Questions & Answers
Q1
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Prime Minister promised integrity, professionalism and accountability upon taking office.
When the Prime Minister got the job on his first day, he promised 'integrity, professionalism and accountability'. The questioner assumes the Deputy Prime Minister agrees with this promise. Therefore, does he agree that the Prime Minister should ensure no Minister who has a complaint of bullying upheld against them continues to serve in the Government?
The hon. Gentleman is right to quote what the Prime Minister said, and I take it as an article of personal faith that we behave with absolute integrity and accountability. On hearing two complaints had been made against me—I believe they were made yesterday; I was notified this morning—I asked the Prime Minister to set up an independent investigation.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Sikh community celebrates Gurpurab of Guru Nanak Dev Ji.
Many constituents were celebrating the Gurpurab of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, an important figure for equality and selfless service. The Midland Langar Seva Society and the Guru Har Rai Gurdwara are among organisations contributing positively to communities. Will my right hon. Friend thank the community for their ongoing contributions?
At this important time of year, I join her in what she has said about the Sikh community making an outstanding contribution to her constituency and to the whole country through organisations like the Midland Langar Seva Society and the Guru Har Rai Gurdwara.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Ukraine faces missile attacks from Russia while world leaders meet.
Russia is launching missile attacks on Ukrainian civilian infrastructure while leaders are meeting. The Government have requested establishing the facts to avoid speculation regarding an incident in Poland last night. Does the Deputy Prime Minister agree that Putin's actions show contempt for international order?
I entirely agree with what she said. President Putin started this war and whatever determination is made regarding yesterday's events, they result from the unlawful aggression perpetrated by the Russian Government.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The G20 is an opportunity to tackle economic issues, including multinational companies using tax havens.
While international allies are tackling the use of tax havens by multinationals, this Government are dragging their feet. The upcoming Budget will impact families across Britain. Does the Deputy Prime Minister accept that every pound hidden in tax havens is a pound lost from working families' pockets?
We are making sure people come to this country to create jobs and generate tax revenue. The Prime Minister led the charge with the G7 presidency on international minimum corporate tax rules, reducing the tax gap under this Government compared to Labour.
▸
Assessment & feedback
specific ask about hiding profits in tax havens
We Are Committed To
Working On It
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The UK is part of the OECD's two-year growth league table.
Non-dom status has not been abolished. The Conservatives would have us believe economic problems are out of their control, but working people pay the price for protecting corporate profits over household incomes. Where does the UK rank in the OECD's growth league table?
Unemployment remains at a 50-year low, half the level left by Labour. The IMF says we will have the strongest G7 growth.
▸
Assessment & feedback
specific ask about OECD ranking
Too Early To Say
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Deputy Prime Minister acknowledged formal bullying complaints.
After days of dodging, the Deputy Prime Minister finally acknowledged formal bullying complaints. It's Anti-Bullying Week. Will he apologise?
I received notification this morning and immediately asked the Prime Minister to set up an independent inquiry into the complaints. I am confident that I behaved professionally throughout, but of course I will engage thoroughly.
▸
Assessment & feedback
specific ask about apology
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Deputy Prime Minister faces multiple allegations, including a Cabinet Minister resigning over his behaviour, another breaching the ministerial code, and junior staff being too scared to enter his office.
The Deputy Prime Minister knows that his behaviour was unacceptable, so what is he still doing here? When will the Government appoint an independent ethics adviser?
The recruitment of the new ethics adviser is already under way and taking place at pace. The British people want a Government who can deal with the real challenges, and Labour Members are not up to it.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide any specific timeline or details on the appointment of an independent ethics adviser.
The Recruitment Of The New Ethics Adviser Is Already Under Way
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Deputy Prime Minister faces ongoing issues including a Cabinet Minister resigning with his good wishes, Home Secretary breaching the ministerial code, and being reportedly banned from meeting junior staff without supervision.
The Deputy Prime Minister knows that civil servants are liars, suggesting no ethics or integrity. When will the Government appoint an independent ethics adviser?
The recruitment of the new ethics adviser is already under way and taking place at pace.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide any specific timeline or details on the appointment of an independent ethics adviser.
The Recruitment Of The New Ethics Adviser Is Already Under Way
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Hope House Children's Hospice in Telford and Shropshire is holding an online fundraiser called the Big Night In, aiming to raise half a million pounds. Among prizes are premium tickets to the Telford steam railway polar express.
Please will the Deputy Prime Minister log on to Hope House Children's Hospice's Big Night In this Sunday? If he wins a pair of tickets to the Telford polar express, I shall be delighted to go with him.
I thank my hon. Friend, and congratulate her and Hope House Children's Hospice on the amazing work they do. I have been working very closely with Shooting Star Children's Hospices, a similar organisation in my constituency.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address whether he will participate in the fundraiser.
I Thank My Hon. Friend, And Congratulate Her And Hope House Children'S Hospice On The Amazing Work They Do.
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Prime Minister was asked six times to apologise for the financial crisis caused by the mini-Budget but refused. People are waking up to the news of worst inflation in 41 years.
Yesterday, the Prime Minister was asked six different times to apologise for the disaster of the Tory mini-Budget and the financial crisis it caused. Will the Deputy Prime Minister stand up today and do what his boss would not? Will he say sorry?
May I thank the hon. Lady for what she said about both Poland and the importance of our solidarity with the international community against the appalling illegal invasion by Russia of Ukraine? Inflation is clearly a problem. We have a plan to grip inflation, to balance the books and to drive economic growth.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not apologize for the mini-budget crisis or say sorry.
May I Thank The Hon. Lady For What She Said About Both Poland
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Tories are imposing austerity measures with their Budget, while Scottish child payment increased to £25 a week helping 400,000 children.
If the Government cannot even say sorry for the mess that they have made, what hope do we have of them fixing it? Will the right hon. Gentleman's Government join the fight against child poverty tomorrow and follow the lead of the Scottish Government by matching the Scottish child payment?
The hon. Lady will know that we are facing challenges that are faced all around the world, because of covid and the war in Ukraine. We have seen rising inflation in Germany, the eurozone and the US. The reality is that this Prime Minister and this Chancellor have a plan—more detail will be set out in the autumn statement—but of course, the UK Government will continue to work collaboratively with the Scottish Government to safeguard and protect the most vulnerable right across the United Kingdom.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to matching the Scottish child payment.
The Hon. Lady Will Know That We Are Facing Challenges That Are Faced All Around The World
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The community in Belper Mills, a UNESCO world heritage site in Mid Derbyshire, is worried about the mill's disrepair and potential loss of its world heritage status.
Belper Mills in my Mid Derbyshire constituency are in a state of disrepair. The community is hugely worried about their future. It matters not just for my constituents but for the whole country, because the mills are part of a UNESCO world heritage site. If appropriate redevelopment is not agreed soon, the site risks losing its world heritage status. Will my right hon. Friend confirm that the Government will pay close attention to this case to ensure that we do not lose our world heritage status? Will he come with me to visit the mills and discuss potential solutions with local people?
I thank my hon. Friend for her campaigning on this. Yes, we will of course continue to monitor the condition of Belper Mills and the planning applications. The best I can say is that we strongly encourage all the local bodies—whether it is the council or the applicant—to continue to work together because, above all, her constituents will want to continue to celebrate the proud and rich tradition represented by Belper.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm specific government action or commitment beyond encouraging local bodies to cooperate
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Deputy Prime Minister is asked to confirm the timing of the £400 energy support payment announcement for households in Northern Ireland, given the importance of securing Northern Ireland's place within the Union.
I am sure that the Deputy Prime Minister will join me in welcoming the comments made yesterday by the Foreign Secretary to the European Scrutiny Committee—that securing Northern Ireland's place within the Union will be the priority of the Government in the negotiations with the European Union on the Northern Ireland Protocol. One of the benefits of the Union is the support that the Government of the United Kingdom are providing to households and businesses across the entire country to tackle the cost of living crisis. Will the Deputy Prime Minister assure me that the £400 energy support payment that is due to be made to households in Northern Ireland will be announced as soon as possible?
I thank the right hon. Gentleman. What he said about securing Northern Ireland's place within the constitutional and economic integrity of the UK is absolutely vital. The Prime Minister has been very clear on that, as has the Foreign Secretary. Of course, the Chancellor will say more tomorrow on the economic measures and, in particular, on the fiscal measures that the right hon. Gentleman referred to.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm specific timing of energy support payment announcement
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Deputy Prime Minister is urged to remove pull factors for illegal migration by providing legal power to arrest, detain, and deport illegal migrants through the new Bill of Rights.
Even if an illegal migrant is stopped on a French beach, he will simply come back the next day as no one is ever arrested. Will the Deputy Prime Minister ensure that we remove all pull factors for illegal migration by using his new Bill of Rights so that we have the legal power to arrest, detain and deport illegal migrants, and, for instance, have a review about a national identity card so that people do not just vanish and never get deported?
I totally agree that we need to strain every sinew to stop this appalling trade in misery. There is no silver bullet, although I think the agreement the Home Secretary made with her French opposite number will help, and we are embedding UK officials with their French counterparts for the first time. My right hon. Friend the Member for Gainsborough (Sir Edward Leigh) is right to say that the Bill of Rights can also help, not least in preventing interim orders from the Strasbourg Court from being recognised in UK courts. On ID cards, we already have e-visas for people coming to visit and live in the UK, and they act as digital evidence of a person's immigration status. What is clear, however, is that we will have to do all these things in the teeth of opposition from Labour Front Benchers.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to implementing national ID cards or specific measures beyond mentioning e-visas
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A headteacher in Wyre faces budgeting difficulties due to school cuts, leading to the need for external services like PE classes and meals transportation.
Our small rural schools in Wyre face particular difficulties. The headteacher at Scorton and Calder Vale St John Church of England Primary Schools told me that: “Budgets in schools like ours are stretched as we have to pay for lots of additional services which larger schools can provide in-house.” She has to hire the village hall for PE because the schools have no hall, and she has to hire taxis to bring in school meals because they have no kitchens. Given the school budget cuts, what does the Deputy Prime Minister advise this headteacher to cut from our local children?
We are very sympathetic to the challenges that all our schools face. More will be said about specific measures tomorrow, but the hon. Lady should stand assured that we are the top spenders as a percentage of GDP on primary and secondary education in the G7, and that standards, which matter to pupils and parents the most, have increased, with the proportion of schools rated good or outstanding up from 68% in 2010 to 87% today.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific advice on what to cut or address budgeting difficulties directly
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Deputy Prime Minister is asked about the situation of Torbay's tourism and hospitality sector, which faces challenges like increased energy costs and business rates.
The Deputy Prime Minister will be aware of the opportunities but also the challenges that face Torbay's tourism and hospitality sector, including increased energy costs and the impact of business rates. What consideration is he giving to the situation of Torbay's iconic industry and further measures to support it?
My hon. Friend is a fantastic champion for Torbay. The Chancellor will make a statement tomorrow and I cannot speculate on the spending decisions, but my hon. Friend will have noticed already the tourism recovery plan, which will help recovery from the pandemic and is also part of the wider levelling-up agenda.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific measures beyond mentioning an existing recovery plan
Response accuracy
Q17
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Deputy Prime Minister is asked to tackle housing issues in the private rented sector, which has seen an increase of 1 million people since 2010.
Private rents in my constituency are completely out of control, and since the Government broke the economy and broke the mortgage market, the hope of earning a home is quickly receding. With the cost of living skyrocketing, Tory tax rises through the roof, and an extra 1 million people in the private rented sector since 2010, will the Government get a grip and tackle housing in my constituency and across the country?
As a former Housing Minister, I know how important these issues are. I can tell the hon. Lady that the Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities is looking very carefully at the situation of renters and landlords, and legislation is to be brought forward shortly.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific actions beyond stating intention to look into the issue
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A constituent, Mikey Akers with verbal dyspraxia, expressed frustration about societal judgment towards people with disabilities.
My constituent Mikey Akers said he is ashamed of those who judge him without knowledge or understanding. The Royal College of Speech and Language Therapists and the Dyspraxia Foundation reported that 5% of children have speech and communication needs, suggesting more awareness raising is needed. Will you convene a meeting with the Prime Minister to raise awareness about verbal dyspraxia?
I thank my hon. Friend for being a doughty champion and highlighting Mikey's campaign. All children and young people should receive the support they need to make the very best of all their talents and potential. I will certainly make sure that he gets a meeting with the relevant Minister.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer does not specifically mention convening a meeting with the Prime Minister, only with the relevant minister.
Did Not Address Specific Ask
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner inquired about the Deputy Prime Minister's involvement with non-disclosure agreements related to employment disputes.
Can you tell me if you have ever entered into a non-disclosure agreement connected to a complaint against you?
The hon. Gentleman is referring to an employment dispute that was settled before I entered the House. It involved a confidentiality clause, which was standard at the time.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Answer does not confirm or deny NDA involvement directly but only mentions it as part of settlement.
Did Not Answer Yes/No
Response accuracy
Q20
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner seeks support for Education Cannot Wait to deliver education in refugee camps.
Will the Deputy Prime Minister, as a former Foreign Secretary and Development Minister, commit to backing the work of Education Cannot Wait which delivers education in refugee camps?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right about the brilliant work that Education Cannot Wait does. We will look at what more we can do to support that work, particularly for children growing up in refugee camps.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Does not commit explicitly to backing Education Cannot Wait's specific work but acknowledges its value.
Vague Commitment
Response accuracy
Q21
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner inquires if the ban on no-fault evictions from the Conservative manifesto is being reconsidered.
Does the Deputy Prime Minister's comeback signal that the ban on no-fault evictions is back on and will it be put on the statute book?
My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities is looking at all such matters. He will have heard what the hon. Lady has said and he will write to her to address her specific proposals.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Does not commit to putting ban on no-fault evictions onto statute book but says it's being looked at.
Will Look Into It
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner criticizes those who are currently criticizing the Deputy Prime Minister for their past actions regarding bullying.
I wonder whether my right hon. Friend has noticed that those currently criticizing him have a record of bullying. Does he think this criticism is hypercritical?
My right hon. Friend makes his point in his usual inimitable way. I think it is important that we all take responsibility for our actions.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The response does not address the question about hypercritical assessment but instead responds defensively to criticism.
Defensive Response
Response accuracy
Q23
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner inquires about the legal rights of nuclear test veterans to obtain their medical records.
Will the Deputy Prime Minister investigate and inform me of the legal rights of veterans who participated in nuclear weapons tests to obtain their medical records?
I thank the hon. Lady, who has been a consistent champion on this issue, for which I recognise and pay tribute to her. The information is available to veterans and their families. If the hon. Lady writes to me, she will get an adequate answer.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Does not commit to specific investigation or immediate action but offers to write back with more details.
Will Investigate Further
Response accuracy
Q24
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner asks for the new Prime Minister to recognize the service of nuclear test veterans by awarding them a medal.
Will the Deputy Prime Minister and our new Prime Minister recognise these brave servicemen not only by doing what the hon. Lady has asked but also by giving them the service medal that they so richly deserve?
My right hon. friend is absolutely right. We should be grateful to all those who participated in the British nuclear testing programme. Officials have been asked to look again at recognition with medals, and recommendations will be announced in the usual way.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Does not commit explicitly to recognizing or awarding a medal but says officials are looking into it.
Will Investigate Further
Response accuracy
Q25
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Conservative Prime Ministers have repeatedly promised Northern Powerhouse Rail but failed to deliver. The current Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy questioned the point in going ahead with NPR.
Seven years ago, a Conservative Prime Minister told me to stop griping about rail investment plans. A few weeks ago, the new Secretary of State said there wasn't really much point in going ahead with Northern Powerhouse Rail. Will the Deputy Prime Minister now put on the record whether he supports Transport for the North's preferred option for NPR, with a stop in Bradford?
I can tell the hon. Lady that our £96 billion integrated rail plan will make Northern Powerhouse Rail a reality. We are committed to the project; the precise details will be set out in due course.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment to supporting Transport for the North's preferred option with a stop in Bradford was not provided
We Are Committed To
Response accuracy
Q26
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner believes that immediate returns of illegal migrants to France would stop illegal migration, break the economic model of smugglers, and benefit northern French cities. The Home Secretary has a deal with her French counterpart.
If migrants who crossed the channel from France illegally were immediately returned to France, it would stop illegal migration to this country, break the economic model of the people smugglers and, perhaps more importantly, stop thousands of people descending on northern French cities, which would benefit the French. When the Prime Minister spoke to the French President, was a returns policy discussed? If so, what was the President's response?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right to raise this issue. I cannot tell him the precise read-out from the meeting—I have not seen it yet—but I can tell him that the Home Secretary's deal and agreement with her French opposite number means a 40% increase in officers patrolling beaches in northern France; UK officers embedded with their French counterparts for the first time; investment in port security infrastructure; more technology; and more wider European co-operation.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide information on returns policy or President's response
Under Review
Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q27
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner attributes blame to the Tories for issues such as running public services poorly, inflaming tensions with asylum seekers, and trashing the economy.
It is not trade unions that have run public services to the ground—it is the Tories. It is not asylum seekers fleeing war and famine who are inflaming tensions—it is the Tories. It is not those in low-paid jobs who are trashing the economy—again, it is the Tories. Can the Deputy Prime Minister inform the House when the Tory Government will finally accept responsibility for their economic, social and political mismanagement, rather than blaming everyone else?
It is not a matter of blaming anyone; it is a matter of a team effort and shared endeavour, working with the Scottish Government, to make sure that we get a grip on inflation, which is the No. 1 priority.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific timeline or commitment for accepting responsibility
Blaming Others
Response accuracy
Q28
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The questioner supports the Home Secretary and wants reassurance that she will be given tools to solve the migrant crisis despite a bullying campaign from the Opposition.
Now then. We have a brilliant Home Secretary but the Deputy Prime Minister will be aware of the wicked and vicious bullying campaign led by the Opposition over the last four weeks or so to get her sacked. Can he reassure me and the people of Ashfield that the Home Secretary will be given all the tools that she needs to solve the migrant crisis and keep the bully boys out of No. 10?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. We fully support the Home Secretary and the important measures she has taken, whether on the Rwanda scheme, implementing the Nationality and Borders Act 2022, or the new deal with France to make sure that we collaborate with our international partners on a shared issue.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q29
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner highlights the ongoing issue of child hunger in Jarrow despite past promises, and asks for a commitment to provide free school meals.
In 1936, people from my constituency marched to Parliament demanding jobs. They were living in poverty and were hungry. Some 86 years later, 39% of kids in Jarrow are still hungry. Will the Deputy Prime Minister and the Government end that scandal and commit to providing free school meals to all 800,000 children—40,000 of whom are in the north-east—from households in receipt of universal credit?
I thank the hon. Lady. She will know that we have extended the eligibility of free school meals to 1.9 million pupils. On top of that, there is the £200 million holiday activities and food programme and the £1,200 of direct payments to the most vulnerable.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide commitment for all 800,000 children or specific action
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q30
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner argues that the Government's financial difficulties are due to overspending, not under-taxing. She questions whether HS2 should proceed given the need for potential tax rises.
Given that we have the highest burden of taxation in living memory, it is clear that the Government's financial difficulties are caused by overspending, not due to under-taxing. Does the Deputy Prime Minister therefore agree that if the Government have enough money to proceed with HS2 at any cost, then they have sufficient money not to increase taxes; but if they have so little money that they have to increase taxes—the last thing for a Conservative Government to do—then they do not have sufficient money for HS2? So can I gently urge the Deputy Prime Minister not to ask Conservative MPs to support any tax rises unless and until this unnecessary vanity project is scrapped, because I for one will not support them?
I thank my right hon. Friend. I think I followed the various steps of logic in that question. I understand her opposition to HS2. I think we have some very difficult decisions to make. They will inevitably involve a balanced approach.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific stance on HS2 or tax rises
Difficult Decisions
Response accuracy
Q31
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner notes the high usage of food banks in his constituency and asks for a commitment to ensure that benefits will always be enough to purchase essential items.
In my Caerphilly constituency, we have five food banks. One of those food banks is run by the Trussell Trust, and it has issued over 2,000 food parcels during the last six months. There is a question from the users of that food bank, which is: will the Government give a firm commitment to ensuring that benefits will always be enough to purchase essentials?
The hon. Member raises a really important point, and we are doing everything we can to support those who may be reliant on food banks or otherwise struggling to make ends meet. He can see that with the £1,200 cost of living support that is going to the 8 million most vulnerable households, the energy price guarantee and further measures for pensioners.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide firm commitment on benefits covering essentials
Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q32
Partial Answer
▸
Context
In the context of recent debates about standards and conduct within the House, the questioner seeks to affirm the principle of innocence until proven guilty.
My right hon. Friend is also the Justice Secretary, and everybody in this House, irrespective of party, will know that for the reputation of this House standards are important. He has said that from the Dispatch Box this afternoon. However, in response to some of the points raised by Opposition Members, am I naive to still believe in that good British tradition that one is innocent until proven guilty?
My hon. Friend makes an important point. I have said I will co-operate fully with the independent investigation. In fact, I welcome the opportunity to address these complaints. I think, though, that it is important that we have zero tolerance for any bullying and hold the highest standards in public life, and it is important for all of us to adhere to those standards.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The questioner's specific ask about the principle of innocence until proven guilty was not directly addressed.
Response accuracy