PMQs 2021-06-16

2021-06-16

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Context
The Prime Minister praised the collaborative nature of the G7 summit, focusing on upholding international rules-based systems.
I know that the Prime Minister will report to the House in more detail later on the G7 summit. In taking forward the agenda—in particular, the part of the agenda of the summit that calls for us to work to uphold the rule of law and respect for an international rules-based system—will the Prime Minister bear in mind and task all parts of the Government to promote the great asset that we have in English common law, and in the expertise and reputation for integrity of our judiciary and legal systems? Will he make sure that those willing assets are harnessed in the pursuit of that G7 agenda?
My hon. Friend raises an important and vital sector of our economy—our legal services industry and judicial system, which is admired around the world. It is one of the reasons that we are capable of attracting so much inward investment to this country and one of the key exports that we have been able to promote just recently—thanks, for instance, to our free trade deal with Australia.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not explicitly task all parts of the Government to promote English common law or its judicial system in the pursuit of the G7 agenda.
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The fourth anniversary of the Grenfell fire was marked, with over 200 high-rise flats still having cladding issues.
This week also marks the fourth anniversary of the Grenfell fire tragedy. It is frankly an outrage that there are still more than 200 high-rise flats with Grenfell-style cladding and many leaseholders trapped in homes neither safe nor sellable. The best way to mark this tragedy is not with words, but with action. I urge the Prime Minister finally to end the cladding scandal.
No. Captain Hindsight needs to adjust his retrospectoscope, because he is completely wrong. We put India on the red list on 23 April, and the delta variant was not so identified until 28 April and was only identified as a variant of concern on 7 May.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address the cladding issues or take action to resolve them.
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister was questioned about the UK's decision to keep borders open, leading to higher rates of the delta variant.
This is absurd. I have, on seven occasions at PMQs, raised the question of the borders with the Prime Minister. They are all marked up in the transcript; they are all there in Hansard, Prime Minister. It is time for a better defence: your defence is as bad as your border policy.
There is a very simple reason why the UK generally has a better understanding of the variants in these countries: we do 47% of the genomic testing in the world.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not provide an explanation for high rates of the delta variant.
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister was questioned again about the UK's decision to keep borders open, leading to higher rates of the delta variant.
The question was: what is the Prime Minister's explanation for our high rates of the delta variant? Answer came there none, other than that, apparently, we understand the variants. The data is very, very clear. Our NHS has been doing an amazing job with the vaccine roll-out, but while the NHS was vaccinating, the Prime Minister was vacillating.
For the ease of the House, the right hon. and learned Gentleman should begin by pulping his document in which he incorrectly identifies what the delta variant is. We took the most drastic steps possible to put India on the red list on 23 April, before that variant was even identified.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not provide a clear explanation for high rates of the delta variant.
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The delta variant is responsible for 90% of infections in the country. The current traffic light system has been criticized for not being effective.
I am concerned about the Prime Minister's handling of border security and travel restrictions due to the delta variant. Despite the situation, he continues with a traffic light system that is ineffective. What do we know? Will the government drop this system, secure borders properly, and take action to save the British summer?
The right hon. and learned Gentleman does not even know what the delta variant is. We have the toughest border measures anywhere in the world, and we will continue. We have 50 countries on the red list.
Assessment & feedback
Prime Minister did not address dropping traffic light system or securing borders better
Does Not Know What Delta Variant Is Claims To Have Toughest Border Measures
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister's decision on the red list led to a significant number of people coming from India, causing issues with the delta variant. Businesses are facing difficulties due to these decisions.
I have learned that as the situation worsens for the PM, his response becomes more inadequate. The decision not to put India on the red list earlier was flawed, leading to the spread of the delta variant. In Wales, support measures like business rate relief and new supports are being provided by the Labour Government. When will similar support be offered in England?
We are proud of the support we have given to businesses up and down the country. The whole point about the cautious approach we are taking is to continue support with furlough, support through business rates, support through grants of up to £18,000.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify whether additional measures like extended relief would be provided in England
We Are Proud Of The Support We Have Given Emphasis On Cautious Approach
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister's indecision regarding travel restrictions has led to economic losses for hospitality businesses, according to UKHospitality. The Federation of Small Businesses warns that the government is being dangerously complacent.
