Topical Questions 2026-04-14
2026-04-14
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Labour Government is investing heavily [K in community diagnostic centres to improve healthcare access.
I am concerned about the investment being made in [2D [K in 36 new and better community diagnostic centres in shopping centres and h [1D [K high streets across England. This represents a significant expansion in dia [3D [K diagnostics, shorter waits for tests, checks, and scans, and an NHS on the [K road to recovery.
We are investing in 36 new and better community dia [3D [K diagnostic centres in shopping centres and high streets across England. Thi [3D [K This is the biggest expansion in diagnostics in a generation, shorter waits [5D [K waits for tests, checks and scans, and an NHS on the road to recovery.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A constituent named Emma has been fighting [K for corrective treatment due to injuries sustained during childbirth, but h [1D [K has been denied care on the NHS.
A constituent of mine, Emma, has been left with s [1D [K significant injuries following poor maternity care during childbirth. She h [1D [K has fought for over 20 years for corrective treatment which was deemed cosm [4D [K cosmetic despite impacting her mental health and relationships. What steps [K can be taken to ensure women in such circumstances have access to necessary [9D [K necessary treatment?
The injuries sustained by women during childbirth a [1D [K are often ignored and unaddressed. We need to learn from cases such as Emma [4D [K Emma's to ensure constituents receive the care they deserve.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions or policies not addressed
Response accuracy
Q3
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The British Medical Association has recentl [7D [K recently ended industrial action but online comments suggest future disrupt [7D [K disruptions are likely, impacting patient treatments and NHS staff.
Reports indicate individuals boasting of 10 days [K off following the end of recent BMA industrial action. Does this behaviour [K represent a slap in the face to patients whose treatments have been cancell [7D [K cancelled and NHS staff who had to pick up the pieces?
Yes, the BMA's actions reflect poorly on them, infl [4D [K inflicting disruption and a £300 million bill on the country in difficult t [1D [K times. The strike action was unnecessary and needs to be addressed.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
This is a rare occasion, as I agree with the Secretary of State. The increasingly militant stance adopted by the BMA is plainly out of step with some resident doctors, who continue to report for duty. The Government’s handling of this dispute has been marked by inconsistency. First, they attempted to buy their way out of trouble, then they withdrew the training places that this House voted for. Instead of persisting with a failed strategy, is it not time for the Government to heed our calls and bring forward legislation to ban doctors from striking?
The Government’s approach has been consistent. We recognise that resident doctors suffered years of pay erosion and worsening conditions under the Conservatives. We came in and sought to address that substantially with a 28.9% pay rise and an offer on the table that would have gone further on pay, gone further on training places and cancelled exam fees, which is the best deal that anyone will have got in the entire public sector. Resident doctors have rejected that approach, but the shadow Secretary of State reminds the BMA that however much it might disagree with this Labour Government, the alternatives are far worse. It is far better to work with us than against us, but we will not cave.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
The much-loved Pembridge hospice in north Kensington has been closed to in-patients for several years, meaning that an area with acute health inequality has very limited palliative care options, despite a promise from the new West London integrated care board to provide enhanced care beds in all its boroughs. Will the Minister join me in urging the ICB to set up a meaningful engagement process with residents to secure these urgent care beds as soon as possible, potentially at Pembridge, and to bring proper palliative and end-of-life options back to our community?
I thank my hon. Friend for his question; he is a strong voice for palliative care and for Pembridge hospice in his constituency. Palliative care is vital in our communities, and I completely agree that ICBs, like West London, should engage with their local communities to ensure that they can meet their palliative care needs.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
Wherever I go in North Shropshire, constituents tell me that access to a GP only gets worse when new homes are built, and they are right. Across the country, there are billions of pounds in unspent community infrastructure levies for new surgeries, and the average number of families that a GP serves has gone up by 917 since 2015. Will the Minister support Liberal Democrat calls for CIL to be used to support the early running costs of new GP practices, or to expand existing ones, as soon as people move into new housing, so that GP access really does come first when housing developments happen?
There is absolutely an issue with developers not delivering what they say they are going to deliver either through section 106 or through CIL. We are working closely with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government to address this issue. I would be more than happy to hear more about the hon. Lady’s specific proposal. We want to work pragmatically and constructively to resolve this issue.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
Short waiting lists for cataract surgery are a success story, thanks in part to the partnership between the NHS and providers such as SpaMedica, headquartered in my constituency. However, ICB indicative activity plans could see waiting lists increase from weeks to over four months. How will cataract patients be protected while we maintain those all-important short waiting lists?
Ophthalmology waiting lists have fallen since we have taken office. Average waiting times have reduced, and 18-week performance has improved. ICBs have the flexibility to commission services across specialties within a fixed financial envelope, and may use contract levers to manage that activity. That is good management of public money to achieve the outcomes we want to see.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Secretary of State announced £10 millio [6D [K million for the Royal Berkshire Hospital to fund a new site, but £400 milli [5D [K million is needed to maintain the existing hospital until rebuilding starts [6D [K starts in 2039.
Last week, the Secretary of State announced £10 m [1D [K million for the Royal Berkshire hospital to fund a new site. After years of [2D [K of Conservative neglect, £400 million is needed to maintain the existing Ro [2D [K Royal Berks until rebuilding starts in 2039. What is the Minister doing to [K support the hospital and its excellent staff to help fix its many maintenan [9D [K maintenance issues?
I am delighted that, as well as announcing the £10 [K million needed to purchase the new site for the Royal Berkshire, we are inv [3D [K investing in the existing estate; that is what local residents deserve. I w [1D [K was delighted to make that announcement last week with our brilliant Labour [6D [K Labour Reading council team.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions and funding details for addressi [8D [K addressing maintenance issues at the Royal Berkshire Hospital were not prov [4D [K provided.
Deflecting Onto Labour'S Work With Councils
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Residents in the Smethwick constituency are [3D [K are benefiting from the investment and changes to the NHS introduced by thi [3D [K this Labour Government, including shorter waiting times and ambulance waiti [5D [K waiting times.
Can I first take this opportunity to wish a very [K happy Vaisakhi to the Sikhs around the world who are celebrating it? Reside [6D [K Residents in my Smethwick constituency are benefiting from the investment i [1D [K in and changes to the NHS introduced by this Labour Government; the benefit [7D [K benefits include shorter waiting times and shorter ambulance waiting times. [6D [K times. Can the Secretary of State tell us what progress has been made in im [2D [K implementing the Government's 10-year plan for the NHS?
I wish a happy Vaisakhi to all who are celebrating [K today. Let me reassure my hon. Friend that he is absolutely right. As I rep [3D [K reported only this morning on BBC West Midlands, we are bringing down waiti [5D [K waiting lists in his area and across the west midlands, and we will make fu [2D [K further and faster progress; that is what a Labour Government do.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific details or statistics about the implemen [8D [K implementation of the 10-year plan were not provided.
Relying On General Statements About Progress W [1D [K Without Specifics
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
In Epsom and Ewell, many residents face a daily battle to get a GP appointment. There are numerous potential housing developments on the horizon, and the rising population is set to put even more pressure on already stretched GP services. The Liberal Democrats would require developers to build new GP surgeries, ready for when residents move in. Can the Government explain what they are doing to support GPs in my constituency, so that they can manage the surge in patient demand from day one of a development being completed, rather than leaving communities to pay the price later?
As I said to the hon. Member for North Shropshire (Helen Morgan), we are looking at the way that section 106 and CIL are used. I certainly look forward to working with councils across the country, but as my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State has said, when people go to the ballot box on 7 May, they should think very carefully about how much more effective it is when councils work in partnership with this Labour Government.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
What more can the Government do to ensure that social enterprises delivering NHS services get the same support as internal NHS trusts, and play a bigger role in NHS reform?
These organisations play an important role. We are making sure that they are treated fairly, and are supported to play a bigger role. They will be supported by the forthcoming plan for voluntary, community and social enterprise spending targets to 2028, and a combined action plan for small and medium-sized enterprises and VCSEs. That will include measures to ensure clearer visibility of opportunities, earlier market engagement, proportional financial and evaluation requirements, and a strong performance on prompt payment across the health system.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The British Dental Association has highligh [8D [K highlighted that only 39% of adults can access NHS treatment within two yea [3D [K years due to budget constraints.
The British Dental Association has highlighted th [2D [K that current budgets allow just 39% of adults to access NHS treatment withi [5D [K within a two-year period. Is that really the height of the Government's amb [3D [K ambition, and if not, what access percentage are the Government aiming for? [4D [K for?
We are working closely with the BDA on long-term co [2D [K contract reform. It has to be about getting the balance right, so that dent [4D [K dentists are incentivised to do NHS dentistry and we maximise access. A pub [3D [K public consultation on fundamental contract reform is coming before the sum [3D [K summer, and I am sure the hon. Member will want to take part in it.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a specific target percentage for [K NHS dental access
Working Closely With Bda
Public Consultatio [11D [K Consultation
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
In Scotland, about a third of people eligib [6D [K eligible for bowel cancer screening do not complete the faecal immunochemic [12D [K immunochemical test (FIT), rising to up to half in deprived areas.
Increasing the uptake of bowel cancer screening i [1D [K improves early diagnosis and saves lives. About a third of those eligible i [1D [K in Scotland are not completing FIT tests, with rates even lower in the most [4D [K most deprived areas. What collaborative work is being done to improve parti [5D [K participation and reduce health inequalities?
In Scotland there is no NHS app, but in England, th [2D [K the app facilitates bowel cancer screening and increases uptake. The SNP ha [2D [K has provided some dermatology services in Lanarkshire over 20 years.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address collaborative work to improve par [3D [K participation rates
No Nhs App In Scotland
Snp'S 20-Year Record [6D [K Record
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Residents of Maldon have been promised a ne [2D [K new health hub to replace the old St Peter's hospital, which is over 150 ye [2D [K years old. The ICB submitted a case for the second round of neighbourhood h [1D [K health centres.
My constituents in Maldon have waited more than 3 [1D [K 30 years for a new health hub replacing St Peter's hospital. Despite an uns [3D [K unsuccessful first attempt by the ICB, may I press the Government to includ [6D [K include Maldon in the second round? Will the Secretary of State meet me and [3D [K and my right hon. Friend to discuss this matter?
The Minister for Secondary Care has met the right h [1D [K hon. Gentleman, but the ICB was disappointed. There are further ways to do [K this, and it should keep trying.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm Maldon's inclusion in the next ro [2D [K round or a meeting with the Secretary of State
Met Right Hon. Gentleman
Further Ways To Do [2D [K Do This
Response accuracy
Q15
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The James Williams healthy living centre re [2D [K recently opened in Chatham, allowing constituents to receive care closer to [2D [K to home rather than travelling to the other end of Medway.
The James Williams healthy living centre has open [4D [K opened in my constituency. More residents can now access care locally inste [5D [K instead of traveling to the hospital. Will the Secretary of State join me f [1D [K for its official opening in the summer?
I would be delighted to. Let us arrange a date.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question concerns the January changes b [1D [K by the Government to prioritise British graduates for NHS training places, [K which has reduced competition but still causes uncertainty and demotivation [12D [K demotivation among graduates.
The changes that the Government made in January t [1D [K to prioritise British graduates for NHS training places were very welcome i [1D [K indeed, but the current system of random allocation demoralises and disince [7D [K disincentivises our brightest graduates, and it causes profound uncertainty [11D [K uncertainty for people at the start of their career. Will the Secretary of [K State consider changing the process, so that those places are instead alloc [5D [K allocated on merit?
The Medical Training (Prioritisation) Act 2026 is m [1D [K making a difference. It has reduced competition from four to one to less th [2D [K than two to one. We are absolutely up for looking at that issue as part of [K the workforce plan.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific request to change the process to mer [3D [K merit-based allocation was not directly addressed with a commitment or time [4D [K timeline.
We Are Absolutely Up For Looking At That Issue [5D [K Issue As Part Of The Workforce Plan.
Response accuracy
Q17
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Phil Woolas, a former Member of Parliament [K with glioblastoma, passed away recently. The question highlights the lack o [1D [K of improvement in treatment for this condition over 40 years.
At 2 pm today, many Members will be attending the [3D [K the funeral of Phil Woolas who died from glioblastoma brain tumour on 14 Ma [2D [K March. I am sure everyone would wish to send condolences but does the Secre [5D [K Secretary of State agree that condolences are not enough given no improveme [9D [K improvement in treatment for this condition in 40 years?
