Topical Questions 2021-02-22

2021-02-22

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Direct Answer
Sarah Olney Lib Dem
Richmond Park
Context
The question concerns the relocation of MHCLG headquarters to Wolverhampton and its implications.
On Saturday, I was delighted to announce that the Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government will be opening a new dual headquarters in the great city of Wolverhampton. Can the Secretary of State tell me about this decision?
On Saturday, I was delighted to announce that the Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government will be opening a new dual headquarters in the great city of Wolverhampton, taking Ministers, senior civil servants and decision makers to the west midlands. We are leading efforts to level up all parts of the country, so it is only right that MHCLG brings decision makers to the communities that we seek to serve. This is about more than just the hundreds of jobs that we will bring to the region, with 800 MHCLG staff outside London by 2030—it is about pride, prestige, proximity to power, ensuring that more local voices are reflected in the creation of Government policy and playing our part in raising the stature of smaller cities such as Wolverhampton.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Sarah Olney Lib Dem
Richmond Park
Context
The question concerns the impact of ending protections for renters and asks about provisions to assist those affected.
Can the Secretary of State tell me what projections have been made of the impact on homelessness of the ending of the protection for renters at the end of next month? What provision will be made to assist local authorities in supporting those who find themselves evicted?
My right hon Friend the Lord Chancellor and I are working to consider what further steps are necessary. We will hear in a few moments' time the Prime Minister's statement, which will set out the road map for the reopening of our economy, but it is important that we keep in place measures that protect the most vulnerable in society, including those who are renting. That is exactly what we have done since the beginning of the pandemic, and I intend to keep doing so for as long as is necessary.
Assessment & feedback
Specific projections or provisions were not provided.
Working To Consider
Response accuracy
Q3 Direct Answer
Context
The question concerns the closure of multiple banks and cash machines in Prestatyn.
With Prestatyn facing the imminent closure of TSB, Barclays and HSBC, and following on from the loss of NatWest and the Royal Bank of Scotland in recent years, the town's high street will be left without a single bank or cash machine. Can my right hon Friend outline what conversations he is holding with major banks to ensure an adequate and fair distribution of banking facilities in high streets across the UK?
My hon. Friend raises an important point. We went into the pandemic as one of the leading countries in the world in terms of having a cashless society. The chief executive of the Royal Mint, based in Llantrisant in Wales, has suggested recently that coin use may have dropped by as much as a fifth over the course of the pandemic, and much of that will not be restored afterwards, so it is important that we protect access to cash for the most vulnerable in society, including those in smaller towns, villages and rural areas. My right hon Friend the Chancellor has committed to doing just that and ensuring that the infrastructure that supports cash is sustainable in the long term, including proposals that would see cashback offered at shops without consumers having to make a purchase.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Context
The question concerns the Resolution Foundation's findings and the government's decision to freeze local housing allowance.
The Resolution Foundation has found that 450,000 households have fallen into rent arrears since last January due to the covid pandemic. Does the Secretary of State think the Government's decision to freeze local housing allowance will improve that situation or make it worse? What objections has he raised in Cabinet about this freeze?
I am proud of the response that this Government have made to the pandemic. At every turn, we have tried to protect the most vulnerable people in society. My Department has protected renters through bringing forward the moratorium on evictions. We raised the local housing allowance to the 30th percentile, ensuring that there is more support for those people who need it.
Assessment & feedback
Specific objections and impacts not provided.
Pride In Response
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Context
The question concerns the status of East Yorkshire devolution negotiations and Hull and East Riding of Yorkshire Council's proposal.
Hull and East Riding of Yorkshire Council submitted their bid for East Yorkshire devolution some months ago. That included a request for full allocation for the Goole town deal bid, but I digress. Can the Minister tell me where we are with regard to opening up negotiations with Hull and East Riding of Yorkshire Council, to get East Yorkshire devolution moving forwards?
We have a clear commitment to give more power to local communities, providing opportunity across the country. We want to build on the more than 50% of the north now covered by our devolution deals, with a new deal in West Yorkshire signed in Parliament just last month. We welcomed the devolution proposal from Hull and East Yorkshire, and my Department will respond shortly, with a view to further formal engagement with councils following the local government elections.
Assessment & feedback
Specific status not provided.
Commitment To Local Power
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Context
Leaseholders are footing the bill for dangerous cladding despite property developers making significant profits. Developers have donated £2.5 million to the Conservative party since 2017.
Last week, The Sunday Times revealed that property developers who built flats covered in dangerous cladding have donated £2.5 million to the Conservative party since 2017. This comes after they made £15 billion in profit since Grenfell Tower disaster and during the pandemic due to stamp duty holiday market boom. Why are leaseholders still paying for building safety crisis?
We will bring forward levies and taxes on property development industry. We believe in polluter pays principle but will wait for Chancellor's announcement to determine scale of levies. Many buildings were built under Labour government who did nothing; we are clearing up mess with new building safety regime.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment on how leaseholders will stop footing bill without waiting for further announcements
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Context
UK Government's £3.6 billion towns fund is a good initiative but question about full Barnett consequential being passed to Welsh Government.
Time and again, constituents worry about town centre state. UK's £3.6 billion towns fund in England is fantastic. Could my right hon. Friend confirm that full Barnett consequential from this has been passed to the Welsh Government for Cardiff bay priority?
£3.6 billion towns fund is being delivered in England successfully. Nothing prevents Welsh Gov from investing similarly but they received additional £1.3 billion next year through Barnett formula and £12 million changes in settlement. Encourage holding Welsh Government accountable.
Assessment & feedback
Question about full funding confirmation to Wales
Nothing Prevents Welsh Gov From Investing Similarly
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Wes Streeting Lab
Ilford North
Context
Strong message received from businesses in Ilford town centre about action on business rates needed to help high street businesses.
Message from businesses is that action on business rates is needed. Can Secretary of State have word with Chancellor to ensure support for shops remaining open when people return?
Does not need reminding as he was the Chancellor who gave business rates holiday supporting hundreds of thousands of businesses. Wait till Budget next week where Chancellor will set out continued support for businesses and jobs UK wide.
Assessment & feedback
Specific ask about having a word with Chancellor
Wait Till Budget Next Week
Response accuracy
Q9 Direct Answer
Context
Stating concerns over Mayor of London spending thousands on committee to take down statues and rename streets instead of focusing on crime, council tax precept, affordable homes.
Will Secretary of State condemn Mayor of London decision to spend thousands on taking down statues and renaming streets? Is this reason for voting Conservative Mayor?
Agree wholeheartedly with right hon. Friend. Priorities should focus on crime, council tax precept, affordable homes rather than statues and street names.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Context
Concern about Prime Minister calling devolution settlement a 'disaster' and 'mistake'. Suggests real reason for ripping up settlement is PM's dislike of Scotland's Parliament.
Prime Minister called devolution settlement a disaster mistake. Is this loathing of Scottish Parliament the real reason why Government are ripping it up, grabbing back powers and imposing shared prosperity fund bypassing elected Members?
Elected to level up UK including Scotland. Shared prosperity fund ensures more funding goes to communities than EU. Strange aversion to localism and giving councillors say over areas in Scotland.
Assessment & feedback
Question about Prime Minister's loathing of Scottish Parliament
Strange Aversion To Localism
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
Wants to work with East Devon District Council to help Exmouth stay a great place to live and work. Asks for update on next round of funding.
Since elected, have spoken up for Exmouth in Parliament and secured support for hospitality industry, airport and Chiefs. Want to work with council for town's future. Could Secretary of State provide update on next round of regeneration funding?
Visited East Devon during election campaign. Exmouth is type of town we want to benefit from funds. Levelling-up fund and shared prosperity fund will build future high streets and towns fund. Prospectuses for these will be published soon.
Assessment & feedback
Next round of regeneration funding update
Prospectuses For These Will Be Published Soon
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Daniel Zeichner Lab
Cambridge
Context
The UK Census is due shortly, but with Cambridge facing significant challenges from the ongoing pandemic and reduced population mobility.
Census 2021 is due in just a few weeks' time, at a time when cities such as Cambridge would normally be packed with students, researchers and visitors. In the middle of a pandemic, does the Secretary of State really think we will get accurate figures? Remember that these figures are going to be used for the next 10 years.
Of course, we are working closely with the Cabinet Office on the delivery of the elections and the census. We have provided extra funds to make sure they can be delivered safely, and we have published guidance alongside that as well. We have also committed, for the coming year, £11 billion directly to councils since the start of the pandemic, of which Cambridge City Council has so far received more than £5.4 million.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address potential inaccuracies in Census data due to reduced population mobility
Provided Funds For Delivery
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
The UK government has announced leasehold reform legislation which is expected to bring significant changes. However, concerns have been raised about the provisions not applying uniformly across different regions.
