PMQs 2021-04-28

2021-04-28

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The UK has already committed some support to the humanitarian disaster in India. The question arises from the scale and gravity of the situation.
I join the Prime Minister in his remarks about the humanitarian disaster we are witnessing in India. Given the scale and gravity of the disaster, I hope the Foreign Secretary will set out today what more the UK will do to help the Indian people in their hour of need.
No, Mr Speaker. The right hon. And learned Gentleman is a lawyer, I am given to understand, and I think that if he is going to repeat allegations like that, he should come to this House and substantiate those allegations and say where he heard them and who exactly is supposed to have said those things.
Assessment & feedback
Setting out additional support for India during the humanitarian crisis
Redirecting To Questioner'S Alleged Unsubstantiated Claims
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
Reports suggest that someone other than Boris Johnson initially paid for the redecoration of his Downing Street flat.
Well, somebody here is not telling the truth. The House will have heard the Prime Minister's answer and I remind him that the ministerial code says: “Ministers who knowingly mislead Parliament will be expected to offer their resignation”. Who initially—“initially” is the key word here—paid for the redecoration of his Downing Street flat?
I have given the right hon. and learned Gentleman the answer, and the answer is that I have covered the costs. Of course, the Electoral Commission is investigating this, and I can tell him that have I conformed in full with the code of conduct and the ministerial code, and officials have been advising me throughout this whole thing.
Assessment & feedback
Specific details about who paid for initial invoice
Referencing Electoral Commission Investigation
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
There are questions about who initially paid for the redecoration of Boris Johnson's Downing Street flat.
Normally when people do not want to incriminate themselves, they go, “No comment.” Let us explore this a bit further. This is the initial invoice, Prime Minister. Either the taxpayer paid the initial invoice, or it was the Conservative party, or it was a private donor, or it was the Prime Minister. I ask him again: who paid the initial invoice—the initial invoice, Prime Minister—for the redecoration of the Prime Minister's flat?
I think I have answered this question several times now, and the answer is that I have covered the costs. When it comes to the taxpayer and the costs of No. 10 Downing Street, it was under the previous Labour Government that I think Tony Blair racked up a bill of £350,000.
Assessment & feedback
Specific details about who paid for initial invoice
Referencing Historical Costs During Previous Government
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
There are questions about who initially paid for the redecoration of Boris Johnson's Downing Street flat.
The Prime Minister talks of priorities. What is he spending his time doing? Just last week, he spent his time phoning journalists to moan about his old friend Dominic Cummings. He is telling the civil service to find out who paid for the redecoration of his flat—the Cabinet Secretary has been asked to investigate who paid for the refurbishment of the flat. Why doesn't the Prime Minister just tell him? That would be the end of the investigation. Can the Prime Minister, if he is so keen to answer, confirm: did Lord Brownlow make that payment for that purpose?
I think I have answered this question several times now, and the answer is that I have covered the costs. When it comes to the taxpayer and the costs of No. 10 Downing Street, it was under the previous Labour Government that I think Tony Blair racked up a bill of £350,000.
Assessment & feedback
Specific details about Lord Brownlow's payment for flat redecoration
Referencing Historical Costs During Previous Government
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Electoral Commission thinks there are reasonable grounds to suspect that an offence or offences may have occurred in relation to the Prime Minister's flat refurbishment.
That is what the public scream at their televisions every PMQs: “Answer the question!” The Prime Minister has not answered the question. He knows he has not answered the question. He never answers the question. Can the Prime Minister tell the House: does he believe that any rules or laws have been broken in relation to the Prime Minister's flat?
No, I don't. What I believe has been strained to breaking point is the credulity of the public.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a direct answer about whether any rules or laws were broken regarding the flat refurbishment.
Straining Public Credibility
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
Crime is rising, NHS waiting lists are at record levels and millions of people are concerned about their jobs. There are concerns over the Prime Minister's integrity.
Can I remind the Prime Minister of the Nolan principles? Instead of these principles, we get dodgy contracts, jobs for mates and cash for access. The British people deserve a trustworthy Prime Minister, not one mired in scandal. Do not the British people deserve a PM they can trust?
Last week, the right hon. and learned Gentleman attacked me for talking to James Dyson about ventilators. He has now said any PM would have done the same thing. We are rolling out many more nurses with 10,000 more in NHS now than last year, and 8,771 more police officers on streets. The EU voted to approve Brexit deal which Labour opposed.
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address whether British people deserve a trustworthy Prime Minister regarding current issues.
Diverting To Past Actions Mentioning Unrelated Achievements
Response accuracy
Q7 Direct Answer
Joy Morrissey Con
Beaconsfield
Context
The UK is a world leader in covid-19 vaccination efforts.
Thank the Prime Minister for swift action on vaccine delivery and thank volunteers like Kirsty Griffiths, Guy Hollis, Paul Bass at Marlow vaccine centre. Thank you for the vaccine roll-out in South Bucks.
My hon. Friend should thank everybody involved, it has been a fantastic national effort led by the NHS, local council officers and officials, Army, and huge numbers of volunteers.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Context
BBC and ITV have multiple sources confirming the Prime Minister said he would rather let bodies pile high than go into lockdown. People find this remark utterly sickening.
May I associate myself with PM's remarks about India humanitarian crisis and Post Office injustice? Over 127,000 people have died from covid in UK. NHS staff gave their all to fight the virus but many lost loved ones. The Prime Minister's remark is utterly sickening: that he would rather let bodies pile high than go into lockdown. Sources confirm this was said by PM under oath. Are you a liar, Prime Minister?
Mr Speaker, I leave it to you to judge whether these remarks were in order.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the question directly regarding being a liar.
Leaving Judgement To Mr. Speaker
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
The Prime Minister faces ongoing allegations of impropriety regarding financial transactions. These allegations include contracts for cronies, tax breaks via text messages, and payments related to personal refurbishments.
Given the allegations that money was funnelled through Tory HQ into the PM's bank account, when did this occur? When will he pay back any funds and what is the interest rate on the loan if applicable? Who provided the original funding? Is there a risk of prosecution by the Electoral Commission if these details are not disclosed?
The right hon. Member is speaking nonsense about these matters. I will emphasise our investment in policing, which includes 20,000 more officers on UK streets, including Scotland.
Assessment & feedback
Financial irregularities and Electoral Commission warnings
Changing Subject To Police Funding
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Context
A major construction site in Longbridge, involving JCB diggers and the development of an industrial park with up to 5,000 jobs. However, there is a desire for similar investment along Northfield High Street.
Given the successful Bristol Road South project creating new jobs, does the Prime Minister support Andy Street's vision for West Midlands growth? Will the Government work closely with local Conservative councillors and Mayor Street to regenerate Northfield High Street?
I commend Andy Street's efforts, including plans for jobs, transport improvements, and addressing issues like A55 and M4. I encourage voting for him in May elections.
Assessment & feedback
Specific regeneration plan for Northfield High Street
Talking Up Mayor'S Achievements
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Liz Saville-Roberts PC
Dwyfor Meirionnydd
Context
The Prime Minister is under scrutiny for multiple breaches of the ministerial code, including alleged inappropriate language about body counts. The sole arbiter on these matters is the PM himself.
Given that the Prime Minister has violated principles like selflessness and honesty, what measures will be taken if he continues to flout the rules? How can citizens ensure accountability when the judge of his conduct is him?
Voters should choose between Welsh Labour's failures and the Conservative vision for Wales: 65,000 high-skilled jobs, A55 improvements, more teachers and nurses, addressing M4 issues.
Assessment & feedback
Conduct breaches and ministerial code violations
Directing To Election Choices
Response accuracy
Q12 Direct Answer
Context
A judicial ruling has been made regarding the wrongful convictions of many postmasters in a systemic error case involving the Post Office. The question highlights the need for justice and accountability, including a public inquiry.
Given that last week's ruling was just the start, what measures will the Government take to address this miscarriage of justice fully? A judge-led public inquiry seems necessary to achieve true justice and hold those responsible accountable.
The ruling was indeed awful for postmasters and sub-postmasters. A former High Court judge, Sir Wyn Williams, will make recommendations on further actions and apologies.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
Last year, the UK Government intercepted a potential deal between Wales and Roche pharmaceuticals for daily covid tests. The PM's decision is seen as undermining Welsh health infrastructure.
Given that in March last year, the UK Government halted a deal between Wales and Roche for 5,000 daily covid tests, why was this action taken? Did it not compromise Welsh lives during the pandemic?
The hon. Gentleman is incorrect about the test situation but correct that Wales contributed to our fight against covid. Wockhardt, along with Oxford Biomedica, has been vital in rolling out vaccines.
Assessment & feedback
Interference in Welsh test procurement
Crediting Vaccine Efforts
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Context
The AWE has a strong representation of female employees who have won awards for their work. The Government is investing significantly in these areas, raising questions about gender parity.
Considering the significant investment in the Atomic Weapons Establishment (AWE) as part of future nuclear capabilities, will my right hon. Friend outline plans to improve women's participation in defence and nuclear sectors? May I invite him to visit AWE?
I would be delighted to accept your invitation. Alison Atkinson became CEO of AWE, and there are numerous opportunities for women in armed services due to increased defence spending.
Assessment & feedback
Comprehensive strategy details
Citing Specific Female Role Model
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Sarah Olney Lib Dem
Richmond Park
Context
The question is prompted by the Prime Minister's recent commitment to include aviation and shipping in the UK's emission targets. There are concerns about missing these targets with a third runway at Heathrow.
I welcome the Prime Minister's commitment last week to include aviation and shipping in our emissions target, but surely he knows that we will miss that target if we proceed with a third runway at Heathrow, and, furthermore, that that would undermine the progress towards net zero. Will he therefore take this opportunity to commit to amending the airports national policy statement?
The third runway at Heathrow is a private sector venture and it is up to them to produce the capital for it. The government is looking instead into jet-zero aviation with lower carbon emissions, an area where BEIS and DfT are working together.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to amending the airports national policy statement
Looking At This Working On It
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Context
The level of business optimism is high due to the success of the UK vaccination program. The question highlights this as a reason for voters in Scotland and Wales to support the UK government.
Right now, levels of business optimism are higher than they have been since the start of the pandemic, with many firms planning more hires and apprenticeships. Does my right hon. Friend agree that there has never been a more important moment for voters in Scotland and Wales to reject negativity and divisiveness and look forward to a brighter and stronger future as one United Kingdom?
Absolutely. The PM agrees with this sentiment, paying tribute to the work of Wockhardt in Wales and Valneva in Scotland.
Assessment & feedback
Specific issues in Scotland and Wales
Working Together
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Janet Daby Lab
Lewisham East
Context
The Electoral Commission is investigating the Prime Minister's Downing Street flat funding, suspecting an offense.
It is shocking that we have heard about the Electoral Commission's investigation into funding of the PM's Downing Street flat. Why does the Prime Minister think these stories keep happening to him and his government?
People are determined to find anything they can hang on to talk about, except the vaccine roll-out or our plans for levelling up.
Assessment & feedback
Reasons for ongoing scandals and investigations
People Are Determined Talk About Other Issues
Response accuracy
Q18 Direct Answer
Context
A major water leak occurred at Doncaster Royal Infirmary, with patients moved to safety. Upcoming local elections are prompting a call for full support from the Prime Minister.
I thank all staff and emergency services for dealing swiftly with a major water leak yesterday, fortunately no one was hurt. However, will the PM offer his full support to the Doncaster Conservative mayoral candidate, James Hart?
My hon. Friend is right to thank all staff and emergency services for dealing with yesterday's incident safely. I am glad to take this opportunity to support him in his campaign for James Hart.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q19 Direct Answer
Context
The Prime Minister promised to publish the account of his dealings with Sir James Dyson regarding a tax issue.
The PM promised in texts to 'fix' a tax issue for Sir James Dyson. Last week, he promised to publish these texts but has not done so yet. When will they be published?
I have already published the account of my dealings with James Dyson as promised, which I believe is exactly what was asked for.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q20 Direct Answer
Luke Evans Con
Hinckley and Bosworth
Context
With the bank holiday weekend approaching, there is a call to support local attractions like Twycross zoo and Mallory Park racecourse.
My constituency has many attractions such as Twycross zoo and Mallory Park. With the bank holiday coming up, does the Prime Minister have any plans for Bosworth? More importantly, what are the Government doing to support these attractions and domestic tourism this summer?
We are supporting local attractions through initiatives like the £56 million welcome back fund and extending VAT cuts for tourism and hospitality until September.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Lilian Greenwood Lab
Nottingham South
Context
The question refers to ongoing political controversies involving the Prime Minister.
Is not the truth behind all of this—the sleaze, the scandals, the jobs for your mates, the cash for curtains —that the Prime Minister thinks that rules, laws and decency are for other people?
I think that what people think is that the Labour party is losing all the arguments across British politics, that it has nothing to say, and that it has no plan for our future and no vision for our country. People see a Conservative Government who are getting on with uniting and levelling up, with the most ambitious agenda any Government have had for generations, and I think that is what they are listening to.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address the question about personal ethics and integrity directly.
Shifted Focus Onto Labour Party'S Perceived Failures
Response accuracy
Q22 Partial Answer
Context
Upcoming local elections in Nottinghamshire where the Conservative Party seeks to maintain its majority.
Next week, residents here in Nottinghamshire will go out to vote for the first time since that incredibly successful 2019 election. Despite that success, many areas still have mainly Labour councillors at a local level. Does my right hon. Friend have a message for Nottinghamshire voters?
I do, and I thank my hon. Friend for all the wonderful work that he does for his constituency. My message would be, yes, I hope that the people of Nottinghamshire will get out and vote Conservative. It is we who share their priorities on crime, on the NHS, on investment in infrastructure and on levelling up across our country, so I hope they will vote Conservative on 6 May.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address why some areas still have mainly Labour councillors despite the success of the Conservative Party at a national level.
Shifted Focus Onto Priorities And Policies
Response accuracy
Q23 Partial Answer
Rachel Hopkins Lab
Luton South and South Bedfordshire
Context
The European Super League plan was a controversial proposal that faced opposition from the UK government.
When were the Prime Minister and his chief of staff first made aware of the plan for a European super league?
I first was made aware of the plan for a European super league on, I think, the Sunday night, and we acted decisively using the arsenal of legislative freedoms that we now have thanks to leaving the European Union, which the right hon. and learned Member for Holborn and St Pancras (Keir Starmer) opposed, of course.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not specify a date but provided context on the action taken in response to the plan.
Provided Context Rather Than Specifics
Response accuracy
Q24 Direct Answer
Context
The question relates to plans for celebrating the Platinum Jubilee of Queen Elizabeth II.
My constituency of Stroud recently won the title of best place to live. There is much to visit there, including an historic lamp standard that was erected to celebrate Queen Victoria's diamond jubilee. Next year, our own Queen will mark 70 years since her accession to the throne. Will the Prime Minister join me in supporting the gift being proposed by Parliament to mark Her Majesty's platinum jubilee?
I thank my hon. Friend for that wonderful proposal, and I certainly encourage all colleagues to support and contribute to her project.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q25 Partial Answer
Context
Upcoming local elections where the Conservative Party aims to win seats.
Next week, we will elect our first Mayor of West Yorkshire. Does the Prime Minister agree that for far too long Labour has taken our northern heartlands for granted?
Well, Mr Speaker, they don't like that sort of thing, do they? They don't like focusing on the issues that actually matter to the British people and the people of West Yorkshire. I thank my hon. Friend, who is absolutely right.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not directly address whether Labour has taken Northern constituencies for granted.
Criticised Labour'S Perceived Lack Of Focus On Relevant Issues
Response accuracy