Topical Questions 2026-03-12
2026-03-12
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP highlights Soul Farm, a cooperative business in her constituency, and mentions the 'Save the Stag' campaign to take over a local pub. She asks about support for new and transitioning cooperative models.
Soul Farm, which delivers organic and sustainable food, is an example of a co-operative business in my constituency that benefits its community. I also have the “Save the Stag” campaign in Ponsanooth, which is trying to take over and run the local pub, as has already been done at the Ship Inn at Portloe. Setting up or transitioning to a co-op model can be difficult. Will the Minister update me on what support the Government are providing to help new co-ops to start up and existing businesses to transition to employee ownership?
I am grateful for my hon. Friend's important question. She will know that our manifesto committed to double the size of the co-op and mutual sector, and we are well on the way to doing so. She will also know that a consultation on this issue closed very recently. We are analysing the results and we will make further statements very soon.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask was not directly addressed as the Minister did not provide details on the support being offered.
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP is concerned about the upcoming business rate rises, especially in hospitality businesses, and their impact on employment.
The Government do not create jobs; business does. With unemployment rising, this is the last chance to ask the Secretary of State a question ahead of the start of April when a tsunami of business rate rises will hit. Shops and restaurants will see a 50% increase on average and the business rates of hotels will double. He and I both represent wonderful Sussex constituencies full of hospitality, high street and tourism businesses, but young people need those jobs. For their sake and for others, will he finally postpone his business rate rise?
I enjoy these exchanges with the shadow Secretary of State. I note that Reform's self-styled shadow Secretary of State—or, as I call him, the shadowy Secretary of State—is not in his place, despite being just next door in the Tea Room a few minutes ago. I think that speaks volumes. The shadow Secretary of State knows that the private sector has created 380,000 jobs under this Government. We will continue to grow the economy and the number of people in work, and make sure that people benefit from all the rights we are delivering, which are pro-business and pro-worker. He spent 14 years letting down Britain. Now he has spent 18 months talking it down.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask was completely avoided.
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP questions the current employment law in the context of a high-profile case involving Peter Mandelson and seeks a review of Labour's policy on uncapping employment tribunal payouts for high earners.
The Secretary of State forgets that I have not even been here for 14 years. Some days it feels like that, but I can assure him that it is not the case. There was no answer to that question, so let me try another. Does he agree that there is something pretty badly wrong with employment law in this country when Peter Mandelson, the friend of a convicted paedophile and leaker of classified Government documents, walks away with a £75,000 pay-off? The permanent secretary thinks that is good value for money. Will the Secretary of State review Labour's policy of uncapping employment tribunal payouts for the highest earners?
As is so often the case when we have these exchanges, the shadow Secretary of State spends a lot of his time slagging off his own record in office. The Conservatives had 14 years to reform tribunal rights—they did not even touch it. They had 14 years to update workers' rights and employment status in this country—they did not do it. The economy moved forward; they failed to move forward. Turning to the issue of Peter Mandelson, I start by recognising that there are victims at the heart of this debate and the issues surrounding it. Those victims are in my mind today as I answer this question, and they have been all the way through. We will make sure that those victims get the justice they deserve. When it comes to the issues surrounding Peter Mandelson, there are multiple inquiries under way. Thames Valley police is leading on a criminal inquiry, and I will leave it at that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask was completely avoided.
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP discusses new rights of trade union access in the Employment Rights Act 2025 and proposes setting fines for breaking these rules at a percentage of global turnover.
I refer Members to my declaration of interest as a former employee of USDAW. The new rights of trade union access in the Employment Rights Act 2025 could be game changing, but there is a proposal to cap fines for breaking new rules at £75,000, which is loose change for union-busting employees like Amazon. Will my hon. Friend consider setting fines at a percentage of global turnover, as is the case for GDPR breaches and ticket touting websites?
I thank my hon. Friend for her work in this area. The Government believe that trade unions are absolutely essential for tackling insecurity, inequality, discrimination, enforcement and low pay. We are providing a legal framework for businesses and unions to negotiate access to the workplace. We recognise that for the framework to effectively facilitate that access, it has to be supported. That is why we are consulting on this. Officials are reviewing those responses, and we will publish a response in due course.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask was not directly addressed as the Minister did not provide details on considering fines at a percentage of global turnover.
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP is concerned about the impact of the fuel duty rise on small businesses in Bridgwater.
Small businesses in Bridgwater were hit last year with the Chancellor's jobs tax. This year, they face the additional burdens of the Secretary of State's unemployment Act and higher business rates. With petrol and diesel prices rising, the last thing they want is a fuel duty increase. Will he speak to the Chancellor and ask her to cancel her fuel duty rise in September?
Fuel duty is currently frozen. The key thing we can do to make sure we deal with this instability in energy prices is de-escalate in the region. I remind the hon. Member that his party has been calling for us to join the war.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask was completely avoided.
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Co-operatives are important for building a fair and resilient economy. The government has committed to doubling the size of the co-operative sector.
I am concerned about the progress of doubling the co-operative sector. Can the Minister update me on the progress towards achieving this ambition and what further measures are being brought forward to support co-operatives?
