Topical Questions 2020-09-17

2020-09-17

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Direct Answer
Context
Discusses various challenges presented by COVID-19 to transport systems and highlights the importance of safety measures at London Bridge station.
My Department continues to tackle the very many different challenges that covid presents to all the forms of transport discussed here this morning. If he will make a statement on his departmental responsibilities.
My Department continues to tackle the very many different challenges that covid presents to all the forms of transport discussed here this morning. It might be worth mentioning that I visited London Bridge station earlier in the week, where a programme that involves all the Network Rail stations is being rolled out. It is using antiviral cleaning materials, which means that surfaces become protected from coronavirus for up to 30 days. In addition, yesterday, the first meeting of the Hammersmith bridge taskforce took place.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Direct Answer
Context
Highlights the economic impact of Orwell bridge closures due to high winds on the town of Ipswich. Highways England has a plan involving a 40 mph speed limit aimed at keeping the bridge open even during windy conditions.
Arguably the biggest transport issue that impacts on my constituents in Ipswich is the Orwell bridge. At the moment, the current speed limit is 60 mph, and when it closes because of high winds, the whole town grinds to a halt. The economic impact of this should not be underestimated. Highways England has a plan involving a 40 mph speed limit, which will I hope mean that the bridge can stay open even when it is very windy. However, I am slightly concerned about the timescale. Will my right hon. Friend communicate to Highways England his expectation that these new measures will be put in place before the new winter season—the windy season—when these closures will continue if we do not implement the new measures?
My hon. Friend is right that the Orwell bridge is another key artery for Ipswich. I know that it is subject to ongoing work by Highways England that requires wind tunnel validation. I have been promised that that work will be completed by the end of September. From the Dispatch Box, I send a clear message to Highways England that I expect to see it on my desk.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Jim McMahon Lab Co-op
Oldham West, Chadderton and Royton
Context
Discusses the economic impact of coronavirus on transport industries, highlighting that frontline workers have kept the country going during difficult times. Expresses concern over the lack of information regarding current rail franchise emergency measures agreements.
Our transport industries have been devastated by coronavirus, but its frontline workers have kept the country going in difficult times. We owe them a debt of gratitude. At the outset of topical questions, with 72 hours to go before the current rail franchise emergency measures agreements are due to expire, I expected the Transport Secretary to update the House. I am afraid my sheet is blank because no such statement, comment or indication followed. That is absolutely staggering. Are we to expect that, rather than something being reported to the House, it will come out over the next couple of days or the weekend, denying the House the opportunity to look into it? Will the Transport Secretary commit to making a statement to the House on Monday?
The hon. Gentleman will know that the first emergency measures were worth some £3.5 billion to ensure that our rail sector was able to continue. I have already described how passengers are now returning to them and the work that is going on to make sure that they are safe to return. As the hon. Gentleman points out, it is the case that the EMAs, as they are called, come to an end quite shortly. I do not think the House would realistically expect me to stand here and carry out those negotiations in public, but I reassure him that I will certainly return to make a statement in the House as soon as there is something to say.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment to make a statement on Monday was not provided
Will Return To Make A Statement
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Jim McMahon Lab Co-op
Oldham West, Chadderton and Royton
Context
Highlights the decrease in passenger numbers due to coronavirus. Expresses concern over planned rail fare increases despite reduced usage and lack of support for the sector.
There are just 72 hours left to go—it is literally last-minute. It is a timetable that would make Northern shy. I do not know what is going on with the Transport Secretary. We know that passenger numbers have fallen to 7% of what they would be in normal times, yet rail fares are set for another increase in January. The average commuter will pay £3,000 for their season ticket, which is over £900 more than they would have paid in 2010. To encourage commuters back safely, will the Government commit to freezing fares and introducing part-time season tickets, as Labour has proposed?
I hate to play politics at the Dispatch Box, but it is worth reminding the hon. Gentleman that, under Labour, there were inflation-busting fare rises that added 4.9% during its time in office. Again, I want to make sure that we are speaking on the basis of facts. I will return to the House on the emergency measures. It is not true to say, as I think the hon. Gentleman did, that the number of passengers is down to a single-digit percentage.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment regarding rail fares was not addressed
Hate To Play Politics Reminds About Past Labour Fare Rises
Response accuracy
Q5 Direct Answer
Context
Concerns over the accessibility of Ruabon station in relation to projected increases in footfall due to new housing and commercial developments. Emphasises the urgent need for step-free access.
