Topical Questions 2026-03-10

2026-03-10

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Daniel Francis Lab
Bexleyheath and Crayford
Context
The conflict in the Middle East is causing anxiety among families and businesses due to rising costs.
I am concerned about the conflict in the Middle East and its impact on businesses and families. The charity Shelter has campaigned for people without fixed addresses to access bank accounts without ID. Which groups might benefit most from this?
The major banks have committed to work with Shelter to make it easier for people without standard ID to access a bank account. This will particularly help people who are homeless and support them to rebuild their lives.
Assessment & feedback
Specific groups that will benefit were not detailed
Pay Tribute To Colleague'S Work
Response accuracy
Q2 Direct Answer
Daniel Francis Lab
Bexleyheath and Crayford
Context
Petrol prices are surging, and the previous government froze fuel duty for years.
Given the rising cost of oil and gas, why did the right hon. Lady choose to increase fuel duty now instead of continuing the previous government's freeze?
The plans inherited from the previous government would have seen fuel duty increase in April. We reversed these plans, introduced a cheaper fuel finder, and will begin to unwind the 5p cut from the pandemic in a staggered approach. We are meeting petrol retailers to address price gouging.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Mel Stride Con
Central Devon
Context
The questioner asks about the government's stance on importing oil and gas versus extracting it from the North Sea.
Given the rising cost of oil and gas, why is it better to import it than to extract it from the North Sea?
The price of oil and gas is volatile due to the conflict in the Middle East. The North Sea will play an important part in the energy mix for years to come, and I met North Sea oil and gas companies to discuss how we can help.
Assessment & feedback
Specific reasons for preferring imports were not detailed
Discussing The Conflict In The Middle East
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Mel Stride Con
Central Devon
Context
The rural fuel duty relief scheme is meant to give a 5p discount on petrol and diesel in island rural communities but is found to be less effective.
The rural fuel duty relief scheme is meant to give a 5p discount on petrol and diesel in specific island rural communities, but I found that petrol in Stornoway is 9p more expensive than in Glasgow. Can the Minister look at this scheme again?
The rural fuel duty relief scheme does provide a 5p discount and will benefit constituents on the islands and in communities. We will keep all taxes under review and I am happy to meet the MP to discuss this.
Assessment & feedback
Specific review of the scheme was not committed
Keep Taxes Under Review
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Torcuil Crichton Lab
Na h-Eileanan an Iar
Context
The UK Government often spends more on energy support than other countries due to the broken energy market.
Energy market support for households and small businesses is higher in the UK than in other comparable countries. Some suppliers refuse to supply hospitality businesses. Will the Government instruct the CMA to investigate bad practices in the energy market?
The Chancellor and Ministers have been clear with the CMA that companies should not take advantage of customers, whether for domestic heating oil or hospitality businesses.
Assessment & feedback
Specific CMA investigation was not committed
Long-Term Answer Is More Domestic Energy Security
Response accuracy
Q6 Direct Answer
Damien Egan Lab
Bristol North East
Context
The MP is concerned about the economic impact of the conflict in the Middle East on the UK and its NATO allies.
Given the events in the middle east, can the Chancellor share with us what work is being done here and alongside our NATO allies and other partners to understand the economic consequences, people's changing needs and the impact that has on Government spending when countries face times of conflict?
I am proud to be the Labour Chancellor who has overseen the biggest uplift in defence spending since the end of the cold war. Just last week we announced a £1 billion helicopter deal with Leonardo, based in Yeovil, just down the road from my hon. Friend. Yesterday I confirmed to the House that the Ministry of Defence has access to the special reserve. That means that the added costs of deploying additional capabilities in the middle east will be funded entirely by the Treasury special reserve.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
David Mundell Con
Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale
Context
The MP is addressing the significant rise in heating oil costs affecting his constituents, particularly Craig Ritchie who faces a 200% rise in oil costs.
I am the Member of Parliament for one of the largest rural constituencies in the United Kingdom, so the rise in the cost of heating oil is obviously a major concern for me. I welcome the opportunity to meet the Financial Secretary, and I hope that liquefied petroleum gas can also be on the agenda for that meeting, because that is a heating source for many of my constituents. People such as Craig Ritchie in Symington will be looking for concrete outcomes from that meeting, given that they face a 200% rise in their oil costs.
I thank the right hon. Gentleman for raising the important issues with heating oil that his constituents are facing. I very much hope that he will be able to attend the meeting tomorrow. There are two key issues: making sure that vessels can again flow through the strait of Hormuz, which requires a de-escalation of the crisis; and stopping the price gouging that some businesses are engaged in at the moment. That is why I have asked the CMA to look at that too.
Assessment & feedback
The questioner requested concrete outcomes from the meeting, but the answer focused on de-escalation and price gouging without providing specific commitments.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Paul Davies Lab
Colne Valley
Context
The MP is highlighting the importance of co-operatives, such as Co-operative Care Colne Valley, in delivering ethical and not-for-profit home care services to the disabled and elderly.
In my constituency, Co-operative Care Colne Valley is testament to the value and importance of co-operatives. It delivers ethical, not-for-profit home care services for the disabled and elderly. The group's community ownership and local empowerment demonstrates the value of co-operatives. Will the Minister advise me what steps her Department is taking to drive the growth of co-operatives across our communities?
I thank my hon. Friend for highlighting the important work of Co-operative Care Colne Valley, which is an excellent example of how co-operatives can deliver high-quality community-owned care for elderly and disabled people. His constituency is home to a number of other fantastic co-operatives, including the Green Valley Grocer and the Handmade Bakery. The Government are committed to doubling the size of the co-ops and mutuals sector, exactly because we recognise the very positive role that it plays.
Assessment & feedback
The questioner requested specific steps to drive the growth of co-operatives, but the answer provided general statements of support without concrete actions.
Committed To
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Liz Jarvis Lib Dem
Eastleigh
Context
The MP is concerned about the challenges facing businesses in her constituency, particularly David, who is concerned about inflation and the ability to plan ahead.
David, who owns the Steam Town Brew Co. in my constituency, tells me that his biggest concerns right now are inflation and the ability to plan ahead. What reassurance can the Minister give him that businesses in my constituency will be supported with the stability and certainty that they need?
Businesses in the hon. Lady's constituency, and indeed across the country, can know that, whatever instability we face in the world in the months and weeks ahead, the Government have done the right thing for the economy by bringing down inflation, interest rates, borrowing, debt and debt costs. All that puts us in the strongest possible position to be resilient going into the future.
Assessment & feedback
The questioner requested specific reassurances for businesses, but the answer provided general statements about the economy without addressing the specific needs of businesses.
Committed To
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Sam Carling Lab
North West Cambridgeshire
Context
The MP is concerned about young people struggling to access mortgages due to thin credit files and is exploring options for requiring lettings agents and large landlords to report rental payment data to credit reference agencies.
Young people in North West Cambridgeshire and across the country are struggling to access mortgages and get on to the housing ladder due to thin credit files. Will the Minister explore requiring lettings agents and large landlords, with the consent of tenants, to report rental payment data to credit reference agencies so that a record of paying rent on time can contribute to tenants' credit histories and help them access mortgages?
I know how passionate my hon. Friend is about the Government's priority to get more first-time buyers on to the housing ladder. As he and I have discussed before, people looking to buy a home can build their credit history through rent payments by using third-party services that report these things to credit reference agencies. I think that he and I would agree that better awareness of such services and the mortgages available that take account of tenants' rental payments would be a good thing.
Assessment & feedback
The questioner requested specific exploration of reporting rental payment data, but the answer focused on existing third-party services and awareness.
Committed To
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
John Milne Lib Dem
Horsham
Context
The MP is addressing the immediate crisis faced by constituents due to a sudden rise in heating oil costs, particularly a constituent facing a 129.9p plus VAT per litre price.
Even while sitting here, I have had word from a constituent whose heating oil cost has risen, in one go, to 129.9p plus VAT per litre. I recognise that the Chancellor has been pressed by a number of Members on this. Can she assure us of immediate action, as vulnerable residents are in immediate crisis?
While only 4% of people in Great Britain use heating oil, I recognise that this is a particular issue for many constituents, and in Northern Ireland the figure is more than 60%. I am keen for the hon. Gentleman to take these issues to the meeting with the Financial Secretary to the Treasury tomorrow. We are working closely with the Competition and Markets Authority to stop price gouging. There is no reason why a company should be charging twice as much as it was for heating oil; we need to put a stop to those practices.
Assessment & feedback
The questioner requested immediate action, but the answer focused on future meetings and ongoing work with the CMA without specific immediate action.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Jessica Toale Lab
Bournemouth West
Context
The MP is concerned about the condition of roads in her constituency and is urging the council to address the issue of potholes.
The junction of Surrey Road and Prince of Wales Road; Wimborne Road, between Kinson library and Bear Cross; and Hankinson Road, around Winton rec—these are some of the more than 35 roads in Bournemouth West where residents have told me potholes are out of control. Lib Dem-led Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole council has been given £7.5 million to maintain our roads and fix potholes. I will be writing to BCP council later today, but in the meantime, will the Minister join me in urging it to get its act together and finally fix our roads?
As my hon. Friend makes clear, we need to ensure that our extra funding for local roads maintenance is spent effectively, and that local residents can hold councils like Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole to account. The Liberal Democrats have typically not been shy about mentioning potholes in their leaflets; now is their time to deliver.
Assessment & feedback
The questioner requested the Minister to join in urging the council, but the answer deflected to criticising the Liberal Democrats' record on potholes.
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Desmond Swayne Con
New Forest West
Context
The Chancellor mentioned meeting North sea oil industry representatives to help the industry, but the questioner argues that the focus should be on how the government can support the industry.
The Chancellor said that she will meet representatives of the North sea oil industry to see how it can help. The proper question is how she can help it, is it not?
Alongside the Budget last year, we published the new North sea oil and gas strategy, which, for example, allows tie-backs, so that more use can be made of existing fields. The previous Government brought in the energy profits levy when energy companies' profits went through the roof after Russia's invasion of Ukraine. That is still in place, so that when prices are high, we can bring money in to help people with their bills.
Assessment & feedback
The answer does not directly address how the government can help the North sea oil industry.
Response accuracy
Q14 Direct Answer
Lloyd Hatton Lab
South Dorset
Context
The Treasury and Ministers are expected to continue working with the Ministry of Defence to secure investment in the defence sector in Dorset and the wider south-west.
I welcome the Chancellor of the Exchequer's work to get the Leonardo helicopters contract over the line, as that will help protect defence jobs right across Dorset, Somerset and the wider south-west. Will the Treasury and Ministers continue to work with the Ministry of Defence to secure investment in the defence sector in Dorset and across the west country?
I thank my hon. Friend for what he said about the Leonardo contract at Yeovil, which supports many thousands of jobs in Somerset, and indeed Dorset. I am proud to be the Chancellor who has overseen the biggest uplift in defence spending since the end of the cold war; that has enabled us to support this investment and many others.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Freddie Van Mierlo Lib Dem
Henley and Thame
Context
Residents with student loans are facing high marginal tax rates of 71% at the £100,000 income level due to the tax system. This is one of the reasons why salary sacrifice is popular.
The £100,000 tax trap means that some residents, if they have a student loan, are paying 71% marginal rates. That is one of the reasons why salary sacrifice is so popular—but those people want to use that money in the economy now. What is the Chancellor doing to address the tax trap at £100,000?
