PMQs 2020-11-18

2020-11-18

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Anna McMorrin Lab
Cardiff North
Context
The question was prompted by reports that the UK government was cutting its foreign aid budget, despite previous manifesto commitments. These cuts affect initiatives addressing global challenges like climate change and poverty.
This pandemic has shown how interconnected we are and how vulnerable we are to global challenges. When we are still grappling with covid, the climate emergency and growing hunger, why are this Government reported to be breaking their own manifesto commitment and cutting the aid budget, which saves lives and builds resilience? Will the Prime Minister stop this retreat from the global stage and take this opportunity to rule that out, here and now?
I can tell the hon. Lady that everybody in this country can be immensely proud of the massive commitments that this country has made, and will continue to make, to tackling poverty and deprivation around the world. I think they can be even prouder of the commitment that we are now making, leading the world to tackle the threat of climate change. The investment we are making, whether through official development assistance or other means, in tackling that problem is second to none across the world.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not commit to maintaining foreign aid as promised and avoided addressing why reported cuts were happening.
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Andrew Rosindell Reform
Conservative
Context
The question concerns a long-standing problematic junction in Romford, which the MP previously brought to attention as Mayor of London. The issue is now compounded by financial constraints at Transport for London.
The Prime Minister will know that my constituents in Romford have to put up with a dangerous junction and flyover at Gallows Corner, which was meant to be only a temporary structure but has been there for 50 years. The Prime Minister has been there with me when he was Mayor of London. So as part of this Government's plans to build back better, will he commit today to stepping in where Sadiq Khan has failed—bankrupting Transport for London to the tune of £10 billion—and guarantee the necessary funding to replace and reshape the junction, especially as it will form a major route to and from the new lower Thames crossing?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right to say that it is the current Labour Mayor of London who blew TfL's finances, which were left in remarkably good condition by the previous Mayor of London, even before the pandemic struck. I can assure my hon. Friend that the Department for Transport will be working with TfL to see what we can do to resolve the problem at Gallows Corner that he mentions, and we will update him in due course.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not provide a commitment to funding, but promised to work on it and report back later.
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
Devolution in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland is a source of controversy with the Prime Minister recently stating it has been a disaster. This prompted questions about his stance on devolution.
May I start by sending my best wishes to the Prime Minister and all those across the country who are doing the right thing by following the rules and self-isolating? Devolution in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland is one of the proudest achievements of the last Labour Government. Until now, whatever our disagreements, there has been a very broad consensus about devolution, so why did the Prime Minister tell his MPs this week that Scottish devolution is, in his words, “a disaster”?
I think what has unquestionably been a disaster is the way in which the Scottish nationalist party has taken and used devolution as a means not to improve the lives of its constituents, not to address their health concerns or to improve education in Scotland, but—I know this point of view is shared by the right hon. and learned Gentleman—constantly to campaign for the break-up of our country and to turn devolution, otherwise a sound policy from which I myself personally benefited when I was running London, into a mission to break up the UK. That, in my view, would be a disaster.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not explain why he considers Scottish devolution a disaster but focused on his perspective of the SNP's role in it.
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister has previously referred to devolution in Scotland as a disaster. This prompted further questions about his stance on the issue, including criticism of how he handles internal market bills and the COVID response.
The single biggest threat to the future of the United Kingdom is the Prime Minister, every time he opens his mouth almost. When the Prime Minister said he wanted to take back control, nobody thought he meant from the Scottish people, but his quote is very clear. He said “devolution has been a disaster north of the border”. This is not an isolated incident. Whether it is the internal market Bill or the way the Prime Minister has sidelined the devolved Parliaments over the covid response, he is seriously undermining the fabric of the United Kingdom. Instead of talking down devolution, does he agree that we need far greater devolution of powers and resources across the United Kingdom?
Tony Blair himself, the former Labour leader, has conceded that he did not foresee the rise of a separatist party in Scotland and that he did not foresee the collapse of Scottish Labour. I think the right hon. and learned Gentleman is quite right: there can be great advantages in devolution, and I was very proud, when I was running a devolved administration in London, to do things in which I passionately believed, such as improving public transport, fighting crime and improving housing for my constituents, and we had a great deal of success. What disappoints me is that the Scottish National party—by your ruling on its correct name, Mr Speaker—is not engaging in that basic work.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not directly address whether he supports more devolution but instead focused on the perceived shortcomings of the SNP.
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The MP questioned whether the Prime Minister's statements about devolution could be fuelling separatism. The question also referenced the financial support available to those self-isolating during the pandemic.
Of course I do not want the break-up of the United Kingdom, but if anything is fuelling that break-up, it is the Prime Minister. Turning now to the Prime Minister's handling of the pandemic, the Prime Minister is doing the right thing by self-isolating after being notified by track and trace, but does he think he would have been able to do so if, like so many other people across the country, all he had to rely on for the next 14 days was either statutory sick pay, which is £95 a week—that is £13 a day—or a one-off payment of £500, which works out at £35 a day?
It is good finally to hear something from the right hon. and learned Gentleman in praise of NHS Test and Trace. I think it has secured at least one of his objectives, which is to keep me away from answering his questions in person. I believe that the package that we have in place to protect people and support people throughout this crisis has been outstanding and exceptional.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address financial constraints preventing self-isolation but praised NHS Test and Trace instead.
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
Only one in eight workers qualify for the £500 self-isolation scheme, leaving many unable to afford proper isolation. 11% of people who are asked to self-isolate actually do so due to financial constraints.
The Prime Minister must understand that there is a huge gap in the system, because if someone cannot afford to isolate, there is little point in their being tested or traced. While the Prime Minister and the Chancellor will not pay people enough to isolate properly, we learned this week that they can find £21 million of taxpayers' money to pay a go-between to deliver lucrative contracts with the Department of Health and Social Care—£21 million.
When this crisis began, we were urged by the right hon. and learned Gentleman to remove the blockages in our procurement process to get personal protective equipment. Nobody had enough PPE at the beginning of the pandemic. We shifted heaven and earth to get 32 billion items of PPE into this country. Now 70% of PPE is made or capable of being made in this country, up from only 1% at the start.
Assessment & feedback
The specific question about £21 million for a go-between was not addressed; instead, PM defended procurement process.
Changing Subject To Ppe Procurement
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister initially rejected calls for a circuit breaker, but later implemented one. A longer harder lockdown is now in place due to this delay.
I called for a circuit breaker; the Prime Minister stood there at the Dispatch Box and said it would be a disaster and he was not going to do it. Then he caught up and did exactly that just a few weeks later. We now have a longer, harder lockdown as a result of his delay.
All Government contracts are going to be published in the due way. They are already being published. We faced difficulties getting PPE during the pandemic, but I am proud of securing huge quantities.
Assessment & feedback
The question about assurance for proper process and transparency was not directly answered; instead, PM defended procurement of PPE.
Changing Subject To Ppe Procurement
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
Only one in eight workers qualify for the £500 self-isolation scheme, leaving many unable to afford proper isolation. 11% of people who are asked to self-isolate actually do so due to financial constraints.
The Prime Minister must understand that there is a huge gap in the system, because if someone cannot afford to isolate, there is little point in their being tested or traced.
We continue to encourage people to self-isolate. We have given £13.5 billion in support for self-employed people and have uplifted universal credit.
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address the affordability issue; instead, mentioned existing supports like universal credit.
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
Covid-19 has impacted football clubs, particularly those relying on ticket sales. Lincoln City Football Club is a significant organisation in Karl McCartney's constituency.
I feel like a positive rose between two negative thorns today. I am sure that my right hon. Friend is aware of recent successes that Lincoln City Football Club have enjoyed. Unfortunately, covid-19 has hit football hard, especially those clubs dependent on ticket sales. Will he urge his Cabinet colleagues to review grant funding for football clubs and perhaps outline how we can return fans to matches at all levels of the game, as I have requested in previous correspondence? As it has been a while since the Prime Minister visited Lincoln, would he care to join me at an Imps match when we can return in person as fans of the beautiful game?
I can tell my hon. Friend that we do not want any football team to go out of business as a result of this pandemic and that we are doing everything we can. I understand the frustration of fans, and we want to get crowds back into the ground as soon as possible. As for his invitation to come and watch the Imps, I will do whatever I can to oblige as soon as possible.
Assessment & feedback
Specific review of grant funding and outline of how to return fans was not addressed
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Context
Over the past two decades, Westminster has implemented various controversial policies that have affected Scotland negatively. The Scottish Parliament has delivered several benefits to its citizens in contrast.
May I wish the Prime Minister and all those who are self-isolating well? Over the past 20 years, Westminster has imposed an extreme Brexit, an illegal war in Iraq, £9,000 tuition fees, the Windrush scandal, the rape clause and the bedroom tax, and a decade of Tory austerity cuts which have pushed millions into poverty. At the same time, the Scottish Parliament has delivered free prescriptions, free tuition fees, free personal care, free bus travel, the baby box, the Scottish child payment, and world-leading climate action, all of which make Scotland a fairer and more equal place in which to live. Does the Prime Minister understand why the people in Scotland think it is he and his Parliament that are the real disaster?
I respectfully refer the right hon. Gentleman to the answer I gave to the Leader of the Opposition. I do think that his policies of wanting to break up the Union are a disaster and I wish that he and his party would focus on the real priorities of the people of Scotland—on education, on health, on tackling crime, on housing, and on the issues that matter to all our people.
Assessment & feedback
The question about why Scots view Westminster as disastrous was not answered
Focusing On Devolution Redirecting To Priorities
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
The Scottish Government has delivered various benefits that make Scotland a fairer place. However, there is concern about the Tory power grab Bill, which could further undermine devolution.
My goodness, I am not sure if the Prime Minister was listening, because I just charted some of the achievements of the Scottish Government delivering on behalf of the people of Scotland. We have seen no apology and no regrets from this Prime Minister. His attack on devolution was not just a slip of the tongue; it was a slip of the Tory mask. The chasm between Westminster and the Scottish people has never been bigger. We now face an extreme Brexit, a power grab and another round of Tory cuts, all being imposed against our will by a Tory Government that we did not vote for. Is it not the case that the real disaster facing the people of Scotland is another 20 years of Westminster Government? Is it not clearer than ever that the only way to protect Scotland's interests, our Parliament and our place in Europe is for Scotland to become an independent country?
I could not disagree more with the right hon. Gentleman; he is totally wrong. What the UK does as a whole is far bigger, better and more important than what we can do as individual nations and regions.
Assessment & feedback
The question about 20 years of Westminster governance and independence was not answered
Denying The Claim Focusing On Uk Unity
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Context
The aviation sector has lost tens of thousands of jobs due to the pandemic, with hundreds of thousands more at risk. The current quarantine arrangements are a concern.
Tens of thousands of jobs have already been lost in aviation, and hundreds of thousands more hang in the balance. Will my right hon. Friend throw the industry a lifeline by ensuring that the Government taskforce reports in time for a testing regime to replace the current quarantine arrangements as we come out of this lockdown on 3 December?
We are certainly working very fast to see whether we can replace the current quarantine arrangements for every category of self-isolation. Whether it will come fast enough for me, I do not know, but I will keep my hon. Friend informed of developments.
Assessment & feedback
No specific timeline or confirmation was provided on taskforce report
Hedging Language
Response accuracy
Q13 Direct Answer
Context
Northern Ireland has received £165 million for rural broadband investment, following population testing initiatives in Liverpool.
The people of Northern Ireland will today see again the benefits of the Union, with £165 million invested in rural broadband across Northern Ireland—the result of our agreement with the Government during the last Parliament. Following on from the current population testing initiative in Liverpool, does the Prime Minister agree that Northern Ireland's 1.8 million population, which is spread across 11 local government districts, would prove ideal for the next phase of the Government's ongoing programme of work on large-scale covid testing?
I thank the right hon. Gentleman for his excellent proposal. He is right that mass testing of that kind is a very powerful weapon in the fight against covid. We will certainly be talking to the Northern Ireland Executive about how to proceed.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Gareth Bacon Con
Orpington
Context
Residents of leasehold flats under 18 metres are facing issues with cladding removal, leading to delays in obtaining the necessary EWS1 form. This affects residents' ability to sell their properties or move.
I have been contacted by many constituents who are owners of leasehold flats in buildings under 18 metres in height that are covered in cladding, and the freeholder has not replaced that cladding or produced an EWS1 form. Some of these residents are desperate to move but cannot because their flats are effectively valueless without the form. Will the Prime Minister update the House on what progress is being made by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors and the National Fire Chiefs Council to develop the urgently needed risk prioritisation matrix, so that my constituents can move on with their lives?
I have deep sympathies with people who face this problem. It is not right or fair because if your building is under 18 metres you do not need one of these EWS1 forms, and you would hope that lenders would understand that. But we are working as fast as we can to make sure that all the buildings in question are identified and that we remove cladding wherever it is necessary and give assurance and security wherever that is necessary too.
Assessment & feedback
Progress on developing a risk prioritisation matrix was not addressed, only general efforts were mentioned.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q15 Direct Answer
Kate Osborne Lab
Jarrow and Gateshead East
Context
Government plans to scrap the union learning fund mean that about 200,000 workers a year will miss out on training opportunities. With rising unemployment levels, there is concern over how these people can access education and retraining.
Government plans to scrap the union learning fund mean that thousands of workers—about 200,000 a year, many of them low-paid—will miss out on training opportunities. With unemployment levels rising, will the Prime Minister today act on his commitment to offer a lifetime skills guarantee to help people to train and retrain at any stage in their lives, and reverse this decision to ensure that working people can access education, training and skills for the future?
That is exactly what we announced only a few weeks ago with the lifetime skills guarantee. The purpose of the lifetime skills guarantee is this: if you are over 23, you are not currently eligible for support from the Government in getting a new skill or a new qualification, but we will now pay you for that skill—we will support you. Particularly in the context of this pandemic, we want to help to train and retrain people throughout their lives so that they can adjust to our changing economy. The hon. Lady makes a very good point.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Gareth Davies Con
Grantham and Bourne
Context
The constituency of Grantham and Bourne requires significant infrastructure investment. There is a need to mobilise billions of private capital to achieve this.
In order to truly level up constituencies like mine in Lincolnshire, we will need to mobilise billions of private capital to help us to pay for new infrastructure investment. Will the Prime Minister consider launching a new financial institution such as a national development bank to help to achieve this?
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for what he is doing to campaign for Grantham and Stamford and for Lincolnshire. I can tell him that we are putting another £125 million into Greater Lincolnshire through the growth deals and another £25 million through the Getting Building fund. We will be bringing forward further measures—I take his point on board very sincerely—to boost investment in UK infrastructure in due course.
Assessment & feedback
Launching a new financial institution was not addressed, only current funding measures were mentioned.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Context
The UK has suffered from one of the deepest recessions among G7 countries and has had the highest number of covid deaths in Europe.
In March, the Government's chief scientific officer said that keeping covid deaths below 20,000 would be a good outcome but still an enormous number of deaths. We have now passed 50,000 deaths and suffered the deepest recession of any G7 country, with GDP dropping by 10% in the past year. Why does the Prime Minister think the UK has had the deepest recession in the G7 and the highest number of covid deaths in Europe?
This is a global pandemic and one in which the UK has, as the hon. Gentleman rightly says, been badly affected, and we mourn every life that has been lost. Of course we are supporting businesses with all the firepower of the UK economy. But I have absolutely no doubt that we will get through this strongly by next spring, as the scientific advisers and the medical officers have said. We have the tools to do it and we have the scientific weaponry to do it. That is why we are engaged in the current restrictions to get the R down to suppress the virus now and to try to get the economy moving in a way that I am sure he would like.
Assessment & feedback
The economic performance question was not directly addressed, only general support measures were mentioned.
Changing Subject
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Context
Independent retailers in Rugby are currently closed due to covid restrictions. They appreciate financial support but are concerned that supermarkets and multiple retailers continue to sell the same products, generating profits without business rates.
Most of our fabulous independent retailers in Rugby are currently closed due to covid restrictions. While they appreciate the very welcome financial support provided by the Government, they are concerned that supermarkets and multiple retailers continue to sell the same products as them, such as homeware and clothing, enabling them to generate substantial profits while at the same time having had a holiday on the payment of business rates. Does the Prime Minister agree that there should be fairness between retailers, and that with the Government spending £200 billion to support businesses and people in these very tough times, it would be a welcome gesture from multiples who continue to trade to volunteer to pay those retailers' businesses rates?
I understand the point that my hon. Friend makes and the feeling of unfairness that he describes. What we are trying to do with the business rates holiday and all the other measures we have announced is to help all retailers. The best thing we can do is to get through this tough period as well as we possibly can and allow all retailers to reopen and give them our support with our custom. That is what we are aiming for.
Assessment & feedback
Voluntary payment of business rates was not addressed, only general measures were mentioned.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q19 Partial Answer
Context
A constituent's EU settlement scheme application has been pending for fifteen months. The end of the transition period is approaching, creating urgency.
My constituent applied for the EU settlement scheme in September 2019 for her and her son. Fifteen months on, she is still waiting for a decision on her application. With the end of the transition period just a few short weeks away, will the Prime Minister give a cast-iron guarantee that my constituent's application and all other outstanding applications to the scheme will be concluded before 31 December 2020?
I understand that the case is now under urgent review and a decision will be made shortly.
Assessment & feedback
Cast-iron guarantee was not given, only an urgency statement was provided.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q20 Direct Answer
Context
A recent survey found that one in five people say they will not take the covid vaccine. There is concern about anti-vaccine disinformation on social media.
It is fantastic that we will very soon have the covid vaccine, but extremely concerning that in a recent survey, one in five people say they will not take it. Does the Prime Minister agree that social media companies should be doing more to remove anti-vaccine disinformation and conspiracy theories? Will he consider including requirements to do that within the scope of the Government's forthcoming online harms Bill?
Yes. I am very pleased that Facebook, Twitter and Google have committed that no company should profit from or promote vaccine disinformation and that companies should respond to that kind of content very quickly. We are going to publish our response shortly to the online harms White Paper consultation and will be setting out our plans for legislation.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Chi Onwurah Lab
Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West
Context
The North East Child Poverty Commission reported a significant increase in child poverty in Newcastle upon Tyne Central between 2015 and 2019. Additionally, 15,000 of the poorest households in the constituency are set to lose £1,000 annually due to planned cuts to universal credit.
Child poverty is evil—I know; I grew up with it. The North East Child Poverty Commission reports that our region suffered the country's biggest increase in child poverty between 2015 and 2019, when half of children in Newcastle upon Tyne Central were growing up poor, and that was before covid. Yet 15,000 of the poorest households in my constituency stand to lose £1,000 a year because of planned cuts to universal credit in April. Instead of damaging last-minute U-turns, will the Prime Minister now commit to maintaining universal credit at least at the current rate?
The hon. Lady is right in what she says about the impact of child poverty, and that is why this Government have worked so hard to combat child poverty. That is why we did indeed uprate universal credit, which is right for the exceptional circumstances we are in. That was £1,000 a household, and we will continue to support people throughout the country, but the most important thing we can do is to ensure that we get people into work and support families to get the jobs they need. It is the record of this country in creating jobs, and new jobs in particular, that has meant that 400,000 children have been lifted out of poverty in the past 10 years. That is progress. It is not enough, but it is progress.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not commit to maintaining universal credit at its current rate.
Working With Partners Under Review
Response accuracy
Q22 Partial Answer
Christopher Chope Con
Christchurch
Context
The BMJ reported on 2 November that individuals who have tested positive for covid-19 and recovered will be protected from reinfection by their T cells for at least six months. This suggests that these individuals could be exempted from current restrictions.
More than 1 million fellow citizens have recovered after testing positive for covid-19. On 2 November, The BMJ reported that all those people will have protection from their T cells, which will ensure that they cannot be reinfected for at least six months. In light of that, will my right hon. Friend follow the example of Sweden and exempt from all the covid regulations those who have tested positive within the past six months and thereby show that he is following the science and also common sense?
I thank my hon. Friend for his very well meant suggestion. It is very kind, but there is evidence both ways on that. What everybody would expect is that everybody who gets pinged and gets contacted by NHS Test and Trace should follow the rules.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not provide a direct answer to the specific suggestion made.
Following The Science
Response accuracy
Q23 Partial Answer
Mohammad Yasin Lab
Bedford
Context
During the pandemic, disabled people have faced challenges such as reduced care services and isolation difficulties. Additionally, they were excluded from the Government's communication efforts.
Six out of 10 people who have died from covid-19 are disabled. Yet, during this pandemic, disabled people have seen their care cut back, have struggled to isolate without sufficient support, and have been excluded from the Government's shambolic communications. As we start Disability History Month, will the Prime Minister tell the House why disabled people have been so let down by his Government?
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman for the question and for his campaigning on behalf of the disabled but I must reject what he says. We have done everything we can to reach out to disabled and vulnerable groups of all kinds, to give them all the advice that we think is necessary and all the support that we possibly can throughout the pandemic. I know that this has been very tough for people, and I thank them for the way that they have pulled together and followed the guidance.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not directly address why disabled individuals were let down.
Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q24 Partial Answer
Context
The UK Government's contribution to the Moray growth deal is set to be spread over a period of 15 years, which could potentially limit the immediate benefits.
The Prime Minister is aware of the success we have seen across Scotland through city region and growth deals. Moray is set to benefit from both the Scottish and the UK Governments' working together on our local deal. However, will my right hon. Friend agree that the benefit to Moray could be even greater if the UK Government's contribution was spread over a shorter period than the current 15 years—say, 10 or less? Will he agree that that would be very worthwhile, beneficial and welcomed by everyone involved in the Moray growth deal?
I thank my hon. Friend for this campaign. He has raised the idea with me before. What I can say is that while we will certainly look at what he says, I am very glad that we have signed the heads of terms on the Moray growth deal, delivering over £30 million of investment.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not commit to spreading the contribution over a shorter period.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q25 Partial Answer
Ian Byrne Lab
Liverpool West Derby
Context
Professor Ian Sinha from Alder Hey Children's Hospital stated that the environment a child develops in, even before being born, can affect its DNA detrimentally by 10%. The Government's policies are leading to food poverty for millions of families.
Professor Ian Sinha from Alder Hey Children's Hospital in Liverpool, West Derby, recently stated that the environment a child develops in, even before being born, can affect its DNA detrimentally by 10%. This Government have been responsible for creating an environment that is pushing millions of families into food poverty, which will be shaping this terrifying outcome. To address this, will the Prime Minister—I ask him for the second time—work with me and other groups to put the right to food into law?
The hon. Gentleman is right to raise the issue of food poverty and of poverty generally. That is why, in answer to the previous question from the hon. Member for Newcastle upon Tyne Central (Chi Onwurah), I made the point that we have actually been successful, as we have been championing work and employment, in getting large numbers of families out of poverty.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not commit to working with Ian Byrne on putting the right to food into law.
Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q26 Direct Answer
John Lamont Con
Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk
Context
The United States has imposed tariffs on Scottish cashmere and whisky industries as part of a trade dispute with the European Union. These tariffs are causing significant harm to these iconic Scottish products.
As the Prime Minister will know, the Scottish cashmere and whisky industries are being hammered by the tariffs imposed by the United States as a result of the trade dispute with the European Union. Those tariffs are now doing serious harm to such iconic Scottish products, costing us jobs in the Scottish borders. Will the Prime Minister reassure me that the Government are doing everything they possibly can to find a resolution to the dispute?
My hon. Friend is entirely right to raise that issue. It continues to be a cause of grave concern, and I raise it repeatedly with our American friends. I am working with my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for International Trade to reach a negotiated solution as fast as we possibly can.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q27 Partial Answer
Bambos Charalambous Lab
Southgate and Wood Green
Context
A recent study of 18 million people shows that black, Asian and minority ethnic people are twice as likely as white people to catch coronavirus and more likely to go into intensive care. Researchers suggest structural inequalities rather than genetics are key.
Lead researchers have suggested that structural inequalities, not genetics, are the key differential. How will the Prime Minister redress these structural inequalities as the vaccine is rolled out?
The hon. Gentleman raises a very important point, and we are thinking about this issue in government right now. In response to early data showing the impact on black and minority ethnic groups, enhanced testing procedures were brought forward for particularly vulnerable groups exposed to heavy viral loads. The Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation will consider these factors in deciding how to roll out the vaccine.
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures or commitments to address structural inequalities in the vaccine rollout were not provided
Response accuracy