Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Cambridge NHS workers face higher living costs than those in outer-London boroughs but receive no cost-of-living supplement, making it difficult to retain and recruit staff.
I am concerned about the high cost of living for NHS workers in Cambridge compared to those in outer-London boroughs. They get paid 15% less despite higher rents, impacting Addenbrooke's Hospital's ability to retain and recruit staff. Will my right hon. Friend work with me to ensure these workers are fairly compensated?
My hon. Friend is a fantastic champion for his constituents and for Addenbrooke's. We are very proud of our NHS, which is why we are putting in record investment.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to fair compensation or additional funding for NHS workers in Cambridge
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Energy bills have risen significantly since the previous week, adding hundreds of millions to household costs while energy companies see significant profit gains.
Since Labour first called for a windfall tax on oil and gas profits four and a half months ago, hundreds of millions more pounds have been added to families' bills. When will people expect him to use those profits to reduce their bills?
We are putting £22 billion into people's pockets already, cutting council tax by £150, reducing fuel duty, and lowering national insurance contributions. We have a strong economy that allowed us to come out of covid faster.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to implementing windfall tax or specific timeline
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Prime Minister has delayed implementing a windfall tax despite Labour's repeated calls over four months. The delay cost households £53 million per day.
Every day of dithering adds £53 million to household bills, causing unnecessary suffering. If the Government was ready to act six months ago, why have they not done so?
We took tough decisions to drive the fastest vaccine roll-out in Europe and now we are abating fuel costs for people up and down the country.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address delay or specific reasons for not implementing windfall tax
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Prime Minister delayed a windfall tax despite Labour's repeated calls over four months, causing significant household bill increases.
With every day of delay adding £53 million to household bills, why have they not acted on the high inflation rate since October's mini-Budget?
The Government are putting in place measures to support people with heating costs, raising universal credit by £1,000, and taking steps like driving vaccine roll-out faster than any other European country.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to windfall tax or address specific delays
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question follows criticism of the Chancellor's economic predictions, specifically on inflation and growth. Keir Starmer points out that despite boasting about better-than-competitor growth rates, Britain is set to have the lowest growth except for Russia.
It was not just the Chancellor back in September—the Prime Minister called fears about inflation “unfounded”. He was the last person to spot the cost of living crisis. In the same speech, the Chancellor boasted about growth and how we would do better than all our major competitors. It was obvious that he was being complacent. Why has his Government inflicted on Britain the twin-headed Hydra of the highest inflation and the lowest growth?
The right hon. and learned Gentleman loves running this country down. Last year, we had the fastest growth in the G7 due to steps taken by our Government. We will return to the fastest growth by 2024-25. Labour does not care about getting people into jobs; we deliver a high-wage, high-skill, high-employment economy.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister avoided addressing why his government's policies led to high inflation and low growth.
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question follows criticism of the Chancellor's past statements about tax rises. Keir Starmer points out that despite claims to support hard-working people, the government has implemented 15 tax rises since taking office.
The Prime Minister talks about running this country down; he is running it down! It was not just complacency on Labour's windfall tax, which he is now backing; it was not just complacency on inflation, which is now through the roof; and it was not just complacency on growth. Then he put their taxes up. Does the Prime Minister want to explain how his 15 tax rises since taking office have helped people to keep more of their rewards in their pocket?
Firstly, we are funding vital public services due to steps taken. We put money back into pockets through measures like cutting national insurance contributions and lifting the living wage. The right hon. and learned Gentleman is wrong about our growth performance; he was proved wrong on covid.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address how recent tax rises have benefitted hard-working people, instead focusing on funding public services.
General Principles
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question addresses concerns about a backlog of 500,000 passport applications potentially affecting holiday plans. Keir Starmer mentions raising the case of Phoenix Halliwell, who needs daily dialysis and is concerned about energy bills.
Just delusional. Last week, I raised the case of Phoenix Halliwell, whose kidney condition means he needs daily dialysis and whose energy bill has gone through the roof as a result. Government officials got in touch with Phoenix yesterday. With the summer holidays looming, there are reports that the Home Office already has a backlog of 500,000 passports to issue. Can the Prime Minister reassure people they will not miss out on their holidays due to Home Office failures?
I thank the right hon. and learned Gentleman, but everyone is getting their passport within four to six weeks. We are driving leadership; we got Brexit done and vaccinated people faster than others. The Opposition would never have done it.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address the specific issue of passport delays impacting holiday plans.
