Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Kilmarnock, a town in Ayrshire, Scotland, has f [1D [K faced decades of industrial decline. The Government's £20 million Pride in [K Place investment has sparked renewed hope and the creation of a town centre [6D [K centre masterplan.
My home town of Kilmarnock was once the industrial po [2D [K powerhouse of Ayrshire, but after decades of decline and deindustrialisatio [18D [K deindustrialisation, it has never fully recovered. I welcome the Prime Mini [4D [K Minister's determination to revive our high streets and his focus on doing [K so, and I extend a warm invitation to him to visit the town at any time. Ho [2D [K Hope has been rekindled in Kilmarnock thanks to the Government's £20 millio [6D [K million Pride in Place investment. We are seeing the creation of the first [K Kilmarnock town centre masterplan for over 50 years, led by the community, [K setting an achievable vision for a successful future, and we want to build [K on that momentum. Will the Prime Minister champion a new partnership betwee [6D [K between Kilmarnock, my home town, Manchester and—
It does my heart good to hear my hon. Friend talk about [5D [K about rising hope in Kilmarnock and the masterplan for the town, backed by [K the Government with the Pride in Place funding—and yes, I can assure her th [2D [K that No. 10 North is as much at the service of her constituency as it is at [2D [K at the service of any constituency in the House. We will turn what is happe [5D [K happening in Kilmarnock into real momentum for the town.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about a new partnership between Kilm [4D [K Kilmarnock and other towns was not addressed
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There has been confusion over whether the Prime [5D [K Prime Minister will fund 3% of GDP for defence by 2030. The Chancellor resi [4D [K resigned from his position as Defence Secretary because of disagreements ov [2D [K over this issue.
After last week's session, the country was thrown int [3D [K into confusion over whether the Prime Minister was or was not going to fund [4D [K fund 3% for defence by 2030. After today he will have another five weeks of [2D [K off PMQs, but there are some serious threats to national security that cann [4D [K cannot wait. His Chancellor resigned as Defence Secretary because the Labou [5D [K Labour Government would not increase defence spending to 3% by 2030. Does t [1D [K the Prime Minister think that he was right to quit?
As I said last week, I appointed this Chancellor becaus [6D [K because of his strong commitment to the defence of this nation—that was the [3D [K the reason—and we will honour our NATO commitments: 3.5% by 2035, and a tar [3D [K target date for 3%. That will all be set out in the spending review. I do n [1D [K not feel, though, that the right hon. Lady gets the right to come to this H [1D [K House and claim the moral high ground and point fingers wherever possible, [K when defence spending was 2.3% of GDP and fell during 14 years of a Conserv [7D [K Conservative Government. On this issue, I think we should do more problem s [1D [K solving than point scoring, and I say to the right hon. Lady that we would [K do our armed forces well if we could agree more on this crucial issue acros [5D [K across the House.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about the Chancellor's resignation w [1D [K was not addressed
Claiming Moral High Ground
Point Scoring
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question arises from concerns about the [3D [K the UK's commitment to reaching the NATO target of 2% GDP on defence spendi [6D [K spending, with particular reference to recent threats from Argentina and Ru [2D [K Russia.
The Prime Minister says the target is 2035. That [K is a decade away. If he cannot get to 3% by 2030, why should we believe he [K will get to 3.5% by 2035? The spending review is next year. Last week, I se [2D [K set out how we would get to 3% by 2030. The threats are now. Argentina is t [1D [K threatening the Falklands—now. Russia is threatening us in the North sea—no [6D [K sea—now. The Prime Minister did not answer my question. I asked him if the [K Chancellor was right to quit. The Chancellor was right to quit, which is wh [2D [K why it is so wrong that he is not sticking to his principles. The Chancello [9D [K Chancellor used to say that not hitting 3% by 2030 would put our troops at [K risk. He also said that Keir Starmer was “unable”, and the Treasury “unwill [7D [K “unwilling”, to provide that funding. So is the Prime Minister unable, or i [1D [K is he just unwilling, to get that money by 2030?
This Chancellor, of all Chancellors, will be willin [6D [K willing to provide that funding to our armed forces and back our defence in [2D [K investment plan. We have taken the strongest possible stance in supporting [K President Zelensky and Ukraine. We are playing our role around the world, a [1D [K and we will continue to do so. The right hon. Lady mentions the plan that s [1D [K she has set out, and this is why I say that we should have an honest conver [6D [K conversation across the Dispatch Box; I looked at it, and I do not think th [2D [K that taking £4 billion out of housing benefit is going to get the right con [3D [K consensus around this issue. That would create levels of homelessness in th [2D [K this country that we would not have seen before, with hundreds of thousands [9D [K thousands of children in temporary accommodation. I say to the right hon. L [1D [K Lady that, yes, we do everything to support our national security, but it c [1D [K cannot come at the expense of social security. Having strong national secur [5D [K security also depends on resilience in our communities. We on the Labour Be [2D [K Benches will not be forced to choose between the two, and we will set out a [1D [K a plan to get to 3.5% by 2035 at the spending review.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about the Prime Minister's willi [5D [K willingness and principles regarding the 3% defence spending target by 2030 [4D [K 2030 was not directly addressed.
Under Review
Pragmatic Approach
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question is prompted by concerns about [K the UK's ability to fund its defence commitments, specifically in light of [K recent decisions by major taxpayers and the increasing welfare bill under t [1D [K the current government.
It is unbelievable that the Prime Minister would [K say that. He is clearly unwilling. We need to fund our defence, not spend a [1D [K all our money on welfare. I cannot believe that he would actually say that. [5D [K that. He is clearly unwilling, but there are ways to do this—he is not unab [4D [K unable. On Monday, Chris Rokos, Britain's third biggest taxpayer, announced [9D [K announced that he was leaving the country. That is £330 million of taxes wa [2D [K walking out the door because of this Labour Government—every year, £330 mil [3D [K million. His taxes could be going on defence. The Prime Minister is talking [7D [K talking about spending more on welfare. The benefits bill is set to rise by [2D [K by £32 billion under him—that is not all of it; that is the rise. That mone [4D [K money could be going on defence. The Prime Minister will not approve the Ro [2D [K Rosebank oilfield—£1.4 billion of tax revenue that could be going on defenc [6D [K defence. So, will the Prime Minister tell the country: where is he going to [2D [K to find the money to fund our defence?
I cannot comment today on quasi-judicial decisions, [10D [K decisions, but we will take a pragmatic approach to oil and gas, as I have [K said before at the Dispatch Box. Let us get to the heart of this question, [K as the right hon. Lady invites me to do. What is the right way to fund defe [4D [K defence and, yes, bring the welfare budget down? She would make crude cuts [K to housing benefit. As I have said, if £4 billion is taken out in the next [K few years, families will be made homeless and rough sleeping on our streets [7D [K streets will increase. So here is the Labour way—the way that we do it on t [1D [K this side of the House. We have set out plans for the biggest council house [5D [K house building programme this country has seen in a generation. If the righ [4D [K right hon. Lady looks at research from the National Housing Federation, she [3D [K she will see that that is the route to save billions from housing benefit. [K We will shortly respond to the final report of Alan Milburn, who is looking [7D [K looking at the issue of young people not in education, employment or traini [6D [K training—again, something left behind by the last Government. We will take [K the Labour way: change education, support our young people, and provide mor [3D [K more mental health support. That is the Labour way to get the welfare bill [K down, and I say to the right hon. Lady that that is the right way to fund d [1D [K defence.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about finding money to fund defe [4D [K defence was not directly addressed.
Pragmatic Approach
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
No, it is not. The truth is the Prime Minister does not know where he is going to find the money. He is talking about anything except defence, including council housing. He will not fund the military. I will tell you what he is funding though, Mr Speaker—Keir Starmer’s £35 billion surrender of the Chagos islands and its crucial military base. That is British sovereign territory. That is a weak decision, and it is no wonder that Argentina is now threatening the Falklands. We need to project strength. We need to show that British sovereign territory is non-negotiable. So why, just like Keir Starmer, is he planning to surrender the Chagos islands?
The right hon. Lady has to do better than that. They are the worst kind of points to be scoring when the country is watching. We will not surrender our base at Diego Garcia—we are in discussions with the United States about that—and we will always respect the rights of the Falkland Islanders to choose to be British. That will never change under this Government, and we will be relentless in defending that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The defence funding has been debated with conce [5D [K concerns over the £35 billion to be paid to Mauritius and the cancellation [K of £30 million for soldier training.
The defence funding is being questioned, with critici [7D [K criticism that £35 billion is being paid to give away British territory whi [3D [K while £30 million of training for British soldiers is cancelled. The questi [6D [K questioner points out that defence funding fell in real terms under the cur [3D [K current government and asks why the choice is being made to send £35 billio [6D [K billion to Mauritius when soldier training funding is being cut.
Defence spending was 2.5% of GDP when the last Labour G [1D [K Government left office and 2.3% under the current government, now set to be [2D [K be 2.7% in the next year. The government aims for fully funded defence inve [4D [K investment, proposing a path to reach 3.5% of GDP by 2035. The answerer inv [3D [K invites collaboration to set a clear path for secure and fully funded defen [5D [K defence spending.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not directly address the specific qu [2D [K question about sending £35 billion to Mauritius and the cancellation of £30 [3D [K £30 million for soldier training.
This Is An Area For Problem Solving Rather Than Po [2D [K Point Scoring.
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner criticises the Prime Minister's [K portrayal of the previous Labour government as successful, pointing out tha [3D [K that Keir Starmer resigned, indicating the failure of the previous governme [8D [K government's policies.
The Prime Minister seems to think that the last Gover [5D [K Government were a Conservative Government. The last Government were a Labou [5D [K Labour Government and they failed, which is why Keir Starmer resigned. He k [1D [K keeps talking about their record as if it was fantastic. If it was, then wh [2D [K why is Keir Starmer not sitting there? Where Britain needs leadership, what [4D [K what we have at the moment is just vibes. He said he appointed the Chancell [8D [K Chancellor because he cares about defence, but he will not fund it. Other c [1D [K countries are making claims over our sovereign territory. They smell weakne [6D [K weakness. He is pretending that he is the change candidate, but the fact is [2D [K is he is still failing to cut welfare, he is still paying to hand over a so [2D [K sovereign territory, and he is still not funding defence. On the issues tha [3D [K that really matter, is he not just continuity Keir?
The right hon. Lady mentions leadership. Let me tell he [2D [K her and the whole House where Britain is showing leadership. There have bee [3D [K been Conservative politicians at this Dispatch Box—Labour politicians, too— [4D [K too—for decades who have talked about the importance of the two-state solut [5D [K solution between Israel and Palestine. Words from any politician about a tw [2D [K two-state solution will be only words if they are not backed with action. L [1D [K Leadership is about taking action where there is injustice, where we need t [1D [K to correct unfairness: people being driven out of their homes, losing their [5D [K their homes, being intimidated in their daily lives. I credit the Father of [2D [K of the House, the right hon. Member for Gainsborough (Sir Edward Leigh), wh [2D [K who yesterday applauded the action that this Government are taking. In this [4D [K this difficult and dangerous world, Britain has to stand for something. Bri [3D [K Britain has to show leadership. Britain has to stand for fairness against i [1D [K injustice. Where people are being bullied out of their homes and intimidate [10D [K intimidated, we will always stand with the underdog and take what action we [2D [K we can to support them. That is leadership on the world stage; Britain bein [4D [K being true to what it has always been about. That is what the British peopl [5D [K people expect of us and that is what this Government will do.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about leadership, welfare, and defen [5D [K defence funding was not addressed with concrete actions or commitments.
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Warrington's town infrastructure, including the [3D [K the hospital and leisure centre, is inadequate for the growing population. [K The leisure centre's pool is closed due to safety concerns.
The Prime Minister grew up in Warrington so he will k [1D [K know that our town has changed enormously, but too much of the infrastructu [12D [K infrastructure that people depend on has not changed with it. Much of Warri [5D [K Warrington hospital was built in a different century for a much smaller pop [3D [K population, while Broomfields leisure centre is at the end of its life and [K its pool is now closed on safety grounds. Will the Prime Minister come home [4D [K home to Warrington, meet me and set out how the Government will deliver the [3D [K the infrastructure that my constituents deserve?
I am a more regular visitor to my hon. Friend's constit [7D [K constituency than she might realise, constantly nipping in and out for vari [4D [K various reasons, so I know Warrington well. I believe it is a success story [5D [K story, actually; something of a jewel in the north-west crown. It is a grow [4D [K growing town—almost a city, given how successful it has been in recent time [4D [K times—but it does need new infrastructure. I would like to see a remodelled [10D [K remodelled Warrington Bank Quay, with high-quality east-west, north-south c [1D [K connectivity running through it. When it comes to leisure—Mr Speaker, you k [1D [K know this as much as anyone in the House and perhaps more than anyone—this [K is a Prime Minister who will back grassroots sport to the hilt. I assure my [2D [K my hon. Friend that I am happy to talk to her about the leisure centre she [K mentioned.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask to meet the Prime Minister and discu [5D [K discuss infrastructure was not directly addressed
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
I associate myself with the Prime Minister’s opening remarks, not least about the 25th anniversary of the horrific terror attacks of 9/11. I welcome the Government finally banning imports from illegal Israeli settlements, something Keir Starmer should have done a long time ago. On Back British Farming Day, can I also celebrate British farmers? I hope the Prime Minister will do more than that and end the family farm tax.
