Levelling-up and Shared Prosperity Funds 2021-06-14
2021-06-14
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP discusses the levelling-up fund and UK shared prosperity fund, noting concerns about democratic engagement in Scotland.
I have been involved in discussions with my local authority regarding the levelling-up fund; however, it occurred to me last week that there was something of a democratic deficit in the process. Given that the fund can be used in devolved policy areas, why is there no mechanism for councils to formally consult their Scottish Parliament representatives? Will the Minister advise what his Government are doing to ensure projects are realised with as much collaboration as possible?
There is nothing at all to stop councils consulting with or speaking to the Scottish Government before submitting their bid. The funds are about localism, encouraging direct relationships between local authorities and the UK Government. We will speak to devolved Administrations at the shortlisting stage of bids to seek advice on conflicts with policies.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer avoids addressing the specific ask for formal consultation mechanisms.
Changed Subject
Repeated Positive Statements
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP criticises the centralised approach of the UK Government, highlighting lack of involvement from devolved Administrations in spending decisions.
There is not one new penny of money available for these funds. The EU structural funding had direct involvement of Ministers from devolved nations. How can the Minister now justify a centralised Whitehall-led approach that cuts out directly elected Governments of devolved nations?
There is new money being invested through the UK community renewal fund. £220 million is invested to trial priorities and projects ahead of the introduction of the UKSPF. Local authorities in Scotland can consult with devolved Administrations, and we will seek advice at the shortlisting stage.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer avoids justifying the centralised approach directly.
Repeated Positive Statements
Accusatory Language
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Public Accounts Committee delivered a damning verdict on the towns fund, stating lack of transparency and reasoning for selection or exclusion.
In view of the Public Accounts Committee's criticism, what specific measures will be announced today to ensure transparency and freedom from political bias in the distribution of levelling-up funds?
All information is published on gov.uk. The Government are supporting communities in Scotland that have been let down by nationalists for many years. We are investing billions of pounds in people, infrastructure, regeneration, transport, and high street refurbishments.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer does not address transparency or political bias measures at all.
Changed Subject
Accusatory Language
Response accuracy