I join my hon. Friend in paying tribute to Phil Woo [3D [K Woolas and send condolences to his family. The National Institute for Healt [5D [K Health and Care Research brain tumour research consortium, backed by over £ [1D [K £25 million-worth of investment, aims to unlock new treatments and transfor [8D [K transform outcomes. Earlier this year, we announced £3 million with Cancer [K Research UK for the brain tumour centre of excellence including the glioma [K centre. We are close to major breakthroughs but hold NIHR and NHS England's [9D [K England's feet to the fire on improving treatment.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The questioner sought specific commitments or act [3D [K actions addressing the lack of progress in treating glioblastomas, while th [2D [K the answerer provided general statements about research efforts without con [3D [K concrete timelines or mechanisms for ensuring improvements.
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Cerys, a patient at Park House in Greater M [1D [K Manchester, died while an in-patient. The coroner described the unit as “a [K shambles”. There is concern over national patterns of mental health trusts [K failing to learn and act when tragedies occur.
Cerys was 22 when she took her life while an in-p [4D [K in-patient at Park House in Greater Manchester, with the coroner describing [10D [K describing the unit as a 'shambles'. Reports on preventing future deaths ar [2D [K are issued but no mechanism ensures recommendations are acted upon. How can [3D [K can accountability be strengthened?
Anyone receiving mental health treatment deserves d [1D [K dignity and high-quality care. Where care falls short, this Government's ap [2D [K approach is that sunlight is the best disinfectant. We are committed to lea [3D [K learning and taking action to protect patients and improve in-patient menta [5D [K mental health care up and down the country. NHS England and the Care Qualit [6D [K Quality Commission are acting to keep patients safe.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The questioner sought specific mechanisms or acti [4D [K actions for ensuring accountability after patient tragedies, while the answ [4D [K answer provided general statements about improving care without concrete me [2D [K measures for accountability.
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Patients in Chickerell struggle to access G [1D [K GP services and travel long distances. A new surgery was confirmed years ag [2D [K ago, but significant delays mean it has not been delivered.
Patients in Chickerell often struggle to access G [1D [K GP services in their area, and instead must travel long distances. Some yea [3D [K years ago, it was confirmed that a new surgery should be built in Chickerel [9D [K Chickerell. However, significant delays mean that we are still waiting for [K that surgery. Will the Minister work with me and the NHS locally to finally [7D [K finally deliver a new GP surgery in Chickerell?
I know that the local town and county council have [K been working in partnership with Dorset ICB over many years to support GP p [1D [K partnerships in the Chickerell area in developing a business case for NHS c [1D [K capital or revenue funding. I would be delighted to meet my hon. Friend, an [2D [K and to continue to make plans for applying pressure to ensure that this is [K delivered.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to specific action or timeline to [K deliver the new GP surgery in Chickerell.
Response accuracy
Q20
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Twenty-two people a day are diagnosed with [K lobular breast cancer. The Moon Shot Project aims to provide hope for these [5D [K these patients by securing research funding.
Twenty-two people a day are diagnosed with lobula [6D [K lobular breast cancer, including my colleague Councillor Fiona Corps in Nor [3D [K North East Fife, but many more are living with it, because researchers and [K clinicians know so little about it. In advance of vigils next week, can we [K ensure funding for the Moon Shot Project, to give these women hope?
We strongly support the aims of the Moon Shot Proje [5D [K Project; the challenge has been getting the proposal to a suitable standard [8D [K standard for funding. The moment we overcome that obstacle, the money will [K be there.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to providing specific funding or t [1D [K timeline for the Moon Shot Project.
Response accuracy
Q21
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The infected blood inquiry recommended acti [4D [K action to protect the safety of haemophilia care. There is concern that rec [3D [K recommendation 9 is not being implemented.
The infected blood inquiry recommended action to [K protect the safety of haemophilia care, but there is mounting concern among [5D [K among clinicians and patients alike that recommendation 9 is not being impl [4D [K implemented. Will the Minister meet me and members of the all-party parliam [7D [K parliamentary group on haemophilia and contaminated blood to discuss these [K real concerns?
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for making these po [2D [K points about haemophilia care. We are committed to implementing all recomme [7D [K recommendations of the review, and good progress has been made, including o [1D [K on non-plasma-derived treatments and the revision of the national service p [1D [K provision. NHS England and the Department of Health and Social Care will co [2D [K continue to provide updates on the Government response. I am happy to meet [K my hon. Friend to discuss this.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to a specific meeting or timeline [K for discussion with members of the all-party parliamentary group.
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
NHS England has reduced the faecal immunoch [8D [K immunochemical test threshold. The questioner asks for further investment i [1D [K in endoscopy and related treatments to increase survival rates.
It is welcome news that NHS England has reduced t [1D [K the faecal immunochemical test threshold from 120 micrograms to 80 microgra [8D [K micrograms, bringing England into line with Scotland and Wales. We now need [4D [K need investment in endoscopy and other related treatments to ensure that pe [2D [K people suffering from bowel cancer are spotted early and given the ultimate [8D [K ultimate chance of survival. Could Ministers look at further investment her [3D [K here to increase survival rates?
Yes; as part of our national cancer plan, we absolu [6D [K absolutely want to see survival rates improve in the way the hon. Gentleman [9D [K Gentleman describes. I welcome the new Minister working on this—the Under-S [7D [K Under-Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, my hon. Friend the Mem [3D [K Member for Washington and Gateshead South (Mrs Hodgson)—to her place, and t [1D [K thank my hon. Friend the Member for West Lancashire (Ashley Dalton) for all [3D [K all her leadership in this area, too.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to specific investment or timeline [8D [K timeline for endoscopy and related treatments.
Response accuracy
Q23
Partial Answer
My constituent Harley Harris is 15. He has spondylocarpotarsal synostosis syndrome, which has caused his spine to curve 120° and damaged his lungs, leaving him with significantly reduced lung function and in continual pain. Harley needs lifesaving surgery, but his family have been unable to get a referral to have it performed in the UK. Will the Minister commit to urgently reviewing Harley’s case to ascertain what support can be provided to him and his family?
I am very sorry to hear about Harley’s condition, and my thoughts are with him and his family. I am sure my hon. Friend understands that neither the Department nor NHS England can comment on the clinical appropriateness of suggested treatments for an individual. I understand that Harley and his family have already been in touch with the Department, and would suggest that my hon. Friend continues to raise this case with NHS England. We are committed to improving the lives of those living with rare diseases, including Harley’s condition of SCTS.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q24
Partial Answer
In 2022, Grantham saw the opening of one of the country’s first community diagnostic centres; since then, more than 100,000 tests have been completed for the local population. Now, I want the same for the town of Bourne. Will the Minister meet me, so that I can make the case for a new community diagnostic centre in Bourne?
I was happy to announce the further expansion of CDCs this morning. We will continue to work to roll out these centres across the country. I am happy to discuss with the hon. Gentleman the proposals from his local ICB, if he wants to provide a bit more detail on that, as these centres are critical to getting down our waiting lists.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q25
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The success of sickle cell bypass units in [K reducing pressure on emergency departments and improving care for sickle ce [2D [K cell patients is threatened. The MP seeks to secure ongoing central funding [7D [K funding to maintain these vital services.
Will the Secretary of State join me in welcoming [K the success of sickle cell bypass units in north-west London and across the [3D [K the country in reducing pressure on emergency departments, while improving [K care for sickle cell patients? Does my right hon. Friend recognise that the [3D [K the future of these units is threatened, and will he meet me to discuss the [3D [K the need for ongoing central funding?
I congratulate the units on their work. I appreciat [9D [K appreciate concerns about sickle cell services, which we must maintain. It [K is so important that we work together—that Labour's investment and modernis [8D [K modernisation works alongside NHS leaders and those promoting public health [6D [K health—and work with great Labour councils.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Meeting to discuss ongoing central funding for si [2D [K sickle cell bypass units
Response accuracy
Q26
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A recent event highlighted the need for mor [3D [K more financial support from grassroots mental health organizations that hel [3D [K help people of all ages and backgrounds who have fallen through the cracks. [7D [K cracks.
The MP attended the Beat the Odds event in his co [2D [K constituency, where 36 grassroots mental health organisations expressed a c [1D [K clear need for more financial support. What steps is the Minister taking to [2D [K to ensure these organisations receive funding to deliver frontline services [8D [K services that save lives?
I commend the community groups in the hon. Gentlema [8D [K Gentleman's constituency. There are record amounts of funding going into me [2D [K mental health provision under this Government, and we are committed to ensu [4D [K ensuring that funding is disseminated into the community.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific steps for grassroots organisations recei [5D [K receiving funding
Response accuracy