Economic Recovery 2020-07-01
2020-07-01
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The UK is in the process of recovering from a pandemic, which has affected various sectors including benefits administration.
Some individuals are facing more than just financial issues as we exit this crisis. A year ago, an APPG report highlighted heartless DWP rules that prevent terminally ill people from accessing fast-track benefits unless they have less than six months to live. Despite pressure from the APPG and others, there has been silence from the Government since launching a review. Meanwhile, thousands of individuals have passed away without receiving support. The Scottish Government committed to scrapping this rule when they take over PIP, but universal credit and employment and support allowance are reserved matters. Will the Secretary of State urge his colleagues to end this policy?
Universal credit support has been increased during the covid crisis, but the point about the last six months of life will be raised with the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions. If Drew Hendry writes to him on this subject, he would be pleased to push the case.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Ian Murray discusses a tragic incident involving a three-year-old boy killed by a car in his constituency. He then addresses the economic challenges faced by Scotland as lockdown measures ease.
He emphasizes the need for both UK and Scottish Governments to protect jobs and support businesses, particularly those hard-hit sectors like tourism, hospitality, and creative industries. Murray highlights that many freelancers working through pay-as-you-earn contracts are falling through the cracks of current Government schemes. He asks Alister Jack to commit to raising in Cabinet the need for additional support.
Jack acknowledges the challenges but emphasizes that unprecedented sums are being provided to Scotland through the £3.8 billion business support package and the furlough scheme, which has supported 800,000 jobs. He states he will continue to raise these issues with the Chancellor.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Murray criticizes the Scottish Finance Minister for questioning the Barnett formula and advocating for full fiscal autonomy.
He questions whether Alister Jack has undertaken any analysis of how this policy would affect post-covid recovery. Murray also asks if the Secretary of State will work collaboratively with the Scottish Government to address immediate budget challenges.
Jack defends the Barnett formula, stating that it provides £125 per head of spending in Scotland for every £100 in England. He points out the support provided by the formula and warns against full fiscal autonomy, suggesting it would create significant economic challenges.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Black notes that the Chancellor will be updating the House on the furlough scheme but asks specifically about any specific requests made by Alister Jack.
She questions what recommendations and requests have been made to the Treasury regarding Scotland's needs, especially in sectors like tourism and hospitality.
Jack notes that discussions with the Treasury are confidential but highlights threats around tourism and hospitality. He criticizes the Scottish First Minister's comments about the border as irresponsible.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Black addresses the issue of public health decisions made by Scotland. She then asks about the UK Government's stance on universal basic income.
She questions why the UK Government is blocking Scotland's universal basic income trial and seeks assistance from Alister Jack to unblock it.
Jack argues against universal basic income, stating that it is not targeted at those who need it most and can increase poverty. He mentions successful trials elsewhere have been abandoned due to these issues.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy