Topical Questions 2021-05-27

2021-05-27

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Christine Jardine Lib Dem
Edinburgh West
Context
The MP is asking about the government's focus on recovery efforts, particularly in constituencies such as hers.
We have all heard already this morning about the importance of levelling up in our covid recovery, but in constituencies such as mine, Edinburgh West, it is also important to reinforce and remind people of the strength and support available from the UK Government. Does the Minister for the Cabinet Office agree that it is vital that we remain focused on that and on recovery, and that we do not get side-tracked by the SNP's damaging obsession with independence?
The hon. Lady puts the case in absolutely the right way: we need to focus on recovery. It was good to hear the First Minister stress in our conversation yesterday that she appreciated that that was a priority.
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address the SNP's obsession with independence, only agreed to focus on recovery.
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Christine Jardine Lib Dem
Edinburgh West
Context
The MP is asking about the proper place for learning from the pandemic and whether a Select Committee should be involved in appointing the chair of an independent public inquiry.
Does my right hon. Friend agree that, following yesterday's Wagnerian-length Committee session, the proper place for learning from the pandemic will be in the independent public inquiry announced by our right hon. Friend the Prime Minister? Given that the chair of that inquiry will require the confidence of the nation—and not least that of this House—does the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster agree that that chair should be subject to a pre-appointment scrutiny hearing by the relevant Select Committee?
I am a great fan of Wagner, but I also recognise that the young tenor voice of my hon. Friend as Chairman of the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee is one that deserves to be heard in the debate about how the inquiry should go forward.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address whether a pre-appointment scrutiny hearing is necessary for the chair.
Changed Subject Entirely
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Context
The MP is questioning the government's handling of the pandemic based on testimony heard in committees, particularly regarding Dominic Cummings' claims.
I welcome the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster to our first exchange at the Dispatch Box, but I only wish that it were in better circumstances. The testimony that we heard yesterday has left families across the country wondering what happened to their loved ones and how they died. It has left all of us fearing that the Government have not learned the lessons or taken the action needed to prevent more avoidable loss.
The Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster once said that he had
“reluctantly but firmly”
concluded that the Prime Minister was
“not capable of…leading the party and the country in the way that I would have hoped.”
The Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster knows Dominic Cummings very well as his former chief of staff—better than anyone else in this House. Does he believe him to be a credible and truthful witness?
First, may I welcome the right hon. Lady to her place? She is someone who started her working life on the frontline of social care, who has been a highly effective trade union representative and who has spoken passionately and movingly in this House about the need for greater social mobility and educational reform.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address whether Dominic Cummings is credible or truthful.
Changed Subject Entirely
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Angela Rayner Lab
Ashton-under-Lyne
Context
The MP is questioning the government's handling of the pandemic based on testimony heard in committees, particularly regarding Dominic Cummings' claims.
I thank the Minister for his comments, but learning the right lessons could save lives and the truth matters to us all, so can he tell us which, if any, of the claims made by Dominic Cummings he is now prepared to refute at the Dispatch Box?
I have not had the opportunity to read all the evidence that was given yesterday, and indeed the Speaker has enjoined brevity on me, but I think that the public inquiry that we have been discussing is the right place to review all the evidence from every individual.
Assessment & feedback
Did not refute any of Dominic Cummings' claims specifically.
Redirecting To A Broader Process
Response accuracy
Q5 Direct Answer
Angela Rayner Lab
Ashton-under-Lyne
Context
The MP is discussing the importance of ensuring equal opportunities for all, especially through improving teaching and support for schools and skills programmes in less advantaged regions.
Everyone, no matter where they grow up, should have access to the same opportunities in life. Can my right hon. Friend confirm that a key part of the levelling-up agenda will be to improve teaching and provide support for schools and skills programmes in disadvantaged areas, to ensure that everyone has the opportunity to reach their full potential?
That is exactly it. My hon. Friend is completely right.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Jessica Morden Lab
Newport East
Context
Bereaved parents who lost their children to the contaminated blood scandal are concerned about being omitted from future compensation packages. The Smith family, who tragically lost their son Colin due to infection with blood from Arkansas prison, have raised concerns.
I am concerned that bereaved parents may be omitted from future compensation packages for victims of the contaminated blood scandal, as they were with ex gratia payments. I have written to the Paymaster General about this issue and would like her to meet me and the Smith family who lost their son Colin.
I would be very happy to meet the hon. Lady and any of the victims of this appalling scandal. I raised this issue at the recent meeting of the all-party parliamentary group on haemophilia and contaminated blood, and I want to let all those people who have lost children know that just because we published the written ministerial statement, which made reference to other support for other individuals, that does not mean that they are not at the forefront of our minds.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment to meet the Smith family was not provided
Raising Issue At Recent Meeting Statement About Victims Being At Forefront Of Mind
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Context
Following Lord Pickles' report on electoral fraud, a ten-minute rule Bill was introduced to support the introduction of voter ID.
I have introduced a ten-minute rule Bill to support the introduction of voter ID. Will my right hon. Friend do all he can to ensure that this will be delivered by the local elections next year?
It is a great ten-minute rule Bill, Bolton West is a wonderfully vibrant and diverse community, it has a brilliant local MP, and we are on it.
Assessment & feedback
No specific commitment to implement voter ID for local elections next year
Descriptive Praise Vague Statement
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Afzal Khan Lab
Manchester Rusholme
Context
The Conservative party published the Singh report on Islamophobia within its ranks. The latest hate crime figures reflect a rise in anti-Muslim prejudice.
Earlier this week, the Conservative party finally published the much delayed Singh report on Islamophobia and discrimination within its own ranks. Will the Minister meet me and the Muslim Council of Britain to discuss what action is required to root out Islamophobia from our society?
The hon. Gentleman makes an important point. The Singh report—of which I have not read every word—is clear about the steps that we need to take to root out anti-Muslim prejudice, and it is absolutely critical that we do so.
Assessment & feedback
No commitment to meet MCB
Acknowledgment Of Report Vague Statement
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
As lockdown restrictions are lifted, there is a risk of new covid hotspots emerging in various parts of the country.
It is inevitable that we will see pockets of covid hotspots and variants spread throughout the country. Will my right hon. Friend say now that, wherever possible, we will try to use local measures to suppress these hotspots?
That is a very thoughtful point with which I completely agree.
Assessment & feedback
No specific commitment to use local measures
Agreement Without Specifics
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Context
Mr Cummings testified about the chaos at the heart of Government and the need for an independent inquiry.
The Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster was not mentioned in Mr Cummings' evidence. Will he commission an independent inquiry into the operation of the Cabinet Office during the pandemic?
The broad public inquiry that we have set up—with, of course, consultation with the First Minister of Scotland—will, I hope, look at every aspect of our pandemic response. Although I did not hear all the evidence history, I understand that I was mentioned and the point was made that I got some things wrong.
Assessment & feedback
No commitment to independent inquiry
Reference To Broad Public Inquiry Acknowledgment Of Criticism
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
Levelling up is central to the Government's agenda, with challenges existing across all parts of the UK.
Will my right hon. Friend confirm that he is working right across all Government Departments to ensure that the commitment to levelling up is reflected in their policy agendas?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. We heard earlier from my hon. Friend the Member for St Austell and Newquay about the particular challenges in Cornwall. Challenges exist across the United Kingdom, and as part of our levelling-up drive we are committed to meeting them.
Assessment & feedback
No specific commitment across departments
Agreement General Statement
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Andrew Gwynne Ind
Gorton and Denton
Context
The Government have prioritised spending on PPE over NHS pay rises, with examples of wasteful expenditures.
My right hon. Friend highlighted how levelling up is central to the Government's agenda. The same Government spent £250 million on unusable facemasks, £133 million on faulty testing kits and £2.6 million on a briefing room at No. 10. Are their priorities wrong?
I do not think so, but the hon. Gentleman raises an important point: we should thank those at the frontline of the NHS for the amazing work they have done. Part of supporting them is making sure that they have the right personal protective equipment.
Assessment & feedback
No acknowledgment of wrong priorities
Acknowledgment Of Point Description Of Ppe Importance
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
The UK steel sector is interconnected and concerns about removing safeguards on certain products that could affect jobs. The question references the importance of promoting UK steel in government projects.
My right hon. Friend will know that the UK steel sector is interconnected and that removing steel safeguards on certain products could affect UK steel businesses and jobs. At this crucial time for the UK steel industry, will he outline what steps his Department is taking to promote the use of our world-class UK steel in Government projects and down the supply chain?
My hon. Friend makes an important point. There is a proud tradition of steelmaking in Scunthorpe and she is absolutely right to draw attention to the importance of the issue. My colleagues in the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy have established a new joint industry and governmental steel procurement taskforce, which was launched on 12 March.
Assessment & feedback
Specific steps beyond mentioning the launch date were not provided
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Debbie Abrahams Lab
Oldham East and Saddleworth
Context
The question references the collapse of construction company Carillion in 2018 which led to insolvency of 780 businesses and losses for thousands more. The issue of project bank accounts is raised as a potential preventative measure.
I was rather taken aback by the Minister saying earlier that the Government are doing all they can to support small businesses. The collapse of the construction giant Carillion in 2018 saw 780 businesses go into insolvency, while the thousands that survived—including that of Neil Skinner, whose business is in my Oldham constituency—averaged losses of more than £140,000. If the Government had implemented project bank accounts, they would have prevented many of the losses. Given that, and the Minister's response to my written questions, why is the Cabinet Office no longer monitoring the extent of the use of PBAs across Government?
The hon. Lady raises an important point and I look forward to the opportunity to perhaps meet her to discuss exactly how we can improve the way in which the Cabinet Office supports small businesses.
Assessment & feedback
No explanation provided for the cessation of monitoring PBAs
Changing Subject
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Context
The question is about the future implications of Brexit for Yorkshire, particularly Rother Valley, in terms of trade opportunities and funding.
As my right hon. Friend knows, I am a strong proponent of the enormous new benefits that Brexit brings all of Yorkshire in international trade and funding, which we see more and more every day. Will he give his thoughts on what Brexit means for Yorkshire in the long term, particularly what it means for Rother Valley?
Rother Valley is a centre of enterprise in South Yorkshire, and it contains brilliant businessmen such as Mr Don Wightman, who is a manufacturing superhero. He, like his Member of Parliament, recognises that the new trade opportunities that Brexit brings, and indeed the new opportunities for smarter regulation, mean that enterprises in Rother Valley and across Yorkshire have a very bright future.
Assessment & feedback
No specific long-term implications were provided
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Context
The question is about the Cabinet Office's monitoring of public appointments, particularly regarding the Ofcom chair position. There are concerns that the appointment process has been scrapped and rules may be rewritten for a specific candidate.
Perhaps the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster should have read the warning signs when Dominic Cummings used to sign in at his Department, when he was Secretary of State for Education, under the name Osama bin Laden. That might have been the moment when he could have dealt with the issue. On the right hon. Gentleman's responsibility on public appointments, what is going on with that of Ofcom chair? We read in the paper today that, apparently, the appointment process has been scrapped and is to be restarted because Paul Dacre failed under the current rules, so those rules are being rewritten so he can apply a second time and be appointed.
Public appointments to Ofcom are of course a matter for my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport. I should say that the hon. Gentleman would be a superb chair of Ofcom, given the range of experience that he brings.
Assessment & feedback
No information provided on current state of appointments process
Changing Subject
Response accuracy
Q17 Direct Answer
Context
The question is about support for the Prime Minister, with reference to recent comments made by Dominic Cummings. The issue of whether the Prime Minister or Cummings are correct in their statements.
Yesterday, Mr Cummings said the Prime Minister was not fit for office and had been lying. I believe and support the Prime Minister. Does the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster agree that the Prime Minister is right, or Mr Cummings?
I think the Prime Minister is absolutely right. I think my right hon. Friend has been doing a great job as Secretary of State for Health and Social Care.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q18 Direct Answer
Caroline Nokes Con
Romsey and Southampton North
Context
The question is about the Government's commitment to including people with visible differences in their publications, referencing a Welsh Government pledge to do so.
Changing Faces has convinced the Welsh Government to sign up to its Pledge To Be Seen campaign on including people with visible differences and disfigurements in Government publications. Will my right hon. Friend consider doing likewise so that Government information campaigns across the UK are as inclusive as possible?
My right hon. Friend is a great champion of widening opportunity and has done a fantastic job in ensuring that equality is taken more seriously across Government. The campaign that she mentions is absolutely right, and something that I will ensure we embrace in Government publications.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy