Topical Questions 2026-04-28

2026-04-28

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Direct Answer
Cat Smith Lab
Lancaster and Wyre
Context
The Labour MP notes positive economic indic [5D [K indicators but questions the approach, citing lower unemployment and borrow [6D [K borrowing compared to other G7 nations.
If she will make a statement on her departmental [K responsibilities. Unemployment is down, the economy is growing, interest ra [2D [K rates have been cut six times, last year Government borrowing was lower tha [3D [K than it was the previous year and is set to fall by more than in any other [K G7 economy. At the same time, the Government are acting responsibly on the [K world stage. This is a war that we did not start, we did not enter, and we [K are working with our international allies to de-escalate.
We are on the right path with the right economic pl [2D [K plan. Unemployment is down, the economy is growing, interest rates have bee [3D [K been cut six times, last year Government borrowing was lower than it was th [2D [K the previous year and is set to fall by more than in any other G7 economy. [K At the same time, the Government are acting responsibly on the world stage. [6D [K stage. This is a war that we did not start, we did not enter, and we are wo [2D [K working with our international allies to de-escalate. Our focus is on prote [5D [K protecting family finances, supporting businesses and taking care with the [K public purse to improve Britain's economic resilience.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Direct Answer
Cat Smith Lab
Lancaster and Wyre
Context
The Labour MP highlights the lifting of the [3D [K the two-child benefit cap, emphasizing its moral and economic benefits for [K families in Lancaster and Wyre.
I thank the Chancellor for her work to lift the t [1D [K two-child benefit cap, which was cruelly brought in by the Conservative Gov [3D [K Government. Does she agree that that is not only morally the right thing to [2D [K to do, but economically good news for the 1,690 families in Lancaster and W [1D [K Wyre who will have more money in their pockets to spend in our local econom [6D [K economy in Lancashire—unlike the super-rich, who would have just taken it t [1D [K to offshore tax havens?
Just a couple of weeks ago, I hosted an event in Do [2D [K Downing Street where I met people who are benefiting from the change in the [3D [K the two-child limit and people who had campaigned for that change. Mums tol [3D [K told me that they were going to use the money to pay for their kids to go t [1D [K to after-school clubs with their friends, swimming lessons that they could [K not afford before, or a new school coat rather than a second-hand one. That [4D [K That is the difference that this money is making to families up and down th [2D [K the country. I am proud to be the Chancellor who has scrapped the two-child [9D [K two-child limit.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Mel Stride Con
Central Devon
Context
The Conservative MP questions the Chancello [9D [K Chancellor about government borrowing, referencing a deficit reduction plan [4D [K plan and comparing current plans with inherited ones.
In response to the question from my right hon. Fr [2D [K Friend the Member for Godalming and Ash (Sir Jeremy Hunt) on borrowing, the [3D [K the right hon. Lady suggested that she was following a strict deficit reduc [5D [K reduction plan. I think she made reference to a reduction in the deficit of [2D [K of £20 billion year on year—but, of course, it is easy to reduce something [K if you pump it up recklessly in the first place. Could she tell the House h [1D [K how much more borrowing this Government will undertake across this Parliame [8D [K Parliament compared with the plans that she inherited from the last Governm [7D [K Government?
To start with, let us remember that the plans we in [2D [K inherited from the last Government would have seen fuel duty go up straight [8D [K straightaway; the plans that we inherited from the last Government would no [2D [K not have seen £29 billion of investment a year in our NHS; and the plans th [2D [K that we inherited from the last Government would have seen business rates f [1D [K for our high street businesses—our retail, hospitality and leisure business [8D [K businesses—go up straightaway. We did make the decision to change that inhe [4D [K inheritance because we thought it was the right thing to do, and we still d [1D [K do. The International Monetary Fund confirmed that we have the fastest rate [4D [K rate of fiscal consolidation of any country in the G7, and our borrowing as [2D [K as a share of GDP fell to 4.3% in the last financial year and is due to fal [3D [K fall in every single year of this Parliament. This is the first time that o [1D [K our deficit has been lower than 5% since 2019.
Assessment & feedback
The specific amount of borrowing was not provided [8D [K provided, only comparisons with previous government's plans and general fis [3D [K fiscal consolidation figures were given.
Working With International Allies Change Th [2D [K That Inheritance Because We Thought It Was The Right Thing To Do
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Mel Stride Con
Central Devon
Context
The question arises from concerns about gov [3D [K government borrowing compared to the previous administration's plans. The r [1D [K right hon. Member references a significant increase in borrowing.
Why has this Chancellor increased borrowing by on [2D [K one quarter of a trillion pounds, leading to higher borrowing costs, inflat [6D [K inflation, interest rates, and sluggish growth?
The right hon. Gentleman would have increased fuel [K duty and business rates; we reduced them instead. We are reducing the budge [5D [K budget deficit, now below 5% of GDP for the first time in six years, leadin [6D [K leading the Bank of England to cut interest rates six times since our elect [5D [K election mandate.
Assessment & feedback
The economic impact of borrowing
We Are Committed To Reducing Costs
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Yuan Yang Lab
Earley and Woodley
Context
A constituent fears becoming homeless due t [1D [K to high rent costs following the invasion of Iran. The question addresses t [1D [K the need for a rent freeze to protect renters.
Will the Chancellor examine the case for a fixed- [6D [K fixed-term rent freeze in the private rented sector, considering the impact [6D [K impact of inflation and conflict on constituents' affordability?
We have taken action on energy prices, fuel duty, p [1D [K prescription charges, and rail fares. We introduced the Renters' Rights Act [3D [K Act 2025 and are helping people with mortgages. We will also help those in [K the private rented sector to ensure they do not become poorer due to confli [6D [K conflicts.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to a rent freeze
We Have Taken Action On Energy Prices
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Daisy Cooper Lib Dem
St Albans
Context
Small businesses are facing high bills foll [4D [K following revaluations, leading some to close. The question requests a revi [4D [K review of these assessments.
Will the Chancellor look again at eye-watering bu [2D [K business rate revaluations and release the full 20p discount for small busi [4D [K businesses as legislated?
This Government inherited plans for an independent [K revaluation of properties. We then put in £4.3 billion of support to limit [K increases, introduced a differential within the business rates system, and [K continue to review all taxes.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to reviewing and releasing full 20p di [2D [K discount
We Will Keep All Taxes Under Review
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Antonia Bance Lab
Tipton and Wednesbury
Context
The economy was growing, unemployment was d [1D [K decreasing, and borrowing was lower than forecast. The question highlights [K the Chancellor's decisions during this period.
We now know what was going on in the economy befo [4D [K before the attack on Iran. Growth was up. Unemployment was down. Borrowing [K was lower than forecast. The Chancellor took the right decisions and it was [3D [K was working. Does my right hon. Friend agree that families and businesses s [1D [K should know that, when times are tough, it is Trumpflation that is to blame [5D [K blame?
I thank my hon. Friend for that question. While oth [3D [K other parties—specifically Reform and the Conservatives—wanted us to enter [K this war, we stayed out of it, and are working to de-escalate the conflict [K and reopen the strait of Hormuz. The economy was growing, interest rates we [2D [K were coming down and inflation was falling. As a result, every month since [K I have become Chancellor, wages have risen by more than inflation, easing t [1D [K the cost of living pressures that the previous Government oversaw.
Assessment & feedback
The specific question about attributing economic [K difficulties to 'Trumpflation' was not directly addressed. Instead, the ans [3D [K answer focused on the broader context and actions taken regarding the confl [5D [K conflict and economy.
Stayed Out Of It Working To De-Escalate
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Olly Glover Lib Dem
Didcot and Wantage
At a recent meeting with members of Wantage chamber of commerce, local businesses were united in their concerns about business rates and unconvinced by recent Government tweaks that Ministers have just alluded to. Page 31 of Labour’s manifesto states:
“The current business rates system disincentivises investment, creates uncertainty and places an undue burden on our high streets. In England, Labour will replace the business rates system, so we can raise the same revenue but in a fairer”—
I am always happy to take questions on business rates, even months after the decision set out at the Budget, and I thank the hon. Member for reading out the Labour manifesto. We have made significant changes to business rates by introducing the new lower multiplier for high street businesses so that they can pay a lower tax rate than the largest online giants.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Given that Reform in Worcestershire promised to cut taxes but has instead increased county council tax for Redditch residents by nearly 9%, does the Chancellor agree that at the Redditch borough council elections on 7 May the only way to protect vital local services and keep taxes low is to vote for Redditch Labour candidates?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right that although Reform-led Worcestershire council said that it would cut taxes, it has instead put them up. That is why I urge people in Redditch and across the country to vote Labour on 7 May.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Sarah Olney Lib Dem
Richmond Park
Context
More than 1.3 million people use lifetime ISAs [K to save for their first home, but the property cap of £450,000 has been fro [3D [K frozen since 2017 despite rising house prices in London.
First-time buyers across London face a 25% penalty if [2D [K if buying over the £450,000 threshold. Data from February this year showed [K that the average price paid by a first-time buyer in London was £463,000. C [1D [K Can the Chancellor ensure first-time buyers are not unfairly disadvantaged [K by using lifetime ISAs?
The Government recognise that the LISA is not working f [1D [K for everyone, and have launched a short consultation on a new ISA product t [1D [K to support more first-time buyers. The new product will include the Governm [7D [K Government bonus paid at the point of withdrawal for home purchase.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitments or timeline for implementing cha [3D [K changes were not provided
Response accuracy
Q11 Direct Answer
Tom Rutland Lab
East Worthing and Shoreham
Context
BP's profits have more than doubled due to the [K conflict in the Middle East, raising concerns about excessive profits made [K by oil companies.
BP's profits have more than doubled due to the confli [6D [K conflict. Does she agree that a windfall tax on oil and gas is necessary at [2D [K at this time?
The energy profits levy remains in place for now, captu [5D [K capturing profits made by UK companies during conflicts. The Conservative o [1D [K opposition opposes this tax, which would just mean higher profits for oil a [1D [K and gas companies.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Chris Coghlan Lib Dem
Dorking and Horley
Context
There are reports that the Chancellor is consid [6D [K considering issuing defence bonds to increase R&D and economic growth.
Does the Minister agree that issuing defence bonds co [2D [K could be a powerful way to support R&D and raise economic growth?
Spending funded by bonds must adhere to fiscal rules, b [1D [K but the Minister acknowledges the importance of research and development wi [2D [K within the defence industry. Last year, £400 million was allocated for UK d [1D [K defence innovation.
Assessment & feedback
Specific details on whether issuing defence bonds is [K under consideration were not provided
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Michael Wheeler Lab
Worsley and Eccles
Context
Workers in Worsley and Eccles now get statutory [9D [K statutory sick pay from day one, thanks to Labour's efforts.
Does the Chancellor agree that only Labour, with its [K trade union link, is on the side of working people by ensuring workers get [K sick pay from day one?
Strengthening statutory sick pay is part of Labour's co [2D [K commitment to make work pay, and USDAW's efforts have been recognised.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about Labour being on the side of wo [2D [K working people was not addressed directly with a clear commitment or action [6D [K action
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Shockat Adam Ind
Leicester South
Context
The home ownership rate in Leicester South [K is just over 40%, nearly 23 percentage points below the national average. T [1D [K The city's house prices are 8.5 times higher than the local earnings.
Leicester South has a home ownership rate of just [4D [K just over 40%—nearly 23 points below the national average—in a city where t [1D [K the average house costs 8.5 times average local earnings. My young constitu [8D [K constituents work very hard and save responsibly to get on to the housing l [1D [K ladder, yet the tax system offers them absolutely nothing, while incorporat [10D [K incorporated landlords deduct full mortgage interest through a company stru [4D [K structure. Canada and Nordic countries are offering targeted tax relief for [3D [K for first-time buyers. Has the Chancellor considered introducing a similar [K relief here to ensure that young people are supported by the tax system, no [2D [K not left behind?
This Labour Government are committed to enabling mo [2D [K more people to realise the dream of home ownership. Mortgages have become m [1D [K more affordable under this Government, thanks to increased economic stabili [7D [K stability and six interest rate cuts.
Assessment & feedback
Specific tax relief for first-time buyers was not [3D [K not addressed
Response accuracy