Topical Questions 2020-11-16

2020-11-16

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Context
Local councils face new national restrictions and are receiving £7 billion of direct funding alongside a sales, fees and charges scheme worth over £1 billion this year.
I am concerned about the leasehold system in Scotland where each owner must get their own EWS1 assessment carried out despite not having the English leasehold system. How does the Secretary of State intend to resolve this costly and bureaucratic system which is causing difficulty for constituents affected by the cladding scandal? Will he arrange a socially distant meeting with me to discuss this further?
I would be very happy to meet the hon. Lady. The noble Lord Greenhalgh, the building safety Minister, and I have been meeting lenders and UK Finance to discuss the EWS1 form and urge them to take a more proportionate, risk-based approach. This form was designed for buildings over 18 metres with external wall systems but is now being used for buildings below 18 metres without cladding.
Assessment & feedback
Specific resolution plan not provided
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Context
Leaseholders face costs for items such as waking watch due to regulatory failure, causing difficulties in Northpoint where residents have spent over half a million pounds.
I welcome the Housing Minister's acceptance that leaseholders should not bear the costs of remediating cladding. Does the Secretary of State agree that neither should they be expected to pay for items like waking watch arising from unsafe cladding, as seen in Northpoint?
My hon. Friend will know that my Department is working closely with Northpoint residents who are part of the building safety fund worth £1.6 billion. He is right to draw attention to waking watch issues; it's a scandal with contractors charging outrageous fees for little support.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment not provided
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Context
Public concern over misuse of taxpayers' money from the £3.6 billion towns fund to boost Conservative election campaigns by blocking funding for deprived areas.
There is growing public concern that the Secretary of State misused taxpayers' money from the £3.6 billion towns fund, but he can easily clear it up. Will he publish in full the accounting officer's advice and criteria used to block funding for the 100 most deprived towns?
The Department has already made it clear that a robust process was followed before I became Secretary of State. We will not apologise for investing in communities underinvested by the Labour party. Accounting officer assessments are not routinely published; my officials will consider replying to the Select Committee.
Assessment & feedback
Refusal to publish accounting officer's report
We Will Not Apologise For Investing In Communities Underinvested By The Labour Party
Response accuracy
Q4 Direct Answer
Steve Reed Lab Co-op
Streatham and Croydon North
Context
Street homelessness is a crisis of housing, health, mental health, and addiction. The pandemic has brought people off the streets into safe accommodation with wraparound support.
I share the belief that street homelessness is a crisis not just of housing but of health, mental health, and addiction as well. How does our approach from the start of the pandemic to bring people in off the streets into safe and secure accommodation fit into this?
My hon. Friend shares my belief that street homelessness is a crisis not just of housing but of health, mental health, and addiction as well. Our approach from the start of the pandemic has been to bring people off the streets into safe accommodation with wraparound support.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Ben Spencer Con
Runnymede and Weybridge
Context
Mencap is concerned about the lack of clarity on the shared prosperity fund, a successor to the European Social Fund. Disabled people have benefited greatly from it.
Last week I met Mencap who were extremely concerned about the lack of clarity on the shared prosperity fund. Can the Secretary State agree to meet me and outline a way forward for this fund?
I would be happy to have that conversation. My officials have been engaging with devolved Administrations from all nations of the United Kingdom. Further details will be published at the spending review.
Assessment & feedback
Specific meeting not confirmed
Response accuracy
Q6 Direct Answer
Context
The right hon. Friend wrote to the Minister about safe sleeping pod-style accommodation for rough sleepers during winter.
I have written to my right hon. Friend recommending covid-safe sleeping pod-style accommodation for rough sleepers this winter. Despite the Government's efforts, some will still be on our streets. Will he tell me what steps are being put in place to ensure their safety and avoid night shelters which many find terrifying?
The Government are providing a £10 million cold weather fund to all local authorities, along with a new £15 million protect programme and a £2 million transformation fund. These initiatives aim to provide self-contained accommodation, innovative shelter options, and support for faith and community centres.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Context
Cheshire West and Chester Council has a funding gap of about £56 million, including an unconfirmed £7 million income compensation scheme payment.
The council faces a £1 million deficit due to covid activities despite the Chancellor's promise to do 'whatever it takes'. Will the Government make good on the funding gap or leave local governments in uncertainty?
Total covid-19 additional funding is £25 million, with an almost £39 million total from across Government. The sales, fees and charges scheme will contribute 75p in the pound for lost income, and a similar scheme is planned for council tax and business rates.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment to cover remaining deficit of £1 million was not made
Under Review Committed
Response accuracy
Q8 Direct Answer
Context
The Government have prioritised ending homelessness with social housing playing a key role.
Will the Minister update on measures taken to increase social housing investment under this year's affordable homes programme to help end homelessness?
The Government have made £11.5 billion available for 180,000 new affordable homes in five years, a significant proportion of which will be for affordable or social rent. The abolition of the housing revenue account cap allows local authorities to build more social homes if they wish.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Chris Bryant Lab
Rhondda and Ogmore
Context
Acquired brain injury is a hidden epidemic with local authorities bearing significant costs for neuro-rehabilitation.
Will the Secretary of State meet me to discuss better co-reliance among agencies working with people who have brain injuries, including those affected by covid?
The hon. Gentleman has been a fantastic champion of this cause, and I would be delighted to do so.
Assessment & feedback
No specific commitments or actions were provided
Would Be Delighted
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Robbie Moore Con
Keighley and Ilkley
Context
The shadow Secretary of State has defended Tony Newman, the former leader of the bankrupt Labour-run Croydon Council.
Does my right hon. Friend agree that instead of scoring political points, the shadow Secretary of State should address the serious letdown by Labour councils in managing public funds?
The situation in Croydon is deeply concerning with catastrophic financial mismanagement. The council has issued a section 114 notice, and we will consider findings from the urgent review concluding later this month.
Assessment & feedback
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Kate Osborne Lab
Jarrow and Gateshead East
Context
Significant reductions in Government funding for children's social care since 2010 have led to more children entering care due to prevention cuts.
Will the Minister ensure that any new funding formula recognises pressures and need, especially in areas with higher deprivation?
The funding has been deployed taking deprivation into consideration. As we approach the spending review, I will argue for further funding for local authorities so they are properly and sustainably financed.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment to new formula was not made
Under Review Committed
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Context
Gullis brought his Planning (Proper Maintenance of Land) Bill before the House in September, with support from Historic England. He aims to protect and preserve heritage sites such as Price & Kensington.
My right hon. Friend will be aware that I brought before the House my Planning (Proper Maintenance of Land) Bill back in September with the support of Historic England. Will he confirm whether he will adopt this in the planning reform Bill, helping my fight to protect and preserve our nation's heritage at places such as Price & Kensington in Stoke-on-Trent North, Kidsgrove and Talke?
I congratulate my hon. Friend on securing the Second Reading of his Bill. We are looking to strengthen the powers and sanctions in respect of both heritage and planning enforcement as part of our White Paper reforms of the planning system. I am sure that he will be lobbying us to ensure that that is part of the wider package.
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm whether they would adopt the Bill
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Justin Madders Lab
Ellesmere Port and Bromborough
Context
The Secretary of State allocated towns fund money without following civil servants' advice, raising concerns about the decision-making process.
When the Secretary of State ignored his own civil servants' advice on which areas to support with the towns fund, was that on his own initiative or was he receiving instructions from Downing Street?
It is a shame that the hon. Gentleman makes party political points without understanding the facts, because no Minister in my Department has ignored the advice of their officials. The Department produced a robust process, which was followed by myself and any other Minister in the Department, so he should be careful before making wild and false accusations.
Assessment & feedback
Avoided answering on whether Downing Street influenced the decision
Accusing Questioner Of Ignorance Making Party Political Points
Response accuracy
Q14 Direct Answer
Context
Deal faces issues with sewage and water flooding, leading to planning objections against local homes. There's a need to match housing delivery with infrastructure capacity.
For years, some water companies and Ofwat have failed to get a grip on repeated sewage and water flooding, including in the historic town of Deal. As a result, planning objections are mounting against the delivery of much-needed and wanted local homes. Will my right hon. Friend consider what more can be done to ensure that additional planned housing delivery can be matched by additional planned capacity in water, electricity and broadband utilities?
I am obliged to my hon. Friend. She is a doughty campaigner for her constituents in Dover, and particularly, in this case, in Deal. She will know that the national planning policy framework makes it clear that local authorities should make provision for infrastructure, including water supply and energy, through their strategic planning authorities. As to what further we can do, our White Paper on planning reform proposes an infrastructure levy that will get that sort of infrastructure that she refers to in place at the get-go so that communities get not just the housing they need but the infrastructure to go with it.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q15 Direct Answer
Context
Ealing Council faces a £30 million funding shortfall despite receiving support from the Secretary of State to fight covid-19.
Ealing Council is facing a funding shortfall of around £30 million even after efficiency savings and delaying investment. That is despite a promise from the Secretary of State that it would have everything that it needed to fight covid-19. Will the Secretary of State stick to his promise and give local authorities what they need, or will he be the one to explain why children's centres, libraries and sports facilities have to close?
I can assure the hon. Gentleman that we are very much sticking to our promise to support local authorities. We have already given local authorities more than £7 billion since the start of the pandemic, with the sales fees and charges and the business rates and council tax schemes. We are approaching £10 billion of additional support for local authorities, and in his case, in Ealing, it is £30 million, so he is quite wrong to say that we are not supporting his constituents.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Wera Hobhouse Lib Dem
Bath
Context
The UK has declared a climate emergency, but the Secretary of State proposes changes to planning laws that could affect local authorities' ability to negotiate biodiversity net gains.
Under the planning laws, Bath and North East Somerset Council in my constituency negotiated a 64.9% biodiversity net gain as part of planning consent for a new development. Why does the Secretary of State propose to take that opportunity away from local planning authorities, given that the UK has declared a climate emergency?
I am happy to look into what the hon. Lady says, but she is mistaken. This party is doing quite the opposite. We are legislating to embed biodiversity net gain as an essential part of the planning system.
Assessment & feedback
Did not explain why the proposal could take away local authorities' negotiation opportunities
Stating The Opposite
Response accuracy