Topical Questions 2021-05-18

2021-05-18

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Kerry McCarthy Lab
Bristol East
Context
The Queen outlined the government's plans to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic and build back a better country. The justice system is expected to play a significant role in this recovery.
I am concerned about the specific departmental responsibilities in light of the government's plan to cut crime, protect victims, and guarantee fairness in society as outlined by the Queen last week.
In the Gracious Speech last week, the Queen outlined this Government's plans to recover from the covid-19 pandemic and to build back a better country for our future. The justice system has a vital part to play in that—to cut crime, to protect victims, and to guarantee fairness in our society. My ministerial team and I look forward to steering a number of new Bills through Parliament during this Session.
Assessment & feedback
The specific actions or initiatives are not detailed.
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Kerry McCarthy Lab
Bristol East
Context
There has been no update on the Government's website regarding when prisons will reopen for family visits, despite some prisons reaching stage 3 of the national framework.
I am concerned about the lack of updates and inconsistencies in re-opening prison visits. Will you give an update?
Of course, Her Majesty's Prison Bristol will be near to or in the hon. Lady's constituency. I am glad to tell her that the majority of prisons have now reached stage 3 in accordance with the plan that I published last year. The individual decision making is very much up to governors and regional group directors, but I can assure her that Ministers and senior officials are driving forward progress on reopening, allowing visits, and indeed considering moving to the next stage, stage 2, which would further open up the prison environment —consistent of course with public health guidance and the needs and the safety of prisoners.
Assessment & feedback
Does not provide specific actions or timelines for reopening visits beyond general statements on progress being made.
Response accuracy
Q3 Direct Answer
John Lamont Con
Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk
Context
The government is looking to use technology innovatively to reduce crime.
How are the Government using technology in innovative ways to reduce crime?
What a brilliant question! I have always regarded myself as an early adopter of technology as one of the first in my family to own a Sinclair pocket calculator—remember those?—so I am now given the opportunity to early adopt in criminal justice as well. There are lots of ways that we can use technology to decrease offending. For example, I referred earlier to the GPS trackers that we are fitting to a group of criminals post release. Some 50% of those released from prison following, for example, conviction for a burglary go on to reoffend. If we know where they are all the time, then they are less likely to offend, but also, if there is a burglary, the police are able to match their location to the data to eliminate them or make them a person of inquiry. Similarly, Mr Speaker, you will be pleased to know that we are rolling out alcohol abstinence tags, which we fit to the ankles of those who are convicted of a crime where alcohol has driven their criminal behaviour. At the moment, compliance with these tags is well over 95%.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4 Direct Answer
Context
The Secretary of State previously stated that incorporating international conventions would make no difference to the quality of safeguarding children in the country.
Did the Secretary of State really say that incorporation of international conventions will not improve safeguarding? If so, does he believe it and is this view applicable to all such conventions?
In a word, yes.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5 Direct Answer
Ben Spencer Con
Runnymede and Weybridge
Context
As the ban on evictions starts to lift, there is a need to ensure courts can handle an expected surge in eviction cases.
What preparations has my right hon. and learned Friend made to ensure that the courts can cope with the surge of applications as the ban lifts?
Volumes of possession actions remain significantly low as a result of measures that we took in response to the pandemic. Indeed, although the ban in England on bailiff-enforced evictions will end on 31 May, the requirement for landlords to give extended notice periods to seek possession orders in all but the most egregious cases has really struck the right balance. We intend to taper down these notice periods to pre-covid levels by October, which will help to manage demand in the courts. I pay tribute to senior judiciary for working at pace to develop a case management approach to possession cases.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Catherine McKinnell Lab
Newcastle upon Tyne North
Context
According to the Government's own research, many people in the north-east do not have photo ID. The questioner is concerned about the impact of new voter ID requirements.
Does the Justice Secretary believe that without evidence of significant abuse, the introduction of voter ID will unjustifiably prevent many from voting?
With respect to the hon. Lady, I think that her concerns are wholly misplaced; I would be kind enough to say that. Some of the objection to this is, frankly, synthetic. The last Labour Government introduced it in Northern Ireland in 2003 without any concomitant reduction in turnout. Countries such as France and Canada and other mature democracies have long had this system in place. We will provide free identification for the tiny minority of people who do not have it. Frankly, the people of this country are wondering why on earth this has not been done before and are bewildered by the Opposition's confected objections.
Assessment & feedback
Does not directly address data requests for voter fraud investigations or prosecutions.
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Luke Evans Con
Hinckley and Bosworth
Context
TSB's internal research shows a significant increase in fraud involving young people, largely through social media.
What conversations are taking place with the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport to address this issue?
My hon. Friend rightly identifies an expanding area of business, sadly, for the courts and the police. He will be pleased to know that just last week, I held a meeting with the National Economic Crime Centre at the National Crime Agency to talk specifically about this issue. He will understand the complexity of online fraud in particular, whereby the offender may well be overseas, laundering money through a third territory and banking it in a fourth. Nevertheless, we need to do more to increase our capacity and capability to tackle this issue, to which we are all, including me, subject.
Assessment & feedback
Does not provide specific details on conversations with DCMS or planned actions.
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Context
The question addresses the issue of short or very short prison sentences given to women, highlighting that non-custodial sentences have better outcomes.
Far too many women are sentenced by our courts to short or very short prison sentences. The overwhelming evidence is that non-custodial sentences, with properly resourced and properly structured alternatives to prison, work better in preventing reoffending. What are the Government doing to ensure that we invest in these non-custodial options for the courts to use?
The hon. Gentleman speaks with a lot of experience, not just as a Member of this House but as a former police and crime commissioner. He will be reassured to know that the female offender strategy continues. In particular, with regard to the work that we are doing on pre-sentence reports, we will help courts and decision makers come to conclusions based upon community sentence treatment requirements, whether that is support for addiction or for mental health problems, which are a constructive direct alternative to those short terms of imprisonment that he rightly criticises.
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions or investments were not detailed.
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
The question seeks assurance on steps taken to improve judicial and public confidence regarding the consistency and severity of sentences.
Will my right hon. and learned Friend reassure my constituents of the steps his Department is taking to improve judicial and public confidence in sentencing?
My hon. Friend is right to hold the Government to account on these issues. He will recall that the White Paper I issued last year set out our plans for a framework that will do just that, by targeting the most serious violent and sexual offenders, ensuring that they serve longer proportions of their sentences of imprisonment in custody, therefore reflecting more appropriately the severity of their crimes and protecting the public, and ensuring that we introduce robust and effective community options for those who commit less serious offences.
Assessment & feedback
Concrete steps or timeline not provided.
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Kate Osamor Lab Co-op
Edmonton and Winchmore Hill
Context
The question addresses the lack of black, Asian and minority ethnic judges on the Supreme Court.
There are no black, Asian and minority ethnic Supreme Court judges. Can the Secretary of State explain what decisive action the Government are taking to ensure greater representation of people of colour across our judiciary?
I am grateful to the hon. Lady. She will be encouraged to know that the Judicial Appointments Commission, senior judiciary and I work together on that very issue, to ensure that the professions are doing all they can to encourage and support applicants from a black and minority ethnic background. In particular, I pay tribute to CILEX, the Chartered Institute of Legal Executives, for driving forward that important diversity. There is much more work to be done, and progress for all of us is frustratingly slow, but I will continue to put my shoulder to the wheel to ensure that we see sooner rather than later someone of a black and minority ethnic background sitting in the Supreme Court.
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions were not detailed.
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Harriett Baldwin Con
West Worcestershire
Context
The question concerns the victims Bill and its impact on those affected by online financial fraud.
Like my hon. Friend the Member for Bosworth (Dr Evans), the Treasury Committee has been hearing about the explosion in online financial fraud. Could my right hon. and learned Friend explain how the victims Bill will help so many of our constituents who are being preyed upon by these financial fraudsters?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right to raise an issue that affects many people. One issue is the embarrassment and shame of people who fall victim to such fraud that they could have been tricked in the first place. Not only is supporting victims to overcome that stigma very much part of the victims code that we introduced in the past month or so, working with the sector, but as we develop the consultation into our new law, there will be opportunities fully to reflect the pernicious nature of online criminality. By helping to design out fraud, the financial services sector can make its greatest contribution to the reduction of such heinous crime.
Assessment & feedback
Specific provisions or timeline not provided.
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Grahame Morris Lab
Easington
Context
The question addresses the lack of a fair pay rise for frontline prison officers.
To return to the questions asked earlier by my hon. Friends the Members for St Helens South and Whiston (Ms Rimmer) and for West Ham (Ms Brown) about the loss of prison officer experience due to experienced prison officers leaving the service, will the Secretary of State confirm whether it was the Chancellor himself who vetoed the fair pay rise for frontline prison officers that was recommended by his own experts?
I remind the hon. Gentleman that in the context of those recommendations, prison officers received rises of between 2.5% and 7.5%. It is right to say that in one specific instance the recommendations of the body were not accepted—we are mindful of our overall duties with regard to the public purse—but I assure the hon. Gentleman that in terms of the recruitment, support and promotion of the vital role of prison officers, the Government will not stint in their unwavering support and encouragement.
Assessment & feedback
Specific confirmation on Chancellor's involvement was not given.
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Richard Fuller Con
North Bedfordshire
Context
The question seeks encouragement from the Minister to expand addiction recovery programmes for low-risk offenders.
Festus Akinbusoye, the inspirational police and crime commissioner for Bedfordshire, has championed the use of addiction recovery programmes for low-risk offenders. Will the Minister tell the House what encouragement he is likely to give to police and crime commissioners to expand the role of such programmes? In particular, what encouragement will he give to Festus for his campaigns?
I join my hon. Friend in celebrating the election of Commissioner Akinbusoye, who is one of the 29 Conservative police and crime commissioners—a full 70% of the available slots were secured by the Conservative party at the elections two weeks ago. My hon. Friend is quite right that police and crime commissioners have a critical role to play in offender management, given that more than half of crime is committed by reoffenders. At the severe end in particular, we know that, on average, all murderers in the country have committed at least seven previous offences. In my role as Policing Minister, I will work closely with police and crime commissioners to make sure that not only as chairs of their local criminal justice board but more widely they can play an important role in driving down reoffending.
Assessment & feedback
Specific encouragement for addiction recovery programmes was not detailed.
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Context
The Scottish Government proposed a 'Bairn's Hoose' initiative to provide comprehensive support under one roof for families and children involved in the criminal justice system.
Will the Secretary of State join me in welcoming the Scottish Government's proposal for a Bairn's Hoose, where families and children would be supported under one roof? Are the UK Government willing to look at this idea?
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman for that suggestion and would be interested in learning more about the specific approach being taken by the Scottish Government. The UK Government's supported accommodation concept is at the heart of efforts regarding young offenders, with smaller units and diversionary work emphasised over the past decade. Incarceration rates for children have dropped from 3,000 to just over 500 in recent years.
Assessment & feedback
Welcoming the Bairn's Hoose proposal or considering it specifically
Would Be Interested To Know More About The Specific Approach Being Taken
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Kevin Hollinrake Con
Thirsk and Malton
Context
The Serious Fraud Office's prosecution of only mid-level managers in the Serco fraud trial highlights a need for legislative changes to tackle corporate-level failure to prevent economic crimes.
Does not the collapse of the Serco fraud trial and prosecuting only mid-level managers highlight the need to bring forward an offence at corporate level for failing to prevent economic crime, and make it criminal?
I pay tribute to my hon. Friend's campaigning on this issue. The Law Commission has been asked for an in-depth review of economic crime law and will publish an options paper later this year, aiming to implement any necessary next steps.
Assessment & feedback
Introducing a specific 'failure to prevent economic crime' offence at corporate level
I Have Always Placed Heavy Emphasis On The Need To Examine The Law Carefully In This Area
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Wera Hobhouse Lib Dem
Bath
Context
The Government's own review warns that changes to judicial review should be made only after careful consideration, highlighting the need for caution in limiting individuals' powers to challenge Government through the courts.
Does the Government intend to listen to their own review and rethink plans to limit individual's powers to challenge Government through judicial review?
We have commissioned an independent review and conducted a public consultation. There will be ample opportunities for debate and scrutiny in this House and the other place before any legislation is finalised, ensuring quality deliberations on the balance between the judiciary, Parliament and the Executive.
Assessment & feedback
Revisiting plans to limit judicial review based on the review's recommendations
There Are Ample Opportunities For All Of Us To Take Part In This Important Process
Response accuracy