Co-operatives are important for creating a sense of connection and are more resilient and productive. We have a commitment to double the co-operative sector. Our call for evidence has closed, and we are working on the proposals that will flow out of that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific measures beyond mentioning the call for evidence
Response accuracy
Q7
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Small businesses in the south-west are gearing up for the busy tourist season.
What steps are the Government taking to support small businesses in the south-west to help them make the most of the summer tourist season?
We have increased finance available to businesses by £4 billion and are proposing stronger measures on late payments and cutting red tape to support small businesses.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q8
Direct Answer
▸
Context
UK titanium dioxide production like Tronox is threatened by Chinese practices.
What is the Minister doing to ensure a level playing field and protect UK titanium dioxide production from aggressive Chinese practices?
The Trade Remedies Authority is investigating. We need to ensure dumping is not acceptable and will use available remedies to protect British businesses.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
High streets in Tonbridge are struggling due to the impact of business rate relief on hospitality industries.
Would the Secretary of State care to discuss the effect of business rate relief on small businesses in Tonbridge?
We have introduced support packages since coming into office. The hospitality sector needs a stable industrial strategy.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the specific impact of business rate relief
Response accuracy
Q10
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Scotch whisky faces high import tariffs in India, which are now being cut.
Does the Minister agree that the tariff cuts will grow the Scottish economy by £190 million a year and benefit the whisky industry?
My hon. Friend is right. The increased bilateral trade with India will help Scottish businesses take opportunities and build strong British businesses.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q11
Direct Answer
▸
Context
UK SMEs are impacted by export licence turnaround times of up to six months for non-controlled goods.
When will we see a significant improvement in export licence turnaround times?
The median time for sorting out export licences is 14 days. I am happy to meet the hon. Member to tackle specific issues.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Doncaster has businesses run by ambitious entrepreneurs.
Will the Minister update the House on how Government support, such as the start-up loan scheme and the growth guarantee scheme, are helping young entrepreneurs and start-ups?
Britain is the start-up capital of Europe. We are doubling down to ensure businesses can scale up and stay in the UK, creating innovation, job creation, and wealth.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific updates on the support schemes
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Anchor Sound and Security in Kings Langley reported being disincentivized to hire due to rising compliance costs and regulatory uncertainty.
Anchor Sound and Security explained to me how it is disincentivised to hire more employees due to rising compliance costs and regulatory uncertainty. What is the Minister doing to stop regulations stifling small business growth and destroying the strong relationships between employer and employees?
The Government have a commitment to reduce the regulatory burden on business by 25%. My Department led on almost £1 billion of regulatory reform for company reporting in just the first weeks of our taking office. The small business plan and strategy will deliver for small businesses, on top of the industrial strategy, which is getting our economy facing the future and into solid growth for now and the future.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the specific ask about destroying employer-employee relationships
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Moot Brew brewery from Halling produces excellent beer and was featured in the Strangers' Bar in the House of Commons.
I add my voice to that of my hon. Friend the Member for Bexleyheath and Crayford in calling on the Government to publish the review of market access for small breweries as soon as possible. Will the Secretary of State support a national guest beer agreement policy, so that more fantastic local brewers such as Moot are represented in my local pubs?
My hon. Friend is a real champion for her local breweries, especially Moot Brew in Halling, which produces excellent beer—I know she visits regularly. We recognise the importance of independent breweries and pubs, and we are committed to ensuring that the sector remains diverse, competitive and rooted in local communities. We have reviewed the beer market to assess any barriers, and I will keep my hon. Friend updated.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the specific ask about national guest beer agreement policy
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Small-volume business manufacturers in the automotive sector are facing significant challenges with exports and costs.
Small-volume business manufacturers in the automotive sector are having a terrible time at the moment. They rely on exports, and exports to the US are critical. Although I welcome the agreement the Government struck, costs are still four times what they were before President Trump introduced his tariffs, and those businesses are also being squeezed by business rates and national insurance at home. Will the Secretary of State make urgent representations to the Chancellor? The market is very delicate, and something must be done to reduce costs.
The right hon. Gentleman raises an issue that is close to my heart. The Government and I care deeply about the future of the automotive sector. Exports are incredibly important to it, but so is the security of supply chains. I have raised this issue not only with our US counterparts and other export markets but with the EU, to protect supply chains. My ministerial colleague chaired the Automotive Council just yesterday; we are listening, gauging and acting on behalf of the sector. Automotive production fell by 50% when the Conservatives were running the country. We are trying to get it back up to where it deserves to be.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the specific ask about urgent representations to the Chancellor
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Small businesses face pandemic-level pressures with standing charges for energy set to rise by 60% in April.
The Select Committee recently flagged that small businesses in our country now face pandemic-level pressures. In April, standing charges for energy are set to rise by 60%, with no price cap protection. Now, soaring oil and gas prices threaten to be the final straw for thousands of SMEs. Will the Secretary of State make an urgent assessment of the risk of soaring energy prices, and give a clear account of how we will keep the SMEs that keep this country running in business?