In light of the decision taken this week by the PM, the sector will lose £3 billion and 200,000 jobs could be at risk due to delays in reopening. Despite these warnings, the PM continues his indecision on borders leading to economic uncertainty. After all the failures and mistakes, why should anyone believe him now?
Why should anybody believe the Leader of the Opposition when he cannot decide what he thinks from one week to the next? He says he has a tough position on borders. Actually, he was attacking quarantine only recently, and saying that it was a “blunt instrument” that should be lessened.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address why people should trust him given past failures
Claims Opposition Lacks Consistency Says He Is Getting On With The Job
Response accuracy
Q8 Direct Answer
Context
Reports indicate that doctors and care settings issued an unprecedented number of DNR orders to patients with learning disabilities and mental health issues, leading to avoidable deaths. Despite guidance, such practices continue.
Doctors and care settings have issued unlawful do not resuscitate orders to patients with learning disabilities and mental illness, causing avoidable deaths. Last week, Sonia Deleon died unresuscitated without her family's knowledge or consent. Are you alarmed about these cases and do you agree they should be independently investigated?
I thank my hon. Friend for raising this very sad case with me, and I am sure the whole House will be thinking of Sonia Deleon and her family. Such decisions on “do not resuscitate” should be made only in accordance with a decision involving the person concerned and their carers and families.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
Concerns about the impact of the UK-Australia trade agreement on Scottish farmers and crofters. The questioner references previous statements by Jo Cox MP and recent events involving journalist Nick Watt.
Can I associate myself with remarks made by others on the death of Jo Cox? We must stand up for journalists' safety. Ahead of Scotland-England football match, I hope Scotland is not dragged out of Euros against its wishes. The Prime Minister's WhatsApp communication and derogatory comments about Health Secretary are in question. Details of the UK-Australia trade deal are being concealed. 35,000 tonnes of Australian beef and 25,000 tonnes of Australian lamb will be tariff-free from day one. Will the PM confirm this?
This is a great deal for Scotland. The SNP does not realise that £350 million-worth of UK food already goes from this country to Australia. This deal turbocharges those exports, benefiting Scottish farming.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not confirm whether 35,000 tonnes of Australian beef and 25,000 tonnes of Australian lamb will enter the UK market free of tariffs from day one.
Talks About Benefits To Scottish Farming Without Addressing Tariff Specifics
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Context
The UK Government's assessment states the Australian deal is worth just “0.02% of GDP”. The deal benefits Australia's economy by $1.3 billion a year.
In desperation to get a post-Brexit trade deal, the Government has given away too much. This deal is clearly beneficial for Australia ($1.3 billion annually) but worth only 0.02% of UK GDP. There has been no scrutiny, consultation, or consent for farmers and crofters. If confident about the benefits, will the Prime Minister put it to a vote in this House?
The people voted for this Government to deliver free trade deals around the world. The right hon. Gentleman's position is out of touch, suggesting going back into the EU and losing control over fisheries and agriculture.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address whether he will put it to a vote in Parliament
Challenging The Questioner'S Position Rather Than Answering
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
The High Peak region has some of the worst broadband coverage gaps in the UK. The kickstart scheme was successful, but more focused support for key industries is needed.
High Peak has some of the worst broadband coverage gaps due to unique geography. We are making progress, but I urge redoubling efforts on ultrafast broadband roll-out, especially to rural areas. Can we build on the kickstart scheme to recruit new generations of skilled engineers for this purpose?
We are working with industry to accelerate rural network coverage. UK coverage has increased thanks to our steps.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specifically commit to recruiting a new generation of broadband engineers in High Peak or building on the kickstart scheme for this purpose
Discussed Progress But Did Not Address Specific Ask
Response accuracy
Q12 Direct Answer
Context
Concerns about the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 and its impact on Northern Ireland's trading relationship within the UK internal market.
The passing of the EU Withdrawal Act 2018 and the Northern Ireland protocol does not imply repeal of Article 6, which enables free trade for Northern Ireland with rest of UK. Will the Prime Minister commit to restoring Northern Ireland's place in the UK internal market?
Yes. Unless we see progress on protocol implementation, which I think is disproportionate, we will take necessary steps to restore Northern Ireland's place in UK internal market.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13 Direct Answer
David Simmonds Con
Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner
Context
The rebuild of Hillingdon Hospital will be beneficial for constituents. There is a need to secure future services at Mount Vernon Hospital in Ruislip.
Does my right hon. Friend agree that rebuilding Hillingdon Hospital will benefit his and my constituents? Will he commit to working with me, other local MPs, and potential future MPs like Peter Fleet to ensure the future of services at Mount Vernon Hospital is protected?
My hon. Friend is right about Hillingdon Hospital's great future. I look forward to working with him to ensure that services at Mount Vernon are also protected, a full consultation due to start in September.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Layla Moran Lib Dem
Oxford West and Abingdon
Context
Keith, a hotel manager, contacted the MP about chronic staff shortages due to pandemic-related uncertainty and post-Brexit immigration issues. The Oxfordshire economy relies on £2.5 billion from the hospitality sector.
Keith, a local hotel manager, is worried that his business cannot recover fully despite reopening plans because of severe staffing issues caused by Brexit and the pandemic. He cannot recruit EU staff anymore or find replacements from abroad due to restrictive immigration policies. The hospitality industry in Oxfordshire contributes £2.5 billion annually to the economy. Will the Government introduce a covid recovery visa for Keith's sector?
We will maintain an open and flexible approach towards allowing talent from overseas, but there is no specific mention of a 'covid recovery visa'. The government wants young people and furloughed workers to fill available jobs.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the request for a specific visa program
Open And Flexible Approach
Response accuracy
Q15 Direct Answer
Context
The UK's shellfish industry faces potential export challenges due to delayed FSA water quality grading. The current timeline is September, and the MP seeks a more immediate resolution.
Will the Prime Minister expedite the FSA report on shellfish water quality grades to ensure timely reclassification of waters for better exports? This could significantly benefit the UK's shellfish industry which relies heavily on EU markets.
The Prime Minister will do everything possible to expedite the FSA report and recommendations, aiming for an earlier completion date than September as requested by the MP. This would help improve export opportunities.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Context
The UK's new trade agreement with Australia has sparked concerns among the National Farmers Union Scotland, who fear adverse impacts on Scottish agriculture and industries due to lack of consultation.
Does the Prime Minister acknowledge the NFU Scotland president's concerns about the UK-Australia deal being rushed through without parliamentary scrutiny or consent from affected parties?
The Prime Minister dismissed SNP criticisms and highlighted opportunities for Scottish industries under the trade agreement. He did not specifically address concerns about consultation and consent.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address concerns over lack of consultation or consent
Different Type Of Mp Missed Point
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Context
The MP questions the Prime Minister's decision-making regarding coronavirus restrictions, particularly in light of lower deaths compared to the five-year average and criticism from a SAGE member.
Given recent statistics showing lower overall UK deaths despite the presence of the Indian variant, why does the PM prefer to trust Professor Susan Michie over his own vaccine programme and public opinion?
The Prime Minister explained that he trusts in the effectiveness of the vaccination program, despite criticisms from certain individuals. He believes more time is needed to vaccinate a larger population.
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address trust in SAGE vs vaccine data
Giving It A Little More Time
Response accuracy
Q18 Direct Answer
Context
A constituent faces repeated cancellations of his driving theory test and is concerned about delaying start of university studies in paramedic science.
Ross, a Hamilton resident starting paramedic training this September, has been invited to sit his theory test in Oban, 100 miles away. This follows two previous cancellations in November and February. Will the Prime Minister meet with me to discuss these delays?
The Prime Minister acknowledged the issue and confirmed efforts are underway to address it by increasing numbers of driving instructors and testers.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q19 Direct Answer
Julian Smith Con
Skipton and Ripon
Context
The MP supports the Prime Minister's statements about Jo Cox and Sir Roy Stone. He emphasizes Northern Ireland's need for a stable, functioning government following recent challenges.
Does the PM agree that it is crucial to adhere to 'New Decade, New Approach' agreements in Northern Ireland? What action will be taken if these agreements are not upheld?
The PM supports the approach outlined by the MP regarding adherence to 'New Decade, New Approach' and emphasizes the importance of a stable Northern Ireland Executive.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Context
The role of the Lord Advocate in Scotland is under scrutiny due to structural flaws.
A new Lord Advocate has taken up position, but the structural flaws in the office remain. In no other legal jurisdiction in the UK, or indeed in the western world, is the Government's senior legal adviser simultaneously the country's chief prosecutor; yet the role is enshrined in the Scotland Act 1998. Will the Prime Minister commit to changes so that that historical anachronism can be changed and a separation of powers achieved?
First, I congratulate the hon. Gentleman on the outstanding success of his party in the recent elections. I will study the anomaly that he raises and revert to him as soon as possible.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to changes for separation of powers was not given
Congratulating The Hon. Gentleman On His Party'S Success
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Context
The Taskforce on Innovation, Growth and Regulatory Reform report was published today.
May I welcome the Taskforce on Innovation, Growth and Regulatory Reform report, published today by my right hon. Friends the Members for Chingford and Woodford Green (Sir Iain Duncan Smith) and for Chipping Barnet (Theresa Villiers) and my hon. Friend the Member for Mid Norfolk (George Freeman)? The report makes recommendations about how to seize new opportunities from Brexit and back start-ups and new tech. Will my right hon. Friend the Prime Minister look closely at that report so that we can make the most of the great benefits of Brexit and lead the world in the development of new technologies?
Yes. I thank my hon. and right hon. Friends for their excellent report, and I think it is time to put a TIGRR in the tank.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to looking closely at the report was not given
Referencing Putting A Tigrr In The Tank
Response accuracy
Q22 Partial Answer
Helen Hayes Lab
Dulwich and West Norwood
Context
A fire at an east London block of flats caused hospitalisation for three people, highlighting the ongoing issue with Grenfell-style cladding.
I associate myself with the remarks concerning the fifth anniversary of the murder of Jo Cox. Jo was a dear personal friend and colleague, who will always be missed and remembered, and whose extraordinary legacy endures far beyond this place. Last month, a fire in an east London block of flats caused three people to be hospitalised and dozens more to be treated for smoke inhalation. That block was one of more than 200 high-rise buildings in England still fitted with Grenfell-style cladding. I ask the Prime Minister why it is that four years after the Grenfell tragedy took 72 lives, and after all the warnings, all the tireless campaigning and the unspeakable injustice, people are still living in unsafe flats, and his Government have failed to end the cladding scandal.
We have invested massively in removing cladding from high-rise blocks, and we will continue to do so. I know the structure in question and I do believe that Ballymore, the company concerned, has been too slow. We are on its case.
Assessment & feedback
Explanation of why people are still living in unsafe flats was not given
Noting The Actions Taken
Response accuracy
Q23 Partial Answer
Paul Holmes Con
Hamble Valley
Context
Independent lifeboat stations such as Hamble Lifeboat respond to over 100 incidents a year in the Solent.
Independent lifeboat stations such as the Hamble lifeboat in my constituency respond to over 100 incidents a year in the Solent. The pandemic has increased the operating costs of independent lifeboat stations while also restricting their ability to raise money. Will the Prime Minister look to see what more the Government can do to support independent lifeboat stations such as the Hamble lifeboat as they keep a watchful eye on all of us?
I thank my hon. Friend for raising the excellent work of Hamble lifeboat. In April last year, my right hon Friend the Chancellor put forward another £750 million in support of charities such as that one.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment to look at ways to support was not given
Mentioning Past Support
Response accuracy
Q24 Partial Answer
Context
Staff at Blue Dog and AdLib in Glasgow have had no furlough payments since the summer of last year.
Staff at two hospitality venues in Glasgow, Blue Dog and AdLib, have had no furlough payments since the summer of last year. Although I have raised this with HMRC directly, the situation still has not moved forward. If I send the Prime Minister the details, will he knock heads together; help the staff, whose bills are going unpaid and debts are rising; and get the cash that they are entitled to into their accounts?
I am very happy to look at it.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment to address the issue was not given
Promising To Look At It
Response accuracy
Q25 Partial Answer
Context
The questioner is concerned about the resumption of SAGE members' media appearances.
When can we expect the co-ordinated chorus of SAGE members recommencing their media appearances to depress morale, and does my right hon. Friend fear having to give another press conference at which he again postpones the return of our freedoms? We are rightly told that we need to learn to live with covid, so what can the Prime Minister say to the country to convince us of that reality?
Academic and scientific freedom are an invaluable part of our country, and I note that my scientific colleagues would echo my sentiment that we need to learn to live with covid.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to convincing the public was not given
Defending Academic Freedom
Response accuracy
Q26 Partial Answer
Context
A constituent faces £1,000 nursery arrears due to the two-child cap and childcare proof of payment rules.
The Government's two- child cap and childcare proof of payment rules mean that my hard-working constituent, Ms Cowan, who is a single parent on universal credit supporting four kids, faces £1,000 of nursery arrears. She is therefore at risk of losing the kids' nursery places, as a result of which she would have to give up work and would therefore be at risk of sanction and forced further into debt and poverty. Can the Prime Minister help my constituent out of this trap and fix these rules that are pushing people out of work and into poverty?
I would be happy to study the case, but the whole point of universal credit, which this Government introduced, is that it is helping hundreds of thousands of people into work. That is its success.
Assessment & feedback
Specific help for Ms Cowan was not given
Promoting The Benefits Of Universal Credit
Response accuracy
Q27 Direct Answer
Context
Kevin Sinfield has been awarded an OBE for his work raising awareness of motor neurone disease.
I associate myself with the comments of the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition about our friend Jo Cox. Will the Prime Minister join me in congratulating rugby league legend Kevin Sinfield on his OBE in the Queen's birthday honours? Kevin has done so much to raise awareness of motor neurone disease and support his good friend Rob Burrow. MND is a devastating disease. There is no cure, but scientists believe they are on the cusp of developing effective treatments. Will the Government please commit to investing £50 million over five years to establish a virtual MND research institute and to accelerate research?
Thank you, Mr Speaker. It is an OBE, and I thank Kevin Sinfield very much for his outstanding work. We are following it up by spending £55 million on research into MND, but there will be more to come as part of our general massive investment in life sciences.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q28 Partial Answer
Context
The RSPCA warned that the Prime Minister's trade deal with Australia will start a race to the bottom in terms of animal welfare standards, affecting billions of farmed animals and UK farmers negatively.
Simply put, the trade deal means undercutting our farmers and short-changing consumers. The RSPCA has said that the deal 'will start a race to the bottom and the losers will be billions of farmed animals and UK farmers.' Does the Prime Minister accept these concerns from the experts at the RSPCA?
I really think that these constant attacks on Australia, its standards and its animal welfare standards will be very much resented by the people of Australia, and will not be recognised. Australia is marked five out of five for animal welfare by the World Organisation for Animal Health performance of veterinary services evaluation team. This deal incorporates high animal welfare standards as part of the package that Australia has agreed.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not directly address the specific concerns raised by the RSPCA about setting animal welfare standards back.
Attacking Australia'S Standards
Response accuracy
Q29 Partial Answer
Context
Noel Conway, an assisted dying campaigner, has died after taking the decision to have his breathing support removed.
Will my right hon. Friend join me in paying tribute to Noel Conway and does my right hon. Friend agree that it is now time for Parliament to properly consider the law on assisted dying?
I thank my hon. Friend, and I know that the whole House will be in sympathy with Noel Conway's family and friends. There are very deeply and sincerely held views on both sides of this matter, and a change in the law would obviously be one for Parliament to consider.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not explicitly agree or disagree about the timing of reconsidering the law on assisted dying but acknowledged it as a matter for Parliament's consideration.
Response accuracy
Q30 Partial Answer
Context
There are concerns from stakeholders that the Prime Minister's negotiations with Australia for a trade deal may negatively impact Scottish farmers and crofters, despite the lack of benefits compared to European markets post-Brexit.
Why is the Prime Minister willing to put the livelihoods of farmers and crofters across Scotland in peril for a shoddy trade deal with Australia, which will not even cover 1% of the lost opportunities to Europe's markets that we have lost through Brexit?
We have not lost opportunities to Europe's markets through Brexit.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address concerns about Scottish farmers or the trade deal's benefit compared to European market access.
Changing Subject
Response accuracy
Q31 Direct Answer
Ben Spencer Con
Runnymede and Weybridge
Context
The Government has signed off the outline business case for a River Thames flooding alleviation scheme which will protect homes and businesses from flooding.
In 2014, Runnymede and Weybridge was hit by devastating floods. The Government signed off the outline business case for the River Thames flooding alleviation scheme last week, allowing detailed design and planning to begin. Will the Prime Minister join me in celebrating this progress?
My hon. Friend is completely right. The £1 million River Thames scheme will reduce the flood risk for 11,000 homes and 16,000 businesses.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy