Topical Questions 2021-07-08

2021-07-08

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Direct Answer
Context
The government's suspension of the English votes for English laws procedure since April 2020 and their review of its effectiveness.
If he will make a statement on his departmental responsibilities. The procedure has been suspended since April 2020, and many believe it has not served Parliament well. My Department is reviewing the process to simplify legislative work.
My Department, along with the Leader of the House, has been reviewing the English votes for English laws procedure. The procedure has been suspended since April 2020 and, having reflected on the procedure, the Government believe that it has not served our Parliament well and that removing it would simplify the legislative process. It is a fundamental principle that all constituent parts of the United Kingdom should be equally represented in Parliament. Any changes, of course, would be for the House to decide and we will bring forward a motion in due course.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Context
Concern about Ministers potentially evading scrutiny by using personal mobiles to conduct official government activities.
How would the right hon. Gentleman reassure a member of the public who thinks that a Minister using a personal mobile phone to conduct Government business is trying to evade scrutiny because they have something to hide? Ministers are known to use personal phones for work, raising concerns about accountability and transparency in government operations.
I would reassure them by saying that all Government business is transacted through civil service colleagues, and that in order to ensure that a single penny of taxpayers' money is spent, or that a single decision is taken, that might infringe, or enhance anyone's liberty, it has to go through the process of review, legislation and action, which civil servants and Ministers do together in a way that is always clear, transparent and publicly accountable.
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not provide reassurance directly related to personal mobile phone use for government business, instead focusing on the general process of ensuring accountability through civil service colleagues.
Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Context
The Select Committee on Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs is investigating the collapse of Greensill Capital, a major financial firm. The committee was invited to interview Sue Gray, who was director general for propriety and ethics at the Cabinet Office during the events.
In the inquiry by the Select Committee on Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs into the collapse of Greensill Capital, many of our witnesses so far have prayed in aid the advice given to them by Sue Gray. She has been invited to attend our Committee but her office declined citing senior Cabinet Office advice. Can I ask my right hon. Friend to ensure that she will attend on Tuesday as planned?
My hon. Friend chairs the Committee brilliantly, but there are rules—the Osmotherly rules. They stress that serving civil servants act only in accordance with the wishes of Ministers and therefore it is rarely appropriate for them to appear to be questioned in the way that my hon. Friend would like. So I am ready, willing and able to appear in front of the Committee, but it is my view that it would be inappropriate for a serving civil servant to appear in the way that my hon. Friend requests.
Assessment & feedback
The question was about ensuring Ms Gray's attendance; the response discussed rules preventing her appearance rather than addressing whether she should attend.
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Angela Rayner Lab
Ashton-under-Lyne
Context
The government's spokesperson previously stated that there was no high priority lane for testing suppliers or separate 'fast track process' in procurement. However, questions have been raised about a consultant to the testing procurement programme who mentioned 'VIP stakeholder engagement'. It is also alleged that procurement director ordered officials to mark bids from Ministers as 'fast track'.
Football is indeed coming home, but I think the chickens are coming home to roost for this Government. The Government's spokesperson said last week that there was no high priority lane for testing suppliers and no separate 'fast track process'. Can you tell me what exactly the role was of the consultant to the testing procurement programme who described his role as leading VIP stakeholder engagement with Lord Bethell, a current Minister?
There were lots of interesting questions there. The first thing that I should say is that Lord Bethell is doing a fantastic job in the Department of Health and Social Care. I think it is quite wrong for the right hon. Lady to cast aspersions on his dedicated public service and the work that he has done as Minister for Innovation.
Assessment & feedback
The question was about procurement processes, but the answer criticised the opposition MP instead of addressing the substance.
Attacked Opposition
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Angela Rayner Lab
Ashton-under-Lyne
Context
Concern about the lack of transparency in government procurement processes during a crisis, particularly related to PPE procurement. There are allegations that some Ministers' emails were marked as 'fast track'.
I listened to the Minister's answer and I can tell him that Lord Bethell is no Sterling. The Prime Minister's official spokesperson stated last week that no Ministers had used private emails to conduct Government business. Surely the Minister now accepts that that is untrue. Will he tell us when the Prime Minister will correct the record? We have submitted freedom of information requests to seek publication of such emails, but will the Minister agree now to publish every email about Government contracts?