Ruabon station in my constituency of Clwyd South is the only station on the Chester to Shrewsbury route that is not compliant with Access for All. Will the Secretary of State meet me to discuss the urgent need for step-free access at Ruabon station, particularly given the projected increase in footfall due to new housing and commercial developments locally?
My hon. Friend makes an important point. The Government are committed to ensuring that our rail network is more accessible. We are in the process of making 16 stations in Wales more accessible as part of our £350-million Access for All programme. My hon. Friend the Rail Minister would be happy to meet him to discuss Ruabon station.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Chris Bryant Lab
Rhondda and Ogmore
Context
The MP noted an increase in illegal advertising hoardings along motorways, contradicting long-standing UK laws prohibiting such advertisements outside towns and cities.
One thing that makes the British countryside unique is that it has been illegal to put up large advertising hoardings since the 1940s. Unfortunately, on my journey back from London last night, I saw 23 such hoardings that have been placed illegally in fields by farmers and others. What is the Government going to do to return the British countryside to its original state without constant advertising along motorways?
No one puts illegal hoardings on land controlled by the Department for Transport or Highways England. Much of this illegal signage is put up on land located next to motorways, so it becomes a planning matter. I will raise these concerns with Housing, Communities and Local Government Ministers.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific actions against illegal hoardings or timeline for addressing the issue
Raising Concerns
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Alicia Kearns Con
Rutland and Stamford
Context
The MP highlighted noise pollution issues caused by speeding vehicles in the Rutland TT race circuit, affecting quiet villages.
My constituents are fed up with speeding vehicles causing noise pollution, especially on the Rutland TT race circuit. Will my right hon. Friend consider running noise camera trials in some of our stunning 160 villages to address this issue?
Trials using noise equipment and automatic number plate recognition software have been carried out. Work is ongoing to compile the results into a report, aiming to address modifications made for noise alone.
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm or deny plans for specific trials in villages mentioned
Ongoing Work Compiling Report
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Wera Hobhouse Lib Dem
Bath
Context
The MP referenced the Secretary of State's previous statement about hydrogen bus towns and hubs, inquiring about specific plans to benefit cities like Bath with steep hills.
Before the summer recess, the Secretary of State mentioned his plans to introduce hydrogen bus towns and hydrogen hubs. Will he update us on these plans, especially for cities such as Bath, which faces challenges with electric buses due to its topography?
We are keen to improve air quality and have invested in car electrification, resulting in more charging locations than petrol stations. 4,000 zero-carbon buses will be coming in, and we will work closely with local authorities like Bath to create clean air zones.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific updates or timelines for hydrogen bus initiatives
Air Quality Improvement Electrification
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Stuart Anderson Con
South Shropshire
Context
The MP requested the Secretary of State's support to reopen the Tettenhall train station for better connectivity in Wolverhampton.
Will the Secretary of State work with me to see that Tettenhall gets the train station it needs, to support the surrounding area and increase connectivity?
The aim of the Restoring Your Railway programme is to reconnect people and communities. I encourage my hon. Friend to contact the programme's team to discuss next steps.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific plan or timeline for reopening Tettenhall station
Reconnecting People Discuss With Program
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Alex Norris Lab Co-op
Nottingham North and Kimberley
Context
The MP noted a previous commitment from the Prime Minister to electrify the entire midland main line, asking if this remains a priority.
Before the general election, the Prime Minister committed to electrifying the entire midland main line. Will the Secretary of State reaffirm that commitment or was it another broken promise?
We are currently delivering the midland main line upgrade, including electrification from London to Kettering. Additional electrification is being examined by Network Rail and will be developed further.
Assessment & feedback
Did not reaffirm full commitment or timeline for future electrification
Current Delivery Examining
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Daniel Zeichner Lab
Cambridge
Context
The MP highlighted the challenges faced by the taxi and private hire sector due to the pandemic, inquiring about an impact assessment.
There are over 360,000 licensed taxi and private hire drivers in England. What assessment has the Secretary of State made of the impact on this sector, and how does he plan to measure the effectiveness of his statutory guidance issued in July?
The statutory taxi and private hire vehicle standards have considerable teeth with national databases for local authorities. We will put work into ensuring that all sign up to these and use them.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a detailed impact assessment or measurement plan
National Databases Sign-Up
Response accuracy
Q12 Direct Answer
Context
The MP raised concerns about taxi drivers having to pay a full £600 fee for permits at Loughborough station despite business declines due to the pandemic.
Many taxi drivers have raised concerns about paying East Midlands Railway a full £600 fee for a permit to ply for hire at Loughborough station. Have there been discussions with rail operators, and if not, is it something you would consider?
Officials from my Department have been in discussions with East Midlands Railway and provided guidance last week to resolve this issue.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13 Direct Answer
Kevin Hollinrake Con
Thirsk and Malton
Context
The MP noted that the electric vehicle charging network in Thirsk and Malton is inadequate, with slow chargers and inconsistent connection types.
I am concerned about the woeful state of electric vehicle charging networks in Thirsk and Malton. Many chargers require sign-up to a membership scheme or specific requirements. What more can we do to prevent the charging network from becoming a deterrent to electric vehicle adoption?
We intend to enforce, particularly on rapid chargers, a system whereby it has to be possible for people to walk up and pay contactlessly for the energy that goes into their car, without signing up to a particular scheme in advance. We have taken powers to enforce this system.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Afzal Khan Lab
Manchester Rusholme
Context
Greater Manchester has been calling for the decriminalisation of moving traffic offences to provide parity across England.
Back in July, the Government committed to decriminalising moving traffic offences. Given that Greater Manchester has called for this change for several years, will you give an update on the timeline for delivering on this commitment?
We intend to extend the powers throughout the country and I will report back to the House shortly.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Context
Thousands of jobs have been lost at easyJet and Airbus, with staff moving to part-time contracts or losing their jobs entirely.
Staff who are losing their jobs in the aviation sector need the promised package of support to avoid more job losses. When will we see this support for the sector?
There has been £1.8 billion of support through the Bank of England's covid corporate financing facility, £283 million from the coronavirus job retention scheme, and over 56,400 staff furloughed with salaries worth well north of £1 billion.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q16 Direct Answer
Context
The Department has yet to publish consultation responses regarding audio-visual announcements on buses, despite a two-year wait.
Passengers have been waiting for over two years since the Department's consultation on audio-visual announcements on buses. When will passengers finally get these benefits? Will you agree to meet me and the all-party group?
During my time as Secretary of State, I have put several million pounds into precisely this issue of audio-visual on buses. I will certainly write to her with the details, and I will also arrange for her to meet the buses Minister.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Context
The A64 Hopgrove roundabout is a vital upgrade for constituents and those from West Yorkshire.
This Conservative Government are investing in the Highways England strategic road network. The A64 Hopgrove roundabout upgrade is essential not only to my constituents but also to people from West Yorkshire and beyond who suffer in queues. Will you give me an indication that this project is still in the programme and of when we are likely to see spades in the ground?
My right hon. Friend is right about the £27.4 billion we are investing in the road investment strategy 2 programme to upgrade and build roads fit for the 21st century. There was very effective lobbying on the roundabout, and I will certainly come back to him in writing to provide more of an update.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Tan Dhesi Lab
Slough
Context
The question was prompted by two major rail incidents: the Stonehaven tragedy that caused fatalities, and environmental damage from the Llangennech derailment. These events highlight ongoing concerns about rail safety.
I know that you, Mr Speaker, the Secretary of State and the whole House will share my grief about the fatal Stonehaven tragedy and the environmental damage wrought by the Llangennech derailment. Given these incidents, I ask when the Secretary of State will make a full statement to this House outlining the future of rail, especially regarding HS2 contracts going to UK suppliers.
The hon. Gentleman is right about Stonehaven, where I went to the scene and saw the damage. The interim report on Stonehaven was issued a week or two back with important conclusions, and I will update the House further shortly. Negotiations are ongoing with nine operating companies regarding the emergency measures agreements (EMA), but these cannot be conducted in public due to their sensitive nature. The EMAs will come to an end shortly, and I will return to the House to update it on what is happening precisely, while noting our commitment to rail investment of £3.5 billion so far.
Assessment & feedback
Percentage of HS2 contracts going to UK suppliers
I Will Return To The House In Due Course I Would Disbelieve Everything That You Read In The Newspapers
Response accuracy