I thank the hon. Member for his second question, and his enthusiastic volume of questions today. The Government balance the needs of public services with tax revenues. I gently point out that Liberal Democrat Members come to the House day in, day out, and call for more spending—we have heard that happen today—but then oppose every single tax rise or tax change required to make that happen. That is not what serious politics looks like. We need to take tax seriously, and it is time for some serious politics from the Liberal Democrats.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Emily Darlington Lab
Milton Keynes Central
Context
The loan charge affected tens of thousands of people across the country, including those on low pay who were not given a choice by their employers.
The loan charge was a scandal that affected tens of thousands of people across this country, some of whom were on very low pay and not given a choice by their employers. At the last Budget, the Government put forward changes. What assessment has the Minister made of how those changes will impact people at the lowest end, including social care workers across the country?
I thank my hon. Friend for the question, and for the representation she has provided for her constituents and, through her work on the loan charge and taxpayer fairness all-party parliamentary group, for many across the country who have been affected by the loan charge. At the Budget, we made the decision to write off £5,000 from the liabilities of everyone who has been affected by the loan charge, so about a third of those affected will have their liabilities written off entirely. I look forward to continuing to engage with her and Members across the House on this important issue.
Assessment & feedback
The answer does not provide a detailed assessment of the impact on low-income individuals.
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Greg Smith Con
Mid Buckinghamshire
Context
The loan charge and taxpayer fairness APPG wrote to Ministers multiple times last year regarding the 2005 preferential deal with large banks.
Following on from that last question, the loan charge and taxpayer fairness APPG, which I co-chair, wrote to Ministers on 1 July, 22 September and 25 November last year, with questions about the 2005 preferential deal with the large banks. Does the Minister feel that it is acceptable that we have not had a reply to those letters? When will we get one?
The letters that were sent will receive a reply very shortly. A decision was made that in the run-up to the announcement of the independent loan charge review, it would not be appropriate for the Government to set out in detail their views on a live issue that an independent reviewer was looking at. That review was published alongside the Budget. I apologise for the fact that the response has not come in the weeks since; it will be with the hon. Member and the APPG very shortly.
Assessment & feedback
The answer does not provide a clear timeline for a reply.
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Chris Webb Lab
Blackpool South
Context
The new crisis and resilience fund aims to provide support to families in crisis, including those in Blackpool.
Two weeks ago, I held an emergency cost of living summit in Blackpool, after record numbers of families, particularly single mums, contacted us in food crisis. They could not access the council's discretionary fund. Will the Minister outline how the new crisis and resilience fund will ensure that families in my constituency can get the support that they need, especially over the weekend?
My hon. Friend is right to point to the crisis and resilience fund as an important lifeline for families across this country. We work with local authorities to make sure that the funding gets to the frontline, because local councils best understand where the most acute pressures are in their areas. I am, however, happy to discuss this with him later.
Assessment & feedback
The answer does not outline specific measures for Blackpool families.
Response accuracy
Q19 Partial Answer
Claire Young Lib Dem
Thornbury and Yate
Context
Heat batteries are the only clean heat technology certified by the microgeneration certification scheme excluded from VAT relief under the energy-saving materials framework.
Heat batteries are the only clean heat technology certified by the microgeneration certification scheme that is excluded from VAT relief under the energy-saving materials framework. This penalises smaller homes and lower-income households that cannot accommodate a heat pump. Will the Chancellor commit to removing that anomaly, and meet me and representatives of the UK heat battery industry to discuss it?
The Government regularly assess whether to add energy-saving materials, including heat batteries, to the list of items covered by the current VAT relief, which is set to continue until March 2027. Any decisions would have to be announced by the Chancellor at a fiscal event, but I am happy to discuss the matter.
Assessment & feedback
The answer does not provide a specific commitment to remove the anomaly.
Response accuracy
Q20 Direct Answer
Antonia Bance Lab
Tipton and Wednesbury
Context
The global situation has implications for industrial energy costs, and the British industrial competitiveness scheme would cut manufacturing energy costs by 25%.
Given the global situation, what discussions has the Chancellor had with Cabinet colleagues on helping to keep industrial energy costs manageable? Will she work with colleagues to bring in the British industrial competitiveness scheme, which would cut manufacturing energy costs by 25%, as soon as possible?
My hon. Friend is a powerful advocate for the energy-intensive industries, and for manufacturing more widely. The supercharger is being extended from April this year. That will help 500 of the most energy-intensive businesses, and increase their discount from 60% to 90%—and next year, the BIC scheme comes in. Given what is happening in the middle east, we will continue to look closely at what we can do to help our energy-intensive industries.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
John Lamont Con
Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk
Context
Over 50% of properties in the Scottish Borders are not on the mains gas grid and rely on heating oil, which has seen a significant price increase, leading to financial hardship for residents.
Over 50% of properties in the Scottish Borders are not on the mains gas grid and are completely dependent on heating oil. They are being hammered by the increase to the price of heating oil over the last week or so, and they need to see concrete action from this Government to stop the excessive prices and the profiteering. What are the Government going to do?
I agree with the hon. Gentleman. We are trying to de-escalate the conflict in the middle east, because if we can get vessels moving again through the strait of Hormuz, we will deal with a lot of these problems. I am working closely with both Lloyd's of London—I met its representatives yesterday—and my G7 colleagues to ensure that those vessels can get moving again. At the same time, I think that everybody has heard the stories in this Chamber and from our constituents about the problems of price gouging. We have to address that, and I have asked the CMA to look at it. Members across the House will have a chance tomorrow to set out their case to the Financial Secretary to the Treasury in more detail, so that we have all the information needed to make the case.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific actions to address excessive heating oil prices
I Am Working Closely With Both Lloyd'S Of London—I Met Its Representatives Yesterday—And My G7 Colleagues To Ensure That Those Vessels Can Get Moving Again.
Response accuracy
Q22 Partial Answer
Adam Jogee Lab
Newcastle-under-Lyme
Context
Residents in Newcastle-under-Lyme are facing poor-quality and dangerous roads, despite the county council receiving funding from the Government.
My constituents in Newcastle-under-Lyme are sick and tired of poor-quality, dangerous roads. The county council has resources from this Government, and must stop being missing in action. What message does the Minister have for Staffordshire county council?
My hon. Friend is right that we need councils across the country to use the extra funding that the Government have made available for local road maintenance to fill those potholes. Councils will have to publish their data online, so that local people can monitor, through a traffic light system available on gov.uk, how their council is performing.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a specific message to Staffordshire county council
Councils Will Have To Publish Their Data Online, So That Local People Can Monitor, Through A Traffic Light System Available On Gov.Uk, How Their Council Is Performing.
Response accuracy
Q23 Partial Answer
Caroline Voaden Lib Dem
South Devon
Context
The UK loses £33.4 billion annually in tax revenue due to multinational corporations and the super-rich choosing tax havens over tax payments.
Every year, the UK loses £33.4 billion in tax revenue, as multinational corporations and the super-rich choose tax havens over tax payments. However, the UN tax convention has the potential to solve this problem, so will the Minister show leadership, not ambivalence, and commit to securing an ambitious UN tax convention in this Parliament?
I am always happy to show leadership, and this Government—and, I may say, previous Governments—have worked hard with international partners, both in the OECD and the UN, to do all we can to reduce tax avoidance and evasion by multinational companies. We continue to work with our partners in the UK and abroad to clamp down on tax dodging.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to securing an ambitious UN tax convention
This Government—And, I May Say, Previous Governments—Have Worked Hard With International Partners, Both In The Oecd And The Un, To Do All We Can To Reduce Tax Avoidance And Evasion By Multinational Companies.
Response accuracy
Q24 Partial Answer
Paul Waugh Lab Co-op
Rochdale
Context
A constituent in Rochdale is concerned about a massive price rise for heating oil, fearing price gouging and war profiteering by oil companies.
My constituent in Rochdale, Louise Marshall, wrote to me this weekend because she is worried sick about the massive price rise she is facing for heating oil. Can the Chancellor assure me, notwithstanding the meeting we are all going to have with the Financial Secretary to the Treasury, that we can be absolutely crystal clear that under this Government, we will not tolerate price gouging or war profiteering from oil companies that try to rip off their customers?
I absolutely agree with my hon. Friend. The price gouging that we see is totally unacceptable, which is why we have already asked the Competition and Markets Authority to look at this. Whether we are talking about petrol at the pumps or heating oil, there is no excuse for any business to use this as an opportunity to rip off customers.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide an assurance regarding tolerance of price gouging or war profiteering
The Price Gouging That We See Is Totally Unacceptable, Which Is Why We Have Already Asked The Competition And Markets Authority To Look At This.
Response accuracy
Q25 Partial Answer
Jeremy Hunt Con
Godalming and Ash
Context
The Chancellor and the previous Government have followed fiscal rules that allowed them to claim debt was falling, when in fact it continued to rise, both in absolute terms and as a proportion of GDP.
One of the things that makes our economy less resilient is high levels of debt. The Chancellor and I have both followed fiscal rules that allowed us to claim that debt was falling, when in fact it continued to rise, both in absolute terms and as a proportion of GDP. Does she think it is time to consider a new fiscal rule that actually reduces debt—for example, a rule that public spending will not increase faster than economic growth?
Debt is lower in every year of the forecast that I published last week than it was in the plans that I set out in the Budget just back in November. The fiscal rules that I introduced in the October after I became Chancellor said, first of all, that we had to balance day-to-day spending with tax receipts, and that is important. They also stated that, subject to getting debt down as a share of GDP, we could invest in the things that can actually grow the economy. The right hon. Gentleman and I both know that growth is the best way to ensure that our public finances are sustainable, and that we improve living standards for working people.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to a new fiscal rule reducing debt
The Fiscal Rules That I Introduced In The October After I Became Chancellor Said, First Of All, That We Had To Balance Day-To-Day Spending With Tax Receipts, And That Is Important.
Response accuracy
Q26 Partial Answer
Perran Moon Lab
Camborne and Redruth
Context
The Government's new industrial strategy has signposted a path to further economic growth and prosperity. Certain regions of the UK can play a significant role in this growth.
The Government's new industrial strategy has signposted a path to further economic growth and prosperity. There are certain regions of the UK that can play a significant role in this growth, so would Treasury Ministers consider working with the Department for Business and Trade to make Cornwall an industrial strategy zone?
In the Budget last year, we introduced the Kernow growth fund to support the Cornish economy because of its specific strengths around critical minerals, defence and clean energy. The National Wealth Fund and the wider Government will do everything we can to unlock the huge opportunities that we know exist in Cornwall.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to making Cornwall an industrial strategy zone
In The Budget Last Year, We Introduced The Kernow Growth Fund To Support The Cornish Economy Because Of Its Specific Strengths Around Critical Minerals, Defence And Clean Energy.
Response accuracy
Q27 Partial Answer
Ellie Chowns Green
North Herefordshire
Context
The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) report suggests that the Treasury's narrow focus on fiscal rules leads to dysfunctional policy making and highlights the uncertainty of fiscal forecasting.
Given the recent Institute for Fiscal Studies report that says that the Treasury's excessively narrow focus on fiscal rules leads to dysfunctional policy making, and given recent global events showing the uncertainty of fiscal forecasting, does the Chancellor recognise that it is time to move to a more flexible and strategic approach to fiscal rule-making and fiscal policymaking?
I totally reject the premise of that question. The fiscal rules that I introduced as Chancellor have unlocked £120 billion for capital investment. We will be spending £50 billion more on day-to-day spending by the end of this Parliament, but at the same time, we are bringing debt down, bringing the deficit down, bringing inflation down, and bringing interest rates down for all our constituents. Economic stability is the way to grow our economy and make working people in all our constituencies better off, and if we forget that, it is ordinary working people who pay the price.
Assessment & feedback
Did not recognise the need for a more flexible approach to fiscal rule-making
I Totally Reject The Premise Of That Question.
Response accuracy