Commons Sense

House of Commons · PMQs

PMQs

Wednesday 9 October 2024 · 28 questions

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Answered 2 Partly answered 16 Not answered 0

Key points

  • Prime Minister's Questions took place on 2024-10-09.
  • The Prime Minister criticized the previous Government's promises regarding NHS improvements and employment law.
  • MPs from various parties inquired about NHS services, employment rights, tax promises, and international relations.

Topics (select to filter)

Questions & Answers

Q1 Gagan Mohindra Con South West Hertfordshire
NHS
Context

The Prime Minister previously committed £400 million for a new hospital in South West Hertfordshire.

Question

The commitment of £400 million for a new hospital at Watford General was one of the many brilliant things that the last Conservative Government did, along with my good friend Dean Russell, the former Member of Parliament for Watford. It would have been life-changing as well as lifesaving for so many of my constituents. Why is the Prime Minister cancelling that funding commitment, and spending billions of pounds on giving pay rises to train drivers instead?

Answer from Keir Starmer

Because the promise of 40 new hospitals did not involve 40 and did not involve hospitals, they were not new, and they were not funded.

Not addressed: The specific cancellation of hospital funding commitment

How: Changed Subject

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q2 Sarah Coombes Lab West Bromwich
NHS
Context

The GP satisfaction rate in the constituency is below national average.

Question

One of the biggest issues in my constituency is poor access to GP services. Our GP satisfaction rate is 15% below the national average. I thank the Government for their focus on improving the situation. What are they doing to ensure that everyone in West Bromwich can actually see their GP?

Answer from Keir Starmer

The most visible sign of the failure of the last Government was the NHS. We are going to expand the role of community pharmacies and accelerate the roll-out of independent prescribers. We need much more care to be delivered in local communities so that problems can be spotted earlier, and we will train thousands more GPs.

Partly answered

Not addressed: Specific measures for West Bromwich

How: Broad Statements

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q3 Rishi Sunak Con Richmond and Northallerton
Context

The Government will publish employment law changes.

Question

Tomorrow, the Government will publish their anticipated changes to employment law. Given the weekend's events, when did the Prime Minister first become a convert to fire and rehire?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I am very pleased and proud that tomorrow we will publish the Bill that will mean the biggest upgrade of workers' rights in a generation. That will do two things: first it will give people basic dignity at work, and secondly it will help to grow our economy—something on which the last Government absolutely failed for 14 long years.

Not addressed: Support for fire and rehire practices

How: Changed Subject

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q4 Rishi Sunak Con Richmond and Northallerton
Context

The Prime Minister promised not to raise taxes.

Question

When the Prime Minister talks about security at work, once again it is one rule for him and another rule for everyone else. I know that not everything or everyone has survived his first 100 days in government, so can he confirm that when he promised not to raise income tax, national insurance or VAT, that commitment applies to both employer and employee national insurance contributions?

Answer from Keir Starmer

As the right hon. Gentleman well knows, I am not going to get drawn on decisions that will be set out. We made an absolute commitment to not raise tax on working people.

Not addressed: Specifics of tax promise applicability

How: Changed Subject

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q5 Rishi Sunak Con Richmond and Northallerton
Context

The Prime Minister promised not to raise taxes.

Question

I don't think that even Lord Alli is buying any of that nonsense. I am not asking about the Budget; I am asking specifically about the promise that the Prime Minister made to the British people. So let me ask him again just to clarify his own promise: does his commitment not to raise national insurance apply to both employee and employer national insurance contributions?

Answer from Keir Starmer

We set out our promises in our manifesto. We were returned with a huge majority to change the country for the better, and I stick to my promises in the manifesto.

Not addressed: Specifics of tax promise applicability

How: Changed Subject

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q6 Rishi Sunak Con Richmond and Northallerton
Context

The Chancellor previously said changing the debt target would be fiddling figures.

Question

I am very happy to welcome investments that my Government negotiated, but when it comes to the Prime Minister's answer on tax, businesses across the country would have found his answer just about as reassuring as Sue Gray found it when he promised to protect her job. It is no wonder that confidence is plummeting on his watch, which he did not mention. Turning to another commitment, before the election his Chancellor said that changing the debt target in the fiscal rules would be tantamount to “fiddling the figures”. Does he still agree with the Chancellor?

Answer from Keir Starmer

The right hon. Gentleman is literally the man who was in charge of the economy. Over 14 years, the Conservatives crashed the economy.

Not addressed: Agreement with Chancellor's statement on fiscal rules

How: Changed Subject

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q7 Rishi Sunak Con Richmond and Northallerton
Context

The previous Government left the lowest debt in the G7.

Question

On debt, we left the Government the second lowest debt in the G7. As the Institute for Fiscal Studies has said—[Interruption.]

Answer from Keir Starmer

I see the right hon. Gentleman is back to his old script of, “They've never had it so good.” It did not work so well at the election, so it might be time to change that.

Not addressed: National debt situation inherited from previous government

How: Changed Subject

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q8 Rishi Sunak Con Richmond and Northallerton
Context

The Prime Minister is facing criticism for potential economic policies and a recent warning from MI5 about evolving threats.

Question

It is clear that the Prime Minister has opened the door to raising employer national insurance contributions, including on pensions. Economic confidence is plummeting, growth is stalling, and borrowing costs are rising. Can he confirm that the terrorism Bill will give security services the powers they need? I can assure him of our constructive support.

Answer from Keir Starmer

I can confirm that we will give the security forces and services the powers that they need. But it is a shame the Opposition cannot celebrate Britain's success under this Government, as investment pours in, NHS strikes end, houses are being built, and workers' rights are upgraded.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The specific ask about confirming terrorism Bill powers was not addressed directly; instead, general statements were made about the government's success.

How: Under Review, Success Under This Government

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q9 Adam Jogee Lab Newcastle-under-Lyme
NHS
Context

The MP's father is receiving cancer treatment, highlighting the need for better cancer diagnosis and treatment.

Question

Will the Prime Minister commit to improving cancer research, early diagnosis, and patient care? Will he join me in thanking NHS staff who look after thousands of cancer patients like my dad?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I am sorry about the MP's father. Cancer standards have not been met since 2015; we announced a £6.4 million AI software network for early cancer identification, improving diagnosis and treatment.

Answered
Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q10 Edward Davey Lib Dem Kingston and Surbiton
Context

The MP is concerned about missed opportunities for a better trade deal with the EU, specifically regarding a youth mobility scheme.

Question

Will the Prime Minister reconsider negotiating a youth mobility scheme with European partners to improve relationships and benefit young people, businesses, and re-establishment of ties?

Answer from Keir Starmer

We need a better deal than the bad one under the last Government; I met with President of the Commission to discuss improvements. Our manifesto had red lines about single market, customs union, and freedom of movement.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The specific ask about reconsidering the youth mobility scheme was not directly addressed.

How: Under Review

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q11 Edward Davey Lib Dem Kingston and Surbiton
Context

Fishermen in the Falklands are facing high tariffs to sell produce in Europe, leading to potential sailing under a Spanish flag.

Question

When renegotiating trade deals, will the Prime Minister ensure that British citizens fishing off the Falklands can sail proudly under the Union Jack?

Answer from Keir Starmer

The sovereignty of the Falklands and Gibraltar is not to be negotiated. We will do everything possible for businesses to trade more freely but remain clear on the Falklands' British status.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The specific ask about ensuring UK flag was not directly addressed; instead, general statements were made.

How: Sovereignty

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Context

Derbyshire county council is proposing cuts to adult social care, affecting those with dementia and their families.

Question

Will the Prime Minister ask Conservatives on Derbyshire county council to think again about devastating cuts to older people's services?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I am shocked by the proposed cutbacks. Councils are suffering due to last Government's economic failure; we will provide multi-year funding settlements for better planning, working with local leaders.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The specific ask about reconsidering cuts was not directly addressed; instead, general statements were made about future support.

How: Last Government'S Economic Failure

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q13 Jim Allister TUV North Antrim
Context

The Windsor framework led to more than 300 areas of law being made in a foreign Parliament, affecting the equality and citizenship rights of constituents.

Question

Does the Prime Minister have any sense of unease that there are more than 300 areas of law in Northern Ireland in which legislation is made in a foreign Parliament? Has he any ambition to recover UK sovereignty over those laws?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I thank the hon. Gentleman for raising that important issue. The Windsor framework was negotiated by the last Government. We supported it, and we continue to support it. We will work to make sure it is implemented properly and fully.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The specific ask about recovering UK sovereignty over laws was not directly addressed.

How: We Supported The Windsor Framework, We Continue To Support It

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q14 Meg Hillier Labour (Co-op)
Context

The constituency has a high rate of child poverty after housing costs. Child poverty increased by 700,000 since 2010.

Question

When does the Prime Minister expect the child poverty taskforce to report so that we can see action?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I thank my hon. Friend for her important question. It is appalling that child poverty has gone up by 700,000 since 2010, after the last Labour Government did so much to bring it down. Tackling this is at the heart of our mission to break down the barriers to opportunity. The taskforce is developing a strategy to reduce child poverty, and it will be published in the spring of next year.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The specific timeline for action was not provided, only that the report would be published.

How: Tackling This Is At The Heart Of Our Mission

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q15 Shivani Raja Con Leicester East
Context

The imposition of VAT on independent schools affects families' ability to choose the best education for their children, risking job losses and resource constraints.

Question

What action is he taking to mitigate these impending threats if he is not undertaking an impact assessment to understand them?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I do understand that many parents across the country save hard to be able to send their children to private school because they have aspiration for their children, but so does every parent who sends their children to a state school. The problem is that we do not have enough teachers in key subjects in our state secondary schools. The Conservative party may be prepared to tolerate that, but I am not. That is why we have made this change to fund 6,500 teachers.

Not addressed: The specific ask about mitigating threats without an impact assessment was not addressed.

How: We Have Made This Change To Fund 6,500 Teachers

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q16 Alex McIntyre Lab Gloucester
Context

Almost 10% of Gloucester households are home to a veteran. The Prime Minister promised to ensure every veteran in Gloucester has a roof over their head.

Question

Can the Prime Minister update the House on what this Government are doing to support veterans, especially meeting his promise for every veteran to have a roof over their head?

Answer from Keir Starmer

We owe an enormous debt to all our veterans. It was a great honour to announce at our party conference that our plans to build new homes across the country will ensure that homeless veterans are at the front of the queue for new social housing, recognising their incredible sacrifice and contribution.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The specific ask about confirming promises was not directly addressed.

How: We Owe An Enormous Debt To All Our Veterans

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q17 Julian Smith Con Skipton and Ripon
Context

Special educational needs budgets are under pressure, affecting provision for children with special needs.

Question

Will the Prime Minister and Chancellor look carefully at how increased funding and changes to the funding formula could make a massive difference?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I am grateful to the right hon. Member for raising this issue, which is of real concern across the country for many parents who are concerned about provision. I agree that children with special educational needs and disabilities are being failed, with parents struggling to get their children the support they need and deserve.

Not addressed: The specific ask about increased funding or changes in formula was not addressed.

How: I Agree That Children With Special Educational Needs And Disabilities Are Being Failed

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q18 Luke Murphy Lab Basingstoke
Context

The Prime Minister's focus is on economic growth, including the international investment summit.

Question

What support will this Government give to ensure high streets across the country are able to grow and thrive?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I remember that visit. Here is the new political vibe: invest with Labour or decline with the Tories. That is why I am so pleased to read out the investments we have had in the last few weeks. We have a big summit coming up on Monday, with hundreds of CEOs coming, and I am confident we will be making further such investment announcements in weeks to come.

Not addressed: The specific ask about support for high streets was not addressed.

How: Here Is The New Political Vibe: Invest With Labour Or Decline With The Tories

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q19 Helen Morgan Lib Dem North Shropshire
Context

The A483 is a dangerous road with National Highways' proposal for improvement, but Treasury rules place constraints.

Question

Will the Prime Minister look at flexing those rules to back National Highways and my residents, to give them the safe road they deserve?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I thank the hon. Member for raising this. It is obviously a big and important issue in her constituency. It is vital that as we invest we improve safety and deliver better journeys for drivers. National Highways continues to study the case for safety improvements to the A483 and will continue to do so.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The specific ask about reconsidering Treasury rules was not directly addressed.

How: It Is Vital That As We Invest We Improve Safety

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q20 Phil Brickell Lab Bolton West
NHS
Context

Bolton Hospice faces a difficult financial future and relies heavily on fundraising. The MP raised concerns about the sustainability of such services.

Question

Bolton Hospice provides vital services to individuals with life-limiting conditions yet, like hospices across the country, it faces a difficult financial future and is reliant on fundraising, including the kind donations I was able to raise when I climbed Mount Kilimanjaro last year and from the campaign run by . What steps is the Prime Minister taking to ensure hospices, like the one in Bolton, are put on a sustainable financial footing?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I congratulate my hon. Friend on his efforts in relation to his local hospice. We want everyone to have access to high-quality care, including end of life care. That is why we require all local NHS bodies to commission services from hospices to meet the needs of their local populations. Most hospices are charitable, independent organisations that also receive funding for providing NHS services.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The question specifically asked about sustainable financial footing but no concrete steps or commitments were given.

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q21 Robin Swann Ulster Unionist Party South Antrim
Context

Northern Ireland has seen more deaths from suicide than those killed during the troubles, some directly related to past violence. The MP is requesting a commitment to address these issues.

Question

Since the signing of the Belfast agreement in 1998, more people in Northern Ireland have now sadly lost their lives to suicide than those who were killed during the 30 years of the troubles. Does the Prime Minister agree that the challenges with poor mental health in Northern Ireland, some of which are directly related to the violence of our past, are a unique and pressing legacy of the troubles? Will he therefore commit to tasking his Government to work collaboratively with the Department of Health in Northern Ireland to explore how these issues can be properly recognised and resolved?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I thank the hon. Member for raising that important matter. I do know at first hand the deep impact that the troubles have had on so many in Northern Ireland. We must ensure that those with mental health issues receive the support and the care that they need. Public services are obviously devolved in Northern Ireland, but we will work with the Executive and leaders to support them in delivering better outcomes.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The question asked for a specific commitment but received only broad statements about working towards better outcomes without concrete steps or timelines.

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Context

Parents in Hexham have to fight tooth and nail to secure fair treatment and full education for their children with special educational needs and disabilities. The MP is seeking government steps to improve outcomes.

Question

In my constituency of Hexham, frightened parents and families are having to fight tooth and nail and to travel extremely long distances to secure fair treatment and full education for their children. Will the Prime Minister outline steps that the Government will take to improve outcomes and results for children with special educational needs and disabilities, particularly those in the most rural parts of the north-east?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I thank my hon. Friend for his question. This reinforces the point that the SEND provisions were a failure of the previous Government, particularly in rural communities. The issue is felt by Members on both sides of the House. It is really important and we have a duty now to pick it up and ensure that all children with SEND receive the right support to succeed in their education, and we will continue to do so.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The answer acknowledges the issue but does not provide specific steps or commitments to address it.

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q23 David Davis Con Goole and Pocklington
Context

The MP is concerned about the time constraints of private legislation making it difficult to get the Assisted Dying Bill right first time.

Question

On the assisted dying Bill, which is a private Member's Bill, the Government are quite rightly staying neutral, but the real issue with the Bill is that the time constraints of private legislation make it difficult to get it right first time. If we get this wrong first time, the consequences are too terrible to contemplate. In 1967, the Government of the day gave time to allow David Steel's Abortion Bill to go through. Will the Prime Minister commit to giving extra time—Government time—to the Bill to ensure that we get this right first time?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I thank the right hon. Member for raising this question on a really important issue. I do understand that there are strongly held views across the House—on both sides and within both sides, if I can put it in that way. I do agree with him that it is important that we ensure that any change to the law—if there is to be one—is effective.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The answer acknowledges the importance but does not commit to giving extra time for the Bill.

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q24 Noah Law Lab St Austell and Newquay
Context

With shared prosperity funding drawing to a close, the MP is seeking strategic sources of investment funding for critical minerals and renewable energy in Cornwall.

Question

With shared prosperity funding drawing to a close, and Cornwall having some of the greatest potential in Europe in critical minerals and renewable energy, it is time for our aspiring Celtic tiger to identify much more strategic sources of investment funding, which take us away from the short-termist begging-bowl politics of the previous decade. Will the Prime Minister meet Cornish MPs to discuss the future of industrial and social funding in Cornwall?

Answer from Keir Starmer

My hon. Friend is a proud Cornish MP. He is absolutely right that economic growth must be spread across the country; it cannot simply be focused in the south-east and London. He will no doubt have seen today the floating offshore wind taskforce report, which sets out that the UK's industry can support tens of thousands of jobs, including huge job opportunities in the south-west.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The question asked for a meeting to discuss funding but received acknowledgment without commitment.

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q25 Wendy Chamberlain Lib Dem North East Fife
Context

The MP first raised the condition in the Chamber 18 months ago after hearing about its devastating impact from a constituent.

Question

Today is PANS PANDAS Awareness Day, which is about a paediatric condition affecting potentially thousands of children across the UK. I first raised the condition in the Chamber 18 months ago, when I heard about its devastating impact from a constituent. Does the Prime Minister agree that it should not be for a charity to fund the pathway analysis and research needed to ensure that people and children get the support they need? Will he help facilitate a meeting for me with the charity and the Department of Health and Social Care?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I thank the hon. Lady for raising this important issue and reminding the House of the impact that it has. I can certainly arrange that meeting so that we can take it further forward.

Answered
Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q26 Mary Foy Lab City of Durham
Context

Durham County Council faces financial pressure due to the Tories' unfair funding formula, affecting essential public services like social care.

Question

My constituents are anxious about the financial situation at Durham county council. The Tories' unfair funding formula has hollowed out essential public services such as social care, while demand has been increasing. What assurances can the Prime Minister give me that essential services will be restored and that a new funding formula will be genuinely fair, focusing on the needs of my constituents, especially the most vulnerable?

Answer from Keir Starmer

My hon. Friend highlights yet another failing of the last Government. Successive years of underfunding have left councils experiencing significant budget pressures, and that is felt by constituents, residents and individuals across the country. This Government will clear up the mess and get councils back on their feet. Multi-year funding settlements will partly help to allow longer-term work to be done. But we recognise the importance of councils, which know their communities best. With greater stability, we can support them in ensuring that the services that they provide get to the people who need them.

Partly answered

Not addressed: Did not commit to a specific new funding formula or timeline for restoring essential services

How: We Are Not Going To Take Lessons From The Conservative Party

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Context

After Storm Pierrick, over 50 homes and businesses in Gosport were underwater; some residents have not returned. The flood and coastal erosion risk management funding application has not been decided by the Environment Agency.

Question

In April, more than 50 homes and businesses in Gosport found themselves underwater when Storm Pierrick hit; some people have still not been able to return to their properties. This has now been upgraded to a one-in-20-year risk. We have still not had a decision from the Environment Agency about flood and coastal erosion risk management funding, for which we have applied. Despite requests, I have still been unable to secure a meeting with the Prime Minister's DEFRA team. Winter is coming and my constituents are worried. When is he going to grip this?

Answer from Keir Starmer

This is a really important issue in terms—[Interruption.] Look, we are not going to take lessons from the Conservative party. Year after year, we visited constituencies and areas that were flooded because there had been a failure to take adequate protection. What I said in the election campaign was that we would set up a flood resilience taskforce to get ahead of the issue. We will do that, and I will ensure that the hon. Lady can get such further information as she needs.

Partly answered

Not addressed: Did not specify a timeline for decision on funding or meeting with DEFRA team

How: We Are Not Going To Take Lessons From The Conservative Party

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email
Q28 Dawn Butler Lab Brent East
Context

October is Black History Month with the theme of 'Reclaiming Narratives'. The PM will host an event at No.10 this evening.

Question

October is Black History Month, and the theme this year is “Reclaiming Narratives”. I thank you, Mr Speaker, for the event that you are putting on in your apartments with The Temptations, and the Prime Minister—[Laughter.] The Temptations tribute band. The Prime Minister will be having an event at No.10 this evening. Does he agree that it is important that we continue to have a debate on the Floor of the House in Government time on Black History Month?

Answer from Keir Starmer

I am not sure that something labelled “Temptations” is quite where I need to go at the moment—[Laughter.] But this is a really important initiative. It is important that it is being marked and I am very pleased to be hosting the event this evening, to which I think my hon. Friend is coming.

Not addressed: Did not address whether debates on Black History Month should take place during Government time

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Get updates like this by email