Topical Questions 2021-01-26

2021-01-26

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Context
The question follows a series of economic measures taken by the government during the pandemic, including the furlough scheme and tax deferrals.
If he will make a statement on his departmental responsibilities. Given the range of measures worth more than £280 billion to support jobs and businesses through the crisis, can the Chancellor provide further details on these initiatives?
Throughout this crisis, our overriding economic priority has been to support people's jobs and businesses through a range of measures worth more than £280 billion, including the furlough scheme, tax cuts, tax deferrals, loans and grants. There will be a Budget on 3 March, when we will set out the next steps in our economic response to coronavirus.
Assessment & feedback
The Chancellor did not provide specific details about his departmental responsibilities but mentioned an upcoming Budget statement.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Context
A detailed and costed policy proposal for a targeted income grant scheme has been submitted to the Treasury, aimed at providing financial support to those locked out of current schemes.
Last week the Chancellor received a detailed and costed policy proposal for a targeted income grant scheme, written by Rebecca Seeley Harris and supported by the gaps in support all-party parliamentary group. That scheme would be a vital first step in giving meaningful financial support to many of the millions who have been locked out of the current schemes and who are desperate, after nearly a year of the covid pandemic. Can the Chancellor tell us today whether he plans to progress with that proposal, or does he have another scheme in mind for the millions in need of support?
I am happy to tell the hon. Lady that my right hon. Friend the Financial Secretary to the Treasury met the authors of the report back in December and is considering it alongside all the other submissions that we receive at the Treasury.
Assessment & feedback
The Chancellor did not confirm progress with the proposal but indicated ongoing consideration.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Context
The UK aims to attract more investment and encourage job creation through private sector initiatives.
What will my right hon. Friend do to make the UK a more attractive destination for investment and capital formation, to encourage the jobs and opportunities of the future that people rely on the private sector to provide?
My hon. Friend is right about needing the private sector to drive growth and create jobs. I am pleased to tell him that the Prime Minister and I chaired the first meeting of the Build Back Better Business Council, where we outlined our plans to invest in infrastructure, innovation and skills alongside businesses. We have also established a new Office for Investment, led by Lord Grimstone, which is charged with securing high-value investment opportunities, and I look forward to hearing from him ideas that we can productively take forward.
Assessment & feedback
The Chancellor did not provide specific measures but mentioned existing initiatives.
Working On This
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Anneliese Dodds Lab Co-op
Oxford East
Context
The Treasury has been involved in debates with the Department for Work and Pensions about financial support measures.
In recent days, the Treasury has been at loggerheads with the Department for Work and Pensions, insisting on taking £20 a week from the pockets of 6 million families. It has also been at loggerheads with the Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies, by claiming that financial hardship is not inhibiting self-isolation. Why is the Treasury putting our economic and health recovery at risk in this way?
The hon. Lady should not believe everything she reads in the newspapers. The Treasury and this Government have put in place a comprehensive and generous set of support to help people get through this crisis, and the results show that we have protected those on the lowest incomes the most.
Assessment & feedback
The Chancellor did not address the specific concerns raised about reductions in support.
Not Addressing Issue
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Anneliese Dodds Lab Co-op
Oxford East
Context
The Kickstart Scheme aims to provide employment opportunities for young people, but there are concerns about its effectiveness.
I was actually following the words of the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions and of SAGE, but I appreciate the Chancellor's response. The kickstart scheme was much heralded, but yesterday we learned that it appears to be missing out around 99 of every 100 young jobseekers. What does the Chancellor say to them today?
I am not entirely sure I know the figures that the hon. Lady is referring to. What I can say is that, since this scheme was announced at the beginning of July and opened for applications in September, it has created over 120,000 jobs for young people. That is, I think, an extraordinary achievement. I pay tribute to the team at the DWP for doing that. I am grateful to the thousands of businesses that are taking part in the scheme. They are working with us to provide hope and opportunity to a generation of young people so that they are not scarred by coronavirus, but can look forward to a brighter future.
Assessment & feedback
The Chancellor did not address the figures cited by the questioner about scheme effectiveness.
Not Addressing Issue
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Context
The Chancellor is expected to announce an early extension of support packages amidst ongoing restrictions.
With the lockdown or some form of restrictions set to continue well into the spring, will the Chancellor please give some certainty to those businesses and individuals struggling financially by announcing an early extension to his various support packages, including help with VAT, business rates and stamp duty, the self-employment scheme and, of course, the universal credit uplift?
My hon. Friend will I hope appreciate that the various things he just mentioned total about, I think, £20 billion or £30 billion, so he will understand it is reasonable that we consider all these things in the round at Budget, when we will set out the next stage in our economic response to coronavirus.
Assessment & feedback
The Chancellor did not commit to an early extension but mentioned considering measures at the Budget.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Meg Hillier Lab Co-op
Hackney South and Shoreditch
Context
The Office for Budget Responsibility estimates potential revenue losses from customs income and VAT, raising concerns about government finances.
The Office for Budget Responsibility estimates that HMRC will forgo around £800 million in customs income and VAT over the next year. Some is deferred, but much is forgone. Will the Chancellor tell us what he is doing to make sure that that number shrinks and that revenue comes in at a time when the Exchequer needs it really very badly?
I will have to go and check the exact figures, if the hon. Lady will forgive me for not knowing the specific paragraph that she refers to. In general HMRC is providing easements over the next few months as we transition to a new set of trading relationships, but she can rest assured that we are always mindful of the impact on revenue and intend fully—very much so—to have a robust set of mechanisms in place. As she will know, there is a phased response for getting to that point between now and July, and hopefully we can work with her to make sure that that path is as seamless as possible.
Assessment & feedback
The Chancellor did not provide specific measures but indicated awareness of the issue.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Context
Concerns have been raised about capital gains tax rates and their impact on revenue, prompting a question about the Chancellor's intentions.
The Chancellor has been widely praised for his work in recent months, but he has also been honest about difficult decisions ahead. I have had constituents raise concerns with me about capital gains tax. He will know that the current rates were set to optimise revenue from the tax. I know he cannot comment on individual measures, but can I seek his assurance that he will not take any steps to raise taxes without doing a proper assessment of the Laffer curve principle that higher rates do not always lead to higher revenues?
I thank my right hon. Friend for his question, which tempts me into indiscretion. He may be aware of this, but HMRC publishes annual estimates to illustrate the impact of changes in tax rates in a document sexily entitled “Direct effects of illustrative tax changes”. It is worth saying, however, that these estimates are themselves uncertain, because of different levels of behavioural response to tax changes, the potential for wider macroeconomic impacts and, of course, the interaction with other measures.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide an assurance but mentioned existing assessment methods.
Not Addressing Issue
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
46% of pubs have not received local restrictions support grants for November, and 74% have yet to receive the £1,000 Christmas bonus.
The pubs and hospitality sector has done everything asked during the pandemic. However, so far 46% of pubs have not received local restrictions support grants for November, let alone December, and 74% of pubs have yet to receive the Prime Minister's Christmas bonus of £1,000. What will Ministers be doing to speed up these payments?
It is absolutely right that businesses get the funds as quickly as possible. Central Government have disbursed that funding to local councils across the country, so it is actually for businesses to take up with their local authority why they have not received the money. There are two sets of grants: there are monthly grants and one-off payments of up to £9,000.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about speeding up payments was not addressed directly
Local Authorities Will Handle This
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Matt Vickers Con
Stockton West
Context
Teesside is seen as having untapped potential and ambition, with a focus on economic success.
Teesside is a place with untapped potential, skills and expertise, and boundless ambition that will play host to the biggest economic success story of the next decade. Can my right hon. Friend think of anywhere better to host Treasury North than one of the country's first free ports?
I thank my hon. Friend for his question. He is a doughty champion for his region and he should know that we remain focused on the commitment we made at Budget 2020 to have 750 roles across the economic campus by the end of the Parliament. The Treasury is still considering a range of location options for the new campus.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about Teesside was not addressed directly
Range Of Location Options Are Being Considered
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Lilian Greenwood Lab
Nottingham South
Context
The Government claim their central economic mission is to level up, but the questioner wants assurance on HS2's eastern leg.