The right hon. Lady quite rightly refers to the very powerful question from the hon. Member for Slough (Mr Dhesi), and I think all of us deeply sympathise with the family loss that he has had to endure, as so many others have had to. It is precisely because we take these things seriously that we took steps to ensure that we could source personal protective equipment as quickly as possible.
Assessment & feedback
The question was about publishing emails; the response addressed sympathy for bereaved families and procurement efforts without addressing publication of emails directly.
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q6 Direct Answer
Context
The Elections Bill was introduced to the House recently, aiming to address concerns about electoral practices and the impartiality of the Electoral Commission.
I was pleased to see the Elections Bill introduced to the House earlier this week. Like many of those who voted in 2016 to leave the European Union, I was concerned by the actions taken by the Electoral Commission following the referendum and the malicious way in which it treated individuals, completely casting into doubt its impartiality. Does my right hon. Friend share those concerns? Will he outline how the reforms in the Bill will seek to address them?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. If we reflect on how public-spirited individuals such as Alan Halsall and Darren Grimes were treated, I think it was quite right for the new head of the Electoral Commission to issue an apology. The Speaker's Committee on the Electoral Commission is a means by which parties across this House can ensure that the Electoral Commission does its important job, and the Elections Bill will ensure that the Speaker's Committee and others play an important role in making sure that the Electoral Commission does its job properly.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Ruth Jones Lab
Newport West and Islwyn
Context
Concerns about a shortage of HGV drivers impacting the movement of food and goods from Europe to the UK. The government has announced extending driving rules until 12 July.
I have heard from a number of HGV drivers in Newport West who are deeply concerned about the shortage of drivers and the impact this shortage is having on the movement of food and goods from Europe to the UK. What discussions has the Minister had with our European neighbours and his colleagues across Government about how to get this serious driver shortage sorted?
The hon. Lady raises an important question. Action is being taken by the Transport Secretary, and the issue was discussed earlier this week at Cabinet. I am also working with Lord Frost to ensure that we can have free-flowing freight and that we get the goods that we need to consumers in a timely fashion.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about discussions with European neighbours was not addressed directly, only internally within government
Working With Lord Frost
Response accuracy
Q8 Direct Answer
Context
Civil service reform includes digital and data improvements to deliver on the Government's priorities.
Does my right hon. Friend agree that, alongside civil service reform in terms of places and personnel, digital and data reforms are also at the heart of the Government's agenda to drive real improvement and deliver on the Government's priorities, which will transform our communities?
Yes, my hon. Friend is absolutely correct. In a former life he was a distinguished leader of West Sussex County Council and, as such, he knows how important it is to the delivery of public services to ensure that one has appropriate metrics, one shares data and that one uses digital innovation to improve service delivery.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Daniel Zeichner Lab
Cambridge
Context
Concerns about Government Ministers using personal email addresses for government-related activities.
A simple question: can the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster tell us how many Government Ministers have been using personal email addresses for Government business?
It is not my job to monitor the personal emails of all my colleagues. The only way you can conduct Government business is through civil servants.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about monitoring Ministers' personal email use was entirely avoided.
It Is Not My Job To Monitor
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Context
Request for the Advanced Research and Invention Agency (ARIA) to be located in County Durham's new county hall.
Does my right hon. Friend agree that that relocation of Government Departments is a key part of levelling up? Could I ask him to encourage his friends in the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy to consider placing the Advanced Research and Invention Agency in the new county hall being built in Durham?
My hon. Friend makes a very important point. The point that my hon. Friend makes about the Advanced Research and Invention Agency's potential location in the north-east is a good one, and I will discuss it with the Business Secretary.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask to encourage BEIS was acknowledged but not directly committed to.
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
Government claim that voter ID is necessary against rampant voter fraud. Request for data on confirmed fraudulent ballots.
The Government tell us that voter ID will secure our elections against apparently rampant voter fraud. That is a worrying claim indeed, so as a matter of urgency will the Minister provide the Government's data on how many ballots have been confirmed to have been fraudulently cast in recent elections?
We are only following what the Labour party does. It was the Labour party that introduced the requirement for voter ID in Northern Ireland, as pointed out earlier. There is no evidence that the requirement for voter ID will do anything to discriminate against Gypsy, Roma and Traveller individuals.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about data on fraudulent ballots was entirely avoided by talking about Labour's policies instead.
Labour Party Introduced It
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Harriett Baldwin Con
West Worcestershire
Context
Concern about the law of primogeniture reserving seats for men among hereditary peers in the upper house.
I know that my right hon. Friend and his colleagues are all passionate feminists, and I am sure that he would agree that it is difficult to justify the fact that an eighth of the seats in the upper House are reserved effectively for men, because of the laws of primogeniture and the hereditary peers. Does he have plans to reform that anomaly?
My hon. Friend makes a very good point. We do not currently have plans to do that, but she makes a fair point. For remaining hereditary peerages in the House of Lords, when an hereditary peer passes away there is a by-election among those who are eligible.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about reforming the anomaly was not directly committed to.
We Do Not Currently Have Plans
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Kate Osamor Lab Co-op
Edmonton and Winchmore Hill
Context
Concern that voter ID plans will exclude Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller communities.
With many lacking ID, the Government's voter ID plans are set to systematically exclude Gypsy, Roma and Traveller people. Why are Ministers, instead of working to improve accessibility, putting their energy into creating barriers to voting for this already marginalised community?
The hon. Lady raises an important point. There is much that we need to do to ensure the more effective inclusion in civic life of Gypsy, Roma and Traveller individuals. First, we must start with making sure that they receive a higher quality of education than is currently the case.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about reasons for exclusion was entirely avoided by addressing educational outcomes instead.
Start With Making Sure They Receive Better Education
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Context
Concerns that the Scottish Government have failed to effectively utilise additional funding provided by the UK Government for businesses, individuals, and communities affected by the pandemic.
On his recent visit to Scotland, the Minister will probably have heard concerns that the Scottish Government have not made full use of the additional funding provided by the UK Government to support businesses, individuals and communities through this pandemic. Will he outline what mechanisms are available to the UK Government to ensure that the Scottish Government make full use of the support available?
My hon Friend makes a very important point. When I was in the north-east and the Western Isles recently, I heard individuals and businesses crying out for economic support. We have no idea how the money has been spent and the Scottish Parliament does not yet have the powers necessary to get that information. However, Her Majesty's Treasury can ask tough questions and require information to be shared, and unless the Scottish Government are more transparent, I will have to consider how I can work with Ministers and with my hon Friend to make sure that Scottish taxpayers know where their money has gone.
Assessment & feedback
Specific mechanisms for ensuring effective use of funds were not detailed
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Context
The question refers to public opinion polls on the Union being hidden, while the private attitude of the Prime Minister is described as hostile due to comments from a former senior adviser.
Polled public attitudes towards the Union may be hidden, but the private attitude of the Prime Minister to devolution is clearly known and is hostile, as shown by his former senior adviser Dominic Cummings. Does that not confirm that the choice for Scotland is between an integrating Union under the Tories and independence?
No. This Government are committed to devolution. Like the Labour party and the Liberal Democrats, we believe in a United Kingdom that gets the best of both worlds: a strong Westminster Government working with strong devolved institutions. On the final point, the hon Gentleman and I are as one.
Assessment & feedback
The hostility towards devolution was not addressed directly
Changing Subject To Unity Of Uk Criticising Questioner'S Party
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Jim Shannon DUP
Strangford
Context
Small businesses in Northern Ireland are facing additional costs and income loss due to the interpretation of the Northern Ireland protocol by some in the European Commission.
Will the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster outline what collective approach has been taken by BEIS and the Cabinet Office to address some of the issues affecting small businesses with regard to the import of hundreds of products to Northern Ireland? Businesses are being prevented from trading normally, as things were pre-31 December 2020; they are under stress and it has reduced their income. Will the Chancellor agree to grant funding for a loss of income, as business have been impacted through no fault of their own?
The hon Gentleman makes an important point. As a result of the particular interpretation of the Northern Ireland protocol on which some in the European Commission have insisted, businesses in Strangford and elsewhere have faced additional costs. We have already devoted money through the trader support service and other means to support businesses, but I will talk to the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, the Treasury and Lord Frost to see what we can do to ensure that businesses in Strangford and elsewhere in Northern Ireland are not further disadvantaged.
Assessment & feedback
Specific funding commitment was not made
Response accuracy