Last week I asked about North Devon’s maternity unit, which is still closed. This week I have to raise Musgrove Park hospital, where the Prime Minister’s Labour colleague Baroness Amos found the “most challenging” maternity estate in the whole country. She described “leaking roofs”, a ceiling propped up by poles and room temperatures that put newborn babies at risk. No mother should have to give birth in such circumstances. Does the Prime Minister agree that Musgrove Park cannot wait until 2033 for work to start on a new maternity unit? Will he offer a meeting to local MPs, so we can move it forward? And will he make fixing the maternity scandal across our country a top priority of his Government?
Last week I asked about North Devon’s maternity unit, which is still closed. This week I have to raise Musgrove Park hospital, where the Prime Minister’s Labour colleague Baroness Amos found the “most challenging” maternity estate in the whole country. She described “leaking roofs”, a ceiling propped up by poles and room temperatures that put newborn babies at risk. No mother should have to give birth in such circumstances. Does the Prime Minister agree that Musgrove Park cannot wait until 2033 for work to start on a new maternity unit? Will he offer a meeting to local MPs, so we can move it forward? And will he make fixing the maternity scandal across our country a top priority of his Government?
That is a fair question. Let me first thank the right hon. Gentleman for his support for the statement made yesterday by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Affairs. It is important that there is support across the House for what was announced. We have all stood together for the two-state solution. The reason my right hon. Friend decided to announce what he did when he did is obviously that the E1 settlement tender concludes before the Israeli general election. It was important to make a clear statement on where Britain stands, for Britain to show leadership. That is what we have done, but we appreciate the cross-party support.
On British farming, I hear what the right hon. Gentleman says and I will set out more measures later.
I looked into the issues with North Devon’s maternity unit, and the right hon. Gentleman will soon receive an update from me. He mentions Musgrove Park hospital in Taunton—a hospital I know. It points to a systemic challenge facing maternity services across the country, as various reviews have said. That is why my right hon. Friend the Health Secretary will next week chair a meeting of the maternity taskforce in the Department of Health and Social Care. We will ensure that all the issues raised, including at the hospitals mentioned, are looked at in detail.
On British farming, I hear what the right hon. Gentleman says and I will set out more measures later.
I looked into the issues with North Devon’s maternity unit, and the right hon. Gentleman will soon receive an update from me. He mentions Musgrove Park hospital in Taunton—a hospital I know. It points to a systemic challenge facing maternity services across the country, as various reviews have said. That is why my right hon. Friend the Health Secretary will next week chair a meeting of the maternity taskforce in the Department of Health and Social Care. We will ensure that all the issues raised, including at the hospitals mentioned, are looked at in detail.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
I thank the Prime Minister for that answer. Britain should be the safest country in the world to have a baby. We will keep raising this issue until it is the safest.
The best legacy of the previous Conservative Prime Minister is our world-leading AI Security Institute, which is now essential to our national security, and to global security, in the age of artificial intelligence. But today, the Financial Times reports that Anthropic did not submit its latest model to the institute for testing, apparently due to pressure from the Trump Administration. Does the Prime Minister think it is acceptable for President Trump to undermine Britain’s efforts to keep the world safe from dangerous AI?
The best legacy of the previous Conservative Prime Minister is our world-leading AI Security Institute, which is now essential to our national security, and to global security, in the age of artificial intelligence. But today, the Financial Times reports that Anthropic did not submit its latest model to the institute for testing, apparently due to pressure from the Trump Administration. Does the Prime Minister think it is acceptable for President Trump to undermine Britain’s efforts to keep the world safe from dangerous AI?
On the specific issue, the institute that the right hon. Gentleman mentioned is indeed a world leader, and is in daily conversation with industry partners, including Anthropic. Those conversations will continue. On the broader issue, the right hon. Gentleman is absolutely right that AI poses risks to our national security, but it could also be the source of solutions for keeping us safer, and that was a discussion that we had yesterday. That is why I appointed a Minister for Artificial Intelligence to the Cabinet. We have lifted the level of conversation about artificial intelligence within Government, and the offer is open to colleagues on all sides of the House who want to be a part of that crucial discussion.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Royal Mail's management is failing to provi [5D [K provide a reliable postal service, affecting constituents in Crewe and Nant [4D [K Nantwich through missed appointments, late fees, and in some cases, county [K court judgments. The Communication Workers Union has raised issues over the [3D [K the years.