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question raises the case of a constituent, Scott, who is immunocompromised and seeks access to Evusheld. The MP asks for personal intervention from the Prime Minister.
When the Prime Minister gets passionate, things get done. Brexit is done. The vaccine roll-out is done. So will he personally intervene so that the immunocompromised, like my constituent Scott, can get access to British wonder-drug Evusheld—not next winter, not next year, but now—so that they can enjoy this summer and enjoy their freedom?
Evusheld has potential to reduce infection risk. We must look at evidence before deciding if it should be available, but I will keep my hon. Friend updated on progress.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not commit to a specific timeline or intervention for access to Evusheld, only to review the evidence and update the MP.
General Principles
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A tragic shooting event occurred in Texas, leading to the deaths of 19 children and two teachers. This is reminiscent of the Dunblane tragedy that took place 26 years ago in Scotland.
I want to join others today in expressing my deepest sorrow at the horrific events in Texas yesterday. Some 19 children and two teachers have needlessly lost their lives. Many of us in Scotland will be remembering the tragic events that took place in Dunblane 26 years ago. The thoughts and prayers of the SNP are with the families suffering today, but we also hope that lawmakers will finally act to bring to an end the scourge of gun violence that plagues the United States. Will the Prime Minister now take the opportunity and resign?
I can tell the right hon. Gentleman that, much as I appreciate his advice, he will have a further opportunity, which I am sure he will take with his customary length, to debate that matter in the course of the statement that will follow directly after PMQs.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address resignation or gun violence in the US; shifted focus to future debate opportunity
Redirecting
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Prime Minister's conduct during the pandemic has been criticised for breaching lockdown rules. The issue of moral authority and public trust is central.
These are serious matters, but it is all a joke to the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister has lost the trust of the public. He has lost what little moral authority he had left. The reality is that no apology will ever be enough for the families of people who lost loved ones—the families who followed the rules, who stayed at home while their nearest and dearest were dying, and who are now forced to look at photographs of the Prime Minister, surrounded by drink, toasting to a party in the middle of a lockdown. If the Prime Minister will not accept that he must resign, those on the Tory Benches must act. This Prime Minister, who has broken the law and shown a cavalier attitude to the truth, cannot be allowed to remain in office. Time is up, Prime Minister. Resign! Resign before this House is forced to remove you!
I thank the right hon. Gentleman very much, and I direct him to the report. I think it would be to his advantage to look through it and then I think we should return to it after PMQs.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address resignation or apology; shifted focus to future debate opportunity
Redirecting
Response accuracy
Q11
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The area of Burslem and Tunstall is suffering from abandoned property issues which impact heritage buildings. The Planning (Proper Maintenance of Land) Bill seeks to address this by imposing unlimited fines on landlords who allow properties to fall into disrepair.
High streets and heritage mean a lot to the people of Stoke-on-Trent North, Kidsgrove and Talke. Burslem and Tunstall are plagued with rogue and absent landlords letting shops sit empty and historically important buildings such as the Price and Kensington Teapot Works fall into ruin. Can my right hon. Friend confirm that, as part of the Government's planning reform, he will adopt my Bill imposing a new unlimited fine so these reckless reprobates can be held accountable?
I thank my hon. Friend for his campaign, and I think he is entirely right. We have adopted the measures that he proposes in the Bill so that those who leave properties derelict unreasonably could face an unlimited fine.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Northern Ireland faces a cost of living crisis similar to the rest of the UK, with families struggling due to economic pressures.
I was pleased to meet the Prime Minister last week in Royal Hillsborough in my constituency. We welcome his commitment to introduce legislation to deal with the protocol and the Irish sea border, and to protect the Belfast/Good Friday agreement. That will take some time. In the meantime, as in the rest of the United Kingdom, hard-pressed households in Northern Ireland are suffering from the cost of living crisis. Will the Prime Minister give me an assurance that any measures brought forward by the Chancellor in the near future to help hard-pressed households will apply to Northern Ireland, and that the protocol will not be allowed to prevent Northern Ireland citizens receiving the support they need from the Government at this time?
I thank the right hon. Gentleman very much. As he knows, I have already detailed to the House a package of measures to support families across the whole of the UK. I may say that I also think it would be an advantage to the people of Northern Ireland, in tackling the issues that we all face across the UK, if Stormont were to be restored.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm measures' applicability; shifted focus to Stormont restoration
Redirecting
Response accuracy
Q13
Direct Answer
▸
Context
There is a need to ensure that small rural and coastal communities benefit from levelling-up initiatives, as highlighted by recent reports.
