Topical Questions 2022-01-13

2022-01-13

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
David Simmonds Con
Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner
Context
The London Borough of Hillingdon has reported benefits from the Public Services (Social Value) Act 2012 in terms of procurement processes.
Colleagues at the London Borough of Hillingdon have told me of the benefits to the procurement process that they see from the Public Services (Social Value) Act 2012, so what measures does my right hon. Friend have in mind to promote the benefits that that Act can bring to public sector procurement, and especially in how it might support the levelling-up agenda?
My hon. Friend knows from his own time in local government how important that Act is in requiring that people who commission public services think about how they can secure wider social, economic and environmental benefit. That is why we are going to extend the terms of that provision. As the Paymaster General set out a moment ago, the new procurement legislation will further empower local authorities, and others procuring on behalf of the taxpayer, to drive better social value, for example by targeting contracts to businesses that employ a larger proportion of those with disability.
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not provide specific measures but rather general principles about extending the Act's provisions and empowering local authorities.
Will Focus On Looking At This
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Angela Rayner Lab
Ashton-under-Lyne
Context
The High Court ruled that the Government's VIP lane for PPE procurement was illegal, highlighting failures in due diligence and resource allocation.
Earlier, in his response to the hon. Member for Harrow East (Bob Blackman), the Paymaster General talked about poor performance. The Government's VIP lane for personal protective equipment procurement was not just dodgy, but actually illegal. That was not my opinion, but the judgment of the High Court yesterday. Once again, this Government have been shown that they cannot seem to stay on the right side of the law. Listening to the Paymaster General, anybody would think that they had won their case in the Court yesterday. Time and again, Cabinet Office Ministers have stood at the Dispatch Box and told us that detailed diligence and full financial checks were done. Yesterday, the Court found that the Cabinet Office simply did not have the resources necessary to undertake due diligence. Officials simply searched online to confirm that one company existed, and another received a red warning but it was not passed on. Can he tell us how much, from those two contracts alone, was spent on equipment that was not even used by the NHS?
With respect, what the right hon. Lady omitted was that the court acknowledged that it is highly unlikely that the outcome would have been “substantially different” if a different assessment process had been followed. What the House would quite rightly challenge the Government on is, first, whether anything different would have occurred had there been a different approach; and secondly, the fundamental point of whether, at a time of national crisis, the Government were straining every sinew to ensure that the clinicians at the sharp end of our NHS had the PPE that they needed, and the answer is that they did do that.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about spending on unused equipment was not addressed; instead, the focus was on whether a different approach would have changed the outcome.
Changed Subject Did Not Address
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Angela Rayner Lab
Ashton-under-Lyne
Context
Court judgment revealed billions of pounds wasted on dodgy contracts through VIP fast lane.
I encourage people to read that judgment, because the Government at the moment seem to think that it was all good and rosy. The Paymaster General told the House that a fair and impartial investigation takes place before there is a judge, jury and executioner. Will the Prime Minister act as the judge and jury even though he is also the man in the dock?
The right hon. Lady is conflating two different issues. More than 16.5 billion PPE items were delivered, at a time of national crisis to ensure frontline protection. The Court's judgment was clear that the outcome would be highly unlikely to have been “substantially different” had a different process been followed.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about Prime Minister acting as judge and jury was not directly addressed.
Conflating Issues
Response accuracy
Q4 Direct Answer
Context
39 places are in competition for city status during the platinum jubilee celebrations.
Does my right hon. Friend agree that city status can deliver more jobs and business opportunities, and play a vital part in the wider regeneration of towns such as Dudley?
I do agree with my hon. Friend. Civic honours are rare acknowledgments awarded by Her Majesty, recognizing individual heritage and community effort. The platinum jubilee will bring people together and help renew the nation as we emerge from challenges.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Brendan O'Hara SNP
Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber
Context
Devolved Administrations have repeatedly asked their people to do the right thing during the pandemic.
Does the Minister think that the Prime Minister's admission of attending an illegal party will strengthen or undermine the relationship between the Government in London and those in Cardiff, Belfast and Edinburgh?
The fact that yesterday I was on a call with First Ministers from Scotland, Wales, and others underscores the commitment to work together. Building on yesterday's conversation, this shows willingness to engage positively.
Assessment & feedback
No direct answer given about relationship being strengthened or undermined.
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Brendan O'Hara SNP
Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber
Context
The PM admitted attending an illegal party during a strict national lockdown.
When did the Minister first become aware that the party had taken place? What advice has he sought from the Attorney General ahead of speaking to the police?
I became aware when it was covered in the media. We cannot anticipate the conclusions of the current inquiry, as the PM said yesterday, and we should allow that inquiry to conclude.
Assessment & feedback
Specific date not provided; no mention of advice from Attorney General
Response accuracy
Q7 Direct Answer
Context
Services for veterans with hearing loss lost considerable funding from LIBOR fines.
Will my hon. Friend meet me to discuss how veterans can get the services they need for often considerable hearing loss?
I am very pleased that my hon. Friend has raised the matter and I will be very pleased to meet him to discuss it further.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Kim Johnson Lab
Liverpool Riverside
Context
Black civil servants under-represented with only 98 out of over 14,000 successful applicants.
Does the Minister agree that this is because of deeply entrenched institutional racism? What actions will be taken to deal with such significant under-representation?
With respect to the hon. Lady, I do not accept the characterisation she places on the civil service.
Assessment & feedback
No agreement or specific actions mentioned
Rejecting Characterization
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
The hydrogen sector's reliance on blue hydrogen derived from natural gas is highlighted, with a call for more green hydrogen.
In considering ministerial responsibility for the hydrogen sector, will the Minister bear in mind that 95% of hydrogen is so-called blue hydrogen derived from natural gas and that, if we really are to have a hydrogen revolution that puts Britain on the map, we need more green hydrogen derived from renewable or nuclear power?
The strategy supports multiple production technologies including both electrolytic green and carbon capture-enabled blue hydrogen production. Following the consultation, an approach to different production routes will be developed by early this year.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment on 5 GW ambition for green vs blue hydrogen was not addressed
We Are Not Limiting Ambition For Any One Technology
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Wendy Chamberlain Lib Dem
North East Fife
Context
Recent actions by the government have damaged public trust in the Union, and a private Member's Bill aims to ensure appropriate representation from devolved nations on public bodies.
Given the damage that the self-styled Minister for the Union has done to public trust in recent days and the decision of some Cabinet colleagues to diminish the role of the Scottish Conservative leader, will the Minister prove that the Government can at least try to do one thing right and commit to supporting my private Member's Bill which would ensure that the boards of public bodies include appropriate representation from the devolved nations?
The Chief Whip will look at the Bill's terms in detail. The Prime Minister is committed to the Union, and it informs much of my work as a Minister.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment to supporting Wendy Chamberlain's private Member's Bill was not addressed
I Am Sure That My Colleague The Chief Whip Will Look At The Bill'S Terms In Detail
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
The Nationality and Borders Bill aims to prevent illegal immigration, but the Home Office cannot solve this alone. Cross-departmental efforts are needed.
The Nationality and Borders Bill is a crucial step forward to preventing illegal immigration and abuse of our asylum system, but the Home Office clearly cannot solve the problem on its own. Will my right hon. Friend update the House on cross-departmental efforts to stop small boats crossing the channel?
My hon. Friend raises an important point. The response is a whole of Government endeavour and I will meet the Home Secretary later today.
Assessment & feedback
Specific details on cross-departmental efforts were not provided
I Am Sure That The Home Secretary Will Update The House Further On Our Progress
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Diana R. Johnson Lab
Kingston upon Hull North and Cottingham
Context
The current Prime Minister is at the centre of allegations of breaking the law and misleading the House, raising concerns about natural justice in judging ministerial conduct.
Does the Paymaster General agree that there is a fatal flaw in our system when the person who ultimately makes judgment on the ministerial code is a Prime Minister who is at the centre of allegations of breaking the law and misleading the House? Does it not go against all the rules of natural justice to be judge and jury in your own case?
Natural justice also requires something on which to impose justice and as yet we do not have any result from the inquiry, so it is premature to judge.
Assessment & feedback
The specific issue of Prime Minister judging ministerial code was avoided
We Do Not Have Any Result From The Inquiry
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
The Places for Growth programme has brought jobs and investment to Stoke-on-Trent, prompting a request for an update on the wider relocation of civil servants.
I want to thank my right hon. Friend and the noble Lord Agnew who, with the Cabinet Office and the Home Office, have managed to bring more than 500 brand-new jobs to the city of Stoke-on-Trent as well as further investment in developing a site. Will he update the House on progress for the Stoke-on-Trent relocation and on the wider move that is taking civil servants out across our United Kingdom?
The Places for Growth agenda fits within a range of Government programmes committed to levelling up Stoke, including those highlighted by Stoke MPs yesterday.
Assessment & feedback
Specific progress on Stoke-on-Trent relocation was not detailed
It Is Fundamental To Greater Diversity In Our Civil Service
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Context
A judge has ruled that the government's VIP lane for PPE contracts was unlawful, raising concerns about corrupt processes involving Conservative party cronies.
The Government's VIP lane for personal protective equipment contracts has been ruled by a judge to be unlawful. The judge found that the operation of the High Priority Lane was in breach of the obligation of equal treatment… Will the Minister agree to release details of the financial checks done on PPE Medpro, including its connections to a Conservative party peer?
The court found that it is highly unlikely that the outcome would have been substantially different. The House considered properly the judgment yesterday.
Assessment & feedback
Specific release of financial checks and connections for PPE Medpro was avoided
It Is Right That The House Considers Properly The Judgment
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Bob Blackman Con
Harrow East
Context
Concerns about personation in local elections and the need for compliance with postal and proxy voting laws.
We will face local elections later this year. Will my right hon. Friend update the House on what action will be taken to make sure that personation does not take place and that postal and proxy voting is in accordance with the law?
My hon. Friend raises an extremely important point. He will be well aware, following the recent machinery of government change, that that subject no longer falls within the purview of the Cabinet Office, so I do not want to incur the displeasure of Mr Speaker by straying into the territory of ministerial colleagues. However, I will ensure that the relevant colleague is alerted to the very good point that my hon. Friend highlights.
Assessment & feedback
Providing an update on actions taken or planned for preventing personation and ensuring compliance with postal and proxy voting laws
Recent Machinery Of Government Change Straying Into The Territory Of Ministerial Colleagues
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Jim Shannon DUP
Strangford
Context
Request for funding to Beyond the Battlefield, a charity supporting veterans with poor mental health in Northern Ireland.
I remind the Minister for Defence People and Veterans of my request to him about the charity Beyond the Battlefield, which does amazing work for veterans who suffer from poor mental health and particularly those who often go under the radar and are not accounted for in the stats process. In Northern Ireland, its work is phenomenal. Will the Minister consider allocating funding to assist with its privately funded veterans centre in Portavogie in my constituency, which is due to open next week? The Minister would be very welcome to come along with me to visit it.
I would be very pleased to meet the hon. Gentleman to discuss that further.
Assessment & feedback
Providing a commitment on funding or visiting the centre
Meeting To Discuss
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Kirsty Blackman SNP
Aberdeen North
Context
Questioning the leader of the Scottish Conservatives being called a “lightweight”.
Does the Cabinet Office agree that the leader of the Scottish Conservatives, the hon. Member for Moray (Douglas Ross), is a “lightweight”?
I think he is a hugely talented colleague. I work extremely closely with him and I look forward to doing so. One of the points that has come out through departmental questions is the commitment from many across the House, although not those on the Scottish National party Benches, to the importance of the Union. That is an absolutely central commitment of the Government and the Prime Minister and the entire Cabinet are committed to defending it.
Assessment & feedback
Agreeing that the leader of the Scottish Conservatives is a “lightweight”
Commitment From Many Across The House Importance Of The Union
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Andrew Gwynne Ind
Gorton and Denton
Context
Concern about the Paymaster General defending the Prime Minister despite clear case against him.
Can I give a bit of friendly advice to the Paymaster General, who has been valiantly defending the indefensible? When the ship is about to sail, you jump on it because it is leaving without you. The ministerial code matters, standards in public life matter and trust in politics matters. The case against the Prime Minister is clear. Why is the Paymaster General destroying his own integrity to save a man who has none?
It is very kind of the hon. Gentleman to be concerned about my position and I am very grateful to him. My position is clear: the Prime Minister answers to the people of this country and to this House. He came to the House yesterday, at Prime Minister's questions, and he apologised. He has said—and I agree—that we should wait until the result of the investigation that is in progress. That would be the case with any individual facing any allegation anywhere in this country. One waits until due process is complete.
Assessment & feedback
Explaining why he is destroying his own integrity to save a man who has none
Prime Minister Answers To The People Of This Country And To This House Due Process
Response accuracy
Q19 Partial Answer
Context
Challenging the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster about statements made by Cabinet colleagues.
Despite the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster's words at the Dispatch Box, the reality is that his Cabinet colleagues yesterday were calling the Scottish Conservative leader a “lightweight” and irrelevant because he was up in Elgin. Is it not the case that there has never been a Union of equals? It is always “Scotland, know your place,” and that was demonstrated yesterday.
Again, that is a question that pre-empts the discussion that we have had in the House today. I flagged to the hon. Gentleman's colleague a moment ago the very constructive discussions that I, the Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities and indeed the Paymaster General had with the First Minister of Scotland yesterday. We touched on the role—[Interruption.] If the hon. Gentleman wants to heckle through the answer, that is entirely up to him; I was just running through the various things that we do as part of our commitment to places for growth.
Assessment & feedback
Agreement on whether Scotland is treated as an equal within the Union
Pre-Empts The Discussion Very Constructive Discussions
Response accuracy