Topical Questions 2020-10-06

2020-10-06

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Context
The Northern Ireland authorities have taken unprecedented action and committed to pay for private prescriptions for medical cannabis for severely ill children.
Will he do the right thing and follow the example set in Northern Ireland in supporting other children with intractable epilepsy by paying for their private prescriptions—yes or no?
The hon. Lady has long been a campaigner on this subject. We have made significant progress in terms of expanding access where it is clinically safe to do so. On this, as on so many things, I will make sure that I constantly follow the clinical evidence.
Assessment & feedback
The specific yes or no answer regarding private prescriptions was not provided.
Following The Clinical Evidence
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Jeremy Hunt Con
Godalming and Ash
Context
The Secretary of State's letter stated that clinics were going to be set up so that long covid sufferers could get mental health support, face-to-face counselling and rehabilitation.
Have those clinics been commissioned, and when will those long covid sufferers be able to access them throughout the country?
My right hon. Friend makes an incredibly important point. I know very well the impact of long covid; it is something that I understand deeply. We are in the process of setting up those clinics and there will be further information on this very shortly.
Assessment & feedback
The specific timeline for clinic commissioning was not provided.
In The Process Further Information Soon
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Context
The Office for National Statistics has said that deaths have increased three weeks in a row, and there is rising prevalence of the virus.
Can he tell us today what he could not tell us yesterday: how many of the 48,000 contacts—not the index cases, the contacts—have been traced and how many are now isolating?
We have obviously been continuing to contact both the index cases and the contacts. The total number of contacts depends on how many contacts each index case has. That information will of course be made available in the normal way when it has been completed. However, we cannot know in advance how many contacts there are because the interviews with the index cases have to be done first.
Assessment & feedback
The specific number of traced and isolating contacts was not provided.
Will Be Completed Cannot Know In Advance
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Context
The Government aims to vaccinate about 30 million people, and there has been an expectation that the whole population would be vaccinated.
Can he tell us how long it will take, for the 50% of people who will not be vaccinated, for life to return to normal for them?
As the hon. Gentleman well knows, decisions on the distribution of any vaccine have not been taken. The Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation is the body that advises the Government on the appropriate clinical prioritisation of vaccines. It has published an interim guide, which he well knows about and we have discussed. That sets out the order of priority as an interim measure, but we await the data from the clinical trials of the vaccine before we will come to a clinically validated full roll-out plan.
Assessment & feedback
The specific timeline for vaccine distribution was not provided.
Awaiting Clinical Trial Data
Response accuracy
Q5 Direct Answer
Context
GPs surgeries are adapting by holding surgeries outside in car parks.
Does my right hon. Friend agree that in times when alternative methods are replacing the usual privacy of face-to-face appointments behind closed doors, GPs surgeries must be sensitive to the whereabouts and comfort of their patients to ensure that others do not have the same experience as my constituent?
Yes, I wholeheartedly agree with my hon. Friend, who speaks well for her constituent. I am very sorry that her constituent had that experience, and of course GPs should be sensitive, as the large majority are.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Direct Answer
Context
The implications of coronavirus include rising levels of loneliness, which can impact on mental health and physical wellbeing while increasing pressure on the NHS.
What resources can the Government provide to accelerate the spread of such social prescribing schemes so that community groups can deliver tailored local support to tackle this growing problem?
I pay tribute to the group that the hon. Lady mentions. I have put a huge amount of effort into supporting social prescribing, including with funding, and I encourage her CCG to engage with such bodies to make sure that we can get funding to support them on the frontline.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Caroline Johnson Con
Sleaford and North Hykeham
Context
The questioner is concerned about women who are vulnerable, subject to abuse or in coercive relationships due to relaxed abortion services during the first lockdown.
At the start of this pandemic, in the first lockdown, abortion services were relaxed to allow women to enable them to access the service from home. Now that we know that the risk to women of childbearing age from attending a face-to-face appointment is extremely low, what assessment has my right hon. Friend made of the ongoing need to continue in this way?
The Under-Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, my hon. Friend the Member for Bury St Edmunds (Jo Churchill) has committed to consult on the subject to make sure we get to the right outcome.
Assessment & feedback
Specific assessment was not provided, only a commitment to consult
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Kate Osamor Lab Co-op
Edmonton and Winchmore Hill
Context
The Government have refused to meet the group representing families who lost loved ones due to coronavirus.
This Government have repeatedly refused to meet the group representing covid-19 bereaved families. I met the group last week, and they confirmed that they are not in litigation with the Government and never have been. They simply want to put across the concerns of thousands of people who have lost loved ones to coronavirus, so will the Minister now commit to meeting the group and hearing their concerns at first hand?
Of course I have met and continue to meet the families of those bereaved through coronavirus. With this particular group, I am afraid that when I last looked into it, they were in legal action—in pre-action protocol—with the Government, so I am advised that I should not therefore meet them.
Assessment & feedback
The refusal to meet due to legal concerns rather than addressing their request
Legal Concerns
Response accuracy
Q9 Direct Answer
Context
Communities need a clear path out of tighter local restrictions.