The Government claim that their central economic mission is to level up. Can the Chancellor assure me that his Government will deliver HS2 in full, including the whole of the eastern leg?
The hon. Lady is right to draw attention to the commitment the Government have made to infrastructure, including in the forthcoming integration infrastructure plan, but the levelling up is not just about rail; it is also about the £4 billion levelling up fund and, most importantly, about the review of the Green Book.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about HS2 was not addressed directly
Levelling Up Agenda Includes More Than Rail
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Context
Wrexham's brewing industry supports nearly 1,700 jobs and generates £11 million in taxes. The UK Government's furlough scheme has been a lifeline but the future remains bleak.
Will my right hon. Friend the Chancellor in his forthcoming Budget consider deferring business rates and VAT payments even further?
The Government understand that this is a very challenging time for the UK hospitality sector, and we are constantly reviewing the package of covid-19 support. In order to ensure that decisions are made to meet these challenges, we will outline plans for 2021-22 business rates relief early this year.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about VAT deferment was not addressed directly
Plans For 2021-22 Business Rates Relief
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
Paid leave following a bereavement is entirely at the discretion of employers, costing the UK economy £22 billion annually.
In his upcoming Budget what consideration will the Chancellor give to statutory paid bereavement leave for all workers who lose a close family member?
I am happy to look at the specific question the hon. Lady raises, but she will know that in the last Budget we introduced a manifesto commitment to bring in neonatal leave.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about bereavement leave was not addressed directly
Look At The Question
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Context
Suppliers to the hospitality sector have seen dramatic falls in sales.
Is there any additional support he can provide at this particularly challenging time?
My hon. Friend raises a point mentioned by several Members about the difficulties businesses in the hospitality sector and their supply chain have faced during the pandemic. £1.6 billion is being made available for local authorities to support businesses that are ineligible for closed business grants but that may still be impacted by restrictions.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about additional support was not addressed directly
£1.6 Billion Being Made Available
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Context
Some small businesses in the constituency cannot access support they need.
Will the Minister fix that flaw in the system and commit to help small businesses today?
The hon. Gentleman can write to me with the specific issue he has with the guidance, but in general the grants have been functioning well and local authorities are getting them out to businesses.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about fixing a flaw was not addressed directly
Write For Specific Issue
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Context
The MP noted the importance of temporary VAT reductions provided during the pandemic to support businesses in Blackpool. He highlighted the impact on job preservation.
I am concerned about the reopening of the hospitality and tourism industries later this year, will he commit to extending the reduction in VAT for these sectors to help maintain thousands of jobs in my constituency?
The temporary reduced rate of VAT was introduced to support over 150,000 businesses and protect 2.4 million jobs in the hospitality and tourism sectors; it has been extended until March this year but no further plans exist due to significant costs involved.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to extending VAT reduction beyond current timeframe
But The Relief Comes At A Significant Cost We Have No Current Plans To Extend It Further
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Context
The MP inquired about the possibility of reintroducing or modifying the Eat Out to Help Out scheme post-lockdown, noting its critical role during previous easing phases.
Will my hon. Friend assure me that his Department will carefully consider reinstating the Eat Out to Help Out scheme or something similar once we come out of lockdown?
The Chancellor will be coming forward with an update on measures for post-lockdown recovery at the upcoming Budget, where they will carefully examine what is needed.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment or timeline regarding reinstatement of scheme
We Will Continue To Examine Very Carefully The Chancellor Has Indicated That He Will Be Coming Forward At The Budget
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Context
The MP asked about incentives to attract new businesses to the UK post-Brexit and retain existing ones amid global trade challenges.
Given the imperative of forging new trade deals worldwide, what incentives are being considered by the Treasury to both attract new companies to the UK and retain those that are already here?
The Office for Investment, led by Lord Grimstone, is focused on attracting new companies and retaining existing ones; they work with the Build Back Better Business Council.
Assessment & feedback
Specific incentives or timeline
Focused On Exactly That Issue Working In Tandem
Response accuracy