Topical Questions 2022-07-04

2022-07-04

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Kate Osamor Lab Co-op
Edmonton and Winchmore Hill
Context
Teachers' pay has fallen by a fifth in real terms over the past 12 years of Conservative rule. Seven in ten teachers have considered quitting due to unsustainable workload.
The Secretary of State has suggested that it would be unforgiveable for teachers to go on strike. What is unforgiveable is that teachers' pay has fallen by a fifth in real terms in the past 12 years of Conservative rule. At the same time, they have been crushed under an unsustainable workload, hurting mental health and wellbeing. It is no wonder that seven in 10 have considered quitting in the past year. Will he commit to giving teachers the above-inflation pay increase they so richly deserve?
I do not think that any teacher would want to strike after the damage that covid did with students being out of school. In my evidence to the pay review body, I talked about wanting to deliver almost 9%—it was 8.9%—for new teachers this year and a 7.1% uplift next year to take their starting salary to £30,000 a year. My recommendation for more senior teachers was 5% over two years.
Assessment & feedback
The question asked for an above-inflation pay increase but the answer only provided current recommendations without commitment to meet this specific request.
Hedging
Response accuracy
Q2 Direct Answer
Context
A recent damning report confirmed fears of long waiting lists for education, health and care plans and concerns about staff responsiveness.
The Minister will know that I have been hugely concerned about the state of special educational needs and disabilities services in Birmingham for quite some time, and the recent damning report only confirms the fears of parents whose children are on long waiting lists for education, health and care plans, and concerns about staff being told that they are too busy to respond to emails. Will the Minister assure me and parents and children back home in Birmingham that he will be doing everything possible to ensure that SEND services, which look after our most vulnerable children, are improved in Birmingham?
I certainly agree with the SEND commissioner's recommendations for Birmingham City Council to take responsibility for its SEND provision and rapidly make changes for improvement. I will of course continue to work closely with the commissioner and the council to monitor progress, and the Department will not hesitate to intervene further if Birmingham does not deliver on its plan to implement real lasting change.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Bridget Phillipson Lab
Houghton and Sunderland South
Context
The Secretary of State's flagship Schools Bill had 18 out of 69 clauses pulled due to reasons unclear.
Last week, the Secretary of State's flagship Schools Bill was left in tatters as he pulled 18 out of 69 clauses. Will he explain whether that was because he was bamboozled by his officials, he did not understand his own legislation, or he planned it all along? Or was it just the incompetence that we have all come to expect?
At least I am not missing in action. If the hon. Lady had looked at the detail of my White Paper rather than attempted to play politics with it, she would know that I always promised a review of clauses 1 to 18 because we are taking what is in contract with multi-academy trusts and putting it in statute. I have now launched that review to ensure that we get it right so that clauses 1 to 18 come to this place and the Bill gets through to deliver the outcomes that we all want to see for all children.
Assessment & feedback
The question asked about reasons for clause removal but the answer was defensive without providing a clear explanation.
Changing Subject
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Bridget Phillipson Lab
Houghton and Sunderland South
Context
The cost of care is skyrocketing, yet even the Children's Minister admitted that proposed changes will not significantly reduce costs.
Parents will know that the cost of care is skyrocketing, yet even the Children's Minister himself—the Under-Secretary of State for Education, the hon. Member for Colchester (Will Quince)—admitted that the changes the Government are considering are 'not going to significantly change costs'. Labour has already set out how its children's recovery plan would tackle this vital issue and provide immediate help to families now. What will it take for the Secretary of State to find some fresh ideas that actually address this growing crisis?
The hon. Lady again misses the point. The package is not just about the ratios. It is about looking at how we encourage and grow the childminder market, how we ensure the 1.2 million parents who are eligible to get tax-free childcare make that claim and, of course, how we support teachers, both in our brilliant maintained nurseries and across the system, to do much more for the children we want to see them deliver for.
Assessment & feedback
The question asked about addressing the cost crisis but the answer focused on other aspects of childcare policy without directly tackling costs.
Changing Subject
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Neil Hudson Con
Epping Forest
Context
Current law mandates continued education or training but not transport entitlement, impacting rural areas like Alston Moor where the nearest college is 20 miles away.
Currently, 16 to 18-year-olds must legally continue education or training but are not entitled to transport. That penalises young folk living in rural areas such as Alston Moor, where the nearest college is 20 miles away and public transport is poor. I have started a petition calling for fair post-16 transport. Does the Minister agree with my petitioners that transport should not be a barrier to accessing education? Will the Government address the problem through legislation?
I thank my hon. Friend for his question. He will know that it is local authorities, rather than the Department for Education, that have responsibility for transport to education. I understand that Cumbria County Council already provides some support for travel to college for students who are disadvantaged. It is also possible to top that money up with our 16 to 19 bursary, but I am happy to discuss the matter with him further.
Assessment & feedback
The question asked about legislation but the answer noted local authority responsibility without committing to legislative action.
Hedging
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Context
The number of graduates owing more than £100,000 in student loans has increased by over 3,000% in a year, with inflation expected to worsen the situation.
The number of graduates owing more than £100,000 in student loans has gone up by more than 3,000% in a single year, with over 6,500 graduates now having six-figure balances. Next year, with inflation, things could be even worse. Will the Secretary of State detail what urgent action he is considering to tackle the huge levels of graduate debt?
As the hon. Member will know only too well, we responded to the Augar report in full a few months ago. We tried to get the right balance in who pays, between the graduate and the taxpayer, so that we have a fair system in which no student will pay back more in real terms than they borrowed. This Government are focused on outcomes, making sure that degrees pay and deliver graduate jobs.
Assessment & feedback
The question asked for urgent actions but the answer discussed general principles without concrete measures.
Hedging
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Context
The Imagination Library free book gifting scheme has been running in North Lincolnshire for over a decade, with nine out of ten local children signed up and nearly one million books delivered. Recent data shows that participating children perform better on phonics screening tests than their peers who do not participate.
It is now over a decade since I worked with the new Conservative North Lincolnshire Council to introduce the Imagination Library free book gifting scheme for all under-fives. Now, with nine out of 10 local children signed up and nearly 1 million books delivered in that period, our year 1 phonics screening shows that children who receive the free books are doing better at school than their peers who do not. Will the Secretary of State, or any Minister, engage with my local council to look at the benefits of the scheme more widely?
Indeed, the Secretary of State will engage with my hon. Friend on his passion for this subject. He knows we are investing £17 million in the Nuffield Early Language Intervention programme to improve language skills in reception-age children who most need that help.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary of State did not address the specific request about engaging with his local council on the benefits of the Imagination Library scheme.
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Mike Kane Lab
Wythenshawe and Sale East
Context
The Sale High School in the constituency is urgently requiring refurbishment, with local partners working to develop a deal. The matter was taken up by the Minister in another place, but the playing field strategy committee has not yet decided on the case.
The brilliant Sale High School in my constituency is in desperate need of refurbishment. To that end, I have been working with local partners to put a deal on the table. With the help of the Minister in the other place, the deal went to the Department's playing field strategy committee in June. Will the Minister please apprise the House of the outcome?
I recognise that the hon. Gentleman has been pressing my noble Friend in the other place on this matter. The case for the high school did not go to the playing field panel in June, because queries requiring further information from the applicant were raised by the Department's design team. The applicant has been fully updated on the request and the information required. The case should now be going to the panel in September and I will ensure we update him at that stage.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide a clear answer about when he would apprise the House of the outcome, instead focusing on updates provided to the applicant.
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
I hope my right hon. Friend will see this book I have here, “The Children's Inquiry” by Liz Cole and Molly Kingsley, about the damage to children during lockdown. The number of ghost children is still rising: it has risen by 100,000 to 1.7 million absent children. I know my right hon. Friend set up the Attendance Alliance Group, but the fact is that we need to get those children back to school, and the numbers are rising. What will he do to ensure those children get back to school in September?
I am grateful to the Chair of the Select Committee. Those are not just ghost children; they are flesh and blood. We must make sure that we do everything in our power to get them back into school. The national register will identify where those children are, so that we can really focus on that.
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not specify any particular steps for getting ghost children back to school and relied more on general statements.