My right hon. Friend is absolutely right. We have taken action through the British industrial competitiveness scheme, which is a downpayment on exactly the sort of support he describes. We are constantly working on ways to cut costs for small businesses, and I am sure we will work with the Select Committee on that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the specific ask about urgent assessment of energy price risk
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q17
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Syngenta—the company that makes paraquat—announced it would stop production this year.
Last time we were here for Business and Trade questions, I asked about exports of paraquat—the use of which is forbidden here—to other countries. To update the ministerial team, Syngenta put out a press release on 3 March to say that it would stop production this year. May I therefore expand my previous question to ensure that the response includes the export of pesticides and other products whose use is banned in the UK?
Yes.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the specific ask about export of banned products
Deflection
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Private capital has flown into Cornwall due to the Labour Government's investments of about £100 million.
The UK economy needs more and more critical minerals, and in Cornwall we have loads of them. Private capital has flown into the duchy on the back of the Labour Government's investments of about £100 million through the national wealth fund and the Kernow industrial growth fund, but will the Minister update the House on Government plans to unlock more private investment in our critical minerals sector to unleash the Cornish Celtic tiger?
My hon. Friend is right: Cornwall has loads of critical minerals. They will be beneficial in driving not only the UK economy but great businesses and export opportunities. As we have said before, we want companies to scale and grow in the UK, to be headquartered and listed in the UK, and to provide great jobs in the UK. That is why I am working with my hon. Friend and his Cornish Labour colleagues, and with the industry and capital markets in the UK, to corral capital into Cornish critical minerals.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the specific ask about updating the House on Government plans
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q19
Direct Answer
▸
Context
A group of potential investors in the steel industry have made approaches to the Secretary of State.
Since part of Grimsby falls in my constituency, I join my Member of Parliament, the hon. Member for Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes, in celebrating Great Grimsby Day. I recently attended a meeting with the hon. Member for Scunthorpe and a group of potential investors in the steel industry, who I know have made approaches to the Secretary of State. Can he give me an assurance that all potential private sector investments in the industry will be given serious consideration?
I congratulate the hon. Member on Great Grimsby Day, and I can give him that assurance.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q20
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP noted ongoing issues with postal services in Dargavel Village, Bishopton. These issues are compounded by upcoming elections and the potential for people to miss important medical appointments due to delays.
I thank the Minister for speaking to me about the poor postal service in Dargavel Village in Bishopton. In Scotland we have an NHS with significant waiting lists, and we cannot have people missing medical appointments. May I stress the urgency of this matter?
We have called in Royal Mail, brought together unions and management, and had a meeting yesterday with Ofcom to stress that things have to improve. Specific meetings are taking place on postal votes in Scotland, and we have sought assurances that they will not be impacted by the problems with the quality of service.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q21
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Representatives of the British Chambers of Commerce relayed concerns about the UK automotive industry potentially being excluded from the EU's proposed industrial accelerator Act. Nissan and Honda have expressed uncertainty about their future if included.
Yesterday I met representatives of the British Chambers of Commerce, who relayed the profound concerns of the UK automative industry that it might be excluded from the European Union's proposed industrial accelerator Act. What is the Secretary of State doing to ensure that the UK automotive sector is not placed at a competitive disadvantage?
My ministerial team and I have been very active on this issue, raising it directly with Commissioners. We are working with our EU colleagues to make sure that the automotive sector is respected, valued, and secure in the future.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A sudden shift in steel import policy has created uncertainty for firms that have invested heavily in expanding operations based on stable trading conditions. Central Rebar in Alloa is affected.
The sudden shift in steel import policy has created uncertainty for firms that have invested heavily in expanding their operations based on previously stable trading conditions. Will the Secretary of State commit to working with affected businesses in Scotland and provide clarity to prevent further disruption?
The Government are concerned about the erosion of UK domestic steel production compared with imports. My hon. Friend might like a further discussion with me after the steel strategy is published.
▸
Assessment & feedback
commitment to provide clarity and prevent further disruption
Ask To Wait Until The Steel Strategy Is Published
Response accuracy
Q23
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Cavendish House in Cheltenham has been a cherished retail centre for 200 years. It is now empty and owned by Canada Life, raising concerns about the need for big pension and investment companies to pay more respect to high streets.
Does the Minister agree that the big pension and investment companies need to pay more respect to our high streets and bring forward planning applications to redevelop and regenerate as soon as they possibly can?
We are working on a new high street strategy to deal with issues mentioned, want investors to step up, and have a responsibility through planning reform to make it easier to regenerate areas.
▸
Assessment & feedback
agreement that companies need to pay more respect to high streets
Working On A New High Street Strategy
Response accuracy
Q24
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Manufacturers reliant on gas are struggling with recent spikes in energy costs due to the global energy crisis.
Will the Secretary of State confirm whether his Department is considering a transitional dual fuel discount for industries that will continue to use gas for the foreseeable future?
The impact of BICS is essential and fundamental in getting growth into the economy and sustainable businesses into the future. We are looking carefully at how the learning from that can be applied in other areas.
▸
Assessment & feedback
consideration of a transitional dual fuel discount
Looking Carefully At How Learning From Bics Can Be Applied In Other Areas
Response accuracy