Magistrates Sentencing Powers 2022-10-18

2022-10-18

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Nadia Whittome Lab
Nottingham East
Context
Concerns have been raised about further extending sentencing powers, potentially increasing Crown court pressures and prison overcrowding.
That does not really answer my question, although I thank the Minister for his response. My question is whether he intends to extend the sentencing powers further. Although I obviously share his desire to tackle backlogs and reduce waiting times in the Crown courts, concerns have been raised that further increasing the sentencing powers of magistrates is not the right way to go about this. More defendants may elect to be tried in Crown courts anyway, and expanded powers could result in higher sentences, putting even more pressure on already overcrowded prisons and leading to an increase in Crown court appeals.
I make no apologies for locking up criminals. I have confidence in the good blend of district judges and justices of the peace in the magistrates courts. We have not seen how the existing increase in powers has been borne out, and we have not seen what the impact will be. We will keep that under review and, until we have that information, I cannot add anything further.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about future policy intentions was avoided; instead, the minister defended current practices without addressing concerns or considering alternatives.
We Will Keep That Under Review And, Until We Have That Information, I Cannot Add Anything Further.
Response accuracy