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Abena Oppong-Asare Lab
Erith and Thamesmead
Context
Many legal UK residents with years of residence find it difficult to access student finance due to complex residency requirements. Applicants face difficulties in providing necessary evidence, exacerbated by Home Office delays.
Many of my constituents who are in the UK legally and have lived in this country for many years are denied access to student finance because of unnecessary and unfair residency rules. Many applicants find it difficult to provide the evidence required, and Home Office delays mean that some people cannot even apply in the first place. Will the Minister please look into that issue and see whether any changes can be made that could help with student finance, particularly when it comes to eligibility rules?
I am more than happy to meet the hon. Member, but at the heart of our system are fairness and ensuring that our policy and rules are straightforward. I am more than happy to explain that to her.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not address the request for review or potential changes; instead focused on explaining current policies.
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
The Penketh High School has received positive recognition for its academic and sports achievements, but the school estate is in poor condition. The SEND building improvement application has been submitted.
Will the Secretary of State join me in congratulating the team at Penketh High School on its ever improving standards? Ofsted recently improved its rating of the school, there was the sports gold award last week, and year 9 student Leon Stretton has signed for Warrington Wolves—a huge success in the town. However, the school's problem is the poor state of its estate. Will my right hon. Friend look carefully at its recent application to improve the standard of the SEND building?
I very much welcome the success of the school that my hon. Friend has highlighted and will be happy to meet him to discuss the issues further.
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not address the specific application for SEND building improvement, instead focusing on general willingness to discuss further with the MP.
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Context
Local further education colleges face financial pressures due to rising national insurance contributions and utility bills, as well as the need for competitive staff pay rises. These issues threaten social mobility opportunities.
Our further education colleges in Newham give real opportunity to children from the second poorest part of the country, but now our colleges face increasing national insurance contributions and skyrocketing utility bills. What is more, pay increases may be essential for the recruitment and retention of school staff. What are the Government doing to engage properly with the Association of Colleges to keep these engines of social mobility and growth going?
The hon. Lady is absolutely right that FE colleges are engines of social mobility, and we are well aware of the pressures that they are under. We are engaging constantly with the Association of Colleges, principals and colleagues across Government to make sure that we can help them.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide specific actions or timelines for addressing financial challenges; instead, stated general engagement efforts.
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Does my right hon. Friend agree that improving the quality and depth of technical qualifications is vital to our levelling-up agenda and also to helping everyone improve social mobility?
Yes I do. The more runways that we can build from which people's careers can take off, the better.
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not provide specifics on improving technical qualification standards; instead offered a general agreement without details.
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Sarah Owen Lab
Luton North
Context
Reports indicate issues of faith-based bullying and sexual harassment in schools, raising concerns about the adequacy of current Department for Education guidelines on handling such incidents.
I am sure that I am not alone in hearing worrying reports of faith-based bullying and sexual harassment in schools. If this week has taught us anything, it is that we need to lead by example. Will the Secretary of State tell us when the Department for Education's own bullying and harassment policies were last reviewed and updated?
I recently spoke in a Westminster Hall debate on relationships and sex education, and I made it clear that we regularly review our guidance, both on keeping children safe in education and on safeguarding.
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not specify when the policies would be reviewed or updated; instead stated general commitment to regular reviews.
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Julian Lewis Con
New Forest East
Do the Government share my concern at the injection of vast quantities of communist cash from countries such as China and Vietnam into our universities—Oxbridge colleges in particular? Will they set up a taskforce to examine the problem and make recommendations?
We have recently added a further clause to our Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill to ensure that there is more transparency when it comes to the donations that our universities receive.
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not commit to setting up a taskforce; instead, mentioned adding a clause for transparency.
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Mary Foy Lab
City of Durham
Context
The National Education Union has calculated that teacher pay has fallen by a fifth in real terms since 2010, while average teacher salaries are at their lowest in more than 40 years compared with average earnings across the economy.
The hon. Lady noted her concern about teacher pay and the negative impact on teachers' morale and recruitment. She referenced the National Education Union's findings that teacher pay has fallen by a fifth since 2010, while salaries are at their lowest in more than 40 years compared with average earnings across the economy. Despite this, teachers look set to receive a 3% rise—a real-terms pay cut. The hon. Lady asked how the Secretary of State can justify not giving teachers a proper pay rise.
I am grateful to the hon. Lady. We will wait to see the work of the pay review bodies. We have submitted our recommendation, and we will wait to hear what they say about it.
Assessment & feedback
The government's justification for not providing a proper pay rise
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Context
A roundtable at Heathfield Community College included discussions about the need for a parents' pledge to outline expectations from both teachers and parents.
The hon. Member mentioned that he heard great ideas from headteachers and governors regarding the proposed parents' pledge, which outlines not only what parents can expect from teachers but also what teachers can expect from parents. He asked whether this idea could help improve teacher performance by clearly defining mutual responsibilities.
We want to ensure that every child across the country has a complete and well rounded education, receiving targeted support where needed. We have made the pledge to parents to make that happen. If a child falls behind in English or maths, they will receive targeted support to get back on track and parents will be kept up to date with their progress. We expect parents to engage constructively with schools and to give support in terms of both attendance and behaviour, which will maximise their children's opportunities.
Assessment & feedback
The specific idea suggested by headteachers about defining mutual responsibilities
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Emma Lewell Lab
South Shields
Context
A total of 800,000 children are in poverty and denied free school meals due to Government-imposed eligibility criteria.
The hon. Member noted that cross-party calls for extending the free school meal eligibility criteria have been ignored by the government. She referenced a total of 800,000 children in poverty who are being denied free school meals owing to restrictive eligibility criteria set by the Government. The hon. Member asked why the Government refuses to extend these benefits to all families on universal credit.
About 1.9 million children receive benefit-related free school meals, with provision supporting the most disadvantaged. Eligibility has been extended to more groups of children under this Government than under any other over the past half century, and that includes the introduction of universal infant free school meals and further education free meals.
Assessment & feedback
The specific call for extending eligibility criteria to all families on universal credit
Response accuracy
Q19 Direct Answer
Context
The government announced a package to help parents with childcare costs during the school holidays.
With the school holidays approaching, the hon. Member asked whether helping parents with the cost of childcare is a key priority for his Department. He also inquired about the impact of paying up to 85% of the cost of childcare for those on universal credit compared to the previous 70% regime.
The purpose of the important package announced today is to ensure that parents on universal credit, or the tax-free childcare element, claim what is rightfully theirs. We are spending between £4 billion and £5 billion on helping parents with childcare.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Stella Creasy Lab Co-op
Walthamstow
Context
Ministers often emphasize the importance of parents claiming childcare tax breaks, but last year's government spending on promoting this was very low.
The hon. Member noted that despite frequent ministerial reminders about claiming childcare tax breaks, the Government spent only £150,000 on advertising them last year while saving the Treasury £3 billion. She asked what additional funding has been secured for a wider campaign to advertise child tax credit spending.
The hon. Lady and I have discussed this before. Today's announcement was all about increasing accessibility, availability and affordability. We want to see an increase in tax-free childcare. There is going to be a big comms campaign, so watch this space.
Assessment & feedback
Specific details on additional funding for advertising child tax credits
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Paul Holmes Con
Hamble Valley
Context
There is no central Government guidance available to help schools support young carers.
The hon. Member reported that at the YMCA Young Carers Festival, it was learned there is a lack of central government guidance for schools on providing support for young carers. He mentioned how attendance policies can negatively affect their education and mental health. The hon. Member asked what steps will be taken to bring central guidance to schools.
We are updating our attendance guidance, and I should be happy to meet my hon. Friend to discuss further the specific issue of young carers. Having met young carers groups in my own constituency, I know how important it is to engage with them properly and effectively, and we should do that throughout our school system.
Assessment & feedback
The specifics of new guidance for schools regarding young carers
Response accuracy
Q22 Direct Answer
Context
Hartford Manor Primary School in the hon. Member's constituency is struggling with rising energy bills.
The hon. Member visited Hartford Manor Primary School and observed that many schools are suffering due to escalating energy costs. He asked what immediate actions will be taken by the Minister and Department to address this urgent issue for schools across the country.
As I have said many times already, we have put £4 billion in for next year. We want to work with schools to support them. There is support through our school resource management system, and specifically through the “Get help buying for schools” system. We will continue—[Interruption.]
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy