Topical Questions 2022-11-24

2022-11-24

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Peter Dowd Lab
Bootle
Context
The Chancellor's autumn statement was recently delivered, addressing the Department for Transport's budget and rail strikes.
I am concerned about the Department for Transport's responsibilities as outlined in the recent autumn statement. The department is investing £20 billion in transport infrastructure annually and spending £6 billion a year to maintain existing infrastructure and operate vital services. However, I question the direction of such investments given rail strikes and passenger decline post-COVID.
The Chancellor's autumn statement confirmed unchanged budget for transport infrastructure, with £20 billion invested annually. The Government is urging trade union leaders to negotiate with employers on reforming the rail network due to 20% passenger decline post-COVID.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific commitment or timeline for addressing issues related to rail strikes and passenger decline.
Urging Trade Union Leaders To Negotiate
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Peter Dowd Lab
Bootle
Context
National Highways is planning a road through Rimrose valley in Bootle, costing up to £365 million before the current inflationary crisis.
I welcome the team to their places. The National Highways plans for the A5036 road through Rimrose valley are unwanted and unnecessary, exacerbating issues rather than addressing them. Will the Department ask Highways England to scrap these plans?
National Highways is aware of various opinions on its proposals for the A5036 and is committed to working with all stakeholders, acknowledging the hon. Gentleman's views.
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm or deny scrapping plans, only acknowledged stakeholder engagement.
Commitment To Stakeholder Work
Response accuracy
Q3 Direct Answer
Context
The Roads Minister was asked about the proposed Kettering junction on the A14, part of RIS3 for 2025-2030.
Will the Department confirm that a new junction 10a on the A14 at Kettering remains in the pipeline for road investment strategy 3 and is being actively developed by National Highways?
The Government's proposed junction 10a at Kettering on the A14 continues to be developed by National Highways as part of the pipeline for RIS3 schemes.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Mike Kane Lab
Wythenshawe and Sale East
Context
The P&O scandal led to condemnation of companies treating workers with callousness, but Mike Kane found evidence that Irish Ferries pays seafarers £5.50 an hour while receiving public contracts.
Earlier this year, the Transport Secretary condemned P&O for callously treating workers. Now I have evidence showing its competitor, Irish Ferries, pays seafarers just £5.50 an hour and received a taxpayer-funded contract. How can the Government condemn such practices yet hand over money to companies with poor wage models?
We are currently examining this issue speedily, and the Seafarers' Wages Bill is expected in Parliament within weeks to address such matters.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific details on current measures or conditions for contracts.
Examining Issue Seafarers' Wages Bill
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
David Simmonds Con
Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner
Context
During a visit to West Lodge Primary School, David Simmonds saw efforts against bad parking and engine idling. He argues for tailored air quality solutions over Mayor Khan's one-size-fits-all ULTRA scheme.
Visiting West Lodge Primary School revealed excellent work on tackling poor parking and engine idling. We need effective measures to address air quality hotspots in suburbs, unlike the Mayor of London's ULTRA zone scheme which fails to tackle issues like engine idling outside schools.
We agree tackling air quality is important, but how it's done and which schemes are run is devolved to local government. The Mayor of London has consulted on ULEZ extension plans expected soon.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the need for tailored suburban solutions.
Devolution Mayor'S Consultation
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Dan Jarvis Lab
Barnsley North
Context
Concerns exist about the downgraded rail option for Bradford in Northern Powerhouse Rail's core plan.
Decisions on Northern Powerhouse Rail will shape the railways for generations, so we need to be ambitious. The current core plan includes a downgraded rail option for Bradford. Will you reassess this and provide more detail?
The Prime Minister tasked our Department with assessing options for Bradford, including a new station and better connections. I am prioritising this work.
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm review of the current core plan's option.
New Assessment
Response accuracy
Q7 Direct Answer
Luke Evans Con
Hinckley and Bosworth
Context
The Ivanhoe line project, joining Burton to Leicester through Luke Evans' constituency, has gained support from MPs, local authorities, and funding.
The campaign for the Ivanhoe line, supported by four MPs, is gaining traction with significant funding secured. Will you comment on where this programme stands and its likelihood of coming forward?
Network Rail is undertaking development work for different service and scope options, progressing the business case. Decisions are expected in the next year within financial constraints.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Context
The UK Government's £32 million scheme to improve toilet facilities for lorry drivers is entirely unspent a year after its announcement by the Chancellor.
Unite the union discovered through a freedom of information request that the government's scheme to improve toilet facilities for lorry drivers remains unspent. Why has this happened?
The hon. Member may have missed the announcement this morning that the scheme has just been opened. I shall be visiting a road haulage site this afternoon to launch the scheme for match funding across the country to improve lorry facilities for our truckers, who worked hard throughout the entire pandemic.
Assessment & feedback
Reasons why £32 million remains unspent were not provided
Deflecting By Announcing Scheme Opening Instead Of Addressing Non-Spending
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
Highways England is considering safety measures for the A38 between Carkeel and Trerulefoot in South East Cornwall.
While Highways England considers safety measures, what commitment can be made regarding major improvements to the A38, such as a bypass, to support the local economy?
Highways England is developing a package of targeted safety measures for the A38, which will be considered for possible delivery within RIS3. Although we are not considering further massive enhancements such as a bypass at this time, future road plans remain open.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to consider major improvements like a bypass was avoided
Deflecting By Stating Current Focus On Safety Measures Only
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Mary Glindon Lab
Newcastle upon Tyne East and Wallsend
Context
Arriva buses in North Tyneside have led to pupils at North Gosforth Academy needing counselling due to transport worries.
Can the Minister force Arriva to provide a more reliable bus service, given that it affects school students' mental health?
£163.5 million will be heading to the north-east as part of the bus service improvement scheme. We are just finalising details and looking at how we can improve transport services in the future.
Assessment & feedback
Direct enforcement action was not committed
Deflecting By Mentioning Broader Funding Plans
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
The Chancellor announced that capital transport investment will be a central pillar of the Government's growth agenda.
When will details on prioritised projects, such as East West Rail, be set out by the Secretary of State?
Over the coming weeks my colleagues and I will look at priorities across capital projects. We will set them out in the House in due course, and I note his bid for East West Rail.
Assessment & feedback
Specific timeline or prioritisation details were not given
Deflecting By Stating General Review Process
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Context
Car manufacturers are introducing pay-to-use features in vehicles.
Are there plans to regulate these increasing pay-to-use features in new cars?
Commercial matters around car manufacture and delivery are up to individual manufacturers. The Government has put £100 million to support Nissan's next generation of electric vehicles.
Assessment & feedback
Question about regulation was entirely avoided
Deflecting By Mentioning Unrelated Funding
Response accuracy
Q13 Direct Answer
Priti Patel Con
Witham
Context
Railway strikes are expected to increase traffic on roads such as the A12 and A120 in Essex.
Will the Secretary of State meet me and the leader of Essex County Council to discuss these road projects?
I would be delighted to meet her and the leader of Essex County Council to talk about those important road projects.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Wera Hobhouse Lib Dem
Bath
Context
Research suggests that rolling stock leasing companies are being forced to destroy electric units due to delays in railway electrification.
Will the Government ensure no more diesel trains are ordered until they catch up on their electrification plans?
The Government is committed to phasing out all diesel trains by 2040. Electrification is ongoing along the west midlands line, and we are committed to rolling out more electrification.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to not order any new diesel trains was avoided
Deflecting By Referencing Existing Commitments
Response accuracy
Q15 Direct Answer
Context
Electrification of the Chase line has improved services, but passengers from Rugeley face disadvantages.
Will the Rail Minister meet me to discuss issues faced by Chase line passengers?
My right hon. Friend does an incredible job for her constituents, and on that basis of course I say yes to meeting her and learning more about those issues.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Context
The RMT voted overwhelmingly for strike action, affecting public support and service disruption. The Secretary of State mentioned willingness to meet the RMT leader but has not taken decisive action.
Last week the RMT voted overwhelmingly for strike action. Last night the Secretary of State said he would be prepared to meet the leader of the RMT. Some 50% of the public and passengers support those rail strikes. They should not just have been shaking hands last night, but they should be shaking hands today on a deal. The Secretary of State knows full well that he sets the flexibility and parameters for both Network Rail and train operating companies on the financial offer they can put forward. It is in his hands to end those strikes, and to do so today.
As I set out at the start of topical questions, I very much want the strikes not to take place. I have set out my ambition for the rail sector and I will be meeting trade union leaders in the coming days, including later today. In order to pay for a better offer for rail staff, we need to deliver reform. That is why I want trade union leaders to get back around the table with the employers and hammer out the detail of those reforms. Then a better offer can be put on the table and we can end the need for these strikes, which cause enormous damage to passengers and businesses across the country.
Assessment & feedback
Specific ask about immediate action was not addressed; focus was on future meetings and reforms instead of ending strikes immediately.
Future Meetings Reforms
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Context
The government has invested £135 million into Bank Top station, yet constituents still suffer from congestion and emissions on the roads. A northern link road is proposed to address this issue.
May I thank the Government for all that they are doing to improve connectivity at Darlington, including the £135 million invested in Bank Top station? However, my constituents in places such as Harrowgate Hill and Whinfield still suffer from congestion and emissions on the roads. Can my hon. Friend guide me on what more I can do to ensure that we ease this gridlock by delivering a northern link road?
I thank my hon. Friend for his question; he and I have worked closely together on many local transport issues. National Highways and Tees Valley Combined Authority have worked closely on developing proposals for the Darlington northern link road, connecting the A66 and junction 59 of the A1. The work to date will form part of a body of evidence informing the investment plans for RIS3—the third road investment strategy—for future roads between 2025 and 2030.
Assessment & feedback
Specific ask about easing traffic congestion was not directly addressed; focus was on RIS3 and future proposals instead of immediate actions.
Future Plans Ris3
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Richard Burgon Lab
Leeds East
Context
The Government is accused of hindering the resolution of rail strikes by blocking a settlement despite providing indemnity payments to rail companies.
People expect the Government to be trying to help resolve these rail strikes, not block a resolution. How can the Transport Secretary claim that it is not his role to get involved when the Government are handing over tens of millions of pounds a day in indemnity payments to rail companies to back them up during this strike?
I do not think the hon. Gentleman listened to my earlier answers. It is not my interest to block a settlement at all. I want to resolve this issue. I want to facilitate the trade unions and the employers getting together to hammer out some reform measures to help pay for a better pay offer for the staff. I will do everything I can to end these damaging and unnecessary strikes, and I hope he will do what he can to persuade the trade unions to get back around the table with the employers.
Assessment & feedback
Specific ask about resolving strikes through government involvement was not directly addressed; focus was on facilitation of negotiations instead.
Facilitation Negotiations
Response accuracy
Q19 Direct Answer
Context
Whitcombe Pipelines in Rowley Regis has won a substantial contract for HS2 infrastructure, demonstrating the potential for jobs and growth.
Tomorrow I will be visiting Whitcombe Pipelines in Rowley Regis, which has just won a substantial contract for HS2 infrastructure. Does the Secretary of State agree that this demonstrates how HS2 is already delivering significant benefits to my constituency, through jobs and growth, and that it is important that that is maintained?
My hon. Friend makes a very good point. The supply chain for HS2 and the spending benefits constituencies and constituents across the whole of the United Kingdom, including his and, indeed, mine.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Clive Efford Lab
Eltham and Chislehurst
Context
During the pandemic, peak-time services were cut without consultation from Southeastern.
Before the pandemic, the rail services through my constituency suffered from chronic overcrowding, yet the Government used the pandemic as an excuse to cut peak-time services from my constituency without consultation of those rail users. What is he going to do to monitor the damage that he has done and to ensure that those services are restored when those trains get chronically overcrowded again?
Southeastern did indeed ask for a derogation to consult, and changes had to be made quite rapidly during the pandemic, although may I just say that, as a fellow user of Southeastern, the hon. Member will find that there are some benefits from that? It is not just about taking down some costs; it is also about simplifying the line structure, so that at Lewisham, for example, there will not be as many trains crossing. If he would just wait and see how matters progress, he and I might find that it has been a good timetable change after all.
Assessment & feedback
Specific ask about monitoring damage was not directly addressed; focus was on benefits of changes instead.
Future Benefits Simplification
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Context
Derby has significant support from local authorities, businesses and Members of Parliament to be the headquarters of Great British Railways.
Derby's bid to be the headquarters of Great British Railways has huge support: more than 20 right hon. and hon. Members, 40 local authorities, and the businesses forming the largest rail cluster in the country, and maybe even in Europe. Will the Minister confirm when the announcement will be made to confirm which of the six shortlisted locations has won the bidding process?
We have had six excellent shortlisted bids, one of which of course is Derby. The Government remain committed to reform of the railways. We will be looking at all the options, and that includes looking at bringing forward legislation to make this happen and revealing the winning bid at that time.
Assessment & feedback
Specific ask about timing was not directly addressed; focus was on legislative process instead.
Legislative Options Future Announcement
Response accuracy
Q22 Direct Answer
Chi Onwurah Lab
Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West
Context
The hon. Member's constituents suffer from poor bus services which impact their daily lives.
The work, business, leisure, family and educational lives of my constituents are being hugely undermined by atrocious bus services. I heard the Minister's response to my hon. Friend the Member for North Tyneside (Mary Glindon), but the previous Secretary of State promised to meet me to discuss this as a matter of urgency. Will this Secretary of State keep her commitment and meet me?
I thank the hon. Lady for her question; I will certainly meet her. I know how important bus services are, and I will also be meeting, hopefully in the near future, local authorities across the north-east so that we can hopefully deliver that £163 million for them as well.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q23 Partial Answer
Context
Two thirds of Londoners oppose the Mayor's plan to expand the ultra-low emission zone to cover all of Greater London.
Two thirds of Londoners have said no to the Mayor of London expanding the ultra low emission zone to the whole of Greater London. Will my right hon. Friend join me and Conservative MP colleagues to tell the Mayor of London that it is not for the poorest Londoners to foot the bill for his financial failures?
As I said earlier, how to respond to the consultation and proceed is a matter for the Mayor to consider. I know that my hon. Friend has had a massive campaign on this issue, with over 5,000 people getting in touch with him about ULEZ. If hon. Members really want to see this policy changed, the best thing they can do is replace the Mayor of London at the next election.
Assessment & feedback
Specific ask was completely avoided; focus shifted to electoral process instead.
Election
Response accuracy
Q24 Partial Answer
Context
Guide dog owners face significant barriers in accessing public spaces, with over 70% reporting refusal of access to taxis, shops and restaurants. This issue impacts daily life for individuals like constituent Robert and his guide dog Winnie.
Some 73% of guide dog owners have been refused access to taxis, shops and restaurants in the past year. What is the Minister and his Department doing to improve access and ensure that guide dog owners such as my constituent Robert, and his guide dog Winnie, can get out and about with confidence?
I am very familiar with that issue from my time as Minister for Disabled People. The behaviour that the hon. Lady describes is, of course, already unlawful. She has set out a specific case; if she writes to me with the details, we will look into it and see what further work we can do to make sure that the existing law to ensure fairness for guide dog owners is properly enforced across the United Kingdom.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not commit to specific actions beyond reviewing a specific case. He acknowledged unlawfulness but did not provide new enforcement mechanisms or timelines.
Under Review If She Writes To Me
Response accuracy
Q25 Partial Answer
Neil Hudson Con
Epping Forest
Context
Residents and constituents face significant disruption due to poor service from Avanti West Coast, resulting in missed appointments, social events and other commitments. The issue is widespread and impacts daily life.
I, many constituents and countless people up and down the land struggle each week with the poor and unreliable service provided by Avanti West Coast. People are missing interviews, appointments, family events and social occasions. Can the Minister give the latest Government assessment of Avanti's performance and confirm that nothing will be ruled out, including stripping it of its contract if it does not lift its game?
I am sorry for my hon. Friend's experience and that of his constituents. We are working very hard with the Avanti team to get more services restored. In December, with the good will of the unions and the workforce, we will see an increase in weekday services from the current 180 to 264, which would be a greater number than before the unions decided not to work to the rest day agreement, which is something I very much regret. I am committed to ensuring that Avanti services improve, which I know is important to you, Mr Speaker, and all Members of the House.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not confirm contract revocation as a potential measure but discussed current efforts to restore service levels. He acknowledged performance issues without committing to stripping Avanti of its contract.
Committed To Ensuring Working With The Team
Response accuracy