Commons Sense

House of Commons · Ministers' Questions

Topical Questions

Thursday 26 October 2023 · 27 questions

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Answered 8 Partly answered 12 Not answered 0

Key points

  • Virginia Crosbie questioned the Rail Minister about Avanti's reduced train services to Holyhead, with the Minister responding that the changes are due to necessary engineering works and crew shortages.
  • Louise Haigh inquired about the dismantling of the HS2 ministerial taskforce, to which the Minister responded that savings from HS2 would be reinvested in northern and midland transport projects.
  • Kerry McCarthy asked about the Government's response to the consultation on pavement parking, with the Minister stating that the issue requires careful consideration given the significant number of submissions received.

Topics (select to filter)

Questions & Answers

Context

The MP is concerned about the reduction of direct train services from London to Holyhead by Avanti, affecting her constituents.

Question

Thank goodness Santa travels by sleigh, not train! Avanti has just released its new timetable, with London to Holyhead services up to Christmas slashed. It is certainly no Nadolig Llawen for my Ynys Môn constituents, who like me are fed up with this service. Avanti has a new contract; what assurance can my right hon. Friend give to my constituents that he is doing everything he can to restore the number of direct trains from London to Holyhead to pre-pandemic levels?

Answer from Mark Harper

The Rail Minister and I continue to hold Avanti to account for matters within its control. The temporary changes are necessary due to Network Rail engineering works and crew shortages, but £1 billion is being invested in north Wales main line electrification as an early Christmas present from the Prime Minister.

Partly answered

Not addressed: Did not address restoring pre-pandemic train services directly

How: Providing Unrelated Information, Hedging Language

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q2 Louise Haigh Lab Sheffield Heeley
Context

The MP questions the Prime Minister's decision to dismantle the ministerial taskforce overseeing HS2, citing concerns over cost and delivery.

Question

We now know that High Speed 2 was billions of pounds over budget, Parliament may have been misled, and the Government are about to waste hundreds of millions more on the fire sale of the land. Why, then, did the Prime Minister choose to dismantle the ministerial taskforce that was literally designed to oversee the cost and delivery of HS2 when he entered No. 10?

Answer from Mark Harper

The Prime Minister made a long-term decision to reinvest savings from HS2 into northern and midland transport projects, benefiting more people faster. The hon. Member's party leader acknowledged the PM's right stance on HS2.

Not addressed: Did not explain dismantling of ministerial taskforce

How: Changing Subject

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q3 Louise Haigh Lab Sheffield Heeley
Context

The MP is concerned about unfunded projects in Network North due to outdated valuations.

Question

Neither the Secretary of State nor the Prime Minister were paying attention, were they? They have fatally undermined confidence in HS2 and its delivery, which is why no one has confidence in Network North. The Rail Minister failed to respond to my hon. Friend the Member for Wythenshawe and Sale East (Mike Kane) about the fact that dozens of projects in Network North are unfunded because they are valued in 2019 prices. Will he publish the delivery plans and up-to-date costs, or can we all conclude that Network North is not worth the paper it is written on?

Answer from Mark Harper

I am very surprised that the hon. Lady is not welcoming the improvements Network North will bring, including rail upgrades in Sheffield and Hull to Leeds. I am shocked she does not welcome these changes.

Not addressed: Did not address publication of delivery plans or costs

How: Changing Subject

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

The MP requests that parking charges on double yellow lines in London be extended to Bournemouth.

Question

Some 75% of visitors to Bournemouth travel by car. They are most welcome, particularly when they do not park on double yellow lines, but some are choosing to do so for a great day by the sea. They are willing to pay the £35 charge, which obstructs local traffic and, indeed, the emergency services. If someone parks on a double yellow in London, the charge is £65. That is a real deterrent, so can the London charging rates for parking on yellow lines please be extended to Bournemouth?

Answer from Richard Holden

I thank my right hon. Friend for his question and would be happy to discuss the issue further with him, as I recently met with my right hon. Friend the Member for Bournemouth West (Sir Conor Burns) and some members of the local council.

Partly answered

Not addressed: Did not commit to implementing higher parking charges

How: Hedging Language

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q5 Kerry McCarthy Lab Bristol East
Context

The MP asks for a response to the government consultation on pavement parking after more than three years.

Question

By the time we next meet for Transport orals, it will have been more than three years since the Government consultation on pavement parking closed. Are we ever going to see a Government response, or is it time that the Government came clean with disability groups and admitted that they have put this issue in the “too hard to do” pile?

Answer from Richard Holden

It is not a 'too hard to do' issue—it is something we are looking at. It was one of the biggest responses with tens of thousands of submissions, so it is right that we take our time. Local authorities can implement traffic regulation orders.

Partly answered

Not addressed: Did not provide a specific timeline for response

How: Hedging Language

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

Local residents are concerned about potholes and road repairs. The government recently announced £8 billion for pothole repair.

Question

Potholes and road repairs are a key concern for many of my fellow Gedling residents so I warmly welcome the recent announcement of over £8 billion of spend on potholes. Can my right hon. Friend assure me that money will be spent where it is needed most and outline how much of it is coming to the east midlands?

Answer from Mark Harper

Details of how that £8.3 billion of funding will be allocated to local authorities will be published in due course, and I hope we will be able to make an announcement about that in the not-too-distant future to give my hon. Friend that reassurance. It will be for each individual local highway authority to decide how to spend that money and to focus on the most important parts of their network.

Partly answered

Not addressed: Specific figures or commitments about East Midlands funding allocation were not provided.

How: It Will Be For Each Individual Local Highway Authority To Decide How To Spend That Money

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

Scotland has more progressive electric vehicle incentives compared to England, including interest-free loans and enhanced home-charger grants.

Question

Scotland has had a far more progressive approach to encouraging the switch to electric vehicles with incentives including interest-free loans for electric vehicles, enhanced home-charger grants and a far more comprehensive charging network with twice as many rapid chargers per head as England. The Scottish Government's Cabinet Secretary for net zero has described the delay on banning petrol and diesel car sales as an 'unforgiveable betrayal of current and future generations', putting the UK on the 'wrong side of history' on climate change. She is right, isn't she?

Answer from Jesse Norman

I do not think that, for the reasons we have described, there is anything to complain about in relation to the progress we are making across England. Charge point roll-out remains very rapid—43% in the last 12 months —and there are 49,000 public charge points at the moment and 400,000 private and business ones, and new regulations and a new mandate have just been laid.

Not addressed: Did not address Scotland's Cabinet Secretary's criticism directly.

How: Charge Point Roll-Out Remains Very Rapid

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

Chalkwell station in Leigh-on-Sea is entirely inaccessible due to steep steps. Work was supposed to start a year ago but has not.

Question

Chalkwell station in beautiful Leigh-on-Sea has 40 steep steps to get up from and down to the platform; it is 100% inaccessible. I was told last year by the Treasury that work on it is part of the £350 million Department for Transport Access for All programme. Work was supposed to start a year ago, but nothing has happened. The timetable has slipped; it is not due to be completed until March 2026. To ensure that there is no further slippage on this timetable, will the Minister meet with me?

Answer from Huw Merriman

I am very happy to meet my hon. Friend. Chalkwell, Ockendon and Southend East remain within the Access for All programme. We have delivered 230 stations and we will deliver those three as well. We had an issue with the contractor putting in a cost estimate that was about double what I would expect; that is why we have had to look anew, but I will very happily meet my hon. Friend to discuss this further, and she has that commitment.

Answered
Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

There are reports that HS2 trains will travel slower than existing trains due to track design issues.

Question

Can the Minister confirm that although HS2—or maybe HS1- and-a-quarter—is going no further than Birmingham, the HS2 trains will continue to run on the west coast main line? Is he aware of repeated reports that because the new trains are not designed for existing track, the high-speed trains to Glasgow will go slower than the existing trains on that line? Can the Minister categorically assure the House that that is not the case, and tell us how much time will be cut from the train journey from Glasgow to Birmingham?

Answer from Huw Merriman

It comes down to choices. We could have chosen to continue with HS2, which would not have delivered the value we need, with time overrunning, or we could have done as the Scottish National party did when it built two ferries at a shipyard that had been nationalised, going four times over budget and running seven years late.

Not addressed: Did not address reports of slower train speeds or journey time savings directly.

How: We Could Have Chosen To Continue With Hs2

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

The government is keen on approving more open access passenger and freight train operators.

Question

Open access passenger and freight train operators have recovered faster since the pandemic, experience higher staff morale with fewer strikes, provide better deals for passengers and cost taxpayers less too. Over the next three to six months how many new open-access services does the Minister expect to see approved?

Answer from Huw Merriman

I thank my hon. Friend for everything he does to push for more open access. It is something the Secretary of State and I are keen to do. I met this week with the Office of Rail and Road chief executive, our regulator, and we discussed what he can do to allow more open-access applications, and what we can do, and we then met with another bidder. There is another service planned with regard to Wales on the western line, and there is also one in the offing that could work on CrossCountry, plus one for the channel tunnel.

Partly answered

Not addressed: Did not provide a specific number of new services expected to be approved.

How: We Discussed What He Can Do To Allow More Open-Access Applications

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q11 Chi Onwurah Lab Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West
Context

The government's handling of HS2 has been criticised, with concerns over the credibility of the Network North project.

Question

The Government's mishandling of HS2 was and is absolutely staggering, but their attempt to pull the wool over northern eyes with Network North is a farce. Does the Minister really believe the people of the north-east are falling for his fag-end fake network to nowhere?

Answer from Huw Merriman

I just do not accept that at all. I gave a run through of a list of the £36 billion that is being put back into local projects, including £1.8 billion extra for the north-east. That could, for example, be an option for the Leamside line to be reopened.

How: I Just Do Not Accept That At All

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

Local authorities are receiving £200 million for pothole repair, with Dudley Council adopting a new proactive maintenance approach.

Question

The fight against potholes is much like our own fight to stay healthy: if we do nothing about it, we deteriorate faster. I therefore thank the Minister for the additional £200 million allocated to local authorities for pothole repairs. Will he join me in praising Dudley Council's new approach of moving away from traditional, reactive quick wins towards a proactive, high-quality structural maintenance service?

Answer from Richard Holden

I certainly am delighted to praise Dudley Council for its new approach, spending that money wisely but also implementing preventative measures for the future. Well planned road maintenance is essential, and on 4 October the Prime Minister announced that Network North would include £8.3 billion for local highway maintenance right across the country.

Answered
Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q13 Dan Jarvis Lab Barnsley North
Context

South Yorkshire relies on the city region sustainable transport settlements round 2 uplift for local and regional transport infrastructure.

Question

The government has said that every penny spent on HS2 will be reinvested in local and regional transport. To clarify, can you confirm that South Yorkshire's city region sustainable transport settlements round 2 uplift is £543 million, and will the Minister work with the Mayor to maximise this investment?

Answer from Mark Harper

Yes, I can confirm that it is indeed £543 million of extra funding for the South Yorkshire mayoral combined authority. We have already had conversations with the South Yorkshire Mayor about the funding and his plans. My team will continue to do so, and our officials will work with his to make sure we can deliver those plans.

Answered
Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

The global AI summit in Milton Keynes is upcoming, focusing on the regulation of new technology.

Question

With the global AI summit coming up next week, what steps is the Department taking towards regulating autonomous pavement delivery robots?

Answer from Jesse Norman

I have visited the technology my hon. Friend describes, seen it in action, and am pleased to confirm that the Department will fund research on its impacts. The results of this research will be published once concluded.

Answered
Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q15 Ruth Cadbury Lab Brentford and Isleworth
Context

Heavy goods vehicles cause a disproportionate number of cycling deaths, necessitating the study of successful London schemes.

Question

Will the Department look at the successful London scheme to address illegal freight operators contributing to cyclist deaths and encourage partnerships between local authorities, DVSA, and police forces?

Answer from Richard Holden

I am happy to look at measures like this one proposed by the hon. Lady. I regularly meet the National Police Chiefs' Council on this issue, as well as police and crime commissioners' lead. We have updated the highway code but will consider further measures.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The Department did not commit to any specific actions or partnerships suggested by Ruth Cadbury

How: I Am Always Happy To Look At

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

Nottinghamshire submitted a levelling-up fund bid for a new Toton link road but narrowly missed out, despite its potential to ease congestion and unlock economic benefits.

Question

Will the Secretary of State meet me to discuss the £40 million, ready-to-go project in Broxtowe and wider county, especially considering the east midlands has the lowest amount per head spent on transport?

Answer from Richard Holden

With extra £1.5 billion in CRSTS for my hon. Friend's mayoral combined authority, there will be opportunities to look at important road schemes. I would be delighted to meet him as soon as possible.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The Secretary of State did not commit to discussing the specific £40 million Toton link road project.

How: With Extra Funding

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

Previous HS2 plans claimed significant increases in rail passenger numbers and reduced air travel emissions, but the government has made a different choice.

Question

What is the Secretary of State's new prediction for rail passenger numbers making the journey between Scotland and London after abandoning the HS2 project?

Answer from Huw Merriman

I will write to the hon. Lady with the details she requires, but I restate our choice to proceed with transport projects across the country that deliver better benefits and have a stronger business case.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The Secretary of State avoided providing specific new predictions for rail passenger numbers.

How: I Will Write, But I Restate

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

There are concerns about safety for Jews using the London Underground, and a specific incident is mentioned involving misconduct by staff.

Question

Does my right hon. Friend think people of the Jewish faith feel safe on the London Underground? Should not Transport for London equipment misuse leading to harassment be punishable under the Public Order Act 1986?

Answer from Mark Harper

I am familiar with the case raised. I contacted British Transport police after seeing disturbing footage, confirming a suspended staff member is under investigation. The incident is taken seriously by both BTP and London Underground.

Answered
Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q19 Liz Twist Lab Blaydon and Consett
Context

A dispute between Go North East and its employees highlights the need for better, more streamlined franchising models to give communities a greater say on transport.

Question

Is it not essential that we have better, more streamlined franchising models for local bus services so that communities like Blaydon can have a greater say in their transport offer?

Answer from Richard Holden

The hon. Lady welcomed the news of settlement between Go North East and Unite, and also welcomes £163.5 million into bus service improvement plans including options for bus franchising available to all local authorities.

Answered
Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

The reopening of an 11-mile missing track connecting Lancashire and Yorkshire would be fundamental for linking these areas back up.

Question

Will the Minister consider progressing this railway line to the next phase, including drawing up a full business case? Will he meet Members to discuss it further?

Answer from Huw Merriman

I would be pleased to meet my hon. Friend and all right hon. Friends and colleagues. The Department has been working with Transport for the North, Lancashire County Council, and campaign groups on strengthening the case for reopening that line.

Answered
Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q21 Stephanie Peacock Lab Barnsley South
Context

The Mayor of South Yorkshire requested £8 million to restore bus services cut in the past year, not just to 2022 levels as previously stated by the Minister.

Question

In response to a previous question, it was claimed that the Mayor asked for £8 million to restore bus services. However, this request is specifically for restoring cuts made last year. Will the government reconsider the funding needed for South Yorkshire?

Answer from Richard Holden

The response acknowledges that £1.6 million has been allocated this year with an additional £1.6 million next year, along with nearly £8 million more. The Minister also mentions a significant amount—half a billion pounds—of city region sustainable transport settlement funding for South Yorkshire, which will almost triple in the following period.

Partly answered

Not addressed: The specific request to review and increase funding was not addressed directly, focusing instead on existing funding commitments.

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q22 Martin Vickers Con Brigg and Immingham
Context

The question concerns the proposed extension of LNER services from King's Cross to Lincoln, through to Cleethorpes.

Question

When will Ministers give LNER permission to extend its service from King's Cross-Lincoln to Cleethorpes?

Answer from Mark Harper

The Minister hopes to make an announcement shortly regarding the extension of LNER services from King's Cross-Lincoln to Cleethorpes.

Partly answered

Not addressed: A specific date for the decision was not provided, only that it will be made soon.

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q23 Wendy Chamberlain Lib Dem North East Fife
Context

The Department was expected to report on medical licences for fishermen this week but has not done so.

Question

According to regulations, the review should have been published by now. When will it be released? Additionally, when will the department start listening to concerns raised by fishermen?

Answer from Mark Harper

The Minister met representatives from the National Federation of Fishermen's Organisations recently and promises to make policy announcements soon. The department will keep the federation informed, as it does with Members of Parliament.

Partly answered

Not addressed: No specific timeline for publishing the review or addressing concerns was provided.

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q24 David Simmonds Con Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner
Context

The Mayor of London proposed to abolish the travelcard scheme but later intervened to save it from his own plans.

Question

How can my right hon. Friend explain to constituents why the Mayor of London first wanted to abolish the travelcard and then tried to take credit for saving it?

Answer from Mark Harper

The Minister finds the Mayor's change in stance surprising, suggesting that others who raised concerns about his original proposal deserve more credit than the Mayor does.

Not addressed: Did not address the question directly but criticized the Mayor's actions and intentions instead.

How: Criticized Opposition

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q25 Andrew Bridgen Con
Context

Former head of land acquisitions for HS2 alleged that people were short-changed and not given full value for their properties along the route.

Question

What does the Secretary of State think about allegations made by Andrew Bruce, former head of land acquisitions for HS2, regarding property valuation in the acquisition process?

Answer from Huw Merriman

The Minister expects that those who sold their property will be offered it back at current market value. He states he will discuss the hon. Member's allegations further so as to understand the case thoroughly.

Partly answered

Not addressed: No commitment was made to investigate or address the specific allegations raised.

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Context

A constituent's son was assaulted outside a Manchester City match and no arrests have been made despite clear CCTV footage.

Question

Will the Minister meet me to discuss this distressing case involving an unprovoked attack on my constituent's son, and consider more widely the remit and resourcing of British Transport police?

Answer from Mark Harper

The Minister will raise the incident specifically with British Transport police. He also expresses willingness to meet the hon. Member to discuss the matter further.

Answered

Not addressed: null

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)

Q27 Dave Doogan SNP Angus and Perthshire Glens
Context

In Scotland, under-22s travel for free on public transport funded by the Scottish Government. The questioner challenges the English government to match this support.

Question

Will the English Government provide similar support to commuters in England, or are they too proud to follow Scotland's lead?

Answer from Richard Holden

The Minister argues that fares in Scotland have increased by over 10% annually, contrasting this with falling fares in England and highlighting the £2 fare cap for those in low-paid work or seeking employment.

Not addressed: Did not address the specific request to match Scotland's free travel policy but instead compared fare structures negatively.

How: Criticized Opposition

Was this summary accurate? Tell us

How accurate was this summary? (1 = poor, 5 = spot on)