Questions & Answers
Q1
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Sullivan noted her campaign to restore the Gravesend-Tilbury ferry, which was cut by the Conservatives.
Does my right hon. Friend agree that our town and local centres are the lifeblood of our economy? Will he confirm that this Labour Government will do what it takes to unlock the potential of our local economies? One such example would be supporting the campaign to restore the Gravesend-Tilbury ferry.
I congratulate my hon. Friend on her campaign to restore the Gravesend-Tilbury ferry. We are determined to help town centres thrive through our high streets strategy, backed by more than £300 million of investment. The local council can use integrated transport funding for priorities including ferry services.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Coutinho highlighted that Labour banned new oil and gas licences in the North Sea.
Why are the Labour Government happy for Britain to get its oil and gas from Russia or Qatar but not from Aberdeen? Will the right hon. Gentleman tell me how many jobs have been lost in Aberdeen since Labour came to power?
Over 700 jobs were lost in the last 10 years that the Tories were in power, and production fell 75% over the last 25 years. We have secured over £900 billion of investment to support more jobs by taking control with renewables.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Coutinho mentioned that one thousand people are losing their jobs every month in places like Aberdeen South due to Labour's policies.
How many jobs have been lost in Aberdeen since Labour came to power? Can he tell the House how he would feel if the Government forced him to take a 50% pay cut?
Oil and gas are coming out of the North sea 24/7. In the first three months of this year, 52 million barrels of oil came out, and the equivalent of 44 million barrels of gas came out. We do want to create more jobs, which is why we will continue to invest in renewables.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not answer how he would feel about a pay cut
The Right Hon. Lady Used To Be An Investment Banker, And She Has Got Her Facts Wrong.
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Coutinho noted that the Energy Secretary refused to meet the Prime Minister on a matter of national security.
The Government say that those oil and gas workers can get new green jobs, but what they do not say is that those salaries pay half as much. Why has he not been sacked?
When the defence investment plan is published, it will set out how every Government Department is contributing to defence, including the Energy Department.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address why the Energy Secretary has not been sacked
Stop Reading The Papers
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Coutinho mentioned that the Energy Secretary refused to meet the Prime Minister on a matter of national security.
Why has he not been sacked? The right hon. Lady asked again about pay cuts, which the Government should care about because if the Mayor of Manchester gets his way, I am pretty sure that half of the Front Bench will be getting a pay cut pretty soon.
When the defence investment plan is published, it will set out how every Government Department is contributing to defence, including the Energy Department. We will always put national security first.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address why the Energy Secretary has not been sacked
Stop Reading The Papers
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question arises from a perceived inconsistency in the government's priorities, with half of the Defence team quitting last week. It also references the government's refusal to claim £25 billion tax revenue from the North Sea.
If everything is so hunky-dory, why did half the Defence team quit last week? The Government will not find the money to keep our country safe, so let us go through some of the things they can find money for. They can find millions of pounds to build solar farms in the Congo, and tens of millions of pounds for an experiment to dim the sun, but they are turning down £25 billion in tax revenue from the North sea to please their out-of-control Energy Secretary. Does the Deputy Prime Minister really think that any of that is more important than defending our country?
We have said that more spending on defence is our No. 1 priority in this spending review and the next spending review. The right hon. Lady wants to talk about resignations. Let us remind ourselves of the Tory Defence Secretary in the last Government—the right hon. Member for Stone, Great Wyrley and Penkridge (Sir Gavin Williamson)—who was sacked for breaching national security; the Tory Defence Secretary Michael Fallon, who resigned over sexual harassment; and the Tory Defence Secretary Ben Wallace, who admitted hollowing out the armed forces for 14 years.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about prioritising other projects over defence was not addressed.
Changed Subject To Past Conservative Government Resignations
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question reflects the perception of the current government as unstable, with a new Defence Secretary appointed and ongoing speculation about leadership changes.
If everything is fine, why do we have a new Defence Secretary? [Interruption.] He was not here last week, was he? Let us face it: this is a Government on life support. What is their grand plan now? Let me get this straight: they want to make the job-destroying Energy Secretary Chancellor; they want to bring back the former Transport Secretary, who resigned for nicking phones; and they want to replace the Deputy Prime Minister with the former Deputy Prime Minister, who resigned for dodging taxes. Those are all pointless distractions. Here is a better idea: why do they not cut welfare, fund defence, make energy cheap and back the North sea?
It is very thin gruel. I am here, like the right hon. Lady, because I am standing in for the leader of my party. I am proud to serve the Prime Minister and proud of what the Labour Government are delivering: more rights for working people—the biggest upgrade to workers' rights in a generation—the biggest boost to defence spending since the cold war, and lifting more children out of poverty in a single term than any British Government in history.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about current plans was not addressed.
Changed Subject To Labour'S Achievements
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Recent incidents of paramilitary activity have led to families being burned out, health workers intimidated, and businesses ordered to close based on ethnicity or political affiliation.
I, too, wish to pay tribute to Jo Cox and her family, and to the commitment in her name that we tackle division and extremism. We saw extremism play out on the streets of Belfast last week—a pogrom where families were burned out based on the colour of their skin; health workers were stopped and asked for ID by masked thugs; and small businesses were ordered to close. Many minorities are still living in fear after a list of their addresses was circulated widely online. They deserve more than sympathy and warm words; they deserve to know that Governments are serious about confronting hatred online and offline. The UK Government and the Northern Ireland Executive spend millions each year on programmes intended to tackle paramilitarism, but, decades after the troubles, individuals linked to loyalist paramilitaries had a role in directing and fuelling the disorder last week, including menacing a senior journalist on tape. Will the UK Government commit to reviewing how the Northern Ireland Executive are gripping—or failing to grip—paramilitarism? Will they ensure that public money never reaches individuals or groups who fuel, orchestrate or benefit from intimidation and hate?
I join the hon. Lady in utterly condemning the violence. People are right to feel sickened by the sight of people being burned out of their homes because of the colour of their skin. That is racism, and those responsible will face the full force of the law. We must never go back to 1950s Britain, where my father arrived to signs saying, “No blacks, no dogs, no Irish.” We are focused on bringing people together, and that includes by providing a further £24 million to help to tackle paramilitarism and by acting to tackle those who incite hatred online; our social cohesion plan is about bringing our communities together. I am happy to work with all parties in that endeavour.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask for a review of how the Northern Ireland Executive are tackling paramilitarism was not addressed.
Provided General Commitment But No Concrete Plan
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question stems from concerns that the Treasury's refusal to consider new ways of funding defence is undermining national security. It suggests an alternative approach through defence bonds.
May I associate myself and my party with the Deputy Prime Minister's tribute to Jo Cox? We extend our condolences to her friends and family, and to those of Roy Hattersley as well. I also join the Deputy Prime Minister in remembering the horrific tragedy of Grenfell, and that the families still await justice. I congratulate all those named in the King's birthday honours list, congratulate Scotland and wish good luck to England this evening. The right hon. Member for Rawmarsh and Conisbrough (John Healey) is respected across the House. When he says that he was forced to make decisions that could make the country less safe, we should all take heed. It is now becoming clear that the Treasury's refusal to consider new ways of funding defence is undermining our national security, so will the Deputy Prime Minister join with us to make the case in Government for new defence bonds, which could raise £20 billion over two years to defend our country?
We believe we should work with our allies to join up defence, procurement and funding. That is why we are exploring the most effective mechanisms for multilateral co-operation, which is of course a topic of discussion for the Prime Minister at the G7.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about supporting new defence bonds was not addressed.
Changed Subject To Discussing Multilateral Cooperation
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Five years have passed since the Prime Minister set out his red lines on Europe, but global circumstances have changed. The world now faces challenges such as Putin's war in Ukraine and rising costs of living.
We are pleased to hear that the Government is looking at this issue but need them to act much quicker. Given the changes since then, does the Deputy Prime Minister agree that the red lines should be reconsidered or will it be left to a future government?
Our red lines remain but we are focused on negotiating deals that cut prices, offer youth experience schemes and reduce export regulations.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific request to reconsider the red lines was not addressed directly
We Are Focused On Other Aspects Of Negotiations
Response accuracy
Q11
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Mark Sommerville, a constituent with MND since 2023, fights for the disease's cure. He runs a foundation focusing on care improvement and research.
I support Mark Sommerville and his foundation in pushing for a new national MND strategy emphasizing finding effective treatments, enhancing trial access, and accelerating drug discovery. Will my right hon. Friend meet me to discuss further?
We are committed to improving care for people with motor neurone disease and investing in cutting-edge research, including a world-first clinical trial. The Minister for Care would be happy to meet my hon. Friend to discuss further.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Since the Government's coming to power, over half a million businesses have closed, nearly a million young people are unemployed or in training programs, and graduate recruitment is at an all-time low.
Can the Deputy Prime Minister tell me if these outcomes are due to business rate hikes, job tax, Employment Rights Act changes, or some combination of these factors?
We have the fastest growing economy in the G7, borrowing is down and we have just signed our fifth major trade deal. The Tory deputy chairman was on television laughing about a firebomb attack on the Prime Minister's home.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Questioner Was Accused Of Inappropriate Behavior
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A Makerfield candidate for Reform made disgraceful comments about abortions, mums with prams in their pyjamas, and failed to apologize to Carol Vorderman.
Does the Deputy Prime Minister agree that Reform has a problem with women given they have embraced a politician endorsing sexist remarks?
The Prime Minister is putting tackling violence against women and girls at the heart of this Labour Government. By contrast, I am utterly appalled by what we have heard from the Reform candidate in Makerfield.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Reform'S Politics Were Attacked As Opposed To Answering About Women Issues
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There are approximately 400,000 private hire and black cab drivers in the UK facing unsafe working conditions, discrimination, and low pay.
Why is the Government pushing an agenda that will drive tens of thousands out of work due to AI deployment by Uber? Will he arrange a meeting for discussion?
We have to get governance right and test safety measures. I do not think we can stand in the face of innovation.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific concerns about driver employment were not addressed directly
Emphasis On Getting Governance Right
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Yesterday marked the 10th anniversary of Jo Cox's murder, a tragic event that deeply affected her family and community.
I associate myself with the remarks of the Deputy Prime Minister. Yesterday was the 10th anniversary of the murder of our dear friend Jo Cox, who was not just an MP but also a sister, wife, daughter, and mother. Her mantra was 'more in common than that which divides us.' What should we do to ensure her beliefs and legacy are always remembered?
We all have a duty to live up to the values that Jo stood for. She was a trailblazing campaigner against loneliness and inspired the Great Get Together taking place this weekend, in which neighbours come together, differences set aside, and communities choose unity over division.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify concrete actions or commitments to ensure Jo's legacy is remembered beyond general principles.
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
London's police force is facing a reduction in officers due to the Home Secretary's policies and Sadiq Khan's decision.
I know that the Deputy Prime Minister has struggled with police visibility. London will be less safe because of the Government's police cuts and Sadiq Khan's decision last week to block a key contract, leading to 500 fewer frontline police officers. Does he agree with Sir Mark Rowley?
We on the Labour side remember the decisions by Boris Johnson to cut policing across the country. We have put neighbourhood policing back at the heart of our communities and are putting in extra policing across the country.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address whether he agrees that London will be less safe but instead criticized previous government's cuts.
Response accuracy
Q17
Direct Answer
▸
Context
A film called 'People's Emergency Briefing' is being shown to educate communities about the climate emergency.
The People's Emergency Briefing film educates us on the climate emergency. However, the Conservatives have given up on it. Will the Deputy Prime Minister assure me that this Labour Government will continue doing everything possible to combat man-made climate change?
I am proud of restoring the UK's position as a global leader on climate action, with ambitious targets to reduce emissions and seize opportunities in clean power. The net zero economy now supports 1.1m jobs and generates £105bn.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
New steel quotas and tariffs will come into force in two weeks, risking job losses and deindustrialisation.
In two weeks, new steel quotas and 50% tariffs will be implemented. UKF Steel in my constituency faces closure by the end of the year if no action is taken. What steps are being taken to mitigate this economic disaster?
The hon. Gentleman raises a serious issue, but he might have forgotten that this House legislated for emergency measures to save steel across our country. Further action will be taken and discussed at the Prime Minister's G7 agenda.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify concrete actions or timeline beyond stating it is on the Prime Minister's agenda.
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Over 30,000 deaths annually are attributed to poor air quality in the UK. Ella Kissi-Debrah's death highlighted this issue.
In order to keep our NHS working well long-term, we must focus on prevention. Every year over 30,000 deaths are due to poor air quality; Ella Kissi-Debrah's tragic case being an example. Seventy years after the Clean Air Act 1956, will the Deputy Prime Minister support updating this essential law to protect our NHS and children's health?
Through our environmental improvement plan, we are taking action to cut pollutants by a third, reforming industrial permitting to reduce emissions. A Minister is willing to meet my hon. Friend to discuss this further.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly state support for updating the Clean Air Act but offered to discuss it in detail with the MP.
Response accuracy
Q20
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Eastbourne pier is an iconic landmark facing concerns over its future due to liquidation and high maintenance costs.
Eastbourne pier is an iconic part of our heritage, economy, and my personal identity. The residents are concerned after a company connected to the pier fell into liquidation, with maintenance costs being very high. Will the Deputy Prime Minister support my 'Protect Our Pier' campaign and meet me to discuss emergency measures?
The government has allocated £20 million of Pride in Place funding for Eastbourne regeneration. The hon. Gentleman is meeting the Under-Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government to discuss his campaign.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address emergency measures or specific support for the 'Protect Our Pier' campaign
Response accuracy
Q21
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Investors in Thames Water are concerned about the company's restructuring which could impact consumers' bills and the environment.
Thames Water's distant creditors control the company. Their current deal is being objected to by the Government, but there is uncertainty on whose interests will be prioritised in any restructuring: senior creditors or customers and environmental health. Whose side is the Deputy Prime Minister on?
The Government supports consumers, not paying for years of failure by the Conservatives. Labour blocked bonuses and introduced criminal sanctions for polluting water bosses; a new powerful regulator will hold companies accountable.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A small rural settlement, Stoke Heath, is set to receive a significant influx of asylum seekers, raising concerns about the impact on the local community.
Stoke Heath will see an increase of 121 asylum seekers within weeks, equivalent to a massive population surge. This level of dispersal into a small rural area seems unfair. Is the Deputy Prime Minister in agreement?
Reduction in net migration of 82% over 23 months; honesty about detaining people when necessary. Immigration Minister will look at the matter.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not explicitly state whether it is fair for small rural communities to experience such significant population increases
Response accuracy
Q23
Direct Answer
▸
Context
There are growing concerns about the harmful effects of online platforms on children and teenagers, including self-harm, suicide, and mental health issues.
The Government's willingness to protect young people from harmful online content is welcome. Such material often manipulates speech rather than promoting free speech. Companies must be held accountable for harms caused. Does the Deputy Prime Minister agree? What further actions will the Government take?
Agrees; decision to ban social media for under-16s; asked Ofcom to review its capability for enforcing this ban.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q24
Direct Answer
▸
Context
A constituent with a brain tumour received necessary treatment after approaching the Government, highlighting issues of inequity in cancer services across different regions.
The issue of equitable cancer service across the United Kingdom has been highlighted by my constituent Archie Goodburn. How will the Government ensure that people receive the best possible treatment regardless of where they live?
New target to save 320,000 lives by ensuring that 75% of patients diagnosed from 2035 will be cancer-free or living well after five years. End postcode lottery on cancer; introduce a three-year neighbourhood early diagnosis fund and cover travel costs for treatment.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q25
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP thanked the Harlow Town Park volunteers for repairing the zig-zag bridge. He highlighted the Government's new youth hubs initiative, which includes a site in Harlow.
I thank the Deputy Prime Minister and others for their comments about Jo Cox; our thoughts are with her family today, as they are every day. May I also thank the Harlow Town Park volunteers, who I joined this morning in repairing the iconic zig-zag bridge in Harlow? Harlow will be the site of one of the Government's new youth hubs—another example of this Labour Government investing in our town. I believe passionately that Harlow's young people have so much potential. Does the Deputy Prime Minister agree? Does he also agree that this funding will unlock that potential?
My hon. Friend is a former schoolteacher, and I know how much he cares about this matter. I am delighted that we have announced the locations of 180 new youth hubs, which include Harlow; it means that more young people across the country will benefit from skills and training opportunities. This week, we have shown that this Labour Government are working to transform the lives of our young people.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific potential of unlocking Harlow's youth potential was not directly addressed with commitments or details.
Response accuracy