Topical Questions 2026-03-24
2026-03-24
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Since conflict broke out in the Middle East, energy costs have risen significantly. South Cotswolds has a high reliance on heating oil with 20% of households depending on it.
If he will make a statement on his departmental responsibilities. To go back to heating oil, 20% of households in my South Cotswolds constituency rely on heating oil—that figure is four times the national average—and many of them face high up-front costs. Will the Secretary of State consider supporting more flexible payment or credit schemes, and pooled purchasing models, which would enable villages to combine orders, secure bulk discounts and spread costs over time?
The hon. Lady raises an important issue, and I am sure that many Members will empathise as our constituents face difficult times. The Under-Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, my hon. Friend the Member for Inverclyde and Renfrewshire West (Martin McCluskey), tells me that the Competition and Markets Authority is considering all those issues. If Members encounter practices relating to heating and other things, they should bring them to the attention of my hon. Friend, because we want to work as speedily as possible with the CMA to stamp them out.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific request for flexible payment or credit schemes was not directly addressed; instead, the Minister referred it to another department.
Response accuracy
Q2
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Manufacturers in Calder Valley are facing significantly higher energy costs compared to European competitors, impacting firms like Siddall & Hilton and H&C Whitehead.
Manufacturers have been grappling with energy costs long before the current Iran conflict, hitting Calder Valley firms. Siddall & Hilton, which makes fences, is seeing costs four times higher than European competitors, and finishing company H&C Whitehead has seen its energy bills double to £22,000 a month. Will the Minister meet me to discuss how we can support smaller firms and ensure that Government support schemes help energy-intensive firms?
My hon. Friend is right to point out the importance of finishing companies. I know that some spinning and weaving businesses are included in the supercharger, but finishing is often not, even though it is done in the same factory. Clearly, whether they are waterproofing sou'westers or fireproofing mattresses, these businesses are important. I would be happy to meet my hon. Friend to discuss the upcoming supercharger review and what options there may be for those businesses.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Secretary of State has been criticized for policies that could affect the North sea oil and gas industry, including tax revenues and job losses.
Will the Secretary of State be honest and tell the country why he is ideologically obsessed with shutting down the North sea? Is it because he does not think we need the £25 billion of tax revenue it would generate? Is it because he prefers to import gas with higher emissions, or is it because he has never bothered to speak to the thousands of workers who are losing their jobs right now because of his policies?
I am not. As I said earlier, we are using existing oil and gas fields in the North sea for their lifetime, and we have introduced tiebacks for existing fields. While the right hon Lady comes here month after month with proposals that will do nothing to cut energy bills for people, this Government are actually taking action: reducing the energy price cap next week; making plug-in solar available to all families; the warm homes plan to drive down bills; and crucially, a renewable power auction, which she said that we should cancel, to help 12 million homes.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific request about admitting ideology was not addressed; instead, he criticized the questioner's proposals.
Criticised Opposition
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
RenewableUK, unions, Tony Blair, and the Secretary of State's own handpicked chair advocate for an energy transition against the government's policies.
RenewableUK, the unions, Tony Blair and the Secretary of State's own handpicked chair of Great British Energy—the biggest advocates for an energy transition—have said that he has got this wrong. Is his ideology so rigid that he is incapable of admitting when he has got things wrong and that he will put us on a pathway to higher emissions and fewer British jobs? Let us try again. Can the Secretary of State be clear with the House? He knows that we will need gas for decades to come, so why does he prefer to import dirtier gas from abroad than to use the gas that we have in the North sea?
I do not. We continue to use the North sea, and ours is a pragmatic position. But there is a wider lesson that the House has to focus on. Is the lesson of this crisis—a fossil fuels crisis—to double down on fossil fuels, or is it to drive forward with clean energy? We believe clean, home-grown power that we control is the answer.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific question about importing gas was not directly answered; instead, he discussed broader principles of clean energy.
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q5
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Government's focus is on the cost of living, but concerns remain about potential market price shocks due to events in the Middle East.
I welcome the upcoming drop next week in the energy price cap, which I know will help my constituents. With the Government's focus on the cost of living, we are all concerned that events in the middle east will trigger a price shock in the market, making that work more difficult. Can the Minister outline what further steps the Government are taking to reduce my constituents' energy bills?
I thank my hon. Friend for his important question. We are taking three additional measures. We are expanding and extending the warm home discount to 2031. We have supported heating oil customers with the £53 million-worth of support that was announced last week, and our £15 billion warm homes plan is the biggest home upgrade plan in British history. All of that is wrapped up in our clean energy mission—clean power 2030—which will ultimately give us control of our energy.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Over half of South Shropshire residents rely on heating oil, but recent support measures have not helped many constituents.
Over half of South Shropshire residents rely on heating oil or other solutions, such as liquified petroleum gas, to heat their homes. The recent Government support does very little for the majority of my constituents, and the best price today for heating oil is more than double what it was five weeks ago. There is blatant profiteering. What are the Government going to do to seriously address the issue?
We moved swiftly to introduce funding to support people. The £53 million-worth of support, which is being disbursed through the crisis and resilience fund in England and Wales, will provide support for people through this immediate period. We will keep other measures under review, but if hon. Members have examples of unfair pricing practices, it is important that they report them to the CMA so that it can consider them as part of its review.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific request for addressing high costs and profiteering was not fully answered; instead, he referred the issue to the Competition and Markets Authority.
Response accuracy
Q7
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Gawcott Fields Community Solar project aims to invest £2.8 million over 25 years in energy-saving projects.
I recently visited the Gawcott Fields Community Solar project, which will invest £2.8 million over 25 years into local environmental initiatives. Can the Minister update the House on how the Government's local power plan will enable more communities, especially rural and low-income ones, to manage their own energy?
I congratulate all those in my hon. Friend's constituency on what sounds like a fantastic project, and it is an example of what we want to see all across the country. The local power plan unlocks £1 billion of investment, with the ambition that communities right across the UK should be able to own and operate their own energy infrastructure, and the profits from that should flow into local communities.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The SNP's plan to lower energy costs through independence lacks credibility.
The current energy bills crisis is severe, but the government does not seem responsive. The SNP argues that Scotland generates clean, green renewable energy and exports it to the UK. Will they cooperate with the First Minister for a four-nations summit?
We do work very well together, actually, contrary to what it might appear from the hon. Member's contribution. He suggests, quite wrongly—twice now—that Scotland is generating all this electricity by itself. Of course, those projects are funded by bill payers across the UK investing in that infrastructure. His plan seems to be to take a third off energy bills with independence, with absolutely no credibility whatsoever.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The SNP's proposal for taking a third off energy bills through independence and cooperation on a four nations summit
Contradicting The Scottish Government
Denying Credibility
Response accuracy
Q9
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Small firms face unregulated third-party energy brokers that mislead customers.
Third-party intermediaries are exploiting small businesses with cold calls and misrepresentation. The Department promised to appoint Ofgem as the statutory regulator for TPIs. When will this legislation be introduced, and how will Ofgem work to protect SMEs from such practices?
We heard in the responses to our 2024 consultation the concerns about the continued risk to consumers arising from some of these TPIs. The Government plan to bring in new regulation of TPIs and will appoint Ofgem as the regulator, which will be empowered to put in place rules to protect small and medium-sized enterprises and other TPI customers.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Rural residents rely on fuels like heating oil and LPG, which are not covered by the current price cap.
In North Shropshire, around 15,000 households use off-grid heating solutions such as heating oil or LPG. These individuals suffer disproportionately from petrol pump increases due to a lack of alternative transportation options. While everyone connected to mains electricity and gas benefits from the price cap, those in rural areas only receive means-tested support. Will the Government consider introducing a price cap on alternative fuels?
The support on offer is not means-tested; it is at the discretion of local authorities to decide the criteria for those applications. That is the first point. The second point is that the CMA is investigating this in detail.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Introduction of a price cap on alternative fuels
Redirecting To Local Authorities
Mentioning Ongoing Investigations
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Terminally ill people face additional expenses due to their condition.
Individuals suffering from terminal illnesses often incur extra energy costs related to their health needs. What measures is the Department implementing to assist those who are terminally ill and facing higher energy bills?
I welcome my hon. Friend's advocacy for those people. No one with a terminal illness should have to face concerns about their energy bills. I will soon be meeting the Minister for Health Innovation and Safety, my hon. Friend the Member for Glasgow South West (Dr Ahmed), to discuss how Government can better share data in order to target support at vulnerable people and those with health conditions.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures to address energy costs for terminally ill individuals
Promising A Meeting
Mentioning Data Sharing
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Nith Inshore Rescue has lost a sponsor due to rising costs.
The Nith Inshore Rescue Service in my constituency has recently lost its sponsor who provided free fuel. Will the Secretary of State speak to the Chancellor about VAT and fuel costs affecting life-saving operations in remote Scotland?
The Chancellor will have heard the hon. Member's question, because she is in the room. My right hon. Friend is providing support for people but on a platform of fiscal stability, which the Conservative party would do well to understand.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Addressing VAT and fuel costs with the Chancellor
Changing Subject
Criticizing The Opposition
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Residents of Stafford are interested in expanding solar power adoption.
The Minister knows that Stafford residents support the installation of solar panels on all new car parks and industrial buildings, similar to practices in Europe and France. Does he agree this would reduce energy costs for homeowners and preserve rural land? Will he meet me to discuss my campaign?
I am always happy to meet my hon. Friend, so I will do that. She is right: we want to cover as many rooftops in the country as we can with solar panels. Just today we have announced that plug-in solar will be available in the UK in the summer, allowing renters and others across the world to go into a supermarket, buy some solar panels, plug them in and save money.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Installing solar panels on all new car parks and industrial buildings
Promising A Meeting
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Green businesses struggle with credit constraints.
Green firms that innovate extensively are particularly constrained by limited access to credit. Will the Minister meet me to discuss measures the Government is taking to increase credit supply, boost research and development, and spur economic growth?
We now have record public sector investment in the development of this technology, with £86 billion to 2030. As a techno-optimist, I agree with the International Energy Agency that we can now solve 75% of these problems using technology.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Meeting to discuss credit supply for green businesses and R&D
Mentioning Public Sector Investment
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question arises from rising energy bills for constituents in Bedford and Kempston due to global conflicts driving up oil and gas prices.
For as long as the UK depends on oil and gas, global conflicts will continue to drive price hikes for my constituents in Bedford and Kempston, who face soaring bills when the price cap ends in June. Does the Secretary of State agree that lower bills should come before company profits, and will he levy a windfall tax on the fossil fuel companies, which are making billions from this crisis?
As a result of decisions made by my right hon. Friend the Chancellor, we are raising significant sums from the windfall tax. We do not agree with the Opposition parties that now is the time to abolish the windfall tax; we think that is really important revenue that can help many of our constituents.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to levying a new windfall tax but defended existing one
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Operators of the Jackdaw and Rosebank projects claim that both could be producing by the end of the year, pending approval from the Secretary of State.
We keep hearing the argument that it will take five to 10 years for new oil and gas to flow, and that therefore there is not point to starting new drilling, but the operators of Jackdaw and Rosebank say that both could be producing by the end of the year—it only needs the Secretary of State to approve that. Why is he denying the UK that supply of domestic fuel?
Those projects are continuing at the moment at the developers' own risk. They are subject to a process, which the Conservative party will understand because this matter ended up in the courts under the previous Government. We are dealing with that process. Ultimately, none of those projects would take a penny off bills—that is the argument we are making. The Conservatives have no plan for bringing down bills; we have.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Shifted focus to arguing against Conservative policies rather than addressing project approval delays
Response accuracy
Q17
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Medway Maritime hospital is receiving £25.9 million to introduce heat pumps and other measures, highlighting the potential of renewable energy to reduce bills in public services.
Medway Maritime hospital in my constituency is benefiting from a £25.9 million investment to introduce heat pumps and other measures. Does the Minister agree that we could invest in public sector provision to reduce bills in schools, hospitals and other buildings across the country?
I congratulate my hon. Friend's local hospital. He rightly shows the way that cheap, clean, renewable power can cut bills not just for families, but for our public services, as GB Energy is doing, so that we can transfer money to frontline patient care.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There is a high dependence on home heating oil in Northern Ireland, with some government assistance already provided.
The Secretary of State will be aware of the very high dependence in Northern Ireland on home heating oil. Although the Government have offered some help in the past 10 days, has consideration been given to what happens beyond the summer period if the crisis in the middle east continues over the next few months?
We have supplied £17 million to the Northern Ireland Executive, and I had a constructive conversation last week with Minister Archibald about how that is deployed. We will keep other measures under review as the situation develops.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific plans for ongoing support beyond immediate assistance
Response accuracy
Q19
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Secretary of State has supported securing UK private investment in critical minerals, including the potential of Cornwall for future UK energy security.
I thank the Minister for his focus on securing UK private investment in critical minerals—it is fantastic to see. I know the Secretary of State agrees that Cornwall is vital for future UK energy security. One test and demo model in the Celtic sea has come forward in auction round 7, but I want to ask the Secretary of State about the timing of AR8, and whether he will look again at test and demo models in the Celtic sea, so that we can really use that energy base.
We all love Cornwall and its incredible clean energy potential. I can confirm that we will be opening the new renewables auction in July. We see an incredibly bright future for floating wind, and we see Cornwall absolutely at the centre of that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy