Topical Questions 2022-05-16
2022-05-16
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP inquired about the department's initiatives to move civil servants from London and the south-east to other parts of the UK.
If he will make a statement on his departmental responsibilities. The Places for Growth programme has seen civil servants relocated across the country. Will this initiative be joined by Members of Parliament moving to different cities?
Across Government, the Places for Growth programme has seen civil servants relocated from London and the south-east to different parts of the United Kingdom, whether it is Treasury civil servants going to Darlington in County Durham, Home Office officials going to Stoke-on-Trent in Staffordshire or indeed my own officials relocating to Wolverhampton in the west midlands. There was speculation in some newspapers at the weekend that that estimable effort by civil servants should be joined by Members of the other place. I would wholeheartedly welcome the relocation of the House of Lords to one of our great cities.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The MP's specific questions about Northstowe were not directly addressed, instead the answerer focused on the speculation regarding the relocation of the House of Lords.
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP's constituency includes Northstowe, a major new development facing issues like lack of community amenities and environmental problems.
Northstowe has 1,000 houses but no dedicated community centre, café, pub or shop. This new town also causes flooding and water shortages in neighbouring villages due to poor local planning. What will the Department do to address these issues as Northstowe grows?
Steps taken in the Levelling-up and Regeneration Bill and changes to the national planning policy framework should absolutely address the problems my hon. Friend identifies. Of course, the biggest problem he identifies is the fact that, sadly, South Cambridgeshire has a Liberal Democrat-controlled local planning authority that does not care about community but pursues a narrow political agenda, to the detriment of all.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific issues in Northstowe were avoided; instead, the answerer criticized the local Liberal Democrat planning authority.
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Millions of tenants are at risk due to surging rent levels and a frozen local housing allowance, increasing the danger of arrears and eviction. Rent tribunals are not effective safeguards against unaffordable rent rises.
With rent levels surging in the private sector and with the local housing allowance frozen once again, millions of hard-pressed tenants across the country are at risk of arrears and eviction. We know that rent tribunals are not an effective safeguard against punitive rent rises, and that the risk of such rises is likely only to increase when section 21 no-fault evictions are finally scrapped. Will the Secretary of State therefore tell the House why his planned renters reform Bill appears to be completely silent on protections for tenants against unaffordable rent rises?
Our renters reform Bill will specifically ensure that people in the private rented sector are protected, and I look forward to working with the hon. Gentleman to ensure that the Bill satisfies the need of the hour.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific request for details on protections against unaffordable rent rises was not addressed directly; only a vague commitment given.
Response accuracy
Q4
Direct Answer
▸
Context
North Warwickshire Borough Council operates on a budget of £9.5 million, the lowest in Warwickshire.
North Warwickshire Borough Council does a fantastic job of serving our local community despite operating on a budget of only £9.5 million, which is certainly the lowest in Warwickshire and must be one of the lowest in the country. Will the Minister agree to come to my constituency to meet the council and see how it could put the levelling-up funding on offer to excellent use?
I pay tribute to David Wright and North Warwickshire Borough Council because they have done a fantastic job, particularly during covid, in supporting the local community and local business. I would be delighted to visit—not least because it is only 20 minutes away from Harborough.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Shropshire missed out on three levelling-up bids last year and a bus service improvement plan this year, raising concerns about the allocation process.
Just last year, Shropshire's Conservative-run council missed out on three levelling-up bids, and it missed out on a bus service improvement plan bid under the Bus Back Better fund. There is no doubt that Shropshire has need of these funds, so I would like to understand: what steps is the Secretary of State taking to ensure that levelling-up funds are allocated on the basis of need, rather than through some opaque bidding process that seems to be influenced by a council's ability to direct resources at that bid?
We allocate levelling-up fund bids, as the Local Government Minister pointed out earlier, on the basis of appropriate competition in order to ensure value for money, but I have had a chance to talk to the excellent Conservative leader of Shropshire Council, Lezley Picton, to make sure that she and her superb team of Conservative councillors can deliver for the people of Shropshire, as Conservatives always have.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The MP's specific question about allocation based on need was avoided; instead, praise was given to a Conservative leader.
Response accuracy
Q6
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Mid-Wales has received historically high funding from the shared prosperity fund, taking rurality into account.
I thank my right hon. Friend for delivering the shared prosperity fund with historically high funding for mid-Wales and Montgomeryshire in particular at more than £200 per head. I particularly thank him for the golden thread of rurality that we find in this formula, and I press him to continue delivering for rural communities.
One reason why mid-Wales has one of highest shared prosperity fund allocations in the country is precisely because we have taken rurality and the additional costs that come with it into account, and I look forward to building on that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP criticizes the government for treating levelling up as a postcode lottery rather than genuine support.
It is clear that the Government's approach to levelling up is a postcode lottery based on their own political ambitions rather than a genuine desire to help communities. With Portsmouth's high streets in dire need of investment and our city's cultural attractions struggling with the cost of living, when will the Minister stop moving the goalposts and finally stop short-changing Portsmouth?
That scored quite high on the cliché count with 'postcode lottery', 'moving the goalposts' and 'narrow political calculation'. Instead of rehearsing for YouTube clips, the hon. Gentleman would be better employed looking at what we have done, not just for Portsmouth and Southampton, but for communities including Liverpool and Birkenhead where this Government has been responsible for ensuring that local government receives the support it needs.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The MP's specific question about investment in Portsmouth was avoided; instead, criticism of the opposition was given.
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The social housing Bill was mentioned in the Queen's Speech and is expected to give tenants more rights.
I welcome the fact that the social housing Bill will be in the Queen's Speech. Will my right hon Friend confirm that the Bill will give social housing tenants the ability to hold their landlords to account? Will he also detail the likely timing of the Bill?
My hon Friend is right that the social housing Bill will help social housing tenants in Kensington to hold their landlords to account, but we are not waiting for the new legislation; we are driving the “Make Things Right” campaign to make sure that tenants understand how to do so and how to escalate complaints to the housing ombudsman if necessary.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Timing of the Bill was not specified.
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A Bloomberg report suggests levelling up has not been happening in Scotland despite its self-sufficiency in gas and offshore renewables.
Last week's Bloomberg report suggests that levelling up in Scotland is just not happening. Given that Scotland is self-sufficient in gas and has great offshore renewables, should not the stewardship, licensing and revenues be linked to the Scottish Government budget, rather than to Her Majesty's Treasury? Minister, when will these negotiations start?
I am grateful to the hon Gentleman for raising the issue of the importance of the Scottish Government and the UK Government working together on levelling up. That is why I am pleased that, working with the Finance Minister in the Scottish Government, Kate Forbes, we have been able to agree a prospectus for two new freeports in Scotland.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Timing of negotiations not mentioned; instead discussed freeports initiative.
Changing Subject
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Proposals to ensure that empty shops are rented out but there is concern about who they will be rented to.
I welcome the proposals to ensure that empty shops have to be rented, but will the Minister explain whom they will be rented to? Will this enable upper floors to be converted to much-needed affordable housing? When will we see progress on filling key visible empty units in town centres such as Barnstaple?
High street rental auctions will apply to commercial property and make tenancies more accessible to businesses and community groups. We recognise the importance of diversifying high streets and have introduced permitted development rights to allow a wide range of commercial buildings to be changed to residential use without needing a planning application.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specifics on who will rent shops and timelines were not provided.
Response accuracy
Q11
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Individuals involved in the Homes for Ukraine scheme sort matches with hosts through ad hoc Facebook groups, which has raised concerns about potential exploitation.
In the Homes for Ukraine scheme, it is left to the individuals involved to sort out matches with hosts themselves, often through ad hoc Facebook groups. It is not surprising that this has led to reports of sexual exploitation risks. What assurance can the Secretary of State give in respect of the rigour and effectiveness of the separate home checks that are undertaken for the scheme?
The right hon Gentleman raises an important question. I am very grateful to the more than 100,000 UK citizens who have signed up to offer their homes for the scheme. As well as criminal record and police national computer checks before visas are granted, there are vetting and barring and other checks conducted by local authorities at the time that individuals find themselves in homes.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The borough council in the constituency has built new housing specifically for military veterans, raising questions about broader government support.
In my constituency, the borough council has recently built new housing specifically for military veterans. As an ex-serviceperson myself, I was delighted to see this. Will the Minister please outline what more the Government are doing to make sure that there is housing for our veterans?
I thank my hon Friend for his service to his country. The Government are committed to making the UK the best place in the world to be a veteran. Veterans with urgent housing needs are always given high priority for social housing, and we are investing £11.5 billion under the affordable homes programme to deliver more social homes, including housing for veterans.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Concern about the lack of a timetable for the renters reform Bill despite its mention in three consecutive Queen's Speeches.
For many in the privately rented sector, the Government are like Nero, fiddling while Rome burns. When are they going to get on and publish the timetable for the renters reform Bill? Last week's was the third Queen's Speech in which the Bill has been mentioned, yet there is still no timetable.
The hon Lady suggests we are being Neronian in fiddling while Rome burns, but I prefer to think that we have crossed the Rubicon—the die has been cast—and the Bill will be on the statute book in this parliamentary Session.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Timetable for the Bill was not provided; instead compared opposition's view negatively.
Negative Comparison
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Forget-Me-Not group in Blyth is working hard to secure better opportunities for everyone but needs a community base.
The Forget-Me-Not group in Blyth is working hard to secure better opportunities for everyone in its local area of Cowpen Quay; however, the group needs a base in the community to house and deliver its services. This is grassroots levelling up, so will my right hon Friend the Secretary of State agree to meet me to discuss exactly what we can do to help these people?
My hon Friend is right to highlight the work of the Forget-Me-Not group in Blyth, which is doing amazing work in Cowpen Quay. I will do everything I can to support the group and will meet my hon Friend to do so.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Meeting was promised but specific actions were not detailed.
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Parish councillor Lisa Corkerry is working to improve her community but needs adequate funds for local authorities.
Will Ministers join me in recognising and commending the work of Ellel parish councillor Lisa Corkerry? She is never afraid to don the marigolds, grab the litter pickers and clean up Galgate. Lisa would like to know when the Government are going to provide adequate funds for local authorities such that she can put her efforts into making her community better rather than clearing up the mess left behind by others.
The local councillor the hon Lady mentions sounds like an absolutely brilliant champion for her local community. I would love to know more, particularly about what we can do to help in practical terms, and I look forward to working with her.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific funding was not mentioned; instead discussed future work with the councillor.
Changing Subject
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The issue revolves around the challenges faced by private-rented off-grid properties in achieving energy performance improvements.
Energy performance improvements to domestic dwellings are an important part of the Government's agenda in respect of climate change obligations, as well as in respect of the cost of living. May I draw the attention of my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State to private-rented off-grid properties, for which it is much more difficult and expensive to achieve energy performance improvements than for normal domestic dwellings?
It will indeed be much more challenging, which is why I am working closely with the Under-Secretary of State at the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, Lord Callanan, to see how we can address the problem. I look forward to discussing the issue further with my right hon. Friend to see how we can find an appropriate solution.
▸
Assessment & feedback
No specific plans or figures were provided for addressing challenges faced by private-rented off-grid properties in achieving energy performance improvements.
Response accuracy
Q17
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP wants a meeting with the Minister to discuss funding for the Horden masterplan as well as other regeneration schemes in his area.
Many agree that investment in levelling up should be not a competition but a considered plan created in partnership between central and local government to address the areas of greatest need. Ministers are meeting many Conservative MPs, but will the Minister meet me to discuss the levelling-up bid for my area to fund the Horden masterplan as well as to identify funding for other much-needed regeneration schemes in Easington Colliery and Peterlee town centre?
Durham is on the up and east Durham must be part of that story, so, of course, we will make sure that a Minister meets the hon. Gentleman to discuss what we can do to help.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP is concerned about the UK lagging behind Europe in rolling out full fibre broadband, especially in rural areas of the devolved nations.
Full fibre broadband coverage is essential to the Government's aim to level up, but we lag behind most of Europe in rolling it out. What discussions has the Minister had with the Culture Secretary to ensure that the Government have a strategy to work with industry to improve coverage and speed up progress in rural and urban areas of the devolved nations, which currently have the poorest broadband?
The Culture Secretary and I talk daily. One thing at the top of our agenda is ensuring that we have connectivity across the whole United Kingdom. We are, of course, working with the devolved Administrations to make sure that every citizen of the United Kingdom benefits from UK Government investment.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not provide details about specific discussions or strategies for improving broadband coverage in rural areas of the devolved nations.
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP wants to encourage the Secretary of State to make contact with Mayor Tracy Brabin, who chairs a cross-party group of Mayors.
I am sure that the Secretary of State will want to acknowledge the increasingly important role played by metro Mayors. May I therefore encourage him to make contact with Mayor Tracy Brabin, the excellent metro Mayor for West Yorkshire who now chairs cross-party group of Mayors, the M10, to ensure the closest working relationship between national, regional and local government?
I take the opportunity to thank the hon. Gentleman for his years of service as metro Mayor for South Yorkshire, during which, all party political differences aside, he did a superb job. I also congratulate his successor, Oliver Coppard. I look forward to working with Oliver and, of course, Tracy Brabin in the years ahead.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer focused on past service and current relationships rather than explicitly addressing the request for a new contact.
Response accuracy
Q20
Partial Answer
▸
Context
One of the MP's constituents wants to sponsor a family of Ukrainian children, but the process has been delayed.
One of my constituents wants to sponsor a family of Ukrainian children, but the pause in applications has delayed the family's ability to travel to the UK because they are travelling separately. The delay cannot be about safeguarding, as Ministers have claimed, because it has made them less safe. Will the Secretary of State intervene with his ministerial colleagues and enable Ukrainian children who are at risk to reach sanctuary in this country as soon as possible?
I cannot comment on any individual case, but it is absolutely the Government's responsibility to ensure that as many Ukrainian parents and children benefit from our scheme as possible. We have to balance safeguarding concerns with the policy of the Ukrainian Government, but the hon. Gentleman raises an important question, and more will follow.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not provide a commitment or timeline for intervention by the Secretary of State.
Response accuracy
Q21
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP is concerned about the lack of new investment for the north-east in the levelling-up White Paper.
The levelling-up White Paper offered practically no new investment for the north-east, but it did have grandiose missions. Now we see from the draft Bill that those missions—and targets—can be changed at will by Ministers. Is not that a cheater's charter, and are the missions worth the White Paper they are written on?
Newcastle has benefited from great civic leadership from Nick Forbes, who, sadly, is no longer the leader of Newcastle City Council as a result of a Corbynite coup. I want to thank him for his leadership. I stress that the missions can change because we live in a democracy, and this House should be capable of deciding the destiny of this nation. For that reason—[Interruption.] I know that the hon. Member for Newcastle upon Tyne Central (Chi Onwurah) finds the idea of democracy laughable, but democracy, I am afraid, returned a Conservative Government in 2019 to level up and unite this country, and that is the mission we will fulfil.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not address concerns about investment for the north-east or the flexibility of missions/targets.
Attack
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP wants to ensure that his constituents receive at least the same funding from UK shared prosperity funding as they did from EU structural funds.
The Secretary of State likes to discuss the shared prosperity fund in abstract policy terms, but let us bring it back to brass tacks. In Angus, in 2019, we received £2,750,186 from the EU's structural fund. Can he assure my constituents that we will get at least that, plus inflation, minus the Union Jack ribbon?
Whether they are in Arbroath, Montrose or Kirriemuir, people will recognise the vital importance of UK shared prosperity funding and other funding. When the hon. Gentleman talks about “no Union Jack ribbon” is he really suggesting, for example, that UK armed forces based in Arbroath and Montrose should leave? Is that what he is suggesting? Is he suggesting that we rip up the Union Jack in order to make a narrow, nationalist political point? Does he want the Marines to leave his constituency? That is what it sounds like to me. It sounds to me that he is more prepared to make a narrow, partisan nationalist point than to see this country defended at a time of testing.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not address the funding comparison or assurance sought by the MP.
Attack
Response accuracy