PMQs 2021-12-08

2021-12-08

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Direct Answer
Context
The local council's external auditors released a critical report about the Sandwell Council's management, detailing issues such as uncollected bins, damp homes, financial mismanagement, and overspending on transport contracts.
Bins left uncollected, council tenants being forced to live in damp and cold homes, £22 million lost on the Providence Place land deal and a £10 million overspend on special educational needs and disability transport contracts that were almost awarded to Labour councillors' friends—today, our council's external auditors released a damning report that surprises none of us. Does the Prime Minister agree with me that 47 years of Labour control in Sandwell has done nothing but level down my constituency of West Bromwich East, and that my constituents in West Bromwich, Friar Park and Great Barrington deserve better?
Yes, I wholeheartedly agree with my hon. Friend because the instinct of Labour councillors up and down this country is, yet again, to level down rather than to level up.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister's office was accused of misleading the public about a Christmas party at Downing Street despite strict pandemic regulations. The question arises from concerns about potential rule-breaking and loss of public trust.
I heard what the Prime Minister said at the beginning of this session, but frankly it raises more questions than answers. Last week, I asked the Prime Minister: was there 'a Christmas party…in Downing Street for dozens of people on 18 December?'—[Official Report, 1 December 2021; Vol. 704, c. 909.] The Prime Minister and the Government spent the week telling the British public that there was no party and that all guidance was followed completely. Millions of people now think the Prime Minister was taking them for fools and that they were lied to; they are right, aren't they?
I think the right hon. and learned Gentleman probably missed what I said at the beginning, but I apologise for the impression that has been given that staff in Downing Street take this less than seriously. I am sickened myself and furious about that, but I repeat what I have said to him: I have been repeatedly assured that the rules were not broken—[Interruption.]
Assessment & feedback
Whether there was a party and whether rules were broken is left ambiguous.
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
An internal investigation into the Downing Street Christmas party during strict pandemic rules is requested due to allegations of rule-breaking and cover-up.
An internal investigation into what happened? The situation is as clear as day. I thought last week was bad enough; surely the Prime Minister is not now going to start pretending that the first he knew about this was last night—surely. We have all watched the video of the Prime Minister's staff, including his personal spokesperson. They knew there was a party, they knew it was against the rules, they knew they could not admit it and they thought it was funny. It is obvious what happened—Ant and Dec are ahead of the Prime Minister on this. The Prime Minister has been caught red-handed; why does he not end the investigation right now by just admitting it?
Because I have been repeatedly assured that no rules were broken. I understand public anxiety about this and I understand public indignation, but there is a risk of doing a grave injustice to people who were, frankly, obeying the rules. That is why the Cabinet Secretary will be conducting an investigation and that is why there will be the requisite disciplinary action if necessary.
Assessment & feedback
Admitting rule-breaking without providing specifics or timeframe for admission.
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister's credibility is questioned due to the Downing Street Christmas party, with implications for public trust in pandemic measures.
This pretence that further information has come to light—give me a break! The Prime Minister is still taking the public for fools. On the day of the Downing Street party, Trisha Greenhalgh's mum phoned her; she was 'breathless and feverish'—[Interruption.] You might want to listen. Trisha followed the rules and did not visit her mum. Listening? Four days later, on the day the Prime Minister's staff laughed about covering up the party, Trisha's mum was admitted to hospital. Trisha followed the rules and did not visit. Trisha's mum spent Christmas day in hospital; Trisha followed the rules and did not visit. Two days later, Trisha's mum died. What Trisha wants to know is: why did the Prime Minister expect her to accept that the rules allowed a Downing Street party but did not allow her to visit her dying mother?
The first thing to say is that, in common with everybody in this House, I extend my sympathies to Trisha and her family. I understand the pain of everybody who has suffered throughout this pandemic. I know the implication that the right hon. and learned Gentleman is trying to draw: that the case that we are now investigating should somehow undermine public confidence in the measures that we are taking.
Assessment & feedback
Specific questions about fairness and consistency of rules were not directly addressed, focusing instead on broader implications.
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister's credibility is further questioned due to the Downing Street Christmas party, especially as a new variant emerges.
But it is not just the events of a year ago, is it? We are facing a new variant. We may well be in plan B this afternoon. Even the Prime Minister must understand the damage that he has done to his credibility in enforcing the rules now and in the future. Trisha made an enormous personal sacrifice to do the right thing—to follow the rules and help defeat the virus. That is what she was asked to do. Most people were just like Trisha last Christmas. No one was dreaming of a Zoom Christmas, turkey dinners for one, and gifts exchanged at service stations, but the virus was out of control. Four hundred and eighty nine people died of covid on the day of the Downing Street party. The British people put the health of others above themselves and followed the rules. Is the Prime Minister not ashamed that his Downing Street could not do the same?
I have said what I have said about the events on 18 December. They will be properly investigated, Mr Speaker, and I will place a copy of the Cabinet Secretary's report in the Library of the House of Commons.
Assessment & feedback
Shame or personal accountability for the party was not directly acknowledged, focusing instead on investigation.
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The question is prompted by the Prime Minister's handling of the pandemic, including his response to the Queen sitting alone after Prince Philip's death.
There were no Government spokespersons on the media this morning. This virus is not defeated. We will face other tests where the British people may be asked by their leaders to make further sacrifices for the greater good. Leadership, sacrifice—that is what gives leaders the moral authority to lead. Does the Prime Minister think that he has the moral authority to lead and to ask the British people to stick to the rules?
Of course we will do that, and we will get on with the investigation by the Cabinet Secretary. The right hon. and learned Gentleman continually wants to play politics with this issue.
Assessment & feedback
The moral authority of the Prime Minister during the pandemic was not addressed; instead, the answer shifted focus to political gamesmanship.
Play Politics Continually Wants To
Response accuracy
Q7 Direct Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The question is prompted by the Labour leader's demand for a full investigation into alleged parties held at Downing Street in violation of public health guidelines.
Last week, the Prime Minister told us there was no party. Now he thinks that there is something to investigate. The Justice Secretary thinks that the police do not investigate crimes from a year ago. Well, I ran the Crown Prosecution Service and I can tell him that that is total nonsense. At Westminster magistrates court right now, the CPS is prosecuting more than a dozen breaches of covid restrictions last December—including those, Prime Minister, who hosted parties. The CPS is doing its job, enforcing the law set in Downing Street. Will the Prime Minister support the police and the CPS by handing over everything that the Government know about parties in Downing Street to the Metropolitan police?
Of course we will do that, and we will get on with the investigation by the Cabinet Secretary.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Context
The question is prompted by the Government's promise to support Afghans who are members of religious minorities facing persecution, including those at risk due to their beliefs.
We have an Afghan citizens resettlement scheme coming. We have already taken 15,000, but it is important that we get that scheme right. Further details, including the eligibility criteria, will be announced by the Home Office in due course.
Further details, including the eligibility criteria, will be announced by the Home Office in due course.
Assessment & feedback
The timeline for the resettlement scheme was not provided.
Announced By The Home Office
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
The question is prompted by allegations that Downing Street broke public health rules, which has damaged the Prime Minister's credibility and trust among the public.
Downing Street wilfully broke the rules and mocked the sacrifices that we have all made, shattering the public's trust. The Prime Minister is responsible for losing the trust of the people. He can no longer lead on the most pressing issue facing these islands. The Prime Minister has a duty: the only right and moral choice left to him is his resignation. When can we expect it?
The SNP and the Labour party are going to continue to play politics. I am going to get on with the job.
Assessment & feedback
The question about resignation was not addressed; instead, the answer shifted focus to political opposition's actions.
Play Politics Get On With The Job
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Context
The question is prompted by the Prime Minister's alleged misconduct in breaking public health rules, which undermines his credibility to lead the country through a crisis.
People across these islands have followed the rules, even when it meant missing friends and family, missing births, missing funerals, missing the chance to be beside a loved one in their dying moments. People have sacrificed, at times to the point of breaking, while the UK Government have laughed in our faces. This is not a grin-and-bear-it moment; this is a moment of moral reckoning.
I believe that that is the right thing to do. I think it is very, very sad that when the public need to hear clarity from their officials and from politicians, the Opposition parties are trying to muddy the waters about events, or non-events, of a year ago.
Assessment & feedback
The question about moral integrity was not addressed; instead, the answer shifted focus on opposition muddying the waters.
Muddy The Waters
Response accuracy