The recent report on levelling up the rural economy highlighted many areas where more work is needed in small rural and coastal communities to ensure they also benefit from our levelling-up agenda. Does the Prime Minister agree that we need to ensure that levelling up reaches into rural and coastal Devon? Will he meet me and Helen Hurford, our excellent candidate in Tiverton and Honiton, to agree how we can progress our plans for Devon?
Yes, of course. My hon. Friend is a fantastic advocate for Devon and rural communities, and I will ensure that both she and Helen Hurford get a meeting with the relevant Minister to discuss her ideas further.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Fuel costs are causing problems for workers in car-dependent rural areas, such as nurses and care providers. The situation is particularly severe due to long travel distances.
Rising fuel costs are causing serious problems for workers in car-dependent rural areas such as Ceredigion, and for carers and district nurses the situation has reached a crisis point. One carer from Ceredigion often has to travel 29 miles just to reach her first service user of the day and travels about 1,700 miles each month. Will the Prime Minister therefore consider extending the rural fuel duty relief scheme to areas such as Ceredigion to help my constituent and many like her to continue their invaluable work?
I thank the hon. Member for his excellent question. Rural fuel duty relief is there to compensate motorists by helping retailers in some more remote rural areas where pump prices can be significantly higher. It currently operates on a geographical basis, but I am happy to ensure that he gets a meeting with the relevant Minister as fast as possible.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q15
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Labour Party's economic policies are criticized for raising taxes and borrowing excessively.
Labour and socialism have failed the country because their failed policies interfere too much in people's lives, over-regulate, spend too much taxpayers' money, borrow too much and raise taxes. Will the Prime Minister tell the House what policies his Government will follow to ensure that we do not have a similar fate?
Yes, I can. I am grateful to my hon. Friend, who is absolutely right that Labour's instinct everywhere and always is to put up tax, with all its—[Interruption.] Well, Labour Members are bragging about it today—it is ludicrous. What we are doing is not only cutting people's contributions under national insurance but helping businesses to invest with the 130% super deduction that my right hon. Friend the Chancellor put in. That is helping us to have a high-wage, high-skill economy, with unemployment—yes, I have said this before, Mr Speaker—at its lowest since 1974.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A victim of disgraced former Conservative MP Imran Ahmad Khan warned the party before his election.
Days before the election of disgraced former Conservative MP Imran Ahmad Khan, his victim warned the Conservative party of the abuse that he had suffered. Will the Prime Minister tell the House what policies or actions were taken in response?
I hear what the hon. Member says and the sensitivity of the issues that she raises. Given the legal proceedings that are currently going on, I do not think it would be right to comment any further.
▸
Assessment & feedback
legal proceedings preventing a response
Response accuracy
Q17
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Parents are struggling with high childcare costs despite government spending.
While the politics of politics often gets all the attention, back in the real world millions of parents—I declare a quite obvious interest—are being held back by issues with childcare schemes, which have been a muddle under Governments of all political colours. The taxpayer is spending five to six billion quid a year and we have some of the highest costs in the world during a cost of living squeeze. Stroud parents and early years educators are also really stuck with the bureaucracy. I know that my right hon. Friend has personally asked Ministers to investigate options to reduce the costs of childcare. Will he tell us a little more about what we can do urgently, and will he work with me and the Onward think-tank on reforms?
Yes. I thank my hon. Friend very much. She and I have talked about this. This is a subject in which I take a direct personal interest. There are things we can do to make childcare more affordable. One issue is that not enough people take up tax-free childcare, so we need to have more take-up of what is on offer. We can also look at ways in which we can reform and improve the system.
▸
Assessment & feedback
specific reforms or timelines
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Government dropped the recommendation for personal evacuation plans for disabled residents in tall buildings.
Next month marks five years since the horrific Grenfell Tower fire which killed 72 people. My constituency of Vauxhall has many tall buildings similar to Grenfell. In 2019, the Prime Minister rightly told this House that where the inquiry recommends Government responsibility for fire safety, “we will legislate accordingly.” But last week the Government dropped the inquiry's recommendation that a personal evacuation plan should be in place for disabled residents, claiming basic safety would be too expensive. Grenfell United said that that showed “cutting costs is more important than the value of human life.” Will the Prime Minister urgently reverse this deeply inhumane decision and not break another promise to this House?
Let us be clear: if there is an issue with fire safety in a building, extra steps should be taken and remediation should be made. When it comes to self-evacuation, the Home Office has launched a new consultation to support the fire safety of residents who are unable to self-evacuate, but if the hon. Lady has further representations to make on that point, I will be very happy to ensure she gets a meeting with a Minister in the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities.
▸
Assessment & feedback
specific reversal commitment
Response accuracy
Q19
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee had its scheduled meeting cancelled.
Mr Speaker, I am not a cynical sort but I was slightly perplexed this week when the Cabinet Secretary and the director general of Government Propriety and Ethics, no less, were banned from attending my Committee, the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee, to give evidence. That meeting had been scheduled for two months. I cannot possibly think why, Mr Speaker. I wonder which particular subjects my right hon. Friend the Prime Minister was most concerned about being raised by my Committee. Was it the case of undeclared loans and donations in kind, security insights into appointments to the House of Lords, or indeed the consultation of the Propriety and Ethics unit in ministerial appointments?
I know my hon. Friend is not a cynic; he is one of nature's idealists. I will make sure that all relevant Ministers and civil servants appear before his Committee.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q20
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Prime Minister is accused of being out of touch with rising bills.
The Prime Minister is leading a long queue of Conservative MPs lining up to show how out of touch they are. Bills are rising and people are struggling. A quarter of people in work in Putney earn less than the London living wage. They do not need to be told how to budget better, to learn how to cook or how to buy value food. They are already doing so. When will the Prime Minister get a grip on this crisis and when will he bring in the windfall tax?
What we are doing for the people of Putney, and indeed the people throughout the country, is making sure that we invest now in protecting them, as I have said to the House and I have said repeatedly, not just with the increases in universal credit, the living wage and the warm home discount and cutting fuel bills, but with the £330 cut in NICs. The reason we can do that is that we have a robust economic position and strong employment. That is giving us the revenue to pay and to cushion people at this difficult time. It would not have been possible if we had listened to the Labour party during covid.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q21
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Tens of thousands of Huddersfield fans are coming to London for rugby league and football finals.
This weekend tens of thousands of Huddersfield sports fans are coming down to London. On Saturday, Huddersfield Giants are in their first rugby league challenge cup final for over a decade, and, on Sunday, it is Huddersfield Town in the championship play-off final for a place in the premier league. As well as wishing the best of luck to both Huddersfield teams, will the Prime Minister, agree with me that the best way that Labour-run Kirklees Council can honour the sporting tradition of Huddersfield is by following through with its pledge to house the new national rugby league museum in its birthplace, the George Hotel in Huddersfield, and not pull out of that deal, as it has indicated it wants to do?
Is that the Labour council pulling out of its deal? I am not surprised. All I can say is that I congratulate my hon. Friend on his campaign for a national rugby league museum and I urge him to take it up with the Arts Council or other relevant bodies.
▸
Assessment & feedback
supporting Labour council's pledge
Redirects To Arts Council
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Following the pandemic, there has been a significant shift in wealth from the poorest to the richest. Upwards of 175,000 citizens have died due to COVID-19, and now the cost of living crisis is worsening.
Under cover of the pandemic we have seen a massive shift in wealth from the poorest to the richest. A partying Prime Minister and a law-breaking rich list Chancellor have lined the pockets of their wealthy pals while upwards of 175,000 of our fellow citizens have died from covid, and they are now sitting on their hands and laughing in our faces as the cost of living crisis and fuel poverty could well leave thousands more to die of cold in their own homes. So when we saw pictures of the Prime Minister partying in the middle of the pandemic was he toasting his assault on the working class, and how on earth does he sleep at night with so much blood on his filthy, privileged hands?
From furlough onwards everything we have done since the pandemic began has been to get money into the pockets of the working people of this country; those are the people who time and again we have prioritised. I do not for a moment doubt that things are tough—I do not doubt it for a moment—but it is our intention to get this country through it, and we will get through it very well by putting our arms around people as we can, and as we will because of the fiscal firepower we have, but also by making sure that we continue with the high wage, high skill, high employment economy that we have. The best way to get money into people's pockets is for them to have a job.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions or funding for addressing the cost of living crisis and fuel poverty were not provided
Putting Our Arms Around People As We Can
Fiscal Firepower
Response accuracy
Q23
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The opposition has been accused of planning to increase taxes significantly.
Does the Prime Minister agree that when the Leader of the Opposition spins his myth of a low tax Labour party, he clearly needs a memory jog? May I remind Labour Members that in 2019 they all stood on a manifesto that would have inflicted the highest tax burden on the people of this country in peacetime—
Yes, Labour campaigned to put up taxes on business to the highest level this country has ever seen; that was the Leader of the Opposition's ambition, and that is what they would do again. Be in no doubt, that is what they love to do—we can feel the lust for tax rising off those Opposition Benches—and that is why there has never been a Labour Government who left office with unemployment lower than when they came in.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Lust For Tax
Response accuracy
Q24
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Ofgem's head warned MPs about a significant rise in the energy price cap, which could cause hardship for many.
Yesterday the head of Ofgem advised MPs that the energy cap is due to increase to £2,800 in the autumn, more than double last year's cap. I know the Prime Minister has been busy drafting and redrafting his half-arsed apologies rather than helping the people of Bury South, but at which work event did he realise Labour's call was the right thing to do; considering he and his party voted against it last week? Is it just to save his own neck?
I heard enough to have a rough idea of the nonsense the hon. Gentleman was talking. We are not only supporting people now but will continue to put our arms around the people of this country, as we did during the pandemic and beyond.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specifics about recognizing Labour's energy price cap proposal were avoided
Putting Our Arms Around The People
Response accuracy
Q25
Partial Answer
▸
Context
170 British Council contractors are in danger in Afghanistan, with 85 at high risk.
The Prime Minister will recall that I previously raised with him the plight of 170 British Council contractors who remain in Afghanistan in fear of their lives, 85 of whom are deemed to be at very high risk. I had a positive meeting with the refugee Minister, Lord Harrington, last week, but we face bureaucracy that is preventing the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office from helping these people now courtesy of the Afghan citizens resettlement scheme. Will the Prime Minister help us cut through that red tape and help these people, as we owe them a debt of obligation and time is running out?
I will see what we can do to help those particular people but I just remind the House that we not only evacuated 25,000 people under Op Pitting, which was a great credit to this country, but since then have supported 4,600 more to come to this country, and we will do what we can to help the people my hon. Friend mentions.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specifics about cutting red tape were not provided
Remind The House
Response accuracy
Q26
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Inflation is at a high of 9%, making it difficult for workers despite the low pay campaign in schools.
Jubilee LEAD Academy in my constituency, working with Nottingham citizens, recently asked me to visit the school to hear about their low pay campaign. They are tired of seeing people in our community working hard but living in poverty. Bills are rising and inflation is at 9%, yet the Government seem incapable and, frankly, a little disinterested in doing anything to help out. Our children can see the need for emergency action; why cannot our Government?
Everybody in work—30 million workers—will get a tax cut in July, on top of everything that we are already doing, but that is not the end of what this Government are going to do to look after people. I told the House before this afternoon that we will continue to use our fiscal firepower to look after the British people through the covid aftershocks and beyond.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions addressing inflation and low pay were not provided
Tax Cut In July
Fiscal Firepower
Response accuracy
Q27
Direct Answer
▸
Context
A school bus crash occurred, affecting several children and prompting a community response.
On Monday at 3.25 pm, a school bus crashed into a group of schoolchildren in Llanfair Caereinion. Three children were airlifted to hospital, with another child and the bus driver taken by ambulance, and a fifth child was discharged at the scene. Everyone is in a stable condition. Clearly, this is a tragic accident that will stay with the community for some time. Will the Prime Minister join me and, I am sure, the whole House in sending our love and prayers to those in hospital? Will he also praise the teaching staff of both the primary and the high school, Wales Air Ambulance and Dyfed-Powys police for their heroic and continuing response to the community?
I thank my hon. Friend for raising this very sad incident. I am sure that the thoughts of the whole House will be with those who have been affected. I want to join him, in particular, in paying tribute to the emergency services and, of course, the teachers and staff at the school, who did so much to help.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q28
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A constituent of the MP's disclosed in confidence that they were a gay man, but this was breached by the HR department at the Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
My constituent, Robert Walker, sadly died last year. He worked for MI6 and, as such, disclosed in confidence that he was a gay man. That confidence was breached by the HR department at the Foreign and Commonwealth Office. Recently unearthed paperwork showed that that breach largely accounted for his wellbeing issues and enforced early retirement. Will the Prime Minister offer Bob's partner, Stephen Honeyman, a posthumous apology and commit to asking the FCO for a formal response to his treatment while he worked at MI6?
I begin by saying how grateful I am to the hon. Member for raising that case. I am afraid that I do not know directly about the events that she describes. What she says is very concerning and I will make sure that she gets a meeting with the relevant Minister as soon as possible.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment to offering an apology was avoided
Meeting With The Relevant Minister
Response accuracy