PMQs 2021-09-15

2021-09-15

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Caroline Nokes Con
Romsey and Southampton North
Context
The Cumberlege report was published with recommendations including financial support for the parents of disabled children impacted by sodium valproate. However, on the last day before summer recess, recommendation 4 which proposed financial redress was not actioned.
I would like to pass on my condolences to the Prime Minister on the sad loss of his mother. Raising children is very expensive—more so when they are disabled. The children impacted by sodium valproate have suffered physically, mentally and indeed financially. When the Cumberlege report was published, there was real hope that they would get support. However, on the last day before the summer recess, a written ministerial statement indicated that recommendation 4 of that report would not be actioned. May I please ask my right hon. Friend to urge the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care to look again at that and give the parents of those children the financial redress that they so desperately need?
I thank my right hon. Friend for her kind words. On her substantive point, she is entirely right to raise the issues investigated by Baroness Cumberlege. We have given the report full consideration, accept its overarching conclusions and are committed to making rapid progress in addressing all the areas that it mentions, including the one that my right hon. Friend covered today.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment on financial redress under recommendation 4 was not addressed
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister is planning to cut universal credit, impacting families on the minimum wage. The question aims to quantify how many additional hours a single parent would need to work weekly to compensate for this reduction.
I join the Prime Minister in his comments about Emma Raducanu—a tremendous success in the US Open—the Battle of Britain and the G7 Speakers conference. May I also offer my condolences to the Prime Minister on the loss of his mother? As I know at first hand, losing a parent is never easy. How many extra hours a week would a single parent working full-time on the minimum wage have to work to get back the £20 a week that the Prime Minister plans to take away from them in his universal credit cuts?
First of all, I thank the right hon. and learned Gentleman for his kind words. On his substantive point about universal credit, it is absurd, because the Labour party—[Interruption.] I will give you a statistic, Mr Speaker: every single recipient of universal credit would lose their benefits under Labour, because it wants to abolish universal credit. I think that this House and this Government should be very proud of what we are doing and continue to do to support the low-paid.
Assessment & feedback
Number of extra hours needed to compensate for universal credit cut was not addressed
Changing Subject To Labour'S Policies
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions suggested two extra hours per week as compensation for the universal credit cut. The question asks if this figure is accurate or higher.
The Prime Minister did not answer the question. The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions seems to think that it is an extra two hours a week, so let me make it even easier for the Prime Minister: is the correct answer higher or lower than that?
What I can tell the right hon. and learned Gentleman is that under this Government, for the first time in decades, wages are rising. Wages across the board are rising, and they are 4.1% up on where they were before the pandemic. In fact, I am very pleased to say—[Interruption.] Of course, what the Opposition want to do is continue to take money in taxation and put it into benefits.
Assessment & feedback
Number of extra hours needed to compensate for universal credit cut was not addressed
Changing Subject To Wage Increases
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
A single parent working full-time on the minimum wage would need to work more than nine extra hours weekly just to compensate for the universal credit reduction.
It wasn't a difficult question, Mr Speaker. [Interruption.] It is silly, they say. “How many hours would someone working full time on the minimum wage have to work to make up for the cut?” is apparently a silly question. I will give the Prime Minister the answer to the question. The number is much, much higher. A single parent—who could be a constituent—working on the minimum wage and already working full time would need to work more than nine hours a week on top of that full-time job just to get back the money that the Prime Minister has taken away from them. They are already working full time. They have kids. How on earth does the Prime Minister think they are going to find the time to work an extra nine hours—in truth, an extra day every week?
I will tell you what we are doing, Mr Speaker, to support people on low incomes. We are supporting them not only with the living wage, but with 30 hours of free childcare, and by freezing petrol duty and extending the heating allowance to 780,000 people across the country—but, even more important than that, for the low-paid we are encouraging measures to see their wages rise. We are investing in their skills. We are investing in work coaches.
Assessment & feedback
How single parents will manage extra 9 hours of work was not addressed
Changing Subject To Low-Income Support Measures
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister's tax system results in people losing more than three-quarters of their income from working an extra hour, due to the national insurance rise. This impacts low-paid workers negatively.
Let us test that right now. We have had three questions and the Prime Minister has not answered one of them, and it is obvious why. The truth is that these low-paid workers cannot work longer hours to get back the money that the Prime Minister is cutting from them. He knows it; they know it. Millions of working families will be hit hard—very hard—by the Prime Minister's universal credit cut, and the reason, I tell the Prime Minister, is this. Why would those people have to work an extra nine hours—a full day every week—to get that £20 back? It is because of his broken tax system. He has just said how good it is, so let us test it. After his national insurance rise, for every extra pound that those workers earn, his Government will take more than 75p from them. That is why they have to work for those nine hours—one whole extra day. The Prime Minister has just said that he is going to raise wages, and what else he is going to do, but that is the situation. Why is the Prime Minister making a bad situation worse for working people by hammering them with a cut in universal credit and a tax rise?
Actually, what we have done with our local housing allowance is increase by £600 the amount of money available to exactly the type of person the right hon. and learned Gentleman has mentioned. He has attacked the plan that we announced last week to fix the backlogs in the NHS. I have to say that I thought it utterly incredible that the party of Nye Bevan should have come to the House last Wednesday and voted against measures that would fix the NHS.
Assessment & feedback
Explanation for inability to compensate through extra work was not provided
Attacking Labour'S Stance On Nhs
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Labour party criticises the government's economic policies, specifically citing negative impacts on working people due to proposed tax increases and reductions in benefits.
An unfair tax rise which will not fix social care and will not clear the NHS backlog is not a plan. The Prime Minister pretends that there is no alternative but to hammer working people with tax rises and universal credit cuts, but that is not true. His approach means that a working single parent who is a qualified nurse would lose £1,143. A supermarket worker could lose £1,093. A teaching assistant could lose £1,081.
It is absolutely ridiculous that the right hon. and learned Gentleman should attack the Government over salaries for nurses when we have put them up by 3% on top of the 12.8% rise that we introduced, when we are hiring 50,000 more nurses and when we are putting another £36 billion into the NHS and social care on top of the £33 billion that this Government invested when we came into office.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address the specific losses mentioned for workers due to tax rises and universal credit cuts.
Ridiculous Attack
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Labour party argues that the government's economic policies disproportionately affect low-income earners negatively.
I just wonder what the millions of people on low wages who are facing a £1,000 cut will think of that. This country's success is built by working people, but the tax system is loaded against them. Taxes on working people: up. National insurance—up! Council tax—up! Energy bills, food prices, burdens on families: up, up, up.
I can see that the panto season has come early—[Interruption.]
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address any of the issues raised by the question.
Panto Season
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Context
The MP inquires about measures to address the shortage of lorry drivers affecting businesses across various sectors.
Be it farm workers or lorry drivers, my employers are saying that they want more staff. What more can the Prime Minister do to increase the training and mobility of jobseekers to help them into the jobs they need?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right to point out the problem of lorry driver shortages, which is affecting the whole world, from Europe to North America. What we are doing immediately is working to get out more licences. We are taking advantage of our post-Brexit freedom so that all the young thrusters on the Conservative Benches with a post-1997 driver's licence can now drive a vehicle with a trailer as well—everybody can drive a vehicle with a trailer as well.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address increasing training and mobility of jobseekers directly, focusing instead on licensing changes.
Young Thrusters
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
The MP inquires about the specific financial impact of government cuts to social welfare programs on nurses.
I pass on my condolences to the Prime Minister and his family on the sad loss of his mother the other day. And I join the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition in congratulating Emma Raducanu on her fantastic success in New York last Saturday. Of course, we mourn the anniversary last Saturday of 20 years since the horrors of 9/11. We remember all those who paid the sacrifice in that outrage. This morning we learned that the rate of inflation has reached its highest level in a decade. For ordinary workers and families, prices are going up at the very moment when they can least afford it.
We are protecting people on low incomes up and down the country—[Interruption.] Indeed we are. And we are freezing fuel duty and supporting childcare. We have brought in a huge package of measures, not least the living wage, which has already seen an increase of £4,000 for every family on the living wage.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not provide specific figures or impacts on nurses from cuts to social welfare.
Interruption
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Context
The MP criticises the government's policies for negatively impacting essential workers during a difficult winter season.
My goodness, my goodness, an increase in nurses' pay. Either the Prime Minister does not know or he simply does not care. When we take the cuts to universal credit and the increase in national insurance, the figure he was looking for is that the average nurse will lose £1,736.
What is actually happening is that we are funding the NHS across the whole of the UK, including in Scotland I am proud to say, with record sums. We have ensured that nurses have access to a training bursary worth £5,000 and a further bursary of £3,000 for childcare costs, and that is before we put up their pay by 3%. That is only possible because of the investment we are making, the measures I outlined last week and the package we are putting forward for health and social care.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address whether any MPs would stand against cuts to universal credit.
Record Sums Training Bursary
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
Concern over how nationalists may use identity cards to undermine the Union.
Now that the move to have a domestic identity card for each of Northern Ireland, Wales, England and Scotland has started, what consideration has my right hon. Friend given to how the nationalists will use them to break our Union?
I am very grateful for the vigilance of my hon. Friend about the matter of ID cards. I can tell him that we have absolutely no plans to bring them in, but I will watch the nationalists very carefully.
Assessment & feedback
Vigilance
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Colum Eastwood Social Democratic & Labour Party
Social Democratic and Labour Party
Context
Health waiting lists are very high in Northern Ireland, and the DUP is threatening to bring down the Good Friday agreement due to a bad opinion poll.
I, too, offer my condolences to the Prime Minister on the loss of his mother. Health waiting lists are through the roof in Northern Ireland and hard-pressed families are being hit by decisions from this Government, but the Democratic Unionist party has been hit by a bad opinion poll so it is threatening to bring down the very institutions of the Good Friday agreement. Will this Prime Minister commit today to fast-tracking the legislation going through this House, agreed at New Decade, New Approach, to stop the institutions coming down if one political party has a petulant strop?
I thank the hon. Gentleman. I agree with him that it is very important that the institutions of Northern Ireland should be robust and should continue, but I also think that a responsible Government have to address the issues of the protocol, the lopsidedness and the way in which the European Union has chosen to interpret those issues, which I do not believe satisfies the Belfast/Good Friday agreement. That is what we are going to do.
Assessment & feedback
Address The Issues Of The Protocol
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Christian Wakeford Lab
Bury South
Context
The questioner asks to denounce the practice of importing dead animal products for fur in Britain.
May I start by expressing my condolences to the Prime Minister? As my right hon. Friend knows, yesterday I led a Westminster Hall debate on the British fur trade and the import of dead animal products from abroad. I know he cares deeply about animal welfare. Will he please join me in denouncing the horrible, cruel and unnecessary slaughter of an average of 1 million animals every year, just for their skin? In a post-Brexit Britain, we can outlaw this horrible practice, one that I am sure he and many, many other British people hate. Will he meet me to discuss my campaign to end the import of fur to Britain and truly make a fur-free Britain?
I am sure that my hon. Friend speaks for millions and millions of people up and down this country who abhor the fur trade and do not want to wear fur. Obviously, we have banned fur farming in this country for a long time, and we are going to look at what we can do, working with the fur sector, to prevent fur from being imported into Britain.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Chris Bryant Lab
Rhondda and Ogmore
Context
A constituent of the MP passed away due to cancer that was detected too late, highlighting the problem with long waiting lists.
By the time my wonderful friend Lynda went to the doctor, the cancer was already so advanced that she had only a few weeks to live. Many hon. Members have been through cancer and they know well that early detection saves lives. Unfortunately, of course, long waiting lists will make it more difficult to save lives. The real problem we have is a massive shortage, in the thousands, in the number of pathologists and radiologists to catch the cancers in the first place, and a massive shortage of oncologists and dermatologists to do the treatment. So regardless of the money, how are we are going to make sure that we have the personnel, not in five or seven years' time, but now, to be able to save lives?
First, I want to say how sad I am to hear about the hon. Gentleman's constituent Lynda. I think her experiences have been shared by literally millions of people in this country during the pandemic, because they have not been willing or able to get the oncology treatment that they need because of the pressure of covid on the system. The system is now coming back, trying to help everybody as fast as possible to fix the backlogs. So yes, it is necessary to hire more nurses and doctors, and there about 10,000 more nurses now and about 6,000 more doctors—
Assessment & feedback
Fix The Backlogs
Response accuracy
Q15 Direct Answer
Context
Local MPs heard from affected individuals and families about poor maternity services at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust.
Work continues to improve maternity services at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust. Last week, local MPs heard from those affected—including a former constituent of mine whose baby died only eight weeks ago—in a meeting with the Minister for Patient Safety. Does my right hon. Friend agree that it is right that there is going to be an independent review of local maternity services? Will he join me in asking those affected to come forward to give evidence to that review, so that in future mothers throughout Nottinghamshire get the maternity services that they both need and deserve?
Yes. I thank my hon. Friend for raising this matter; I know he has campaigned on that issue. The review is going ahead and we will look at what to do once it has been completed, but in the meantime Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust is going to be supported through the national maternity safety support programme.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Olivia Blake Lab
Sheffield Hallam
Context
Children are not returning to school due to the schools' inability to meet their special educational needs.
Throughout the country, there are children who have not gone back to school because their schools say that they cannot meet their needs. Do the continued delays to the Government's review of special educational needs and disability mean that the Government have abandoned those children? Will the Prime Minister listen to the concerns of parents and young people and make sure that their voices are heard in the review?
The hon. Lady raises an important point. When the Government came into office, a key part of the extra £14 billion that we put into education was for investment in special educational needs, to allow local areas to build more SEND schools where they were necessary. We are putting another £780 million into extra SEND education for our kids. If the hon. Lady wishes to raise a particular shortfall in a particular school or area, will she please write to me about it?
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Roger Gale Con
Herne Bay and Sandwich
Context
Thanet Earth, a large glasshouse company in the constituency, had to destroy £320,000 worth of produce due to lack of pickers and drivers.
I know that my right hon. Friend wants to see the United Kingdom growing more crops. We are not going to blaze a trail to self-sufficiency by building over our finest agricultural land. That has to stop, now. On this, Back British Farming Day, we are in harvest time, and all is not safely gathered in. In three weeks, Thanet Earth in my constituency, which is one of the largest glasshouse companies in the country and grows tomatoes, has had to trash £320,000-worth of produce because there are no pickers and no drivers. Because of the lack of labour force, the crops are rotting in the fields and on trees. Will my right hon. Friend seek to introduce immediately a covid-recovery visa, so that this year's crops are not lost?
My right hon. Friend is absolutely right in what he says about the importance of buying British and eating British. Our food is the best in the world. He is also right to address the problems that we are currently seeing in the supply chain, but we are taking steps. Of course, it has been a problem for a long time, but we will use the seasonal agricultural workers scheme to ensure that British farms get the labour that they need.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about introducing a covid-recovery visa was not directly addressed.
Response accuracy
Q18 Direct Answer
Wera Hobhouse Lib Dem
Bath
Context
No specific background event mentioned, but the question relates to future energy sources and CO2 reduction.
I express my condolences to the Prime Minister and his family. Does the Prime Minister believe that the burning of fossil fuels will not be a source of energy in the UK in future?
Yes. Since just 2012, when I think I was Mayor of London—I was—we have cut CO2 massively and we have cut our dependence on coal from 40% to less than 1%. How about that, Mr Speaker?
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q19 Partial Answer
Neil Hudson Con
Epping Forest
Context
Ullswater Community College, a school with significant catchment area, needs redevelopment to remain fit for purpose.
Ullswater Community College, which is led superbly by headteacher Stephen Gilby, is a fantastic school in Penrith with 1,500 pupils, more than 200 staff and a 600 square mile catchment area. The school is in desperate need of redevelopment to keep the site fit for purpose. In partnership with Myerscough College, the school is providing a lifeline for land-based education in Cumbria, after the sad closure of Newton Rigg College in July. This is a great opportunity for the Government to level up rural areas, so will the Prime Minister join me in supporting the proposed rebuild of Ullswater Community College.
Yes. My hon. Friend is a great campaigner for the people of Penrith and The Border, and I can tell him that in addition to our support for 500 school-rebuilding projects in the next decade—we are doing 100 immediately—Cumbria County Council has been allocated £5.3 million for the financial year 2021-22 to improve buildings, including Ullswater Community College.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about supporting the rebuild of Ullswater Community College was not explicitly answered.
Response accuracy
Q20 Direct Answer
Kim Leadbeater Lab
Spen Valley
Context
Concern about the impact of universal credit cuts on people's financial and mental health during the pandemic.
Does the Prime Minister agree that the impending cuts to universal credit will not just have a devastating financial impact on people, but lead to stress and anxiety and undoubtedly have a hugely detrimental effect on their mental health, which, on top of the pressures of the pandemic, could prove devastating for some?
I have answered that question many times. The answer is no, and, in any case, Labour would abolish universal credit altogether.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Context
Scarborough had a high demand for NHS dental registrations in the past, but today many children and vulnerable families cannot register.
Back in 2004, Scarborough hit the national headlines when rumours of a new dental practice opening led to hundreds of people queuing round the block in the vain hope of registering as NHS patients. Today, while many better-off families continue to enjoy the discounted prices that the NHS offers, many children and vulnerable families still cannot register as NHS dental patients in Scarborough and Whitby. Does the Prime Minister agree that that needs fixing?
Yes, I totally agree with my right hon. Friend. That is why we are investing in the NHS, and we want the NHS to be a better place for the dental profession. Would it not be a fine thing if this House of Commons voted overwhelmingly—with all Members voting—for our package of measures to support the NHS?
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about fixing the registration issue was not directly addressed.
Response accuracy
Q22 Partial Answer
Context
September marks Childhood Cancer Awareness Month, highlighting the ongoing need for better research and support.
September marks Childhood Cancer Awareness Month. Every day across the UK, 12 children and young people will be diagnosed with cancer, and, of those, two will not survive. My constituent Nadia Majid and her family are campaigning to improve research and funding in this field. Nadia's son, Rayhan, was only four years old when he was diagnosed with an aggressive brain tumour. Rayhan tragically passed away only four months after his diagnosis. Will the Prime Minister join me in thanking all the doctors, nurses and support staff who work tirelessly to fight against childhood cancer and meet with me to discuss how the four nations can work together to improve research and funding into childhood cancers and to support families like Nadia's?
I know that the hon. Lady echoes the thoughts of millions of people. There is not a family in this country that has not been touched by cancer. Childhood cancer is particularly tragic, which is why the Government are investing huge sums in research and also in supporting some of the fantastic charities that she mentions, particularly those investigating brain cancers.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about meeting to discuss improving research and funding was not directly addressed.
Response accuracy
Q23 Partial Answer
Context
Dr Camilla Kingdon, president of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, believes routine testing without symptoms is unnecessary.
Dr Camilla Kingdon, the president of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, thinks that the routine testing of children without covid symptoms is still interrupting children and teenagers' school attendance and does not believe that it should continue. She thinks that covid should be treated like other diseases and that only children with symptoms should be dealt with. I agree with her and her colleagues in the royal college; does the Prime Minister agree with them?
I have great respect for Dr Kingdon as I have for my right hon. Friend. It is one of a number of views in the scientific community, but we continue to think that testing is a very important route for keeping schools open, which is the best possible thing for the physical and mental health of our kids.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about agreeing with Dr Kingdon on routine testing was not directly addressed.
Response accuracy
Q24 Partial Answer
Nadia Whittome Lab
Nottingham East
Context
The question stems from concerns about the adequacy of statutory sick pay for those suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder and other illnesses. The Health Secretary previously admitted that statutory sick pay is insufficient to live on.
My condolences to the Prime Minister on the sad loss of his mother. I was privileged to be able to take the time off work that I needed to recover from post-traumatic stress disorder, but that should be a right for everyone, not a privilege. Far too many people cannot take the time off that they need because statutory sick pay at £95 a week is not enough to live on. Will the Prime Minister today commit to full sick pay at a real living wage?
As the whole House will know, what we have done is make sure that everybody who gets covid-related statutory sick pay gets it on day one. We have also ensured that most people in this country receive considerably more than statutory sick pay.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to full sick pay at a real living wage was not explicitly addressed.
Response accuracy
Q25 Direct Answer
Bob Blackman Con
Harrow East
Context
The Scout Association has recently launched the Squirrels program, which allows children aged four and five to join scouting. This initiative aims at areas of deprivation and disadvantaged children.
As a Queen's scout, I am always keen to encourage young people to get into the most successful youth organisation in the world, so last week I was delighted that the Scout Association announced the first new age range in scouting for 35 years—namely, the Squirrels—which allows young people of four and five years old to become part of the scout movement. Does my right hon. Friend agree that we should congratulate the Scout Association, thank the volunteers who give up their time to enable young people to take part, and encourage young people to get involved in a safe environment for adventure and new challenges?
Yes; I had no idea that the Scout Association was doing that, but I think it is fantastic. Uniformed youth services make a huge difference to outcomes for young people.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q26 Partial Answer
Context
The GKN factory in Erdington is facing closure due to a hostile takeover by Melrose, leading to the loss of jobs and exportation of production.
For more than half a century, the GKN factory in Erdington has produced high-quality parts for the automotive industry. Now, following the hostile takeover by Melrose, the company has announced its intention to close the factory, sack 519 workers, and export jobs and production to continental Europe. There has been some welcome engagement with Ministers on this issue, but does the Prime Minister agree that, in one of the poorest parts of Britain, if the levelling-up agenda and support for British manufacturing mean anything, this factory cannot close? Does he therefore also agree that it would be a betrayal of the British national interest were this great, historic factory to become history?
My right hon. Friend the Business Secretary is working with GKN to do whatever we can, but I believe that the future of the UK automotive sector is incredibly bright.
Assessment & feedback
Direct commitment to preventing closure was not made.
Response accuracy
Q27 Direct Answer
Kieran Mullan Con
Bexhill and Battle
Context
The UK is missing out on hundreds of millions of pounds of private capital flowing into the geothermal sector across Europe due to lack of competitive long-term tariff.
At a time when our economy desperately needs investment, right now we are missing out on hundreds of millions of pounds of private capital that is flowing into the geothermal sector across Europe, because the UK does not offer a competitive long-term tariff. Geothermal will help us to heat homes, create jobs and level up the UK. We have not yet found time to meet and discuss the subject, but will the Prime Minister find time in his diary in the coming weeks so that we can discuss the issue and do not miss out on further investment?
I am sorry that we have not yet found time to discuss this matter properly, person to person. The Government are very much interested in what my hon. Friend says about geothermal projects, so I will ensure that a meeting is arranged as soon as possible.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q28 Direct Answer
Jamie Stone Lib Dem
Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross
Context
The Scottish Land Court has given the final green light to establish a space launch facility in Sutherland. This is an opportunity for economic growth and international recognition.
I am sure that the Prime Minister will be as pleased as I am that the Scottish Land Court has this week given the final green light to establishing a space launch facility in Sutherland. On behalf of the delighted crofters of the community of Melness, I extend a warm invitation to the Prime Minister to come to the first launch.
I thank the hon. Gentleman for his kind invitation. I look forward to taking it up. What we need is a suitable payload to send into space, and I think the hon. Gentleman would do very well.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q29 Direct Answer
Context
Rolls-Royce is developing small modular reactors (SMRs) which could play a significant role in achieving zero-carbon emissions.
On Monday, it was a pleasure to meet the Prime Minister and the Chancellor of the Exchequer in Leicester as they discussed a zero-carbon future with British Gas. Does my right hon. Friend agree that the development in neighbouring Derby of the modular nuclear reactors can play a major part in this zero-carbon future? What steps are the Government taking to facilitate the roll-out of this technology?
I thank my hon. Friend. We are already working with Rolls-Royce. We gave £20 million seed money to the Rolls-Royce-led consortium when this Government first came in to help them to develop their small modular reactor design.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q30 Partial Answer
Barry Gardiner Lab
Brent West
Context
The Prime Minister has previously stated that the tactic of fire and rehire is “unacceptable”. The question refers to a private Member's Bill proposing measures against this practice.
The Prime Minister has set out today that he wants a high-skill, high-wage economy. He has also been on the record as saying that the tactic of fire and rehire is “unacceptable”. Surely the best way of ensuring that we have a high-wage economy is to work with the proposals in my private Member's Bill so that we end that tactic of fire and rehire.
The most vivid example of fire and rehire is that conducted by the Labour party. If I recall, the leader of the Labour party himself fired his deputy leader and then rehired her as shadow Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster and shadow Secretary of State for the future of work.
Assessment & feedback
Criticizing Opposition
Response accuracy
Q31 Partial Answer
Context
The question pertains to the celebration of British farming, the importance of using British food in public procurement, and the role of food envoys in promoting British food globally. No specific events or incidents are mentioned.
Will my right hon. Friend come to No. 1 George Street and celebrate great British farming today? Can we have public procurement that uses British food, and can we have food envoys all across the world promoting our great British food and farming?
Yes. I thank my hon. Friend, who is the living embodiment of the robustness of British agriculture, and indeed of the benefits of English food—of British food, particularly the beef of Devon, or Somerset. He is right in what he says about food envoys. We have taken that up. Every single embassy across the world has a food envoy.
Assessment & feedback
The answer does not specifically confirm public procurement using British food, only mentions food envoys which are already established.
Response accuracy
Q32 Partial Answer
Sarah Jones Lab
Croydon West
Context
The MP's constituents in Bridge House, Croydon live in flats with dangerous cladding that is not eligible for the Government's building safety fund due to the type of cladding. They are being charged £23,000 each to remove this cladding.
My constituents in Bridge House, Croydon live in flats covered in dangerous cladding that will cost millions to remove. They are not eligible for the Government's building safety fund because it is the wrong type of cladding. Can the Prime Minister confirm: do my constituents have to pay the £23,000 each that they are being charged to remove this cladding, or does he have a better plan?
If the hon. Lady's constituents are being told that they do not have to remove that cladding, then the answer is no. It is very, very important that this House should recognise that too many buildings have been unnecessarily—unfairly, I believe—categorised as dangerous and unsafe. Of course we must remove dangerous cladding, and we are doing that, but I want householders and leaseholders—people living in flats across this country—to have the confidence that they can do so in safety, and that is what this Government are doing.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister does not confirm whether constituents will need to pay £23,000 each for removal or if there is an alternative plan. He instead discusses the broader issue of categorizing buildings as dangerous and unsafe.
Discusses Broader Issues Does Not Provide Specific Details
Response accuracy