Topical Questions 2021-07-13

2021-07-13

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Context
The East Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust requires significant investment as part of the Government's NHS estate infrastructure improvement plan.
East Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust has the potential to get hundreds of millions in investment as part of the Government's NHS estate infrastructure improvement plan. Will funding be allocated on a two to three-year basis, so that the NHS can better plan its funding and estates plans? Where funding has been indicated for a longer term, what plans are there to ensure that providers have sufficient resource in the shorter term to address immediate issues, or to support covid or recovery?
We have put more and more capital into the NHS. There are always representations from hon. Members, including you, Mr Speaker, for even more capital. My hon. Friend is right to raise the issue of the importance of local healthcare systems, which will need more capital funding as we progress. She will know that we set out our capital plans for this financial year, 2021-22, but she is right to say that multi-year funding will mean that trusts can plan better, and that is a priority; we want the spending review to have more sight and better planning for capital.
Assessment & feedback
Specific timeline or commitment on multi-year funding allocation was not provided
Under Consideration Priority
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Context
The Minister for Patient Safety, Suicide Prevention and Mental Health claimed that no government before 2017 invested in or prioritised mental health services.
Let us consider these words about mental health services: “prior to 2017, no government invested in or prioritised MH services.” Those are not my words but the words of the Minister for Patient Safety, Suicide Prevention and Mental Health, the hon. Member for Mid Bedfordshire (Ms Dorries). Indeed, the new Secretary of State was the architect of these cuts, during his time as a Treasury Minister. The unparalleled devastation he left behind has been simply staggering, so does he agree with his Minister? Can he explain to us why 140,000 children were turned away from mental health services last year? Can he explain why a quarter of mental health beds have been cut since 2010? Is he ashamed of his track record?
The hon. Lady will know that the NHS long-term plan that has been set out by this Government is committed to a transformation in mental health services and mental health spending; some £2.3 billion extra is being invested by 2023-24. In addition, she will be aware of the mental healthcare White Paper and the mental health recovery action plan.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address cuts to services or number of beds cut since 2010
Under Review Future Plans
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Context
The Health and Social Care Committee published a report highlighting inhumane treatment of individuals with learning disabilities and autism.
May I welcome the Secretary of State to his place? I am sure he will do an excellent job. As he thinks about a 24-hour A&E for Chorley, I hope he will also think about the urgent need for a cancer institute at the Royal Surrey County Hospital as only second on his list. The Secretary of State will know that this morning the Health and Social Care Committee published a worrying report about the inhumane treatment given to 2,000 people with learning disabilities and autism in in-patient units, often because no community provision was available. When he brings forward his plans for social care, will he make sure that there is adequate funding for local authorities to give care to such people? Will he also make sure that care workers are always paid the minimum wage, including for the time taken to travel between appointments?
I welcome my right hon. Friend's comments and the work that he and other Members do through the Select Committee to scrutinise the work of the Department. He just referred to some of that work, especially in his comments about learning disability and autism, which will remain a huge priority for the Government and certainly for my Department.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific plans or commitments on funding and care worker pay
Under Review Priority
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Jeremy Hunt Con
Godalming and Ash
Context
There are 1.5 million older people, disabled people and carers with unmet needs who are waiting for care reform.
I congratulate the Secretary of State on his new role. There are 1.5 million older people, disabled people and carers with unmet needs who are desperately waiting for care reform. What is the Secretary of State's estimated start date for the implementation of the care package that the Government claimed was ready in their manifesto more than 20 months ago?
As the Government have said, we want to make sure that every person in this country has the dignity that they deserve in old age. We have recognised that the current system needs substantial reform. The process of reform has already begun in, for example, the Health and Care Bill that will have its Second Reading tomorrow, but we do need a new, sustainable way to fund care and we will come forward with the plans later this year.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific start date or timeline for implementation
Under Review Priority
Response accuracy
Q5 Direct Answer
Neil Coyle Lab
Bermondsey and Old Southwark
Context
From 16 August, fully vaccinated individuals no longer need to self-isolate after possible exposure to the virus.
I know that many of my constituents will be pleased to hear that from 16 August we will end the requirement for people to self-isolate after possible exposure to the virus if they are fully vaccinated. I am sure we all agree that it is right to change the rules as the information changes; however, will my right hon. Friend explain to the House the rationale for making this change on 16 August rather than next Monday?
I agree with my hon. Friend that it is good news that we can move away from restrictions and towards guidance. On the rationale for the decision he referred to, it is about vaccine effectiveness: we know that for those with both doses, vaccination is estimated to be 78% to 80% effective against symptomatic covid-19.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Kate Osborne Lab
Jarrow and Gateshead East
Context
Macmillan Cancer Support calculates that since March 2020, 37,000 fewer people than expected have started their first cancer treatment. In Jarrow alone, an estimated 66 people have not begun their treatments.
Macmillan estimates that the NHS will need to operate at 110% capacity for 14 months to address the backlog of undiagnosed and untreated cases. Will the Secretary of State confirm whether the NHS is on schedule to clear this cancer diagnosis, care, and treatment backlog by March 2022?
Cancer remains a huge priority. The Government has launched the 'Help Us, Help You' campaign to encourage people to come forward and additional funding for rapid diagnostic centres is provided.
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm whether NHS will meet March 2022 deadline
We Are Committed Under Review
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Context
Constituents struggle to get GP face-to-face appointments, leading some to go to A&E.
What measures are being taken to ensure that constituents can access GP services in person when they need it, especially for older individuals?
GP practices have done a magnificent job during the pandemic and we are prioritizing more face-to-face appointments, especially for older constituents as restrictions ease.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify any concrete steps or timelines
Priority We Understand
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Taiwo Owatemi Lab
Coventry North West
Context
Cancer Research UK estimates that nearly 45,000 fewer patients started cancer treatment in the UK due to pandemic-related NHS access limitations.
What actions are being taken by the Government to reach out to those at risk of undiagnosed or untreated cancers over the past year and a half?
The Government is providing additional funding for diagnostics, urging people to come forward if concerned about undiagnosed cancer. More than £1 billion has been allocated towards this effort.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify outreach efforts or methods beyond funding
We Are Committed Additional Support
Response accuracy
Q9 Direct Answer
Caroline Johnson Con
Sleaford and North Hykeham
Context
Sarah Barker, a constituent, is being denied IVF on the grounds that her partner has a child from another relationship.
Does my hon. Friend agree that infertility treatment should be based solely on medical need and not influenced by whether a partner already has children?
Clinical Commissioning Groups should provide fertility services in line with NICE guidelines and not use criteria outside these guidelines.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Helen Hayes Lab
Dulwich and West Norwood
Context
Clinically extremely vulnerable individuals are anxious about mandatory face masks being lifted on public transport from July.
Given that more than two thirds of people do not fully understand the implications for those who remain immunocompromised, should masks be kept mandatory to protect such clinically at-risk residents?
There will be a move from regulations to guidance as restrictions are lifted, while clear mask guidance has been published for those concerned.
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm continuation of mandatory masks on public transport
Guidance Measured Way
Response accuracy
Q11 Direct Answer
Paul Holmes Con
Hamble Valley
Context
Lifting lockdown measures may pose risks such as worsening mental health and domestic violence.
Will the need to balance these hidden costs against the reduced threat from the virus be a key part of the Government's decision-making in easing restrictions?
Removing restrictions carries risk, but so does maintaining them. The hidden costs include increased domestic violence, child abuse, mental health issues, and undiagnosed cancer; lifting some measures allows better addressing non-covid health problems.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Context
Constituents in Colne Valley have reported cancellations and postponements of medical procedures due to rising coronavirus cases. With over 5 million people on the waiting list, concerns about tackling the backlog are growing.
I have been contacted by a number of my Colne Valley constituents who have had operations and medical procedures cancelled or postponed at short notice. With coronavirus cases still on the rise, what is the strategy to tackle the backlog in operations and medical procedures?
My hon Friend rightly raises an issue that I know will be a concern for constituents of all Members of this House. The backlog of treatment—the waiting list—is over 5 million. However, we are making rapid progress with that and so is the NHS. We are looking at a variety of ways to do that—not just providing the funding needed to do it, but through innovation, accelerator hubs and diagnostic hubs, all designed to get the waiting list down and to get people the treatment they need when they need it.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify concrete actions or timelines for tackling the backlog specifically in Colne Valley
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Wendy Chamberlain Lib Dem
North East Fife
Context
Mandating of face masks is likely to continue in Scotland, while the approach differs across regions. There's a need for consultation with the Home Office regarding guidance to British Transport Police.
When I return to my constituency of North East Fife, I will cross into Scotland, where the mandating of face masks is likely to continue. Is it the Government's expectation that passengers will wear a mask only when they cross into Scotland—or, indeed, Wales? What consultation has happened with the Home Office in relation to guidance to the British Transport police? Do the Government accept that a lack of a four-nations approach to such measures is not helpful?
Throughout the pandemic, my predecessor and other Ministers have rightly been working with the devolved Administrations, and of course that work continues; it will remain a priority. I myself have already started weekly meetings with all my counterparts in the devolved Administrations. We discuss a number of issues and keep each other informed, but we also respect that in certain areas, in dealing with this pandemic, we may take a different course.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address expectations for passengers or consultation details directly
We Discuss A Number Of Issues And Keep Each Other Informed
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Rushanara Ali Lab
Bethnal Green and Stepney
Context
Cases of COVID rose by 30% last week, with over 35,000 new cases recorded. Hospitalisations could increase significantly by mid-August due to the rising case numbers.
I congratulate the Secretary of State on his appointment. Cases of covid rose by 30% last week compared with the previous week, and on 10 July we saw over 35,000 new cases, the highest since 22 January. By mid-August we could see 1,000 people a day being hospitalised, and up to 200 people a day could die, despite the excellent vaccination programmes. Given that the Secretary of State now considers it irresponsible not to wear masks, is it not equally irresponsible for the Government not to require people to continue to wear masks rather than leaving it as an option?
The hon Lady understandably talks about the link between case numbers and hospitalisation. She will know that the last time we saw cases at 30,000 and above on a daily basis, we saw a lot more hospitalisations. The reason for the difference now is the vaccine wall of defence. Masks do have an important role to play, but we think that that role can be played by moving from regulation to guidance.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify whether leaving mask wearing as a choice is irresponsible or provide clear direction on this issue
Response accuracy