Covid-19 Public Order 2020-12-14

2020-12-14

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Desmond Swayne Con
New Forest West
Context
The question arises from concerns about the policing methods used during protests against COVID-19 restrictions.
What representations have been received on the policing of protests against covid-19 restrictions?
Our police forces face unprecedented challenges and have the critical role of maintaining public order. They will continue to engage, explain and encourage people to follow the rules, but will enforce where necessary. We have provided £30 million extra surge funding to support additional enforcement and we continue to work closely with our policing partners to ensure they have the necessary powers.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific feedback or representations received on how protests are policed, only general assurances about policing methods and funding.
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Context
There are reports that gyms and other indoor settings have less strict enforcement of COVID-19 rules compared to pubs, causing frustration among pub owners who follow regulations.
There are widespread reports in West Yorkshire of people breaking restrictions when in gyms. This is incredibly frustrating for pubs that are forced to close, with many on the brink of extinction. Can my hon. Friend reassure those pubs, which are watching from the sidelines, that the same robust approach will be applied in all settings?
I know my hon. Friend has a background as a former publican and that his local pubs are very dear to his heart as a key plank of his local communities. We have done everything possible economically to try to support them, but he is quite right that we should, where at all possible, try to maintain a level playing field in terms of enforcement. He will know that the responsibility for enforcement indoors largely falls to local authorities, environmental health and trading standards, but his question today is a good reminder to everybody involved in enforcement that it must not only be fair, but be seen to be fair.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide clear reassurance or commitment to consistent enforcement across all settings, focusing instead on the responsibilities of local authorities and the importance of fairness.
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Desmond Swayne Con
New Forest West
Context
The question arises from concerns about the use of police powers and practices based on reported incidents, including visits to restaurants for people's names and addresses.
Has the Minister seen some of the quite shocking footage of the policing of demonstrations that is available online, and is he aware that the police have been visiting restaurants and demanding people's names and addresses? What is happening to our country?
I know my right hon. Friend is not given to hyperbole and that he has expressed his concern about the enforcement regime around the regulations over some weeks now. The enforcement from place to place is obviously an operational matter for the chief constable in that particular locality, but we are trying, where at all possible and in close conjunction with the National Police Chiefs Council, to maintain a sense of fairness and proportionality, using the “Four Es” where we can. I would just point him to the very small number of enforcement notices that have been handed out against the vast population of the United Kingdom—only in the tens of thousands against a population of 65 million—which shows that encouraging the British people to follow the regulations is largely working.
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm seeing specific footage or address concerns about restaurant visits directly, only provided general context on enforcement practices and statistics.
Response accuracy