It is important that communities, such as mine in Middlesbrough, can see a way out of the tighter local restrictions that have now been imposed. Notwithstanding my right hon. Friend's earlier, very reasonable answer to the hon. Member for Bradford South (Judith Cummins) about the impossibility of setting hard metrics for the release from lockdown, can he set out what would constitute a path out? Does it include, for example, a sustained fall in transmission rates?
The level of cases matters, but so too does the direction of travel, and when the number of cases is falling—especially if it is falling rapidly—that is the sort of indicator that we will look at. One example is the action we took in Leicester a few months ago now, where we removed some of the most restrictive measures when the numbers were coming down sharply.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Ian Lavery Lab
Blyth and Ashington
Context
The north-east of England is experiencing a significant increase in coronavirus transmission levels.
Please, please, Secretary of State, my constituents need extra support. Despite the outstanding efforts of the staff at Northumberland County Council, covid-19 is running rife through our towns and villages. Since stricter local lockdown measures were introduced, we have seen a huge increase in transmission levels. Parts of Ashington, Bedlington, Morpeth and Newbiggin have seen rates of almost 500 per 100,000. Secretary of State, please help us.
I am very worried about the rates of transmission in the north-east, as I am about parts of the north-west of England. I look forward to working with the hon. Gentleman and colleagues from across the regions affected to take the action necessary to suppress this virus and to support the economy, education and the NHS right across this land.
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions were not detailed beyond general commitments
Response accuracy
Q11 Direct Answer
Context
The questioner has personal experience with how effective the app is.
I have first-hand experience of how effective the app has been, as it has kept my father covid-free before he goes into hospital tomorrow. Could my right hon. Friend update the House on the success of the app and advise me of what more Members can do to ensure that the covid-19 app continues to keep us all safe, including my father?
The covid-19 app has now been successfully downloaded by around 15 million people, including my hon. Friend's father. Every extra person who downloads it helps to keep themselves safe and keep others safe. I urge everybody in this House to download it—I hope you have, Mr Speaker. It is one of the tools in the armoury, and everybody can play their part in keeping this virus under control by downloading the app.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12 Direct Answer
Jamie Stone Lib Dem
Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross
Context
There have been issues with people being advised to travel to Inverness for covid tests.
As you can imagine, Mr Speaker, I was astounded to be told that people living in Devon were being advised to go to Inverness for a covid test. Can the Secretary of State reassure me that a truly collaborative effort is being made by Her Majesty's Government and the Scottish Government to beat this virus?
Yes, absolutely. The testing facilities are one example of that. Testing facilities across the UK work very closely with the Scottish NHS, to ensure that people can get a test as close to them as possible. I think we have reduced the problem of people being sent to Inverness, but we continue to work to increase the capacity in Inverness and right across the country.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
There have been reports in Canada and the US about the roll-out of rapid testing.
Partly in response to large queues and hours-long waits for tests in Canada, Health Canada has followed the US Food and Drug Administration in approving rapid testing, such as the ID NOW test, which can give a result in 15 minutes. Can the Secretary of State update us on where we are with the roll-out of rapid testing?
We are making good progress in validating the tests and in doing what needs to be done to be able to use them effectively. I have seen some of these reports from around the world, and I talk regularly to my opposite numbers about how we can get this sort of next-generation testing going.
Assessment & feedback
Specific status on roll-out was not provided beyond general progress updates
Response accuracy
Q14 Direct Answer
Jessica Morden Lab
Newport East
Context
Spina Bifida Awareness Week is coming up and there's a consultation on putting folic acid into flour.
With Spina Bifida Awareness Week coming up, can the Secretary of State say when the Government will respond to the consultation on putting folic acid into flour? It is a move that could help to reduce the number of babies born with defects of the spine, and it is important to hear when that might happen.
I am a strong supporter of the work we have done to look at that approach. The hon. Lady is right to raise it, and I will write to her with a timetable for that response.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Context
Women in Heald Green have missed out on local breast screening twice within three years, affecting take-up and potentially risking undetected cancers.
Positive outcomes are more likely when cancer is detected early through breast screening. Women in Heald Green have missed out on local screening and been directed to Macclesfield, disrupting their three-yearly checks and potentially impacting uptake. Will the Secretary of State agree to meet me to discuss ways to address this situation?
Yes, I would be happy to meet her. The breast screening backlog from the first peak is down from 450,000 to just over 50,000, due to the hard work of the NHS.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary did not commit to addressing local mobile screening issues in Heald Green specifically
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Context
The pharmaceutical industry has highlighted challenges in recreating stockpiles of medicines such as insulin before the end of the transition period.
How will the Secretary of State ensure there are no drug shortages, particularly of medicines like insulin which is not produced in the UK?
A huge amount of work is under way to ensure we are fully prepared for all eventualities this winter.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary did not provide specific measures or timelines to prevent shortages
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Context
The Northgate Hospital investment was announced last week, with a focus on developing technology to reach more patients in remote areas.
I thank the Secretary of State for his commitment to Northumberland hospital investment. Does he agree that Berwick Infirmary is an ideal place to develop telemedicine to serve rural populations?
We have announced a new hospital in Northumberland, funded by the Prime Minister. Community hospitals are crucial for delivering services closer to people's homes with modern advances.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary did not directly address whether Berwick Infirmary is ideal for developing telemedicine specifically
Response accuracy