It is clear to me and many across this House that [4D [K that despite the hard work and dedication of all postal workers, Royal Mail [4D [K Mail's management is failing in its obligation to provide a basic and relia [5D [K reliable postal service. The people of Crewe and Nantwich are paying the pr [2D [K price through missed appointments, late fees and, in some cases, even count [5D [K county court judgments. I have full confidence in this Prime Minister to de [2D [K deliver for our country. Will he join me in calling on Royal Mail's managem [7D [K management to do the same, including by working with the Communication Work [4D [K Workers Union and through the implementation of the recommendations of the [K Select Committee report published earlier this year?
It is good for me to be able to credit the Communic [8D [K Communication Workers Union, because I know it has done a huge amount of wo [2D [K work over the years to raise some of the issues within Royal Mail. It is be [2D [K because of that work that there has now been a commitment from the business [8D [K business to invest £500 million in frontline resourcing. Everyone in this H [1D [K House will know that standards have not been good enough, and people have b [1D [K been facing an unreliable service. We are committed, as a Government, to a [K comprehensive universal service obligation. That is what will safeguard Roy [3D [K Royal Mail's future, but the company now needs to listen to what my hon. Fr [2D [K Friend is saying and get on and deliver it.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address the specific ask to join [4D [K join the questioner in calling on Royal Mail's management to work with the [K Communication Workers Union and implement the Select Committee report recom [5D [K recommendations
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Energy bills will rise, mortgage prices hav [3D [K have increased, and oil prices have risen, leading to higher costs for hous [4D [K households and motorists. The Prime Minister's popularity is high despite t [1D [K these challenges.
In the coming weeks, energy bills will rise again [5D [K again for households across the United Kingdom; within the last few days, f [1D [K five major mortgage lenders have pushed up mortgage prices for households a [1D [K across the United Kingdom; and within the last few hours, the cost of a bar [3D [K barrel of oil has gone to over $100, pushing up prices at the pumps for mot [3D [K motorists across the United Kingdom. Despite that, the Prime Minister still [5D [K still seems fairly well liked. I will let you into a wee secret, Mr Speaker [7D [K Speaker: I quite like the new Prime Minister. But popularity will not pay t [1D [K the bills during this winter's looming cost of living emergency, so will th [2D [K the Prime Minister stand up now and tell people what he is going to do to h [1D [K help?
I will, Mr Speaker. I will remove VAT from electric [8D [K electricity bills next month. It is not going to solve everything for peopl [5D [K people, but it will take a little bit of pressure off, and the hon. Gentlem [7D [K Gentleman should look out for further measures as we go through the year. I [1D [K I appreciate that it does not apply in Scotland, but we will impose a £2 ca [2D [K cap on bus fares across England for the whole of 2027. We are doing this be [2D [K because this is a cost of living Government, and we want to give people hop [3D [K hope that some help is coming.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address the specific ask for mea [3D [K measures to help households and motorists during the winter cost of living [K emergency, only provided some measures without full commitment
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The London Fire Brigade reports 206 e-bike batt [4D [K battery fires in 2025, with deliverers for food delivery services using sub [3D [K substandard batteries. This raises safety concerns following the Grenfell f [1D [K fire.
In Mitcham and Morden, where 72 lives were lost in th [2D [K the Grenfell fire, there is another fire risk with e-bike batteries. Every [K other day, the London Fire Brigade deals with an e-bike battery fire. Will [K the Prime Minister commit to banning the import of substandard e-bikes and [K converter kits, and will his Ministers attend my roundtable in October to d [1D [K discuss this issue with regulators, delivery companies, and insurers?
We recently consulted on conversion kits and will set o [1D [K out a response shortly. A robust response on all issues raised is expected. [9D [K expected. While I may not attend the roundtable, I will ensure a Minister d [1D [K does.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to banning substandard e-bikes and convert [7D [K converter kits was not addressed.
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Energy Security and Net Zero Committee foun [4D [K found that market regulations prevent people living around a community ener [4D [K energy project from purchasing its electricity, despite excess production. [K Beechen Cliff school in Bath has solar panels but its electricity cannot be [2D [K be used locally.
Community energy projects help with energy security a [1D [K and cost-of-living issues. The committee found that regulations prevent loc [3D [K local electricity sales. Beechen Cliff school has excess summer electricity [11D [K electricity but cannot sell it to local households. Will the Prime Minister [8D [K Minister support accelerating market reform to allow community energy proje [5D [K projects to sell their electricity?
We can give the assurance that the local power plan bac [3D [K backed by £1 billion from Great British Energy will benefit every community [9D [K community, including Bath. If the hon. Lady wants to meet with Great Britis [6D [K British Energy, I will facilitate that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Support for accelerating market reform was not addres [6D [K addressed.
Response accuracy
Q15
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Gravesend-Tilbury ferry was once a vital co [2D [K connectivity link for the high street, but its return and sustainable fundi [5D [K funding are currently stalled.
On the Prime Minister's first visit as Labour leader [K to Gravesend, I discussed the campaign for the return and sustainable fundi [5D [K funding of the Gravesend-Tilbury ferry. Will the Prime Minister support thi [3D [K this campaign to unlock barriers and restore the ferry service, as it is cr [2D [K crucial for high street connectivity?
I visited the constituency and saw where the ferry link [4D [K link used to go. I will not accept the abandonment of this service. I will [K work with the hon. Friend to find ways of bringing the service back, suppor [6D [K supported by No. 10 North. She has my word on that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q16
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Residents of Blaby, Enderby, Huncote, Cosby and [3D [K and Countesthorpe, rural or semi-rural villages in South Leicestershire, re [2D [K responded to the Government's consultation opposing the proposal to merge t [1D [K these areas with the city of Leicester. The question pertains to local gove [4D [K government reform rather than devolution.
I hope that the Prime Minister likes South Leicesters [10D [K Leicestershire as much as he likes the southern parts of England. Blaby, En [2D [K Enderby, Huncote, Cosby and Countesthorpe, to name but a few, are rural or [K semi-rural villages that have little in common with the urban area of the c [1D [K city of Leicester. The Government are going against the wishes of the resid [5D [K residents of those villages, who have responded to the Government's consult [7D [K consultation and said that they do not want to be part of the city of Leice [5D [K Leicester. This has nothing to do with devolution; it is local government r [1D [K reform changing the boundaries. I have a very easy ask of the Prime Ministe [7D [K Minister. He said that he is in listening mode; will he therefore meet me, [K the villagers of the areas that I have mentioned, and other stakeholders to [2D [K to discuss the issue of local government reform?
On this issue, I will agree to the hon. Gentleman's req [3D [K request for a meeting. As announcements this week have shown, I believe tha [3D [K that political reform always benefits from the highest degree of consensus, [10D [K consensus, so I give him that assurance here and now.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q17
Partial Answer
▸
Context
BT Openreach decided to pull out of Liverpo [7D [K Liverpool, resulting in the loss of 600 jobs. The decision has led to commu [5D [K community concern and efforts to retain these jobs and the BT presence in L [1D [K Liverpool.
Mr Speaker—I apologise. BT Openreach identified L [1D [K Liverpool as one of its 30 national hubs. However, in July this year, it de [2D [K decided to pull out of Liverpool, leading to the loss of 600 well-paid and [K skilled jobs. Will the Prime Minister join me in calling on BT Openreach to [2D [K to reverse its decision, and will he and the Government join me, the Commun [6D [K Communication Workers Union and the political leadership in Liverpool in do [2D [K doing everything that we can to ensure that these jobs and BT stay in Liver [5D [K Liverpool?
I am aware of the potential office closure in Liver [5D [K Liverpool by BT, and the number of job losses—up to 600, I believe. Steve R [1D [K Rotheram, the Mayor of the Liverpool City Region, and MPs have been in meet [4D [K meetings, including with No. 10 North yesterday, discussing this and other [K issues. We will continue to work to support those jobs. Can I also congratu [8D [K congratulate the Mayor of the Liverpool City Region on bringing buses acros [5D [K across the city region back under public control at the weekend, after 40 y [1D [K years of deregulation?
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment to reverse BT's decision or r [1D [K retain jobs
Changed Subject To Buses
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Yr Heliwr, a community-owned pub in Nefyn, [K is facing economic challenges due to a 20% VAT rate compared to 10% in Fran [4D [K France, Spain, and Italy. The pub supports local businesses and economic gr [2D [K growth in coastal areas.
Yr Heliwr in Nefyn is a community-owned pub, and [K it is buzzing with events fuelled by local beers and food. I have to declar [6D [K declare an interest; I have shares in Yr Heliwr, and it makes my husband ve [2D [K very happy indeed. Supporting businesses like Yr Heliwr is key for economic [8D [K economic growth in coastal areas, but they are held back by a 20% VAT rate; [5D [K rate; in France, Spain and Italy, hospitality pays just 10%. Will the Prime [5D [K Prime Minister have a word with the Chancellor before the autumn Budget and [3D [K and cut VAT for hospitality to prove that postcodes furthest from London an [2D [K and Manchester will not be forgotten in his drive for growth?
In my first week in office, I made the decision to [K cut business rates for pubs. We need to go further to support hospitality. [K I cannot commit, from this Dispatch Box today, to what she is asking, but s [1D [K she should wait for the Budget. We are keen to support high streets and hos [3D [K hospitality up and down the country—in England, Scotland, Northern Ireland [K and, indeed, Wales.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment to cut VAT for hospitality
Committed To Support Hospitality Generally, Bu [2D [K But No Specific Commitment
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Ian Lavery's constituents are concerned about t [1D [K the impact of proposed data centres in Sleekburn and Cambois, including pot [3D [K potential job losses and disruption to local industries.
With tech billionaires driving the deployment of arti [4D [K artificial intelligence, many of my constituents are concerned about job lo [2D [K losses, misinformation and the infrastructure needed to support the technol [7D [K technology. In Sleekburn and Cambois, three vast—I mean vast—data centres a [1D [K are proposed on scarce industrial land that could be used for other industr [7D [K industries that create far more local jobs. Communities are being asked to [K give up valuable land and suffer local disruption. Will the Prime Minister [K support a moratorium on future data centres until regulation catches up, an [2D [K and will he introduce a critical national infrastructure levy, so that host [4D [K host communities can share in the rewards? Will he also visit my constituen [10D [K constituency to hear local people's concerns for himself?
I understand the concern that my hon. Friend is raising [7D [K raising about data centres. I have to say to him that at this point, I will [4D [K will not go as far as a moratorium, but I agree that it is important that c [1D [K communities see the benefits of AI and data centre investment. I can say fr [2D [K from experience that the data centre can be the magnet that clusters in oth [3D [K other investment over time; that needs to be remembered. This Government ha [2D [K have a policy that AI growth zones will allow local authorities to retain 1 [1D [K 100% of business rate growth, so that they can benefit communities.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Moratorium on data centres
I Have To Say To Him That At This Point, I Will No [2D [K Not Go As Far As A Moratorium
Response accuracy
Q20
Partial Answer
▸
Context
In response to a previous question, the Prime M [1D [K Minister stated his commitment to the Good Friday agreement, which includes [8D [K includes a provision for a referendum on leaving the United Kingdom in Nort [4D [K Northern Ireland. Chris Law is asking if the Prime Minister recognises that [4D [K that Scotland should have an equivalent provision for a second independence [12D [K independence referendum.
In response to my question last week, the Prime Minis [5D [K Minister stated that he was 'very aware of every word in the Good Friday ag [2D [K agreement, and I will stick to it 100% as Prime Minister.'—[Official Report [6D [K Report, 1 September 2026; Vol. 790, c. 50.] He will therefore know that the [3D [K the Northern Ireland Act 1998 contains a provision for a referendum on leav [4D [K leaving the United Kingdom, but no equivalent provision exists in the law f [1D [K for Scotland. Does he recognise that the people of Scotland have an equal r [1D [K right to choose their own future, and that the conditions for a second inde [4D [K independence referendum should be set out in law?
The hon. Member mentions the Good Friday agreement, and [3D [K and I will stick to it 100%. I remind him, on the question of a border poll [4D [K poll, that that is to be considered by the Northern Ireland Secretary when [K there is clear consensus in the country—when public opinion has changed to [K the point at which the call has to be considered. I would say that it is ex [2D [K exactly the same situation in Scotland. I am not aware that there is majori [6D [K majority public support for another referendum, and until that changes, the [3D [K there will not be one.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Equivalent provision for Scotland
I Am Not Aware That There Is Majority Public Suppo [5D [K Support For Another Referendum
Response accuracy
Q21
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Five years ago, the questioner lost a close fri [3D [K friend to suicide after the birth of her third child. One in four women exp [3D [K experience mental health challenges during pregnancy.
I thank the Prime Minister for his commitment to ment [4D [K mental health and to building a country that acts sooner when people need h [1D [K help. Five years ago, I lost one of my best friends, Sophie, to suicide aft [3D [K after the birth of her third child; her little girl was just 10 weeks old a [1D [K at the time. Having a new baby can be a time of great excitement and joy, b [1D [K but for one in four women, it is a time of mental health challenges, from a [1D [K anxiety and depression to obsessive compulsive disorder and serious conditi [7D [K conditions like post-partum psychosis. I have introduced a Bill—Sophie's la [2D [K law—to ensure that every pregnant woman gets a mental health check-in. Will [4D [K Will the Prime Minister work with me to ensure that no one else struggles i [1D [K in the way that Sophie did?
I pay tribute to my hon. Friend for the incredible work [4D [K work she is doing in memory of her friend; I know that her dad Nigel has al [2D [K also campaigned so strongly on this. I have always believed in whole-person [12D [K whole-person care—in physical, mental and social care being delivered toget [5D [K together. We are investing more in perinatal mental health and parent-infan [12D [K parent-infant relationships—more funding is going in—but I accept, as she i [1D [K is saying, that more needs to be done. I will look at her Bill. I understan [9D [K understand the call for Sophie's law and will make sure that a Health Minis [5D [K Minister meets her to discuss it.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not commit to working with the MP to e [1D [K ensure Sophie's law is implemented specifically.
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
Hertfordshire has one of the lowest numbers of mental health in-patient beds per head in England. When patients, including some young people, are in crisis, they can be sent hundreds of miles away, which undermines their recovery. The cost of private beds comes in at millions of pounds. Will the Prime Minister commit personally to looking at my three-year campaign to fund a mental health facility in Hertfordshire? It is shovel-ready, would improve health outcomes for patients, and would pay for itself within just a few years.
I thank the hon. Lady for that very direct and good question. She is right to point to wasted spending in the mental health system when people are sent hundreds of miles in search of a bed; those placements can be very costly indeed. We need to move to a more preventive mental health service, and I will look at the specifics in her constituency. This will all be considered as part of a mental health strategy that will come before this House before Christmas.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q23
Partial Answer
I thank the Prime Minister for visiting my constituency during the recent wildfires in Stourbridge, and for meeting affected residents, emergency workers, volunteers and council staff. Will he join me in thanking the brave firefighters for giving their all in the most challenging conditions? On the hottest day of the year, the fire spread over 600 acres, destroying 19 homes and damaging many more. With extreme heat becoming the norm in a changing climate, what are the Government doing to ensure that our fire services are properly resourced for future wildfires?
I remember well my visit to Stourbridge; it will not leave me, actually, because of the devastation, and the loss of everything in a moment for so many families. My hon. Friend’s support for them was really visible on the day, and the community is clearly very strong; that was evident. I am going to be chairing a wildfire summit, and she is welcome to be part of that, if she wishes. Our fire services are not set up for the future. I mentioned community resilience before; we need a fire service that has a statutory responsibility to deal with flooding, that is equipped to deal with wildfires, and with back-up national aerial support, so that there is better support next time we see these issues. I give my hon. Friend my word that we will learn every possible lesson from what she and her community went through.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q24
Partial Answer
Despite long and historic disagreements between successive UK Governments and Israel, it has remained a steadfast ally in counter-terrorist efforts to keep our people safe in this country. We are now embarked, it seems, on a full diplomatic dispute with Israel and tit-for-tat expulsions of diplomats. What advice was the Foreign Office giving Ministers on this matter, and what advice were the security services giving about our national security interest before this decision was taken?
We gave the most careful consideration to all of the issues involved, and indeed all of the risks. The Foreign Secretary and I took close advice from the security services and, of course, officials in the Foreign Office and in our embassies. The risk of the collapse of the two-state solution and the effect that would have on the middle east should concern us all. The risk is that it is dying before our eyes, and that requires us to have the courage to act. In the world that we are in, if Britain loses the confidence to lead on the world stage, where will we be? Where will this country be? It is right that we have taken this action. The Father of the House said yesterday that he “absolutely and fully” supports what my right hon. Friend the Foreign Secretary is doing,
“standing up for freedom, for morality and for justice for all people in this world.” —[Official Report, 8 September 2026; Vol. 790, c. 891.]
Those were his words, and we take great heart from them.
“standing up for freedom, for morality and for justice for all people in this world.” —[Official Report, 8 September 2026; Vol. 790, c. 891.]
Those were his words, and we take great heart from them.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy