Topical Questions 2026-04-23

2026-04-23

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Steve Race Lab
Exeter
Context
No specific background provided, the MP is [K asking for an update on departmental activities.
If he will make a statement on his departmental r [1D [K responsibilities.
May I begin by wishing the Parliamentary Secretary [K at the Cabinet Office, my hon. Friend the Member for Bury North (Mr Frith), [7D [K Frith), a happy birthday, and noting the generosity and co-ordination of th [2D [K the House in not submitting a single question for him to answer today? I en [2D [K encourage Members to submit particularly difficult questions for him in fut [3D [K future. I will update the House on some of the work that I am leading in re [2D [K response to the war in the middle east. As part of our work with the new mi [2D [K middle east response committee, I am chairing a new contingency planning mi [2D [K ministerial group. It will focus on preparing for and mitigating, where pos [3D [K possible, any impact on our economy and domestic security as a result of th [2D [K the conflict. I am convening relevant Secretaries of State twice a week, wi [2D [K with their permanent secretaries, to scrutinise plans and ensure that we ar [2D [K are prepared for different outcomes across major and relevant UK supply cha [3D [K chains.
Assessment & feedback
The response did not directly address the specifi [7D [K specific request for an update on departmental responsibilities; it instead [7D [K instead provided information about contingency planning related to the Midd [4D [K Middle East conflict.
Response accuracy
Q2 Direct Answer
Steve Race Lab
Exeter
Context
The MP references recent Hungarian election [8D [K elections and anti-LGBT policies, asking about the UK's commitment to promo [5D [K promoting LGBT rights globally.
I am sure that the Minister will join me in welco [5D [K welcoming the result of the Hungarian election where, in part, anti-LGBT po [2D [K policies were roundly rejected at the ballot box. As LGBT rights suffer fro [3D [K from backsliding around the world, will the Minister commit to working with [4D [K with our EU partners to promote LGBT human rights across the world, includi [7D [K including by putting the topic on the agenda at the next EU-UK summit?
The Government are absolutely committed to promotin [8D [K promoting and protecting the human rights of LGBT people worldwide. Our UK- [3D [K UK-EU security and defence partnership is underpinned by shared values, and [3D [K and I absolutely give that commitment. We will continue to work closely wit [3D [K with EU partners to uphold those values.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Alex Burghart Con
Brentwood and Ongar
Last week, someone in the heart of Government leaked some extremely sensitive documents to The Guardian. This appears potentially to be a crime under the National Security Act 2023. Has the Cabinet Office reported it to the Metropolitan police?
As I confirmed to the House, I think, a day or so ago, a leak inquiry has begun. When further facts are established, we reserve the right to do so.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Alex Burghart Con
Brentwood and Ongar
Cat Little, the permanent secretary, has just told the Foreign Affairs Committee that a very, very small number of people have actually seen the document in question. Will the Chief Secretary to the Prime Minister commit to the House that when he has identified who leaked it, he will report them to the Metropolitan police?
I can confirm that we take this matter deeply seriously and, as I say, we reserve the right to do so once the facts have been established through the inquiry.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Jo Platt Lab Co-op
Leigh and Atherton
Happy St George’s day, Mr Speaker. The covid-19 inquiry exposed how long covid was repeatedly dismissed, despite its lasting impact on nearly 2 million people, including me. Can the Minister reassure those living with long covid that the Government will fully act on the inquiry’s findings and explain what steps are being taken to ensure that long covid and post-viral illnesses shape future resilience and pandemic planning?
My hon. Friend talks powerfully about the impact of long covid, and it has had that impact on many people following the pandemic. The most recent module 3 report from the covid inquiry covered this issue in detail. Of course, the Government will carefully consider the inquiry’s work on this in our full response—it absolutely should.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Peter Bedford Con
Mid Leicestershire
Last week, a former Attorney General wrote that there was no legal reason for the Government not to publish a list of the Humble Address documents being withheld by the Metropolitan police. Will the Government publish that list?
We are working in co-operation with the Metropolitan police. As the hon. Member would expect, and as I am sure the House would agree, we do not want to do anything that would interfere with the police process.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Callum Anderson Lab
Buckingham and Bletchley
The UK rightly committed 1.5% of GDP to boosting our national resilience, along with our NATO partners. Ahead of the next NATO summit in Ankara in July, can the Minister confirm whether the Government will publish a departmental breakdown of how the UK will meet its commitments?
In the national security strategy, the Government made an historic commitment to spend 5% of our GDP on national security by 2025. That includes funding to protect critical infrastructure, ensure civil preparedness and resilience, unleash innovation and strengthen our defence industrial base. We are currently working through proposals for the UK to meet the 1.5% NATO commitment, and we will set out our detailed plans in due course.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
John Cooper Con
Dumfries and Galloway
Happy St George’s day, Mr Speaker. We face many threats, but happily dragons are no longer one of them.
The Government maintain that the messages between Morgan McSweeney and his mentor Peter Mandelson are under the aegis of the Metropolitan police and therefore cannot be released, but surely the questions are critical to our understanding of what has gone on here and should be available to the House. Will the Government at least commit to publishing the questions?
As I have said from the Dispatch Box, the victims of Jeffrey Epstein want to see justice. A criminal investigation by the police is under way, and it is right that the House does not interfere with that process and works with the Metropolitan police to allow them to undertake their work.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Toby Perkins Lab
Chesterfield
I welcome what my right hon. Friends have been doing on public procurement. On car hire services, it is expected that around 20% of fleet industry vehicles will be electric, but less than 1% of Government purchases have been for electric vehicle hire. I know that the Government take this issue seriously, so will the Minister lay out what the Government are doing to ensure that they hire more electric vehicles?
My hon. Friend raises an important point. He is right about the reforms that we are trying to make to public procurement, and to improve our number of electric vehicles. I will write to him with the specifics on the Government Car Service.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Gregory Stafford Con
Farnham and Bordon
Context
Jonathan Powell was appointed to a position [8D [K position related to the British Indian Ocean Territory, with questions abou [4D [K about his security clearance.
Happy St George's day, Mr Speaker. When was Jonat [5D [K Jonathan Powell appointed as the Prime Minister's special envoy to the Brit [4D [K British Indian Ocean Territory, and what security clearance was he given on [2D [K on appointment.
I do not have that information to hand.
Assessment & feedback
Jonathan Powell's appointment details and securit [7D [K security clearance were not provided
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
A cyber-attack on Jaguar Land Rover affecte [7D [K affected the supply chain in Redditch, raising concerns about the proposed [K cyber-resilience index's scrutiny.
Happy St George's day, Mr Speaker. When Jaguar La [2D [K Land Rover was the victim of a cyber-attack, it had a devastating impact on [2D [K on the supply chain in Redditch. Will the proposed cyber-resilience index, [K which is part of the Government's welcome focus on improving cyber-security [14D [K cyber-security and national security, be subject to parliamentary scrutiny? [9D [K scrutiny?
We recognise the serious disruption that incidents [K such as the attack on JLR can cause for supply chains and local economies. [K We continually assess the resilience of our critical national infrastructur [13D [K infrastructure. The proposed cyber-resilience index will support improved a [1D [K accountability, and we are considering appropriate mechanisms to ensure par [3D [K parliamentary scrutiny as it is developed.
Assessment & feedback
Specific details on how parliamentary scrutiny wo [2D [K would be ensured were not provided
Considering
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Ben Maguire Lib Dem
North Cornwall
Context
Public contracts worth hundreds of millions [8D [K millions were handed to US tech firm Palantir, raising concerns about trans [5D [K transparency and ethical issues.
Successive Governments have handed public contrac [7D [K contracts worth hundreds of millions of pounds to the US tech firm Palantir [8D [K Palantir, including the Ministry of Defence and NHS England, for a procurem [8D [K procurement process that many clinicians and other experts say completely l [1D [K lacks transparency. That is not to mention Palantir's horrifying surveillan [10D [K surveillance of Palestinians on behalf of the Israel Defence Forces, as wel [3D [K well as its unethical involvement with United States Immigration and Custom [6D [K Customs Enforcement. Does the Minister accept the huge risks of outsourcing [11D [K outsourcing our sensitive information contracts to such amoral American dat [3D [K data leeches, and when will the Government prioritise more secure British-b [9D [K British-based alternatives?
As I have said, one aim of the Government's procure [7D [K procurement reforms is to ensure that we support more British companies and [3D [K and end the reliance on external suppliers. The two Palantir contracts that [4D [K that the hon. Gentleman mentions are for the NHS and defence, so it is best [4D [K best to take the matter up with the Department of Health and Social Care an [2D [K and the Ministry of Defence, which are the relevant Departments.
Assessment & feedback
The risks associated with Palantir's contracts we [2D [K were not acknowledged; rather, the issue was redirected to other department [10D [K departments
Best To Take The Matter Up With
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Catherine Atkinson Lab
Derby North
Context
Local businesses in Derby are investing in [K apprenticeships and employment for ex-prisoners, raising questions about ho [2D [K how social value is considered in procurement.
In Derby we have many businesses, including small [5D [K small and medium-sized businesses, that are investing in people through app [3D [K apprenticeships or by enabling people to turn their lives around after pris [4D [K prison through work. How will reforms to public procurement better recognis [8D [K recognise the social value that businesses provide when making procurement [K decisions?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right to raise that. S [1D [K Social value should be integral to the system, but the current system has b [1D [K become too tick-boxy and does not deliver what it needs to for local commun [6D [K communities like those in Derby. We are working with businesses, unions and [3D [K and charities on a new definition. I am happy to speak with her further abo [3D [K about it, but I think it is an important part of improving the system.
Assessment & feedback
Specific reforms or timelines for recognising soc [3D [K social value were not provided
Working On A New Definition Happy To Speak [K Further
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Charlie Dewhirst Con
Bridlington and The Wolds
Context
Concern over the Prime Minister's decision [K to dismiss Sir Olly Robbins, leading to potential employment tribunals or g [1D [K gagging orders.
If the Government are so confident in the Prime M [1D [K Minister's decision to sack Sir Olly Robbins, will the Minister today rule [K out settling any employment tribunal in advance of a hearing or imposing an [2D [K any gagging orders on Mr Robbins?
The House will understand that I am not at liberty [K to comment on a potential ongoing employment dispute.
Assessment & feedback
Settling an employment tribunal and gagging order [5D [K orders specifically
Not At Liberty To Comment
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Polly Billington Lab
East Thanet
Context
Concern over the impact of a conflict in ot [2D [K other countries resulting in shortages and inflation, affecting UK resilien [8D [K resilience. The government is forming a new contingency planning ministeria [10D [K ministerial group.
I am grateful to my right hon. Friend the Chief S [1D [K Secretary to the Prime Minister for confirming that he will chair a new con [3D [K contingency planning ministerial group to develop resilience to the threats [7D [K threats caused as a result of the conflict, which is not ours but having an [2D [K an impact on many other countries across the world, potentially resulting i [1D [K in shortages and inflation. Our resilience is dependent on their resilience [10D [K resilience. In that light, will my right hon. Friend agree to consider conv [4D [K convening a global summit to increase resilience through co-operation and c [1D [K collaboration?
I thank my hon. Friend for her excellent question. [K I can confirm that the Foreign Office is part of our contingency planning w [1D [K work at the centre of Government. On all issues, we look at the internation [11D [K international data available to us, and the Foreign Office will keep that i [1D [K in consideration when trying to support allies and partners, as well as ens [3D [K ensuring security and resilience for the UK.
Assessment & feedback
Convening a global summit specifically
Not Specific On Convening A Global Summit
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Victoria Collins Lib Dem
Harpenden and Berkhamsted
Over the Easter weekend, a 6-acre site in the Chilterns national landscape saw a massive unauthorised development. Despite swift action from Dacorum borough council to issue a temporary stop notice and an injunction, the work continued, with the police powerless to stop it and the council without the resources. What will the Minister do through cross-departmental work to uphold the rule of law and protect our precious landscapes?
I think any constituency MP would find those circumstances utterly unacceptable. If the hon. Member writes to me, I will ensure that I pass the information to colleagues in the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government to see what we can do.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Johanna Baxter Lab
Paisley and Renfrewshire South
A happy St George’s day to you, Mr Speaker. Global turbulence has driven up the cost of living for my constituents. Can the Minister set out how closening trading ties with our closest allies through the EU reset will help bring down prices for my constituents?
That is why the EU-UK reset is so important, as it will help us in bearing down on fuel bills and energy bills, which will help my hon. Friend’s constituents.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Josh Babarinde Lib Dem
Eastbourne
In February, Capita said to Eastbourne resident Keith that his civil service pension would be paid by March. By March, it said his pension would be paid in April. Now it says that it will not be paid before May. How will the Minister intervene to hold this cowboy corporate to account?
The Cabinet Office has been withholding milestone payments from Capita. We have a robust recovery plan, which says that full contractual service has to be restored by the end of June. I have been absolutely clear that I will consider all options at that moment, but I would be grateful if the hon. Member could write to me with the details of his constituent’s case.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q19 Partial Answer
Phil Brickell Lab
Bolton West
Context
The question addresses the issue of fraud i [1D [K in public sector finances and seeks information on government actions to re [2D [K recover funds.
Happy St George's day to you, Mr Speaker. Can the [3D [K the Minister set out what progress the Government have made in cracking dow [3D [K down on fraudsters who seek to defraud the public sector and what success t [1D [K they have had in clawing back money on behalf of hard-working taxpayers?
The Government have taken robust action through our [3D [K our Public Sector Fraud Authority. There is a huge amount of work being don [3D [K done. In fact, last year we saved the public purse more than £7.5 billion. [K A lot has been done, but there is lots more to do, and I am happy to meet m [1D [K my hon. Friend to discuss that further.
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not provide specific commitments o [1D [K or timelines for future actions.
A Lot Has Been Done, But There Is Lots More To [2D [K To Do
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Claire Young Lib Dem
Thornbury and Yate
Context
A business raised concerns about the grid's [6D [K grid's vulnerability to potential sabotage from China, similar to the issue [5D [K issue with Huawei and 5G.
Happy St George's day. A local business expressed [9D [K expressed concern over grid resilience in relation to high-risk Chinese com [3D [K components potentially being used in critical energy infrastructure. Given [K past actions on Huawei and 5G, what steps is the Cabinet Office taking to e [1D [K exclude such components?
If the hon. Member would like to write to me, I wou [3D [K would be happy to look at the details of what she has raised. She will unde [4D [K understand that I do not want to get into the detail of it now, but I give [K her an assurance that we look very carefully at all these matters and take [K decisions in our national security interests.
Assessment & feedback
Specific steps or measures being taken by the Cab [3D [K Cabinet Office to exclude high-risk Chinese components from critical energy [6D [K energy infrastructure were not provided.
If The Hon. Member Would Like To Write To Me, [K I Would Be Happy To Look At The Details Of What She Has Raised.
Response accuracy