I welcome the upcoming leasehold reform legislation, but I do worry that the provisions may not apply for the benefit of my constituents in Delyn and across Wales. Will my right hon. Friend tell us what discussions he has had with the Welsh Government to assist them in ensuring that my constituents are not left behind by Labour once again?
My hon. Friend is right to welcome the landmark reforms that we announced earlier in the year, which will be the biggest changes to English property law for over 40 years. Of course, I would like to see them apply in Wales as well, and we have had conversations with colleagues in the Welsh Government.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specifics on discussions or commitment to extend reforms to Wales
Welcoming Landmark Reforms
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Mohammad Yasin Lab
Bedford
Context
The demand for home adaptations due to aging population, disabilities, dementia, and long-term effects of COVID-19 is increasing. Bedford Borough Council faces significant challenges in meeting this need.
Given the scale of need for help with home adaptations for the rising number of older people with disabilities, dementia and now the impacts of long covid, will the Secretary of State commit to increasing disabled facilities grant funding so that local authorities like Bedford Borough Council can stand a chance of meeting local need?
The hon. Gentleman raises an important point, and we are actively considering it. We have responded to a consultation on how we can improve access to public buildings and to homes for disabled people, and if there is more we can do, we should do it.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to increasing Disabled Facilities Grant funding
Actively Considering Consultation Response
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Context
With the summer approaching, North Devon faces significant pressures to finance and maintain facilities such as car parks, toilets, waste bins, and dog bins.
I thank my right hon. Friend for the support given to councils over the past 12 months, but as we move into what will hopefully be a busy summer for tourism in areas such as North Devon, based on the experience of last summer, some smaller district and parish councils that operate car parks, toilets, and waste and dog bin collections struggle to finance and maintain them effectively to the understandably higher standards that are needed, so can he advise what support is being given to ensure that councils with tourism hotspots are prepared for the likely influx of visitors this summer?
I thank my hon. Friend for her question. We are hugely grateful to parish and town councils, which have been on the frontline in responding to this pandemic. That is why the Secretary of State wrote to them earlier this year to encourage principal councils to work with them to discuss funding. Councils in Devon will receive a further £31 million in un-ringfenced covid funding next year, which will help to ensure that their facilities are maintained and ready for the summer.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify additional operational support beyond financial aid
Encouraged Discussions Covid Funding
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Matt Western Lab
Warwick and Leamington
Context
Local authorities in Warwickshire have spent substantial sums on reports regarding local government reform, raising questions about the use of public funds.
Considering local government reform, the five boroughs and districts of Warwickshire have spent over £100,000 on a report by Deloitte, and I understand that Warwickshire County Council has spent over £50,000 with PricewaterhouseCoopers. Deloitte found that it would be favourable for one sort of authority, while PricewaterhouseCoopers decided that county councils should remain as is. Is that a good use of public money?
Those individual decisions are decisions for local authorities. I can certainly inform the hon. Gentleman that Warwick has received over £3.7 million this year in covid funding, and is receiving a 4.8% real-terms rise in core spending power this current financial year.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address expenditure on reports or cost-effectiveness of reform analysis
Local Authority Decisions Covid Funding
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Paul Holmes Con
Hamble Valley
Context
Lib Dem Eastleigh Borough Council is planning to develop a significant number of houses in Horton Heath. Concerns have been raised about the council acting as both developer and planning authority while seemingly ignoring statutory bodies such as the Environment Agency.
The Minister will be aware of plans by Lib Dem Eastleigh Borough Council to build and develop 2,500 houses in the village of Horton Heath. I know that the Minister cannot comment on specific planning applications, but what general advice can he give my constituents, who are concerned about the council acting as both the developer and the planning authority while seemingly ignoring statutory bodies such as the Environment Agency?
I am aware of my hon. Friend's concerns regarding the new development at Horton Heath. As he says, I cannot comment on individual planning cases, but he is right that where a local council acts as the developer and master planner of a particular site it is incumbent upon it to ensure that it takes account of the views of statutory consultees such as the Environment Agency, of the local community and, indeed, of strong local Members of Parliament like him.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific advice or action beyond acknowledging concerns
Cannot Comment On Individual Cases Incumbent Upon Council
Response accuracy