Topical Questions 2021-05-24

2021-05-24

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Context
The MP references a manifesto commitment to address vexatious claims against armed forces personnel.
Legislating to tackle vexatious claims and put our brave armed forces personnel first was a manifesto commitment of this Government, and a landmark piece of legislation that I was proud to support. Does my right hon. Friend agree with me that legislation needs to be brought forward to protect our Northern Ireland veterans and address the legacy of the troubles?
The Government are committed to bringing forward measures. Those measures were mentioned in the Queen's Speech, and we will obviously publish them as soon as possible.
Assessment & feedback
Specific timeline for publishing legislation not provided
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
John Healey Lab
Rawmarsh and Conisbrough
Context
The MP endorses the Defence Secretary's condemnation of Belarusian authorities' actions and asks for assurances on decision-making processes. The MP also questions the MOD's management of its funding.
May I, from the Opposition Benches, strongly endorse the concern and condemnation the Defence Secretary has expressed over the actions of the Belarus authorities? May I also say that we strongly support the work of Operation Tangham, but in the light of recent press stories, can I ask the Defence Secretary for his assurance that if he takes any decision to commit combat troops to Somalia, he will report such a decision to this House first?
May I ask about the Army's fighting vehicles? The Defence Secretary wrote off over £1 billion of taxpayers' money in March when he scrapped the Warrior. Weekend reports say that the MOD has also paid out £3.2 billion for the Ajax, and so far received only a dozen delivered, and those without turrets. A figure of £4 billion is the total size of the Government's levelling-up fund over the next four years. Given that the Secretary of State has conceded this afternoon that delivery is the MOD's Achilles heel, will he accept that Parliament now needs a system of special measures for the MOD so that British forces and the British taxpayer get much better value from his Department?
I think the right hon. Member is looking at the special measure. The reason I am here as the Secretary of State for Defence is to get the record level of investment that will put right not only five years or 10 years, but 20 years of mismanagement of these programmes.
Assessment & feedback
Specific system of special measures not addressed
Response accuracy
Q3 Direct Answer
Context
The MP welcomes the recent deployment of Royal Navy offshore patrol vessels to Jersey.
Thank you Mr Speaker. I welcome the recent deployment of Royal Navy offshore patrol vessels to Jersey, to conduct maritime security patrols. Does my right hon. Friend agree that that quick response demonstrates the importance of having our Royal Navy vessels more continuously deployed at sea?
I certainly do. Offshore patrol vessels are an extraordinarily versatile platform. Batch 1 OPVs, which are mostly responsible for homeland defence, are at high readiness and are called out for all sorts of reasons, from Jersey, to escorting vessels from other nations through our waters.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Jessica Morden Lab
Newport East
Context
The MP expresses concern about Afghan interpreters and their family reunification issues under the MOD resettlement scheme.
With UK forces leaving Afghanistan, it is all the more important that we do all we can to stand up for those Afghan interpreters, and others, who put their lives on the line for our troops. I have Afghan interpreters in my constituency who have not seen their wives and children for years, due to ongoing issues with the MOD resettlement scheme. Will the Minister admit that that is an issue, and work with the Home Office to sort it out?
Yes, it is an issue, and the Home Secretary and I have worked closely over the past year. We have already changed some of the reasons, to ensure that we bring back more, and in light of the withdrawal, we are working incredibly hard together to see what more we can do.
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions or timeline not provided
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Context
The question arises from the context of supporting defence jobs, particularly in Scunthorpe.
I am pleased to hear what the Department is doing to support defence jobs. Does the Minister agree that promoting the use of world-class UK-made steel in MOD projects would be an excellent support to jobs in Scunthorpe?
Although defence represents a small element of total demand, UK steel has made a significant contribution to it, including the Queen Elizabeth aircraft carrier. Although this is generally a decision for defence primes, we ensure that information is shared as part of our processes, and we encourage the resourcing of UK steel wherever possible.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not explicitly confirm or deny the promotion of UK-made steel in MOD projects to support Scunthorpe jobs.
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Toby Perkins Lab
Chesterfield
Context
The Prime Minister's promise during the 2019 election not to cut the armed services contradicts the current integrated review that funds fewer personnel.
During the 2019 election, The Prime Minister promised that he would not cut the armed service “in any form”, yet the integrated review funds another 10,000 fewer in our armed forces by 2025. We can have an interesting discussion about whether or not force strength is the best use of that money, but does it fundamentally undermine confidence in our democracy when the Government seek election promising to protect the size of our armed forces, knowing full well that they have no intention of doing any such thing?
The Government always go into elections dealing with the threat as they see it. The threat has changed, and it is incredibly important that we do the right thing in responding to that threat. It is the duty of Government members to ensure that if the facts on the battlefield change, so do we.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not address whether undermining confidence in democracy occurs when promises made during an election are not kept.
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Context
The Ministry of Defence announced the procurement of Challenger 3 tanks.
I welcome my right hon. Friend's recent announcement that the Ministry of Defence will procure 148 Challenger 3 tanks, which will be the UK's first digitised tanks. Will he outline how those new armoured vehicles will help to deliver the modern, adaptable and expeditionary fighting force that he set out in the defence Command Paper in March, and will he keep me in mind should they need test-driving?
I will bear that offer in mind. It is a great decision for UK industry, especially for the west midlands, and a great decision for the British Army. The ability to deploy world-class tanks provides policy choice for policymakers against a range of threats in our uncertain world and state of the art Challenger 3s will be a vital asset.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide specific details on how the tanks support the UK's defence strategy.
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Mohammad Yasin Lab
Bedford
Context
The integrated review aims to capitalise on science and technology resources, but there are concerns about facilities and equipment.
The world-class Cranfield University is committed to assisting the goals set out in the integrated review regarding sustaining strategic advantage through science and technology. How do the Government propose to capitalise on their science and technology resource investment if the large-scale complex and secure facilities and equipment have not been invested in, so are not in place to conduct the research?
I am not certain if I would agree with the premise of the question. We will be investing over £6.6 billion in research and development over the next four years. We have, through the frontline commands and through defence science and technology, extensive contacts with our universities. They work with us closely.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not address how facilities and equipment are lacking for research investment.
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
Residents in North Norfolk have expressed concerns about low-flying military aircraft training.
Over the past year or so, my office has been inundated with concerns from residents about low-flying military aircraft all over North Norfolk. Let me be the first person to understand that we need military training to keep us safe, but would the Minister perhaps meet me to discuss further how we can allay those concerns and work out a communication plan for my residents?
I am glad my hon. Friend used the phrase he did. We need to keep our brave air crews safe from harm as they go out every day to keep us safe, and that they get to that level of proficiency through training. However, we always want to do that causing the minimum amount of inconvenience and disturbance. I will willingly meet my hon. Friend to discuss the issue.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not address how concerns about low-flying military aircraft would be allayed.
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Nick Smith Lab
Blaenau Gwent and Rhymney
Context
The number of infantry battalions with less than 70% fully deployable soldiers is a matter of concern.
Can the Secretary of State say how many infantry battalions have less than 70% fully deployable soldiers?
I can write to the hon. Gentleman in detail if he would like. Does he mean deployable or does he mean trade trained strength, because there are a number of different measures? Most soldiers who are trade trained are deployable unless they are on a course.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide specific figures for infantry battalions with less than 70% fully deployable soldiers.
Procedural Response
Response accuracy
Q11 Direct Answer
Context
The RAF contributed to an operation in April, clearing Daesh terrorists from the Makhmur mountain region.
I welcome recent reports that the RAF contributed to an important 10-day operation in April, clearing Daesh terrorists from the Makhmur mountain region, which is a Daesh stronghold in northern Iraq. With approximately 10,000 Daesh terrorists still at large across Syria, will my right hon. Friend confirm that the UK remains committed to Operation Shader?
The Government are committed to Operation Shader and will continue to be so. The threat of ISIS has not gone away.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Chris Elmore Lab
Bridgend
Context
There has been a delay in the roll-out of veterans' ID cards, affecting existing veterans.
I congratulate the new Veterans Minister on his promotion to the Ministry of Defence. In doing so, may I ask him to resolve an issue that I was told six months ago would be sorted out, which is the roll-out of the veterans' ID card? This has been rolled out to personnel leaving the armed forces, but not to existing veterans. It was announced by his predecessor-but-two. His predecessor told me it would be resolved in due course. Six months on, it would be good if veterans in my Ogmore constituency and across the UK had an answer.
I recognise that this is an important issue. This is taking too long, so I look forward to reporting back to the hon. Gentleman with an update on progress.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide a specific timeline for when existing veterans would receive their ID cards.
Procedural Response
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
The delivery of the fifth Astute class nuclear submarine was delayed by several years, leading to increased costs. This has raised concerns about whether the project can meet its 2026 deadline.
The fifth Astute class nuclear submarine was delivered a month ago after many delays and ballooning costs over the last half decade. Given those delays, will the Secretary of State clarify if he still believes that these submarines can be delivered by the MOD by the current deadline of 2026? Can he give us assurances that there will be no further increase in cost?
We will continue with the Astute programme. There were delays in some parts of the programme, but we are managing it closely to ensure BAE Systems in Barrow-in-Furness can deliver the submarines on time.
Assessment & feedback
Specific assurances against further cost increases and a definitive clarification on meeting deadlines
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Context
Capita, which provides firefighting services at the Faslane nuclear base, plans to reduce its firefighter staff by 15%. This has raised safety concerns given the proximity of the site to Scotland's largest city.
Over the past two years, there have been 443 nuclear site event reports at the Faslane nuclear base. Capita, which provides specialist firefighting services on site, plans to reduce the number of firefighters by 15%, a move that has been branded as an accident waiting to happen by the Unite trade union. Will Ministers intervene to reverse these cuts, given the obvious security and safety concerns this reduction raises?
Before making the decision to reduce firefighters by 15%, extensive discussions were held with the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service, and exercises were conducted to ensure safety. The new system was signed off by HQs and the base commander, reflecting improved fire prevention measures. New firefighting vehicles are also being introduced this year.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to reverse the cuts or address specific concerns directly
Response accuracy