia and contaminated blood so that we can discuss the best way to press those cases home expediently?
I thank and congratulate my hon. Friend on his many years of campaigning on this terrible issue. He will know about the Prime Minister's personal involvement in and commitment to this issue, about his personal experience of campaigning alongside the victims, and how important he and the Department consider the matter. The Infected Blood Compensation Authority has now paid out over £2.2 billion in final compensation payments, but we are very aware that there is much more to do. The Minister in the other place will be happy to meet my hon. Friend's APPG.
Assessment & feedback
When the Minister will meet the APPG
We Are Very Aware That There Is Much More To Do
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Wendy Morton Con
Aldridge-Brownhills
Context
A constituent of Morton's has been waiting for her pension and lump sum for over five months since she took partial retirement.
One of my constituents served His Majesty's Revenue and Customs for 43 years, yet more than five months on from taking partial retirement she is still waiting for her pension and lump sum. My office has attended two casework surgeries with Capita and the Cabinet Office, neither of which has secured a resolution. My constituent is now paying additional mortgage interest because of the delays. Will the Minister meet me urgently to resolve this case, secure a payment date and ensure that my constituent is compensated for the financial losses incurred?
I am sorry to hear of the experience that the right hon. Member's constituent has had with Capita. As I have said, its performance has been abysmal, and we will hold it to account every single day until service levels are brought back to a good standard. I would be happy to meet her to discuss the case, and I will personally ensure that it is escalated.
Assessment & feedback
When the Minister will meet her to resolve the case
We Will Hold Capita To Account Every Single Day
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Context
The Prime Minister acknowledged that too many buses are being bought from abroad, and the 10% social value commitment from combined mayoral authorities following the bus manufacturing expert panel may not be enough.
The Prime Minister was right last week to say that too many buses are being bought from abroad. The 10% social value commitment from combined mayoral authorities following the conclusion of the bus manufacturing expert panel earlier this year will not be enough to protect British bus building as China continues to scale up its automotive dumping. Will the First Secretary of State work with devolved mayors, the Department for Transport and the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills to bring social value requirements in line with the 20% she has rightly set for major Government contracts?
I thank my hon. Friend for his work through the all-party parliamentary group. He is a passionate campaigner for British buses, particularly with regard to the impact on his constituents. I am of course happy to meet him to discuss the issue further.
Assessment & feedback
Bringing social value requirements in line with the 20% set for major Government contracts
I Am Of Course Happy To Meet Him To Discuss The Issue Further
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
It was widely reported in the press that the right hon. Lady's responsibility for fraud in the Cabinet Office was removed from her.
Upon her appointment as First Secretary of State, it was widely reported in the press that the right hon. Lady's responsibility for fraud in the Cabinet Office was removed from her. I wonder whether the First Secretary of State could outline why there was such speculation, and if she struggles with that, perhaps she can use the phone-a-friend option.
A number of responsibilities were removed from the Cabinet Office in order to create the new Office for the Prime Minister and Cabinet, a central new body at the heart of Government committed to delivering the priorities of the Prime Minister and the British people.
Assessment & feedback
Why there was speculation
A Number Of Responsibilities Were Removed To Create A New Office
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Context
Despite its pedigree in tech and advanced manufacturing, the Isle of Wight under the previous government was overlooked for funding and investment.
May I say how happy I am to welcome my right hon. Friend the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster to her place? I know she will continue to be a fantastic champion for the Isle of Wight. Per capita—not the pension people but per head of population—the island tops the league for tech and advanced manufacturing, but despite our brilliant pedigree, under the previous Government, we were continually overlooked for funding and investment. Will my right hon. Friend assure me that she will use her office to secure sustained growth in our postcodes, so that the island can finally receive the recognition, investment and job opportunities that its contribution to our economy deserves?
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for his kind words and continual championing of the Isle of Wight. I will ensure that fixing his ferry is top of my to-do list. The proposal that he outlines is exactly the kind of work that No. 10 North has been designed to champion to drive good growth in every postcode, north and south.
Assessment & feedback
Securing sustained growth in our postcodes
I Will Ensure That Fixing His Ferry Is Top Of My To-Do List
Response accuracy
Q15 Direct Answer
Context
North East Hampshire is experiencing unprecedented wildfires this summer, including in the MP's constituency. Volunteers form the majority of fire responders.
Most fire responders in North East Hampshire are volunteers. After an unprecedented summer of wildfires, including in my constituency, will the Minister meet me and fire volunteers to hear about the pressures on the fire service at first hand?
I would be delighted to do so.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Context
In the summer, the docks in the MP's constituency lost a UK Research and Innovation contract to a Danish dockyard. The MP welcomes the procurement changes.
I very much welcome the procurement changes that this Government have brought in. In the summer, the docks in my constituency lost a UK Research and Innovation contract on the RRS Sir David Attenborough to a Danish dockyard. Can the Minister assure me that the new rules will refer to agencies across government, rather than just procurements within Government?
I thank my hon. Friend for her campaigning on behalf of Cornwall and her constituency. I assure her of the seriousness with which we take that issue and broader procurement issues, and I would be happy to meet her to discuss the case.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide assurance that the new rules will apply to agencies across government
Would Be Happy To Meet Her To Discuss The Case
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Robert Jenrick Con
Newark
Context
The Government are giving away powers to the Cabinet Secretary to direct permanent secretaries, which should be the role of Secretaries of State. The MP questions the reason for this.
The Minister said that Governments are elected to lead. Most people would assume that means that Ministers are elected to lead, because they are accountable to Parliament and to the people. Why, then, are the Government giving away powers to the Cabinet Secretary to direct permanent secretaries, which should be the role of Secretaries of State? Do Ministers not want these powers to actually do their jobs?
We are committed, and the Cabinet Secretary is committed, to conducting a full review of the civil service. It is at a relatively early stage, but I look forward to hearing what decisions are made. Of course, what powers are determined will be a matter for the Prime Minister.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide a reason for giving away powers to the Cabinet Secretary
We Are Committed It Is At A Relatively Early Stage
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Christine Jardine Lib Dem
Edinburgh West
Context
Capita is not working and constituents are unable to receive settlements, despite the Government's efforts. Capita is still getting more Government contracts.
I hate to take the Minister back to Capita, but unfortunately, I have a number of constituents who have been through the many stages already explained by the Minister. Capita is not working, and I accept that you are doing all these things in government, but it is not making a blind bit of difference. I have people who cannot pay their mortgages and who have been waiting for more than a year for a settlement sum. Something more needs to be done, and it is very depressing for these people when they read in the papers that Capita is getting more Government contracts, so what more can the Government do?
I hope to be able to update the House shortly after recess with further steps that the Government are taking. As I have said, we have a Capita-funded remedial adviser in place who is identifying the delivery issues, and we have also deployed auditors to Capita to get a full understanding of the exact state of the service. We will continue to look at withholding contractual payments and, as I have said, this Government are committed to the biggest wave of insourcing in a generation. While we inherited this contract from the previous Government, we will ensure that going forward looking at in-house schemes is a priority.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not specify what more the Government will do about Capita
We Inherited This Contract From The Previous Government
Response accuracy
Q19 Partial Answer
Context
Brexit has created red tape preventing businesses in Wokingham from developing relationships with European partners. The MP seeks to know about negotiations for a growth and defence partnership with the EU.
Brexit has created a web of red tape preventing businesses in Wokingham from developing relationships with European partners. Will the Government start negotiations for a growth and defence partnership with the EU to boost trade and growth?
We are engaged in discussions with the European Union on exactly the questions that the hon. Member refers to. We have made good progress in the first two years; I wish to go further, as I set out in my answer to the question before.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not commit to starting negotiations for a growth and defence partnership with the EU
We Have Made Good Progress In The First Two Years
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Tessa Munt Lib Dem
Wells
Context
The MP inquires about issuing emergency alerts on a regional or county basis for important but more local emergencies.
Returning to the emergency alerts, what assessment has the Secretary of State made of issuing alerts on a regional or county basis for important but more local emergencies, such as bluetongue outbreaks in cattle and sheep in rural areas?
I hope that the hon. Member heard my earlier response about how seriously we take the issuing of the alert, and how we take considerable effort to look carefully at how it has worked and whether it can be improved in future. I say to her that every emergency alert is carefully co-ordinated with the responding public bodies and agencies, and each request is evaluated on a case-by-case basis to ensure that it is necessary for public safety.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide an assessment of issuing alerts on a regional or county basis
Each Request Is Evaluated On A Case-By-Case Basis
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Context
The MP's constituent John is struggling with his salary after retiring partly due to ill health. The current system has a four-month advance requirement and no allowance for delays.
I am sorry to return to Capita, but I may have a solution. My constituent John is retiring partly due to ill health and his salary is now at half level—he is really struggling. He explained to me that under the current system a retirement date must be selected four months in advance, and if the delay goes one day past that, rather than amending the figures, the system has to start all over again. My suggestion is that we make a slight tweak so that we save Capita a lot of work and our residents a lot of heartache. Will the Minister comment on that and pick up my constituent's case?
I thank the hon. Member for bringing that idea to this House. I will be happy to put that to Capita when I next meet it, and if she wants to write to me with her case, I will happily ensure that it is escalated.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not comment on the suggestion to tweak the system
I Will Be Happy To Put That To Capita
Response accuracy
Q22 Partial Answer
Context
The next national adaptation programme, NAP4, is not due until 2028, but the wildfires and droughts this summer show that urgent action is needed.
The next national adaptation programme, NAP4, is not due until 2028, but the wildfires and droughts we saw this summer and the impending extreme El Niño show that we cannot wait that long. Will the Minister commit to taking urgent action to tackle resilience before then and give our farmers, communities and householders the support they need to face the challenges of drought, wildfire and flood risk?
I completely recognise the importance of the point that the hon. Lady has made; she has made it previously. The Government have established and tested response protocols in place for all severe weather events. The impact of each is often very different based on different factors, but I give her an assurance of the seriousness with which we take these issues. We are working across Government to ensure that our response is proportionate to the nature of the threat we face from climate change.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not commit to taking urgent action before 2028
We Are Working Across Government
Response accuracy