Context
Dr Hudson references a local school policy restricting mobile phones and criticizes the Government's refusal to implement a national ban despite evidence from UNESCO, OECD, and the Children’s Commissioner. He mentions that young people support such policies.
Question
Many of the young people I meet in schools across Epping Forest are clear that they agree with the local school policy of restricting mobile phones when they are at school. Sadly, however, the Government have repeatedly refused to heed Conservative calls to protect our children with a national ban on phones in schools—even voting against it. Bodies such as UNESCO and the OECD are crystal clear about the negative impacts of phones on young people’s education, so when will the Government listen to the evidence and to our school leaders, and support a ban on smartphones in schools for the sake of our young people’s education and mental health?
Answer from The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Education (Stephen Morgan)
I have said that phones should not be out in schools, and heads have the power to enforce that. The Opposition backed those measures. If they felt they needed to go further, they had 14 long years in which to do so.
Not addressed: The specific request for a national ban on smartphones was not addressed; instead, the Minister referenced past government actions and questioned the Opposition's position.
How: Changing Subject, Questioning Opponent
Was this summary accurate? Tell us
How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)